Out of towner visiting close friends and I talked about how hard it was to come by blackberry pie, even though they grow all over Texas. We were actually on our way to the Spirit Halloween store on Bell and she pointed out Belmar Bakery, see if they had anything I wanted. Wouldn't you know the first thing I saw when I came in was a baker's rack of ready-to-go pies, and they had one blackberry pie left! Snatched it like I was the first customer at a Black Friday sale. Understand, where I'm from, a lot of restaurants have pie by the slice, so I was taking a big leap of faith on a pie I may not like. I'm happy to say I wasn't disappointed!! The crust was solid, slightly buttery and smooth without the soggy bottom you usually get from fruit fillings. Disclaimer: if you get blackberry pie, you also get blackberry seeds in the filling. And I didn't mind! The filling was enough to balance out the crust, creamy--not watery--and tart like it should be (so many bakeries add tons of sugar to get rid of the natural tartness). AND it held up over the course of a few days rather than begin the slow crumbling and mushiness like a lot of fruit filling pies. I enjoyed it so much I bought another one the morning I left to come back home, I don't know much about the rest of the baked goods there (my 4 stars instead of 5) but I wouldn't hesitate to go back and get another ready-to-go pie of any kind if they're as tasty and well made as my blackberry goodness. I have no pictures because I ate it all. :) read more

This is meant to be an informative review. Not one that is shaping any hate and discontent to the local bakery; but rather just to share a disappointed experience. I bought a small cake for my child's birthday , and after cutting the cake, at first bite the cake was dry. I've bought a cake with this business before and it was delicious, which is why it was not a questionable choice to choose this bakery again. The baker did claim it was baked on same day of pick up, but it does not taste as if it were. I did call to report the disappointment in the product and the manager was not disrespectful but well mannered. Just hoped it would have been a better experience. read more

Belmar Bakery & Cafe - Bell St - Slice of cake. - Bakeries Near Me - Amarillo, Texas

See all

Prepaid for rolls. Stale ones proffered, and I refused them. They did give me a refund, but clearly their quality has severely declined. Will not return. read more

I had rarely gone here over the years, more into breads and bagels. Plus can't do milk. But my husband and 2 friends had gotten danishes, turnovers, cinnamon buns here for their coffee talks in our home. One just recently passed away, so my husband asked me to get a few items here. Very disappointed. New ownership? Mostly cookies and over-sweet sweets. Icing on scones? Some items looked hastily made. Girl, only other human there, was very pleasant and seemed to apologize for lack of selection. This is not the busy place it used to be. That speaks of like opinions and observations. read more

This place is difficult to review. I used to love this place - especially for lunch but it's just not the experience it used to be. I've never liked their cakes. There are better bakers in town for those. We love their Beirox - but we struggle with getting what we want - rarely do they have what we want .. one time they pulled one from the freezer and it was not good. I like their cookies - not because they are fabulous - they taste like my childhood - small town bakeries where I lived used these same standard bakery recipes I guess. I definitely like them better than Crumbl! I don't know that I've ever been impressed with their service. I usually feel like I'm bothering them in order for them to do their job. And it's always been that way. It's kind of cozy in there but can get loud quickly if there are many people in there at the same time. read more

I needed a last minute German chocolate cake for my Dad's birthday and Belmar got me taken care of! I called ahead and told them the situation, and they let me know they would get it all packaged up nicely. It was waiting for me when I arrived and I paid and headed straight to dad's house. The process was simple and quick and I'm glad they were able to make it happen. My dad loved his German chocolate cake! read more

Belmar Bakery & Cafe - Bell St - German chocolate cake - Bakeries Near Me - Amarillo, Texas

See all

Fabulous! I've been craving sausage rolls for a while, and they did not disappoint! The lady was very nice and patient, she gave us our sausage rolls in no time. There was lots of space inside for eating, and the inside is very peaceful. read more

Belmar Bakery has the tastiest treats and just plain food of any restaurant in this area. Sandwiches are absolutely the best. Cakes are always sweet and creamy and beautiful!! Don't forget ....their reputation for delicious cookies in several varieties is legend. I use them for about every event that happens in my store and at home. Cynthia Allison read more

They don't have gluten-free items. So disappointing since it came up under gluten-free bakeries in Amarillo. Otherwise, I'm told everything they make is really tasty. read more

Went for a cheese Danish. That is what I told the girl while standing in front of a case that said danish. She gave me something akin to a cinnamon roll with a blob of cream cheese icing on top. The center was completely raw. So disappointed. Usually their overpriced products are good. read more

I ordered cookies and pies for Thanksgiving and Christmas to take to Dallas. Everyone enjoyed everything from Belmar Bakery !

Cupcakes were old, dry and tasteless! I will not trade with this bakery again! I'm disappointed every time!

I spent $34 on a dozen assorted sugar cookies for our Bible study tonight which I will never ever do again. They were horrible! The cookies were hard, tasteless, and the frosting tasted like pure sugar, was crunchy and had a horrible taste. I went there for lunch five years ago and it was horrible. I thought I would try again, after five years, but no change unfortunately. Here's the thing, I just live a few blocks away. I just wish it was a good place like it use to be. read more

I fell in to a food coma last Thursday eating here. Easy to find. Lots of parking. Coming in its very welcoming. You order your food at the counter. As we sit to wait, we were brought out little cinnamon roll cupcakes that just dissolve in your mouth. So good! I ordered the turkey bacon avacado sandwhich and made it a platter. This huge sandwich came out, the jalapeno soup was so creamy, mac & cheese and a snickerdoodle cookie. I could only eat half of my sandwich. And then as I am stuffed. They brought out a free dessert. Chocolate pie with the flaky crust and light cool whip. I want to eat here all the time now!!!! read more

See all

Get the cream cheese frosting on the sugar cookie! I haven't had a non-grocery store cookie in months and that cream cheese frosted sugar cookie was amazing. SOFT frosting, soft cookie. I'm mad I only got one. We bought 5 Halloween cookies and 1 cream cheese and spent $15. Yikes! I would have bought more but I was paying in cash. Also we got there around closing and the server was very short with us. Umm it's not yet 6 pm- technically you're still open and all you need to do is reach in and grab a cookie- not like I'm asking you to make it from scratch. No need for the attitude. In the COVID world we're in now, we are trying to support local businesses but some of these businesses don't want our business. Ok rant over. Great cookie, hard to find location, if Franks was open we would have gone there. read more

Always the cutest cookies and best tasting! I ordered science themed cookies for birthday party gave no other direction. They were perfect! The staff was polite when taking my order and when I picked up! read more

Belmar Bakery & Cafe - Bell St - Bakeries Near Me - Amarillo, Texas

Buyer beware!!! Bought a dozen cookies and a few cinnamon rolls, they seemed old so we called up to the bakery to talk with a manager. Got ahold of the owner who told us he has been selling old goods for YEARS without issue and for us to "shove it" and "f-bleep ourselves" when we had issue with them selling old stuff. Loved their assortment but I guess they have an assortment because the keep stuff on the shelves for days, or in our case--from Saturday till Monday and sold it for full price. read more

I got their macarons and they were delicious I almost ate an entire box in one sitting. They are a good price for the quality you will get and they even added curbside delivery which is perfect for the hard times the world is going through. The workers are so kind and understanding I am absolutely going back. read more

This place is great for a gathering of any kind. I always enjoy it. No matter what you choose to eat, it will be delicious.

I was looking for an alternative to the chain cupcake stores in town. My wife and I went on a Saturday afternoon. There was a decent selection but not too extensive. I got a cup of coffee which was awful unfortunately. It had probably been sitting out for hours. My wife got one of their chocolate cheesecake cupcakes which quite frankly just wasn't any good. It had no taste. And was just bland. Staff were friendly and engaging but I don't think we'd be back. read more

Stopped in moments after finding out my wife and I are having a girl. The Belmar crew hooked us up with an on-the-spot recreation of a cake, placing question marks in blue and pink on the outside. We had a reveal-the-gender party that night. When my wife sliced into the cake everyone screamed when they saw the pink (strawberry) cake beneath the frosting. It was a blast! Thanks to Belmar, we had the cake fast! Also, the cake tasted incredible!!! Highly recommend Belmar Bakery! read more

I grew up on Belmar Bakery Princess Bars for Christmas and many other wonderful creations from there. I haven't been there in many years and wasn't sure if it was still as good as I remembered. We had a 50th anniversary party for my inlaws and I decided to order a cake from here after I saw one they had online that was beautiful. I was hesitant to order blindly over the phone but I didn't have a choice being in Houston. So I asked the young lady on the phone if they could do a sheet cake instead of the tiered cake I saw online with the white on white piping and gold bow in Italian Cream. I went to pick up cake on day of the party and opened the box and was blown away by how beautiful and perfectly elegant this cake looked. They even put sparkling sugar across the top. The cake was delicious and everyone ooohed and ahhhed over it. Ya'll knocked it out of the park!! Thank you!! I can't wait to go back and try your cafe. I spied some cookies that were too cute! read more

The breakfast here was really good...the quiche was so light and fresh... Cute tiny banana nut muffin on each plate... I got a side of fruit and they gave me a REAL fresh fruit cup (see pic). I would of given 5 stars but there were flies in the pastry cabinets. read more

See all

We stopped in early AM to pick out some things for a birthday gift. We found some tasty macaroons, some colorful artisan jellies and the service and attention that we all hope to find. Great job Belmar! read more

Cakeland? More like FAKELand! My 20 and 23 year old daughters ordered a cake for my Birthday and were treated in a condescending manner. They had specific requests: chocolate with raspberry filling with a butter cream icing. When my husband picked up this tiny(!) cake 3 hours later, he was assured it was just as my daughters ordered. First problem: it was small, but a bit tall for a standard box. We were traveling 4 hours to celebrate the birthday. Some poor sucker had to hold it on their lap THE ENTIRE WAY. And later that evening when we cut into it-it was some crappy leftover stale white on white cake. Gross and pathetic. Shame on you Belmar for being condescending and supercilious. Try Ms. Piggy's or Cakes and More. read more

OMG!!!!! I have been coming to Belmar for several years. They always get it right. I am extremely satisfied when I pick up. Great job!!!!! read more

Belmar Bakery & Cafe - Bell St - Bakeries Near Me - Amarillo, Texas

Very friendly and great food. I have gotten countless cookies and food there. They have jams, breads, a bakery, as well as a deli. I have never been disappointed with their service. They are worth a visit read more

I recently purchased a birthday cake from here and it turned out exactly how I wanted. I told them I would like a fiesta them with bright colored flowers. They helped me choose the correct size and assured me that it would feed 30 people. Well, they were correct because it just the right size. The cake was a hit at the party that was in Lubbock and we recommended everyone to stop by the next time they visited Amarillo. They were even nice enough to lend me a cake stand for our party and return it after the party. I will continue to purchase all of my cakes from Belmar Bakery because of their excellent customer service and quality of cakes! read more

I've always used this bakery, I ordered cupcakes 2 doz, @ 33.00 a dozen expecting these big beautiful cupcakes and received these little 2 inch high cupcakes. Sooooo disappointing and they were just average tasting. Get your cupcakes somewhere else, I do love their decorated cookies read more

This is a nice little bakery that serves a variety of baked goods. They offer beautiful decorated cakes for any occasion and they have a deli that serves simple sandwiches. The desserts are very good and the service is great. The cakes are so beautifully decorated and they do some really unique ones. Perfect time to pop in is at the holiday's because they have themed desserts for the season. read more

belmar is always usually great when i go into stores however whenever any time i get a pastry at roasters, which belmar supplies, they are always raw. almost every scone i've had has been raw, the blueberry muffins are always raw and then i got a peach danish and right under the peaches was RAW DOUGH. this is absolutely not okay and could lead to someone getting sick. i don't understand why you guys put so much into what goes into your display cases at the store but absolutely have no care for the people and company's supporting your business. read more

Belmar Bakery & Cafe - Bell St - raw dough under the peaches in my danish - Bakeries Near Me - Amarillo, Texas

If you could deliver to San Antonio, I would love it! I snagged a box of cookies before we drove home and they are wonderful! If I shared, the people are lucky. We also ate at the Cafe, which was great too. Thank you for re-creating yourselves to keep up with today's clientele. You still provided the expected "yumminess" of my youth. read more

I ordered some cookies for an event at work a few weeks ago and went by the store to pick them up. Not only were the hand-decorated cookies adorable, they were delicious and stayed fresh for days. The cafe section is also a winner - with soups, sandwiches, salads, and desserts. I walked out of there with my 24 cookies, a delicious sandwich lunch box, and 2 cupcakes for a coworker and me. All were superb and I can't wait to go back! I definitely recommend Belmar Bakery for birthdays, holidays, lunches, or just a sweet treat/ read more

The bakery was good, decent tasting food. BUT the customer service was disappointing. The minute I walked in with my family there was a blonde girl packing cookies who had the nastiest look on her face. Anytime I would look up at her the dirty looks wouldn't stop.. don't know why they were so rude. Made me want to leave without purchasing but I really wanted to give it a shot. I have warned all my friends/family coworkers who were interested as well in this place to beware of the customer service. read more

As always Belmar is fantastic. They are a little more expensive but the quality and the service is the best in town. I have never had anything that wasn't just amazing from them. We were in a pinch for a dinner that came up last minute and they were there to help! read more

If mediocre is your thing, then this is the place for you. Our first visit will unfortunately be our last. I ordered a birthday cake and went with a safe choice of vanilla and chocolate with buttercream frosting, since they had no samples of their cake. (This should've been a red flag, because had I tasted it, I would've never ordered). On pick up day, I could have excused the child's coloring book artistry (I was initially told they had very talented decorators), had it been good. The cake itself was fine, but the pseudo-buttercream frosting was terrible. It was not a classic buttercream frosting, it was just not good. After our event, we had 1/2 of the cake left over, and NO ONE wanted any (which is saying something, being a household of sweet & pastry lovers!!), so I scraped off all the frosting, and made cake pops with the leftover cake (and my own frosting). What a waste of $70. read more

I needed something for an office birthday recently, but I stopped by too early and they weren't open yet. They opened the door anyway and finished topping 3-dozen fruit kolaches, so I could still make it to work on-time. OMG! Who does that? Amazing service! The box lunches are a nice change of pace (love the turkey cranberry on cranberry bread). We tried that bierox-thing (pastry, meat, and cabbage), but it took a lot of mustard to make it palatable to me, even though I've heard others rave about it. There is a little 'Ace of Cakes' kind of cake shop at the back of the store. We didn't notice that until our second visit and we haven't tried it yet, but it's good to know, for the next time we have a special occasion to celebrate. read more

I've been going here since I was a child. I loved it then and I love it now! I still go here for a surprise treat for my two boys, I will always order cakes and all the other yummy treats offered. Never have I been dissatisfied. I will continue you to come here FOR EVER! read more

I feel like I just left my grandma's house. There is something for everyone here. They even offer gluten free bread for breakfast sandwiches. I tried the breakfast burrito and I have a feeling the eggs came from a chicken pen out back as it was delicious. My family had the breakfast sandwiches and everyone was happy. We loaded up on bakery treats, melt in your mouth fudge, and of course a souvenir mug. Glad we found this passing through town. read more

We had an employee leaving and wanted a red-velvet decorated cake for him. Belmar Bakery did an excellent job on the decorations: they were perfect, and the cake was so moist and delicious. It is sad to lose someone you have worked with for years, but Belmar Bakery came through and helped us show how much we had enjoyed working with him. I would recommend Belmar Bakery to anyone who wants a special decorated cake. read more