Amazing experience! Ambience was great, service was exceptional, and the food was amazing! Large portions, and everything was so fresh. The owner, Billy, was so hands on with helping his staff, and super friendly and welcoming to us. Would totally return when going through Old Forge!! read more

We were recommended this place by extended family so we decided to go here while we were in the area. We called and were able to get a reservation for 4:30 when they opened, which was fine since by the time we ordered and got food it was after 5 pm. The service was good, and the food was very tasty. I shared the hats ala broccoli dish with my mom and we very much enjoyed it. However we were not told that there was a $10 split plate fee which is why I'm deducting a star. The portions were a little small for the price but this is a family restaurant in a touristy town so nothing too unexpected. Overall we enjoyed our meal, and would come back the next time we are in the area. Very small restaurant, so definitely recommend calling ahead if you're planning on dining in. read more

It's a Friday night @ 4:30 the service was slow. My partner said something was bothering him. I found a bug on him. Then I found a bug of some sort on me. The people across from us said they found a spider! Salad was not really fresh. However, the food was fine. read more

One of the best in the area, and definitely the most consistent. Always a very good meal at a fair price. Billy's hospitality is best experienced as sit down. Tables can be tough to get, don't hesitate to do take out! read more

We went there for my husbands birthday on a Facebook recommendation. The hostess was rude. We didn't have reservations but it was 5pm on a Tuesday in August and there were 4 people in the place. I asked for a nice quiet spot telling her it was my husband's birthday. Without so much as a "happy birthday " she said here are the 2 tables I have. Pick one. One was by the kitchen door and 2 more in the middle of the restaurant! You would think they would have some romantic corners for couples since they claim old world italian ambiance. The waitress was very pleasant but also not even a happy birthday greeting. Our food was ok. Nothing special. We took most of it home. Thought they would serve warm bread but no, cold. No reason to go back there again. read more

We made reservations this past Saturday night and our friends were running late and was not gong to make. So we ordered all our diners take out. Thank you for making this happen. As ALWAYS the food was done to perfection and delicious. Thank you again! read more

Food is comparable to Marie Callender's dinners warmed up but without the Marie Callender's price tag. Very expensive for what you are getting. Red sauce and Alfredo sauce taste like it's warmed up right out of a can or jar from Walmart. If you go here due to lack of options, split an entree, the portions are big enough for that and the kitchen will split your dinner for you into two plates which was nice. Service was fine. Ambience was fine. But if I find myself in the area again I would definitely not return and would try any other establishment. read more

We need to eat in Old Forge and I heard good things about Billy's. We did not have a recommendation but we came at the perfect time and were able to be seated almost instantly. I do recommend making a reservation if you come here as the dining room was packed during our visit and it is a small seating area. Service was great. The server was helpful and answered any questions we had about menu items. We had an appetizer of lobster ravioli. Loved this dish. Delicious creamy sauce. Meals came with garden salads, fresh ingredients. Our entrees were huge! We could have shared them. I wish we had a way to save the leftovers but we did not due to our camping set up. Overall would highly recommend this spot. Affordable for the portions you get. Will come back on our next visit to old forge. read more

There's nothing quite like Billy's! The Italian staples are nothing short of perfection! If you love calamari, then please order it here because it will not be overcooked. It will be done perfectly tender and delicious. I always gravitate toward the Penne a la Vodka, but take your pic and you won't be disappointed. There's also a carefully cultivated wine and beer list. Make sure you always have a reservation for both dining and takeout. This popular place gets full every night it's open. Buon appetite! read more

Great food in a quaint atmosphere. Tomato sauce was amazing and the portions were large. Service was excellent. Would definitely go back again. Billy the owner personally greets you and also helps serve the food. I thought that was a nice touch. read more

Billy's Restaurant - Restaurant area - Italian Near Me - Old Forge, New York

Wonderful service. Best shrimp scampi I've had. Relaxed atmosphere and friendly welcoming staff. Definitely need reservations. A very popular place and well deserved. read more

I will never not go here after a trip to enchanted forest. The sauce was everything. My entire family loved their meals.

Was lucky enough to get reservations this past Friday for the 7:00 pm seating. The restaurant is quaint and the food is delicious. Billy made sure he went around all the tables checking on his guests. The portions were quite large. Nice wine selection as well. We come up from Florida to snowmobile every year and will make this a must stop going forward. Thanks read more

The food is great, the service is great, and all the staff is very attentive to your needs. We always have a great experience at Billy's.

I have been to Italian restaurants all over the world and this is truly a hidden jewel. Get there early or you will have to wait for a table. Small, very quaint but great atmosphere. Billy always goes around to every table to see that all is well. Take my word for it and give this place a try; you won't be disappointed. Capt Ron read more

An oasis among pizza and fried food. One of the best meals we've every had and we are big food snobs. The wine was delicious and the food was flavorful. The bread was also amazing as well as the staff. read more

Hands down one of my favorite restaurants I've ever been to. Been coming since I was a kid and actually held the rehearsal dinner for my wedding there! Amazing food (greens are PHENOMENAL), fantastic service, and the cutest little location you'll ever see. Billy (yes, THE Billy) is regularly in making sure all enjoy their dining experience. Also, I am completely addicted to the Stuffed Peppers - only available as a special, but if you see it, GET IT!! read more

We love this little restaurant in Old Forge. The portions were huge and everything we got was great. Definitely make sure you make a reservation to get a spot! Service was great - was in and out in about 50 minutes. read more

Billy's is a very good Italian restaurant in Old Forge. It's a small, intimate 10 table establishment. I had the fettuccine Alfredo with scallops for an entree and the calamari for an appetizer. Food was excellent, portions are large and service was great. Billy sat us and checked up on us during the meal. We used go to Frankie's at this location 15 years ago, it's nice to return there to visit Billy's. read more

The food was amazing but the pricing was expensive but other than that food was good and service was good

Food is always great, Billy is the perfect host, always checking his customers to make sure all is good . Cosy atmosphere, reservations strongly advised. We travel down 22 miles from Raquette lake to have a nice dinner at Billy's read more

Billy's is a very good Italian restaurant in a place you wouldn't expect it to be, the Adirondacks. If you are familiar with Frankie's Taste of Italy, Billy's is in Frankie's previous location behind Walt's Diner in the Fern's Complex. Billy's is what Frankie's used to be - a good restaurant with nice ambiance, friendly waitstaff and reasonable prices. Note: Not trying to slam Frankie's, just preferred it before the move! read more

Billy's Restaurant - a bench outside in the snow - Italian Near Me - Old Forge, New York

One of the store owners recommended we go to Billy's and I am glad she did! It was tucked off of the main road behind Walt's so I probably wouldn't have found it is someone hadn't told me. It was cute and cozy, I loved the patterns on the wall made from corks. Our servers was very nice and attentive. I think she ended up filling our water glasses about 6 times. They had a really nice homemade balsamic dressing in the tale and we got a loaf of fresh baked warm bread with our salad which was delicious. I got chicken parmigiano and my boyfriend got veal parmigiano. We ended the night with hot chocolate lava cake. Everything was so good and an excellent value for what we paid. Plus one of the best parts is the owner was around all night, checking on tables and thanking people for coming in. And he helped his servers out. Any place with such an involved and kind owner will continue to get my business. read more

See all

This restaurant was excellent. We went in on Halloween and the staff was dressed up and very friendly. As far as the food the fresh warm bread was a nice touch. I had hats a la broccoli with chicken and it was amazing. My husband had one of the specials which he also said was great. To end the meal we split a chocolate lava cake which was warm and perfect. Been coming to old forge for a long time and can't believe I just found this place. read more

Billy's Restaurant - Hats a la broccoli with chicken. Yummmm - Italian Near Me - Old Forge, New York

Needed a reservation, but got lucky the night we went and eventually were seated. Good food, somewhat snooty staff, but who knows how their day was going or how diners had been on their shift. I've had bad days, too, so I try not to read to much into that. read more

The best Italian restaurant in OF! Great menu. Always excellent specials. This is REAL Italian, cooked fresh. The place is small so reservations are highly advised. Billy is a great host and will take great care of you and your party. read more

Billy is a great guy with the best Italian around. Perfect date night. Calamari is on point. Sauce is good.

We went to Billy's on the recommendation of friends and one of my customers. Was not impressed whatsoever. I ordered ziti with sauce and a meatball. The sauce was like water, very thin ,it didn't even stick to the pasta whatsoever. The meatball was small like something would buy in a grocery store and reheat.. the ziti was good. I had a salad that was awfully small for an Italian restaurant and there wasn't much to it and they only offered blue cheese crumbly and their own vinaigrette. The bread crust was hard as a rock and wasn't warm. My son had chicken parm which was very small pieces and hardly any pasta under it. Now if you know a good Italian restaurant you know they don't serve it that way. They were turning people away at the door because the place is so small and people we're told 2 hours? I would have recommended them to go to Frankie's down the road it certainly is a far cry more real Italian than here. I just don't understand the people's obsession thinking this place is so wonderful in the reviews, it was nothing like they talked about. Maybe there's another Billy's in Old Forge and I was at the wrong one? One other thing that was very disappointing is that they do not take American Express? but I pay a large membership fee too own that card. I don't understand the thinking in this age and technology.. it should certainly be a convenience for the customer especially traveler's. The small bar across the street on the rooftop takes American Express that is a definite place to visit. read more

Billy is fabulous and everything on the menu is wonderful! Always a wonderful experience. We lucked out having Billy wait our table recently! read more

This is hands down the best food in the ADK and can't beat made from scratch Italian food. The owner is the most genuine guy I've had the pleasure to meet, hardworking white collar man who makes sure your satisfied at all times. Great prices for the portions you receive. A MUST IF YOUR IN THE OLD FORGE AREA!!! read more

Always love coming here. For those that know the local scene, the story of Billys is a bit "scandalous" if you ask me. Nonetheless, the food is always excellent. Lobster ravioli appetizer is clean, well constructed, and tasty (especially in the garlic cream sauce). The house bread and salad dressing are bomb. For those that like vinegar dressings, youre blessed here. Chicken Mama Mia entree is awesome for those looking for a good "taste of the place." The house red sauce makes everything taste good, and goes well with the cheese blend they use. Billy himself is a pleasant guy with a positive attitude. You will certainly enjoy your meal!!! Would have considered 5 stars if the bathrooms werent as weird...the small/unclean space is a bit wiggy for me. Also, the Chicken Mama Mia was a bit mushy. While this is just a personal taste of mine, i dont like my italian food spanked with red sauce. read more

Just ate here on Friday night. The level of service at this establishment stands above the rest in the region. Warm fresh bread is served with a cozy and welcoming atmosphere. The basic dinner salad was so-so, but eh whatever-I'm not a big salad guy. The food is great though. I had a chicken pesto pasta special that was phenomenal and huge! You won't leave this place hungry. The waitress then came by with a dessert plate, full of cakes and cannolis which are really hard to pass up. The meal at this restaurant was the saving grace to a rainy wet weekend in Old Forge with nothing else to do in the offseason. read more

Walked in on Sunday at 4:30pm. We waited 10 minutes before we were even acknowledged. I assume the guy that met us at the door was the same rude individual referenced in other reviews....presumably the owner. We were a party of two. There were a few tables available along with some seating in the small bar area in the front. When we asked for a table, he said 'Try coming back around 7pm....' WTH!?! He didn't offer to take a name or anything......... If that's the caliber of customer service that Billy's offers, I prefer to spend my money elsewhere.........No thank you!!! read more

Billy's is awesome. Like another commenter or two have said, it's in Frankie's former spot in Old Forge, and it features Italian food that's almost as amazing. Having been a Frankie's guy for years now, I was reluctant to saying I liked Billy's as much, but I've been there twice now, and although it still doesn't quite stack up, the chicken riggies are excellent. But the sauce? Oh. My. Goodness. read more

First time visit to this establishment, and let's say I will definitely be back. The atmosphere was quiet, neat, and clean. The staff was very kind, and helpful. The food, wow. The food was great! The size for price was great! We ate there, and brought home enough for another meal. Also got dessert to go, which was amazing!. Great job done by all!!. read more

The lobster ravioli appetizer is a frequent and must have special. I have a friend that refuses to waste any of the sauce, gleefully soaking every last bit of it up with bread. Expect rich flavors, ample leftovers, and a full stomach. The environment is warm and intimate. It is a favorite among locals. Billy, the owner is one of the most chivalrous people I have ever met. Your chair is magically pulled out, and several times my elderly dinner companions had no idea how they got their jackets on so fast. read more

I loved the Crab Scallop Cakes my daughter would say that you could tell they were made with Love. Was very surprised how good all the food was. Place was packed everyone seemed to know the owner. The whole staff seemed to work as a team to make sure that we were happy. read more

See all

So glad to see Billy's open. One of the finest Italian eateries east of the Mississippi. Great people, service and awesome food. If you have a negative comment about this establishment, you may want to think about staying home and cooking. Keep up the great work all. We will see you soon. read more

If you are planning a trip to the area reserve your table in advance. This year we made sure to do so and it was worth it! Everything was made from scratch, portions were reasonable and so was the price. The food was on par or better than that you would find in Little Italy. Best Alfredo I've ever tasted (my daughter shared her kids meal). Vodka sauce well seasoned you can mop it up with made to order fresh Italian bread. Seafood was of excellent quality and cooked well. Give this place a try you won't be disappointed read more

Billy's does it every time ! Excellent food and great service. I am always so impressed with the quality and portions, and with the excellent friendly service. Billy always comes around to be sure everything is excellent -- and it is. THIS PART is for other diners to read: When you're in a small restaurant, like Billy's, do you really have to literally shout across the table at each other? You're two feet away from the person you're shouting at. ... Indoor voices, please. Be considerate of other patrons. read more