The service was amazing, the people here are really friendly and patient with first timers. They…read moreanswered all of my questions about the menu. You can tell this place is good because there was a line outside the door when we arrived. Inside it's the typical deli/ began shop. A lot of options. The bagel I had was the rainbow bagel with the birthday cake creamcheese. It tasted like a cupcake. The bagel was so fresh and soft in the inside. It melted in your mouth. I definitely will be visiting this place again. Especially since I see they have a location in Boca Raton Florida which is very close to me. Highly recommend!

Stopped into LIBC for a Sausage, Egg, & Cheese on an Everything Bagel. The breakfast sandwich was…read moregreat! Eggs were cooked nicely and the bagel was soft and tasty. It was super busy there the day after Christmas, but the service was still nice and quick once I got my order in. The parking lot is a bit chaotic, but that's just Long Island for you!

We came here as a quick stop leaving families house from out of town. Very cute place lots of…read morepeople in and out that seem like regulars so we were excited to try it. We had a bagel egg and cheese sandwich and a bagel with cream cheese. We enjoyed them both! They had plenty of other treats too but we didn't have time to dry them sadly. Next time. Thanks Terry!

This bagel shop is so nice and clean. The bagels here are always consistent and fresh. They always…read morehave a nice variety of assorted bagels and cream cheese. The service varies from some days being very fast to some days being extremely slow. I'm not sure why. They have deals on the white board when you walk in. The staff is always friendly .

The classic LI bagel shop. Their everything egg bagels are so good. I usually buy a half dozen and…read moretake them back to the city they last a long time in the freezer.

Fantastic spot! Delicious food and amazing service. Thank you for supporting your community.read more

I ran in to grab a bagel. Been missing Long Island bagels since I moved to CT. Unfortunately the…read morefour kids that were behind the counter were just laughing and gave me meat when I asked for a vegan cream cheese bagel? I paid $13 for two plain bagels and the one disgusting item in the picture. It was so greasy, There were several other people waiting but just one person in charge of each order so there's no way the brown haired girl did this by mistake . . . I would love to live this place but love will set you free . Also they frequently run out of whole wheat everything bagels.

This little shop has a great variety of Bagels and spreads. I like to come in the late morning to…read morepick up an everything with Veggie Cream cheese. There is parking in the back and in the street out front. The bagels are delicious and always fresh. 4 stars because the staff is inconsistent and not always pleasant.

Still great, consistent bagels. Be sure to visit before June ends. Nick (the owner) is part of the…read moreLGBTQIA+ community and does so much for the community. Please support him during this month!

Rather you're on the run or just got done with a double and in need of some delicious sandwiches,…read moreBagel Gallery is your spot to head to for all those late night cravings. Just imagine your local deli but never closing. So that means you can get your BECs any time you want! That's right, they're 24 hours! Bagel Gallery offers some great breakfast, lunch or dinner options it all depends what you're in the mood for. Bagel with cream cheese, done... bacon egg and cheese, some... A little Mobster sandwich action going, DONE! Cappacola, salami, Italian dressing and all the fixing freshly cut bread on a Semolina? Fuggetaboutitttttttt! Stop on by for a Sandi or two! Oh yeah, they're 24 hours and the Lox is still fresh and Smokey !

Ordered a simple bacon egg and cheese on a roll with SPK and hot sauce, they literally gave me eggs…read moreand cheese on a roll with nothing else on it. Tried calling got hung up on now the calls not going through. Will never order here again. If someone wants to call me my number is 607-476-2444

Great bagels. Great egg sandwiches. Reasonably priced and friendly staff…read more Hidden gem of a bagel shop.

Pretty impressed with this deli for the area. There's a lot of flukes around but this is a true,…read morequality deli with variety. Just what we'd expect on Long Island. I recommend going there and picking up food over door dash! They are reliable and have correct orders in store, door dash seems to impede that. Also friendly but they don't talk your ear off and I appreciate that. Hate to update so soon but I just realized they charged me over $13 for an omelette that has a menu price of $8.89

Probably the most expensive bacon egg and cheese I've bought. Place was clean and staff was nice…read morebut nothing crazy that warrants an outstanding review.

Located on the corner of Hawkins Ave and Middle Country Road its good to find a decent bagel shop…read moresuch as Bagelati. They took over a spot which has housed multiple businesses in the past and have done a nice job here. Good staff, clean, and most of all tasty bagels. A variety of bagels and spreads. Coffees and other drinks. Breakfast sandwiches. Gelatos. Really nice decor with an upscale look for a bagel joint. Reasonable prices.

I've always had a great experience here, and so have my family. It's clean, the staff is warm, and…read morethe food is great. Today, I had a sesame bagel with tofu veggie cream cheese. It was delicious! So glad I tried it.

Where do I begin this local family owned Deli right in the heart of Smithtown is definitely a…read morehidden gem! I randomly found it and placed an order over the phone. The customer service was amazing. The owner and his mom were fabulous they were very sweet. They have a cute storefront with a nice bistro table if you wanted to dine in. It was difficult, making a decision on what to eat because everything looked so good. I ended up settling for the barbecue burger, the sun-dried wrap and egg salad. Everything was super fresh and would really stood out. Was it the egg salad was made when you ordered which was a definite, plus! I will definitely be returning and getting all of my sandwiches from here on out.

The best chicken salad I've found in a very long time! Everyone is so nice here, it's the perfect…read moreold school deli. Love it

I was immediately greeted with a smile and waited a short while before making it to the counter…read more Claudio was excellent! My first question was "do you have turkey bacon?" Claudio answered absolutely they have turkey bacon turkey sausage and of course deli turkey. I ordered a turkey BLT with a chamomile tea with honey. He took my order then walked to the register to ring me up. He then informed me my food would be bought out to my seat. Few minutes later, my food arrived after a quick seat at the window seat to people watch. The sandwich was delicious! I ordered the cucumber side salad which was refreshing and I enjoyed the tea/honey ratio. Im sorry for those who had anything other than an amazing experience as I did.

Have ordered breakfast sandwiches from Strathmore on four different occasions and despite what…read moreother reviews have stated I've been satisfied with both the food and service. Granted each time the store was packed but I was able to place a phone order with an estimated pickup time. The sandwiches and omelets were cooked as requested and were well portioned. Prices are competitive with other restaurants although all food retail pricing has dramatically increased over the past few months. Overall a good bagel store worth visiting offering a wide variety of breakfast and lunch options with ample table seating and parking.