I was really excited to try this place as I have always heard great things. Unfortunately I was not impressed with the pizza I tried. I got a personal pizza with chicken and banana peppers which is one of my favorite combinations. The pizza was just ok, it didn't have any great flavors that stood out and kind of dry. The best part was the crispy cheese edges! That is always a plus. I just wish the rest of the pizza lived up the hype because this was not memorable. read more

Buttercrust Pizza - Personal chicken and banana peppers which - Pizza Near Me - Oviedo, Florida

I came here to watch the magic game and I ordered the buffalo chicken pizza and all I can say is it tasted like the first time you've ever had pizza when you just fell in love with it. It was the perfect flavor and balance of chicken and buffalo sauce and ranch and the crispy buttery edges. read more

I ordered a large pizza and was not satiated with the service, I understand it's a week night but no one was at the front for almost 20 minutes I understand people need to use the bathroom but thata why you should have more than one person working and by the time they got back and the pizza was sitting it was cold and soggy and gross and also the cut on the pizza was horrible I was all clumped together absoultely fucking terrible 0/10 and Im a pizza connoisseur I've been to and tried all over for the us and eaten new york and chicagos best pies and this place is below mid compared to real pizza. I went an hour out of my way that day for this how dissapointing.. read more

Best wings in town, Uncanny, golden brown, The second bake, Truly does make, Every bite so great, Ranch on the plate. Check them out, Revise your route, Unmatched they are, Spicy garlic parm the star, Thank me layer I trust as you are eating wings at BUTTERCRUST. read more

This pizza is delicious. The sauce was awesome, the pepperoni and mushrooms were plentiful and the service was outstanding. Highly recommended. read more

This place is awesome!! I love how it was such a local hangout right in the middle of their little town center! It had so many different quick service restaurants that I really wanted to try them all! But we came for Buttercrust Pizza and it did not disappoint! There is plenty of seating everywhere and they did have an indoor bar area with high tops too! We are not local but wished we were do we could have a fun place to take our family when they come in! The pepperoni rolls were fire! So divine and delicious! And the 4 slice pizza was the perfect size!! Buttery crust-gooey cheese and a great crunch!! Will definitely come back I try more! read more

See all

If you're in Oviedo and craving amazing pizza, look no further than Buttercrust Pizza! I came here to meet up with some friends at Food Factory and ordered it because I was starving and now I can't stop raving about their incredible thin-crust pizza--it's so flavorful and hits the spot every single time. As a fan of thin crust, this one stole the show for me. The balance of crispiness and rich, savory toppings is perfection. Now, let's talk about the chicken wings--WOW. If you're new here, I LOVE CHICKEN WINGS! They were cooked to perfection, juicy, and packed with flavor. Definitely some of the best wings I've had in the area! Since we were sitting in the bar area, we ordered online and then picked up but the little customer service we received was excellent. I was only picking up after all. Eating pizza, drinking beer and listening to live music - a stellar evening! I thought maybe it was because I was so hungry and that the pizza was so good but I recently ordered their pan crust pizza, and while it's equally delicious, the thin crust is my personal favorite. So, it was still incredibly delicious when I wasn't starving :D Highly recommend! read more

Buttercrust Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Oviedo, Florida

See all

Let me tell you how I feel like I've been initiated into being a Buttercrust customer... My first encounter with BCP was my boss buying us lunch for working on Christmas Eve. Pizza is not one of my top food choices. It also doesn't love me because tomato sauce irritates my GERD. So, when I see someone pass by me with a square pice of Meat Lovers pizza that looks like it is fresh out of a commercial, I SPEED-WALK to where it's located! I eat the pizza KNOWING I will get heartburn, stomach irritation, etc... it's some of the best pizza I've ever had! read more

If you are a fan of pan, deep-dish, and/or Sicilian style pizzas, then Buttercrust Square pizza is perfect for you! We tried the buttercrust Square with pepperoni and a classic round with pepperoni. The sauce is heavenly flavored and the cup pepperonis are classicly slightly spicy which blends perfectly with the sharpness of the cheese! This is definitely my new fave spot for pan style pizza! read more

Buttercrust Pizza - Square pepperoni pizza absolutely delicious - Pizza Near Me - Oviedo, Florida

Great pepperoni and cheese pizza. For the garlic bread puffs too and it was all delicious.

Oviedo Food Factory-Although we didn't try the pizza, I would highly recommend the delicious wings! I had the Garlic Parmesan, and my girlfriend had the Buffalo. They make their own ranch dressing and it was VERY tasty. We couldn't decide between the ranch and the blue cheese for our dipping sauces, so he gave us both!! The blue cheese, although it was not homemade, was really delicious as well. We were visiting the food factory, for a pop-up event, and decided to have a drink and a bite to eat. What I love about this establishment is that you can order your food, and then sit in the pub and have a drink while eating. Plenty of space to hang out outdoor or indoors. I can't say that all of the restaurants are delicious because I've only tried a couple of them. The reviews are a little low for most of the restaurants. Service at Buttercrust Pizza was impeccable. He delivered our wings, to us, in the pub. Now that is service! We definitely will be back. read more

Buttercrust Pizza - Buffalo wings - Pizza Near Me - Oviedo, Florida

See all

I opted for a cauliflower crust pizza and I chose my own toppings. The cauliflower crust was surprisingly crunchy and really tasty. I love a savory pizza sauce that's not too sweet, and this sauce was perfect! The ingredients also tasted fresh. I do think it could've been cooked for an additional 1-2 minutes. The only downside is that you can't order using the QR code like you can from the other restaurants. They also won't bring the food to your seat and you have to pick it up. It wasn't very busy when I was there and the guy saw where I was sitting so he was nice enough to bring it to me, which I appreciated. If you're looking for a healthier option at the food factory, a cauliflower pizza is the way to go! read more

Buttercrust Pizza - Cauliflower pizza - Pizza Near Me - Oviedo, Florida

See all

This is one of the worst things that has happened to be in quite some time. This Buttercrust Pizza has opened up literally 150 yards away from my front door. My attempts at proper nutrition, throw it out the window. This pizza is so spectacular, it will certainly be my downfall. But in all seriousness, this is very good pizza. There are a few crust options, but the star of the show is the Buttercrust Square Pan. We tried their main Signature Pizza, the Kickin' Hawaiin (Ham, bacon, and sweet chili pineapple). And wow! First, let's talk about the crust. It is a hybrid of the ever underrated Detroit-style pizza crust and the personal pan pizza from Pizza wHut. Put them both together, and you have this Buttercrust pizza. But the crust has more of a depth of... butteriness, if I dare say that. I can't explain it. You'll just have to try it for yourself. Maybe I'm just super suggestable. The toppings on top of this magnificent crust were perfect. Too many pizzas have heavy topping density in the center of their pie, and then it tapers off near the edges. Amateurs. The topping distribution was absolutely even on every single one of the nine slices here. Professionals. And the toppings themselves were great. The ham was thick and square and in your face. The bacon was very present and added a little smokiness to the whole thing. And the pineapple was everywhereee, adding that needed sweet heat to every bite. So grab your favorite slice type, corner vs edge vs middle, and chow down. We also had the Spinach-Artichoke Pinwheels (Cheesy pinwheels rolled up with marinara and pepperoni). These were awesome! Cheese bombs with a hefty amount of spinach and artichokes. It added that greenness I didn't think I needed from my cheese bombs. Yum. Overall, I'm currently looking at moving. I stare out my window at night now, yearning for more. Delicious pizza. The best I have had in Seminole County. I've already been twice. Will keep going. read more

See all

Pros: This restaurant is a 5 minute walk away from my front door, that's a major pro. Lol. It's in a food hall, so if you are going out with friends, and some of them don't want pizza, they'll have other options. They'll want this pizza, though, because it is absolutely amazing. The best pizza in Oviedo. They also had great sounding apps, like the spinach artichoke cheese balls we had. Cons: There are no cons. Not a single one. Tips: Get the Kickin' Hawaiian pizza, and get it in a square! read more

Buttercrust Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Oviedo, Florida

See all

In my opinion the buttercrust square is the best food item at Oviedo Food Factory! It's honestly probably in my top 2-3 of pizza I've ever had! Everything about the crust and cheese is all goodness. I'm going to give them a 5 star but my only downside is that the pizza is expensive. A full buttercrust just cheese is $20 but the ones with toppings are almost $30. But OMG it's good to splurge every now and again on it. They should offer this pizza by the slice. And the fact that you get the atmosphere of that the Food Factory gives I would recommend on a Friday evening. read more

Buttercrust Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Oviedo, Florida

See all

Pepperoni pizza was good but wings were awful. They were clearly old and were simply reheated to the point of being dry and tough.

We had lunch here today. We ordered at the kiosk and they brought the food out to our table. We got the meatball sub, meat personal size square pizza and the bianca personal square. The food was delicious. I want to try the other micro restaurants nearby too. read more

See all

Amazing thin crust! The lady behind the counter was super sweet. Remembered my name every time I came in. I wish I got her name. I don't review places but this place is great! Mostly because of her. read more

We've eaten buttercrust about a dozen times and I'm seeing the attention to quality drop pretty rapidly. A few weeks ago (early May '24) they forgot to notify me the order was ready. Thirty minutes after it was finished they gave me a room temperature pizza. They made a new one, but only after I walked to my car, at which point I noticed the bottom of the box wasn't hot. Today, we ordered this hastily prepared pizza in the picture. I don't want to eat most of my cheese and pepperoni on three slices. On top of having to knock on the window to get someone's attention so I could pay for this disheveled pie. When it's right, it's great. But you've got two strikes. read more

Buttercrust Pizza - Sloppy preparation. - Pizza Near Me - Oviedo, Florida

One of the best pizzas I've tried in Orlando. I loved the Granny's Pretty Mess since it had three different sauces: pesto, vodka, and marinara. The crust was also amazing. Don't forget to order the Cheese Bombs. everything was so amazing and they both had insane cheese pulls. I'll definitely be back for some more pizza. We also enjoyed some cocktails from The Food Factory Oviedo. It was such a cute and fun spot! - Granny's Pretty Mess - Cheese Bombs read more

See all

Britt was amazing she helped me pick a great pizza and was very informative! We had a great conversation as well.

The pizza wasn't made as usual, and I'm buy the same pizza every week. The pizza was super covered with black olives. Then they placed in a box instead what I'd asked for. Just an uncomfortable situation. read more

Buttercrust Pizza - Pizza. The one in the box is the issue. The other pic is from last week. - Pizza Near Me - Oviedo, Florida

See all

This is a new Pizza Joint seated in the Food Factory within Oviedo on the Park. To be honest, I did not know they were even there. I searched for something to eat for lunch and found them - which is surprising because/c I pass the location all the time. The Food factory is a courtyard with several restaurant around it. When you walk in, there is a self-service kiosk to place your order, then they text you when it is done....so that you can sit and wait for it. The screen told us it would be approximately 30 min wait, but to be honest it really only took about 10 min. We ordered a square Pepperoni Pizza. We decided to order it "to Go" sow we could take it to go ear at one of the tables at Oviedo on the park as opposed to the Food Factory courtyard. It was just a bit too loud./ there were not a ton of people there, but they had a DJ already blaring music at 2om on a Sunday afternoon.....that would make sense for the evening crowd, but it was a bit much to Sid and enjoy lunch. ...but the lake is just a few steps away and there were plenty for seats around in that area.....to be honest it was a nicer environment. The Pizza was fantastic. It was a slightly deep dish, nice cheese, and plenty of pepperoni. Definitly Great! It wasn't;t necessarily a cheap pizza - but it wasn't necessarily too expensive ether. The drinks they have here are just canned drinks and were as bit overpriced however,. Overall, a great pizza NSD will be back! read more

See all

Pizza was very good made as requested Service was excellent even though it almost time to close Highly recommend read more

First time to the restaurant and was a bit lost when there was no one to figure out how to order or ask questions. You just order thru a kiosk. The cook came around and we got his attention to answer a few questions. Anyway, once we got our order everything was over done. We got the pizza rolls and square barbecue. Very stingy with toppings and no real flavor. The crust was hard, look old stale bread reheated too many times with butter poured on top. No rush to head back! read more

The pizza is amazing love it thick crust and very tasty. The staff is very good and quick. We are definitely coming back

Deep dish pepperoni is where it is at. Good place to hang out as you can eat in the common area outside or in the bar.

Ordered a small square pepp and sausage. Very sparse ingredients. One piece of the 4 had no sausage on it. Pizza was very comparable to the little Pizza Hut mini's at Target. At about 4 times the price. Maybe they do better at bigger sizes. Will try their crust next. read more

We ordered delivery so take that as you may. but the food was mediocre and very greasy. Prices were okay. not cheap by any means. I probably wouldn't eat here again read more

Pizza was decent last time we were here. Wanted to try it again, but they had to close for 3 hours for a "large catering order." How many pizzas did you need to make to close for 3 hours?? The Arnold Palmer is a great event. Y'all better knock my socks off next time. read more

Buttercrust Pizza - Servers can't even get in. - Pizza Near Me - Oviedo, Florida

Frequent patrons of Buttercrust. Price is good compared to other establishments. Ease of placing order and pickup easy too.

The food is awesome, with gluten and dairy free options. If you order food here, you can sit anywhere in the food factory, including the bar. There are sports playing on almost every tv and the chairs are super cool. read more

This place is amazing for those with food allergies and those without! I have 101 allergies and everytime i come their pizza master Darius knows how to make my pizza to perfection and suggests other ingredients I didnt know they had it just keeps improving the experience! I completely appreciate the crew. Ingredients are super fresh and delicious! I hope you give it a try and enjoy it too. read more

Was in buttercrust on February 22nd (later in the night). Ordered a round pizza and upon eating it, one of the better pizzas ive had in recent times. Chris is a wizard back there, cool dude and great service. If chris isnt the manager, i hope management can recognize him for providing extremely high quality pizza. Should be glad to have him. read more

This is a second location of a budding franchise that has the kind of pizza you would look for with just the right amount of flavor placing it in contention for the best pizza in Orlando category. The service design accommodates everyone from your "cash is king" customer to the digital currency pioneers to order their food on their website or throw food delivery apps/pick up. The place is clean and in an area that is perfect for the community it serves. I ordered the cheese bombs to come with the large round classic 16", the cheese bombs are amazing they have mozzarella stuffed in the dough that comes with a butter and house garlic blend. The pizza itself was spot on and started with cheese as the true test for anyone that loves pizza. The sauce with its flavor and the crust with just the right amount of crunch texture when biting down on. This food was so good I had come back to pick up another order this time putting pepperoni on half the pie. It came a little blackened around the edges of the pepperoni but the pizza still tasted good so good in fact it was gone as soon as it arrived home. This place comes highly recommended. read more

Buttercrust Pizza - Butter Crust Pizza storefront. - Pizza Near Me - Oviedo, Florida

Such an amazing atmosphere! The pizza is delicious, and the staff is so very helpful and great! read more

Buttercrust Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Oviedo, Florida

It was good pizza. Very quick and easy. Nice interaction when we picked up. I think they might sell by the slice so that is convenient if you're walking around and just want a snack. read more

Very delicious. Crispy crust. Definitely worth it. No parking though if you don't live nearby to walk.

Had the thin crust pie. Nice red sauce and fresh toppings! Chris took time to explain the crust choices. Order from the counter vs the app for friendly service. read more

Very good pizza but the sausage and pepperoni had very little toppings on it could've been more for the price