Decided to grab some food while spending time down the way at Sisters Cider. We ordered online and walked over when we were notified it was ready. There was a friendly face behind the counter when I walked in to pick up at the cute little shop! The pizza was so delicious, happy to try a fun order with the grinder, wish I could try more! read more

Bene Pizza - Grinder pizza - Pizza Near Me - Bainbridge Island, Washington

Great pizza. Perfectly light. Crust was crispy and chewy. Quick service. Highly recommend.

Solid pizza! Quick service and great flavors. Will be ordering again. We ordered while pulling into the harbor on the ferry and it was ready by the time we drove up. read more

Hands down great service! The guy inside was so friendly. We ordered the spinach pizza and it was delicious. The crust was so light and tasted amazing. This place is for take out or to sit outside. They have five little tables and benches. We ate outside as the weather was perfect. read more

Bene Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Bainbridge Island, Washington

See all

The pear, caramelized onion, Gorgonzola and walnut was chef's kiss. The Spinach pesto was also good. I also got a bottle of wine that paired well with the pizza. read more

Bene Pizza - Half Pear, Caramelized Onion, Gorgonzola and walnut and Half Spinach & Ricotta and Pesto. - Pizza Near Me - Bainbridge Island, Washington

My boyfriend and I were looking for a quick meal to grab before waiting for the ferry. Bene pizza was so accommodating with rushing our order. The food was also very delicious! We got the fennel pizza and pear salad. The both the pizza and salad was a pretty portion size. I thought the vanilla vinaigrette on the salad was pretty interesting. Would definitely recommend coming here and checking them out! read more

Bene Pizza - Pear salad with vanilla vinaigrette - Pizza Near Me - Bainbridge Island, Washington

See all

We ordered two 14" pizzas: pepperoni and margherita. We ordered online and the ordering process was simple and straightforward and we received notice that our pizzas were ready on time. Both were decent. We especially liked the marinara/tomato sauce that was used. It was very flavorful (with garlic). The crust was just okay, but we would consider ordering here again. read more

4 stars. Could have been 5. The pizza was excellent!! Well balanced flavors. Perfectly seasoned and perfectly cooked. Loved it. Would come back again! However, the mixed drinks were a struggle to get down. And for being that it's a $12 drink it should have been much better. Order the pizza, forgo the mixed drinks. read more

The pizza is by far one of my top favorites in the area. Their gluten free crust is great and the sauce and toppings are even better. The service is quick and the ambiance inside is cool. However there is no seating inside so keep that in mind. As you need good weather as you'll need to sit outside. read more

Outside seating only, as this place primarily takes away. Two pizzas, Brussels sprouts, tiramisu & a cider was right around $100. The pizza was good, pear/Gorgonzola and a pineapple/sausage. The Brussel sprouts were tasty, but the portion served a bit scant for $14. Tiramisu was rich and flavorful, not too heavy on alcohol. The group agreed, we would all come back here for more tasty eats. read more

This little place makes genuinely delicious pizzas and has a few beautiful tables outside for a pleasant and fairly private meal. I love the Fennel pizza. It's so unique and fragrant and delicious. Their house-made sausage is excellent. The pepperoni, if you have kids along for the ride, is very good. And not that you have to be a kid to love pepperoni either. read more

I ordered pickup on a Sunday. Online ordering was a bit finicky, and I was disappointed to not have a clear way to get delivery. I ordered a prosciutto pizza and the other was a margherita. They both looked nice but I was disappointed to have them not be hot by the time I got home. I'm three minutes from this hard to find location and I left home as soon as I was notified it was ready. Small location, so they only do takeout. With summer weather they have a few tables tucked in along the sidewalk outside but nowhere to sit inside. Looks like they partner with Island bite for delivery but I wonder how much colder my food would be if I had not gone directly to home. Two pizzas and two salads was expensive. At least it gave enough food for an additional small lunch the day after for each adult. The pizza was honestly better the second day. I am going to keep trying other island pizza restaurants before I come back to Bene. read more

Visiting from out of state and stumbled on Bene Pizza. It's a to-go or eat outside establishment only but the evening was gorgeous so it was a win to eat out on their patio. We ordered the pear salad, Greek pizza, and buttered noodles. Everything was delicious, huge portions with great quality ingredients. We thoroughly enjoyed all three meals and had plenty for leftovers. The gentleman taking orders was friendly and personable. I would highly recommend this pizza/pasta/salad place if you find yourself in Bainesbridge. read more

great pizza, but to bad it's now only takeout . There was a time when you were able to be seated n waited on inside, and it was really nice

Good pizzas. Great pasta and excellent salads. They can make the salads vegetarian by removing meat. Huge portion sizes. Outdoor seating. read more

Fairly underwhelming. Tried the Gorgonzola & Pear / Funghi pizza - altogether just didn't taste all that special; seemed like it didn't amount to more than the sum of its parts - tasted rather like cheap goat cheese, very plain/thin crust, and the candied walnuts weren't all that great as noted by other reviewers. I appreciate that they keep a 50/50 option on their menu though. Despite being a "Gorgonzola" pizza the primary flavor I was tasting for most of it was just mozzarella, and the chevre was the dominant flavor of the "Funghi". It just feels like the food here might be more about seeming special than tasting special, as is unfortunately common here on Bainbridge. It wasn't terrible, I'd eat it again, but it's near the bottom of the list of places I'd order a pizza from on Bainbridge, even if I specifically wanted something fancy. Just not worth the price. read more

Bene Pizza - Gorgonzola & Pear / Funghi - Pizza Near Me - Bainbridge Island, Washington

It has been awhile, a few years since we have ordered from Bene. We loved it when Mark was the manager but felt that it slipped a bit afterward. I'm so happy to have gone back! Take out and delivery only now, at least for now- but the increased focus shows in the food quality! We had a 14" half SMO, half house. It was ready in 20 min, fresh and delicious. So happy to have our favorite take out pizza back. read more

Great pizza. They used to have dine-ins before the pandemic. A bit of waste since it has a charming deco with a pretty bar.

We ordered the caesar salad and fennel pizza to go on Saturday and while we waited for our order we got their moscow mule and black manhattan and sat on their patio. The food and drinks were amazing! The pizza was just spicy enough and the dressing on the salad was top notch! read more

Bene Pizza - Moscow Mule and Black Manhattan - Pizza Near Me - Bainbridge Island, Washington

See all

So you need this pizza in your life !! Authentic and wonderful ! It was our first time and we sat outside and enjoyed a bottle of wine and chilled. read more

See all

We ordered a couple pizzas from Bene last night, a thin crust with toppings and regular pie. We've lived on the island for 11 years and wanted to try something different (our go-to has always been That's A Some and T & C flatbreads for pizza). *We did try Bene once before when they had a deal going on a few years ago, but thought maybe because of how overwhelmed the staff was fulfilling orders, and that they were all teenagers making the pies --that was why the pies were not that tasty. Our second go at Bene pizza wasn't any different. We were unimpressed and confused about the four star rating. The sauce is bland and the crust flavorless. My husband said it reminded him of frozen Totino pizzas he ate as a kid. The kids said "meh". No one will eat the leftover slices, so it was a waste of money. Also, the service wasn't friendly when I picked up our order. read more

Almost didn't even see this place. Very easy to miss if you aren't looking for it. But, when you find this place you are going to like it. It is very small, limited seating, but the food is excellent. I ordered the Bolognese and it was delicious. Thick and rich and stuck to the noodles just like it should. I ordered to go and it seemed like a really small box. How could they fit a meal in there? When I got back to my hotel room across the street I began to dig in. There was actually a good portion in that box. After a 14 hour day of work, that hit the spot. Thanks Bene. Very good.. read more

Bene Pizza - Bolognese to go. Delicious - Pizza Near Me - Bainbridge Island, Washington

A MUST TRY!!! can't say enough about this place. The owner, Drew, is spectacular. He made us a caprese salad Upon request that was out of this world with the perfect amount of salt and a tad of brown butter. The gluten free pizza was the BEST I've ever had! Stood on its own, not a hint of soggy to soft, and was amazing. The prosciutto and asparagus was super yummy. The tiramisu was Out of this world good and the caramel Hilario was yummy as well. I can't say enough about this place. I wish it was local and I could eat here weekly. If I were a Bainbridge local I'd eat here regularly. read more

See all

Pasta is incredible! Mushroom Alfredo is some of the best I've had. Very fresh and tasty! However, wine choices are too high for the quality...two reds which were both barely drinkable. But I scored this on quality of food only. Outside seating, pick up or delivery only. read more

We ordered the pepperoni and pear gorgonzola. Both were delicious, the pepperoni they use is amazing. Our only comment is that they put too many walnuts on the pear gorgonzola. We placed our order 30 minutes before they closed and had our pizza ready for pick up in 20 minutes. Will order from them again. read more

Honestly one of the worst meals I have had on Bainbridge Island in 2 years. The pizza was flavorless, under cooked, and a mess (see the pic). $113 for cold sh@# ass pizza and an asparagus app (which was decent), rip off, yes. Honestly this was voted "Bainbridge Best" Pizza??! read more

Bene Pizza - Cheese all over the place, more was on the box than the undercooked pizza. - Pizza Near Me - Bainbridge Island, Washington

We just stood in line for 5 minutes waiting to have our order taken. Another gentleman walked in, cut us in line, asked about his to-go order, and was helped immediately. I get a feeling that the restaurants on this island have poor ratings because the customer service sucks here. Snoby and stuck up . I recommend calling ahead for reservations on weekends, or just take the ferry to Seattle. Better food and better service. read more

What a gem! Tucked away from the downtown Winslow beaten-path, Bene Pizza is worth the trek to Island Village (think Safeway/Rite-Aid area). We dined here on a chilly fall night; it's a tiny place with a cozy bar, inventive pizza & cocktail menu. So glad they are now serving lunch, & thriving after 6 years in biz. Eager to dine outside when Mother Nature allows! Bonus: ample parking! read more

Love this place. Great crust and pizza and the owner lets you customize your pizza toppings! I hate pizza joints that think they know what you want on your pizza better than you and will not let you customize. That's such arrogance. It's just a pizza. Yes we have a couple places like that here. Bene has great salad and pasta too! Wish they would reopen the indoor dining. Seriously it's time already. read more

Best Pizza place I have ever been to! it's the best place to have a good dinner and to hang out afterwards. Their pepperoni pizza is awesome and try their butter noodles because they are great, despite their looks they are delicious (from a six year old). read more

No, no, no! The wait staff was extremely rude. We ordered a pizza with olives. After confirming the olives were not from a can and being blown off by the waiter the pizza arrived burnt and with caned olives. It's was also over priced as per Bainbridge standards. read more

Showed up in person to order a pizza, no recognition for 10 minutes. left.

We've eaten here a few times and love it! The topping combos are really inventive and all of the toppings are fresh and clearly prepared in house (no pre cut veggies from a bag here) they have gluten free crust options are are able consistently accommodate to my no cheese requests with flawless execution. read more

I am literally sitting in the restaurant right now and couldn't wait to add my review. This is the place I wish was open right by my house. The staff is so friendly and fun! The pizza is stunningly great. It's a thin crispy crust, so you Chicago deep dishers stand back please. The house salad with the basil vinaigrette is the best I've ever had. Freshest greens and yummiest dressing. Cant wait to come back!! Edit: still here and time for dessert. Gelato!!! Chocolate or caramel? CARAMEL!!! So great! What a lovely night!! Thank you Bene! read more

Walked in to order. Asked for help and was told they would be right with me. After 10 minutes another customer walked in, asked for his order, was given service and checked out while I continued to stand in line. Will not be back, do not recommend. read more

Stopped here while on vacation. The food was excellent and the staff were very friendly!

More than spectacular pizza. If you have the chance to visit their dining room, they have an excellent wall display of record albums. And they offer more than just pizza. Their additional items are were the entrées of their own. read more

Promise a pizza in 30 minutes. Received pizza in 1 hour and 10. The pizza was good but not worth the wait. I'll try another location next time. Updated review: Ordered a 2nd time. I was late to pick up my pizza this time and they kept it nice and hot! Great customer service and genuinely nice people. If you going during peak hours, expect a wait but overall a wait well worth it. read more

My wife and I relocated to Seattle five months before our visit to Bene Pizza. As a way to get out of the city and celebrate successfully moving 3,000 miles away, we decided to spend a long weekend on Bainbridge. We didn't really have any plans other than to see what the island had to offer and decompress. Out of the meals we had, Bene was by far the best. It might have been that we were enjoying dinner and a bottle of wine outside during a warm spring night, but good on them for providing the opportunity. The outside patio is actually a few tables wedged between two buildings and next to a parking lot and yet that didn't seem the matter. The food was better than I expected. There were good tomatoes in the caprese salad, which is fairly preposterous in the state of Washington. The pizza, while I can't remember the specific type, was also inhaled by my wife and I. The bottle of red wine was warm from being in the boiling hot restaurant but the lead waiter happily took it away and chilled it for a bit. Our waitress seemed very new at waitressing in general, so I don't hold that against the place. All in all a quality experience. read more

Outdoor seating only. Amazing selection of pizza and appetizers. Pizza was so good! Some didn't agree with the walnuts. Nice selection of drinks. Friendly staff. Must try. read more

Bene Pizza - Pear gorgonzola Walnut pizza. - Pizza Near Me - Bainbridge Island, Washington

See all