They were super friendly and greeted us as soon as we walked in! It is a very small place but comfy booths are available to dine in! We went during lunch time during the week so not many people! We chose the deluxe!! It was pipping hot (just how I love it!), cheesy, crunchy pepperoni and tasty, the crust was delicious!! We chose well done read more

Bella Nonna - Bella Nona menu - Italian Near Me - Tavares, Florida

Another perfect pizza pie, Greek salad, garlic knots and hot honey wings!! The staff is friendly and the food is delicious:) read more

Bella Nonna - Chicken Pesto Pizza (16") - Italian Near Me - Tavares, Florida

See all

Nice little pizza joint out of the main business district. Just a few tables inside this little storefront pizza/Italian restaurant, but definitely a good choice in the Tavares area. We got an antipasto salad and a pizza. The salad was plenty to share and featured generous helpings of deli meats and cheese. The pizza had a nice crust with a crispy exterior and chewy interior. Service was friendly and attentive. read more

Updated review: we now live within delivery range of Bella Nonna, and the overall taste and texture has improved since my review 3 years ago. The sauce does not taste as sweet as before. It's definitely our go to for delivery in our area. read more

Great salads and pizza we continue to go back there will venture into trying there other items but for now Pizza and Salad are really good!

When college roommates in up in North Carolina and Mississippi, you meet for pizza in... Florida? Bella Nonna is great little restaurant off the main roads. The pizza was delicious. It was a tad difficult to get a drink refill. But it was a busy night. Also not the easiest place to have a private conversation because of the small space so I wouldn't say great for date night but if you want to grab a pizza and go, this is the place. read more

Bella Nonna - Large pizza. Good even when I flipped it onto my plate and all the toppings came off. - Italian Near Me - Tavares, Florida

AMAZING pizza. Came all the way from brooskville Florida for a pie well worth the drive

Always a great experience in the food is perfect. Excellent that's pizza in Tavares. Pizza hot crispy just perfect.

Hmmm...Dominos or Bella Nonna? Easy, BN. Pay a little more for really good pizza. The crust is the way it should be for a good pie.

Take out pizza Supreme was wonderful!!! Fresh ingredients with thick layers of veggies, meat, and great cheese- crust the best/ brick oven crunchy and elastic- we will be back read more

I go here almost every tuesday after my prenatal appointment for 2 slices and it's usually amazing however today was a huge disappointment. Me and my fiancé got two slices each and asked for 2/4 to be crispy. We got our pizza and the slices looked cooked but as soon as i picked it up let alone bit into it, it was super doughy, and made me sick. I couldn't even finish one slice. The slices are usually big but today they were like regular slices from a 16inch pizza. I hope today doesn't stay like this here forward. read more

Nice little outta of the way place Very family owned establishment (atmosphere at least) Didn't try the pizza this time but enjoyed the sandwiches Pepsi (no coke) They deliver (7mi radius) I'll return read more

See all

Pepperoni pizza for takeout was not good. It's the second Italian restaurant recommended by Italian friends since moving to Florida. It's a pizzeria with a few tables. I guess if you don't know good food it's okay. read more

We heard good things about this place and decided to try it. We ate in the first time and enjoyed the antipasto salad which was loaded with meats. The meat lovers pizza was good, but over salted for our taste. So, our second experience was with takeout. I ordered pepperoni pizza with regular crust. When we opened the box at home, it was obviously a thin crust that had been over cooked to the point of being burned on some edges. The crust was like a cracker , the cheese was way over done. If we had been eating in the restaurant, we would have sent it back, but we were all the way home, so decided to make the best of it. On top of every else, the pizza was so over salted that we ended up throwing some of it out. First time in my life I put leftover pizza in the trash! This should have never been sold. I'd rather wait for a few minutes than have a terrible pizza because someone left it in the oven too long. The only reason this got even two stars is that the salad was good. My advice is, check your order before you take it home. Better yet, eat in so you can send it back if it's not up to par. read more

Best pizza in Lake County. The sauce is not sweet, plenty of cheese. Cooked to perfection. The garlic park chicken wings are sooo good, meaty, crispy and moist. You can't go wrong with the antipasto salad. read more

Amazing pizza place! I love the pizza here! Have not only ordered, but also sat in with family before. Met some nice employees that were great, service was nice and fast. Whenever we order, the food is nice and warm, no matter what. A small restaurant at sight, but truly a great restaurant inside. Easily a 5/5! read more

Hands down the best pizza in Lake County. I absolutely LOVE the crust. Usually I give my crust to the dog, but not if it's from Bella Nonna. The sauce, cheese amount, toppings, everything is perfect. read more

The Buffalo Chicken pizza was amazing! The crust is probably one of the best crusts I've ever had! read more

Bella Nonna - Buffalo Chicken Pizza - Italian Near Me - Tavares, Florida

Food was delicious and service was extremely good. Great little place to eat and enjoy.

Wanted something closer and different. That was exactly what I got! There was no ambiance because the place was small, and my undercooked food was to go. Service was fast, too fast!.. My pizza was very undercooked and greasy. I won't go back! read more

I've only had delivery from Bella Nonna and it's never been anything less than amazing. The Buffalo Chicken Pizza is my favorite and a close second is the Meat Lovers. This is not cheap pizza but it's a great value and you can taste the quality in every bite, no one here says - "better ingredients better pizza" but certainly they aren't making this level of pizza without shelling out some dough on the good stuff. I've must have ordered multiple pizzas here a half dozen times - the pizzas arrive piping hot and the driver who has always been the same is friendly, polite and professional. If I'm in Tavares and eating pizza Bella Nonna is making it... read more

See all

What a place. The wait staff are great and deserve a pat on the back. Thank you. However, the cook is arrogant and can not admit to a mistake. Our pizza was so overcooked that it was more a dried out cheese topped burnt cracker. Cook had the nerve to tell us it was exactly how a NY pizza should be. I don't think so!! Growing up in NYC, I know what a NYC pizza should look and taste like. Rated a 2 only because of the great wait staff. read more

Always 5 stars!! Service is amazing and the food is great. Highly recommend . The white pizza is one of the best in the area .

I love Bella Nonna. The food is just like a NY Italian pizzeria. The service is excellent I go as often as I can. Check it out.

We came here on a whim visiting from out of town. If I lived here, this would be my go to pizza joint. The unassuming appearance in a strip mall and industrial area should not deter you. The server who worked the phone, cash register and tables was super friendly and accommodating. Bonus for me they make an outstanding GF crust - they do run out a call ahead. I did and they saved one for me, sooooo lovely and kind. read more

You MUST try this Italian restaurant! This is the closest you will find to New York pizza in lake county. The owner is from New York and makes amazing food. I go to this establishment once a week (my cheat day) and it's ALWAYS amazing! TRUST ME this is freaking amazing! read more

Bella Nonna - Cheese pizza - Italian Near Me - Tavares, Florida

See all

This is in a little strip with nothing much nearby and might be easily overlooked if you didn't know it was there. The dining area is small, with about 8 booths and a couple of tables. I went at lunch with my mom and we each got a lunch special. Serving sizes are good and food was tasty. Pepsi products for soda selection . The server was attentive and food came out fairly quickly. They have a few beer options, all bottles nothing on tap. I will be back. read more

See all

Interesting little spot in the middle of nowhere Central Florida (you probably know that already) This place is in an industrial strip mall. Happened to stop in for lunch before visiting with a customer nearby. Was surprised at the quality of food they are serving up, which was very good! I orrdered a side Caesar with the lunch portion of lasagna. It was all delicious. With a drink I paid a little over $15 out the door. Go, check this place out. Especially if you're local! read more

Bella Nonna - Lunch portion lasagna was hot and tasty! - Italian Near Me - Tavares, Florida

Awesome first impression! Grace was excellent guiding us through a great menu! We decided on Bake Ziti and Lasagna. Both meals were excellent! Just right size and garlic rolls were very good. We will be back to try a pizza!! Well we tried pizza on a take out order and just as pleased with it! Awesome place, good food and friendly staff. Good job Bella Nona! read more

First time here. My husband and I got side salads, which were good (I got Caesar and he got House). Since I'm keto, I just got wings and they were pretty good. My husband got the chicken parm sub. The bread was crispy, chicken was fresh and tasted great. We will definitely be back to try more food. read more

See all

Pizzas were very good. Only complaint is we called to pick up pizzas at 11:45. When we arrived to pick them up they had not been put in to bake yet, so we did not have time for our athletes to eat during their lunch break. In hindsight I would have stressed the importance of pickup time when placing the order read more

Hi I always order the calzone here. It is excellent. The portion size is generous. I recommend this Italian style choice

Before I review the food I must say that our server Pascal was excellent. Now for the food. I had cheese steak, mushrooms and wings. All of them were very good. The sauce was OK. If they add a little sugar to the sauce it would be excellent. Right now the sauce has a s strong tomato taste. Still good though. read more

Pizza was delicious ! I usually don't eat half a pizza, but when I do I'm hungry in a few hours all over again. I ate the slices at 5pm and stayed full until breakfast. Hearty, fresh ingredients make a world of different than your average pizza chain. I'll definitely be back again. read more

Well, I'm absolutely shocked at the good reviews for this place. We decided to try a couple different pizzas, based on the good reviews. Well, sadly, it was one of the most disappointing pair of pizzas we've had in quite a while. We found the pizza crust to be tough, rubbery, and over done. I don't think the dough was fresh. Both pizzas were light on topping, including cheese. Considering the price vs quality, I highly doubt we'll ever return. read more

Went to Mary's and they were closed due to a passing storm which led us to Bella's. SO glad this happened, the food was great!. The garlic knots were great, so was the pizza, wings and the Philly Chesesteak. Will definitely visit again when back in the area. read more

I'm disgusted with your service! No one answered your phone so I ordered thru number sent me, arrived and you said you don't have an order! Your customer service stinks! read more

Pizza was extremely thin and non flavorful. Your dough on a scale of 1 to 10 was a 2 and your sauce Is a 1. Step up your game Bella Nonna

Great home made Italian food great Pizza, garlic knots, & pizza rolls. Sandwiches are usually good as well. I have only give them 4 stars because I think some of their items are over pricey. 3 small meat balls with cheese cost $7. Their dough tasters fresh & home make. Not sure if the tomato sauce is home made? read more

Pizza reminded me of the great pizza back home in Connecticut. Meatball sub was delicious and bread was toasted to perfection. Our new go to for Italian! read more