Cancel

Open app

Search

NYPD Pizza

3.8 (10 reviews)
Open • 12:00 pm - 10:00 PM

Order NYPD Pizza Takeout or Delivery

NYPD Pizza Photos

Business Info

NYPD PIZZA ATMOSPHERE

What's the vibe?

You might also consider

Recommended Reviews - NYPD Pizza

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

Reviews With Photos

Dine in
Anika C.

I've always loved the NYPD in wintergarden growing up. So I'm so excited to have one close to me in Winterpark. Always so welcoming and I'm glad I experienced it at this location as well. I wouldn't complain at all about the service . The feel inside gives me a New York Vibe and a pizza joint that makes you feel comfortable. Pizza was on point for just a classic half cheese and half pepperoni. Can't go wrong with the classic tastes. Although we did get some Garlic knots, and the flavor was so good, but I will say a little under cooked. I even took one home to my partner and she had said the same thing. Everything else is always good though and sometimes we make mistakes so I won't say I will never order those again because the flavor was still good. I will return for more New York Style pizza

Kamris C.

First time trying this establishment and it was fantastic. As soon as I walked in I was greeted right away, I had time to look through the menu and the young lady working in the front told me about the lunch specials they had. I decided to go with the two slices and a drink before I headed into work. The pizza was fresh, hot and tasty ! I appreciated the quick service and I can't wait to come back with some friends!

See all

5 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

14 days ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

7 months ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

1 month ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

9 months ago

Helpful 2
Thanks 1
Love this 2
Oh no 0
Photo of Astrid P.
41
62
16

4 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of AV B.
1
101
44

6 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of Hazie A.
291
41
58

8 months ago

Business owner information

Photo of Valerie A.

Valerie A.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

8 months ago

Business owner information

Photo of Valerie A.

Valerie A.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

8 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

Ask the Community - NYPD Pizza

You might also consider

DoughBoyz Pizza - Half Margherita and half bbq chicken pizza

DoughBoyz Pizza

4.2(269 reviews)
1.8 mi
•$$

This has become the place we go to when we want good Italian, yes its mainly a pizzeria. They do…read morepizza great I would say best In the area even! But their pastas are also a must try. I f you would have told me I would be someday ordering Pizza with a side of spaghetti I would have told you: "that makes no sense". But here it makes perfect sense! The staff here feels like they know you, they are cool personal and always attentive. They make sure you get what you need fast and good and check regularly to see how they can make it better. The place itself is as New York Italian as you can get. Two big TVs play random stuff (today was old episodes of the price is right, great show BTW) with subtitles while breakdancing music plays in the background. You can hear the bustle of the kitchen and the occasional laughter or screaming match. The Pizza Perfectly cooked! The Vodka sauce is the best I ever had. Creamy and flavorful with the cheese it just drips!!! addictive! Their red sauce is fantastic just the right amount of acidity from the tomato not too salty or sweet . The Brooklyn pizza is a whole thing. The dough is crunchy and fluffy and messy and the peperoni crunchy and salty. Like I said you must try the spaghetti with marinara sauce even if just as a side its beauty in simplicity form and I had their Chicken parmigiana with the spaghetti and it was perfection. Very generous portion. 10/10 The only problem I keep running in to at this place is deciding what to eat. But I always leave full, happy and with a to go box! "Era tutto buonissimo"

We were going to eat inside but it was a little toasty in there. We opted for to go, which wasn't a…read morebad decision. The dough was very nice. Gave the pizza a really light crust. The chicken buffalo pizza was sweet too. Chunks of chicken were juicy and tasty! I'd eat here again

Photos
DoughBoyz Pizza
DoughBoyz Pizza - Arancini rice balls $7 each

Arancini rice balls $7 each

DoughBoyz Pizza - Half Grandma Margherita, half Lasagna

See all

Half Grandma Margherita, half Lasagna

Lazy Moon Pizza - Slice - Cuban Pizza

Lazy Moon Pizza

4.3(961 reviews)
4.0 mi•East Orlando
•$$

Lazy Moon was easily one of the best thin crust pizzas I've had. The slices are absolutely HUGE,…read moreone slice could easily feed two people. The crust was perfectly crispy, which is exactly how I like it, and the pizza had great flavor. Service was quick, and we got our pizza faster than I expected. The atmosphere definitely has a fun college vibe, which makes sense being near UCF, but I could also see it being very kid friendly and comfortable for families. I also loved the decor, especially the real plants hanging along the walls. It gave the place a cool, relaxed feel and made the space stand out. The prices were very affordable, especially considering how large the slices are. Great pizza, huge portions, crispy crust, quick service, and a fun atmosphere. Definitely a place I'd go back to whenever I'm in Orlando!

Stopped by Lazy Moon Pizza and decided to sample a couple of their enormous slices along with a…read moresmall Greek salad. If you've never been, "slice" is a bit of an understatement here. These things are huge, thin crusted, and unless you possess some serious pizza folding skills, best approached with a fork and knife. First up was Jason's Mom's Slice (JMS): tomato sauce, chicken, sauteed mushrooms, caramelized onions, tomatoes, ranch, Jason's Mom's sauce, and mozzarella. Flavor wise, this was my favorite of the two. The caramelized onions were especially good, although I wish they had been distributed a little more evenly across the slice. My only real issue was the crust had quite a bit of sag. I suspect the large tomato slices placed directly on the crust released moisture as they cooked, making an already thin crust difficult to support. Next was the Meaty McMeatface Slice (MMS), loaded with tomato sauce, birria beef, ground beef, pepperoni, bacon, and mozzarella. They aren't kidding about the "meaty" part. The birria was the star and added a nice depth of flavor, but overall I found this slice a little dry. A side of Jason's Mom's sauce would probably have been the perfect companion, although it comes with an additional $1.50 charge. I also ordered the small Greek salad, which was anything but small. It came loaded with perfectly ripe tomatoes, red onion, cucumber, black olives, fetta and pepperoncini. The menu lists romaine lettuce, but what I received looked and tasted more like escarole or frisee, with a noticeable bitterness. I'm not certain what the green actually was, but it definitely didn't taste like romaine. The menu also mentions roasted red peppers, though I couldn't find any in my portion. I liked the dressing, but the salad could have used a little seasoning. I didn't see salt anywhere around the bar where I was sitting. Maybe there was some near the drink station, but apparently, I wasn't motivated enough to launch a salt expedition. The ordering process is straightforward. Walk in, order from the counter underneath the overhead menus, grab your drink, and find a seat. I asked for water and was initially handed a small plastic cup for the self-serve station. I asked if I could get a cold beer pint glass instead, and they happily accommodated the request. Thank you! A small gesture, but one I appreciated. There is plenty of seating, although the bar stools where I sat felt sufficiently rickety to make me question their structural integrity every time I shifted my weight. Total damage was about $37 including a 20% tip. To be fair, the portions are substantial. I boxed up leftover pizza and salad and finished them for breakfast the following morning, so there was certainly plenty of food. Still, for two slices and a small salad at a counter service pizza joint, the final tab felt a bit steep. Overall, some very good flavors and gigantic portions with a few execution and value issues. Jason's Mom won this round, although next time I might ask her to go a little easier on the tomatoes. And yes, giant cold pizza for breakfast remains one of life's underrated pleasures.

Photos
Lazy Moon Pizza
Lazy Moon Pizza - Combination

Combination

Lazy Moon Pizza - Counter area showing their beer choices.

See all

Counter area showing their beer choices.

Seby's Pizza - Half Cheese "Brooklyn classic" & Half The Nolita

Seby's Pizza

4.8(67 reviews)
2.5 mi

A great local NY-style pizza place that uses good ingredients and makes everything nice and fresh…read more I did also really love their beverage fridge - which stood out to me. So many options! This is my husband's new go-to place. He's been dropping by once a week since we discovered it!

I might already be known as the Pizza Connoisseur, but there is so many places I have needed to…read morevisit. I was in the mood for New York style pizza. Just all around wanting no big frills but a plain pepperoni slice. Yelp had led me to Seby's. I placed an online order on a Friday night for an 18 in pepperoni pizza and garlic knots. Once I got to the restaurant, you can tell they are all about the New York vibe. There was all sorts of New York photos and really cool was the New York live stream of someone walking around. We had to wait about 15 more minutes from when it was supposed to be ready but it was a very busy night. Which to me was a good sign. The owner was friendly speaking to many in the front waiting area. Let's get to the food. It was just what I had been craving. It was so delicious would a good amount of pepperonis. It was thinner with great flavor. The crust held up the pizza without being too crisp. We ordered the 18 in but it was SO MUCH PIZZA. For 2 people, I would suggest the 12 in option. The garlic knots were packed with garlic and so yummy. 6 came in an order of knots. Everything heated up amazingly in an air fryer the next day. I have since been back again. Thanks for the great food.

Photos
Seby's Pizza
Seby's Pizza - GARLIC KNOTS

GARLIC KNOTS

Seby's Pizza - Provolone triangles

See all

Provolone triangles

Mister O1 Extraordinary Pizza Oviedo - Maria - Mozzarella, arugula, fresh tomatoes, Prosciutto di Parma, Italian parmesan

Mister O1 Extraordinary Pizza Oviedo

4.5(117 reviews)
6.0 mi•East Orlando
•$$

Finally got to try this place. Ordered a Star Luca for carryout. Ordering online was easy. Parking…read morewas not an issue. Order was ready within about 20 minutes. Only stranger part was them having me sign after paying online for my order. The star luca lived up to my hopes though. I got it just as it comes. It was very good. The ricotta was so light. The salami had just the right kick. Tomato sauce was good and the basil was a nice compliment. The crust is very thin so it didn't hold up to the weight of the slice itself. Which, isn't very heavy, but made eating it a bit awkward. All in all it was really good and I look forward to trying out some other items.

I really wanted to love this place after hearing so many good things, but unfortunately, our pizza…read morewas a bit disappointing. I ordered the Special Vittoria pizza, and my husband ordered the GF veggie pizza. Both were extremely thin, but mine was also burnt and black on the bottom. At around $20 for a 13-inch pizza, I expected better quality and value. On the positive side, plenty of free parking, even on a Friday night! The person I spoke with over the phone was friendly, answered all my questions, and our order was correct. We ordered takeout and didn't try any of their Extraordinary Pizzas, appetizers, or desserts, so I can't speak to the rest of the menu. I'm still undecided about returning. Maybe dining in would be a different experience.

Photos
Mister O1 Extraordinary Pizza Oviedo
Mister O1 Extraordinary Pizza Oviedo - STAR BECKHAM

STAR BECKHAM

Mister O1 Extraordinary Pizza Oviedo - Mushroom pizza

See all

Mushroom pizza

NYPD Pizza - pizza - Updated October 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...