We were told about this place from a coworker, so decided to make the drive to check it out. We were NOT disappointed. This was great classic Italian American food. The restaurant was very nice and clean. The staff was super friendly. And the food was hot, fresh, and delicious. We got the garlic knots to start with, as one does at a pizzeria, and WOW the loads of garlic... loved every bite. Vampires will stay away for weeks. The lasagna was hot and bubbly. That sauce was terrific. Meat sauce is the way to go for sure. Tasted like my moms and I enjoyed every bite of it. Dipped garlic knots in it too, as one does with sauce. Overall, great little place! There are more things I want to try, so until next time... Arrivederci! read more

See all

I have been to just about ALL of the Pizza Restaurants in the area. Tony's is the absolute best Pizza available. Others are good, Tony's is the best, period. You can't beat them. The only thing that they could do to improve would be to allow green olives as an option. I have only been to one Pizza Restaurant in my life that offers them! I would pay extra for them! Tony's is very clean, the service is great. I love Tony's! read more

Great customer service! My first encounter with this establishment was on a Saturday afternoon when I went in randomly based off of the billboard I saw. New to Lake County, I didn't know where to find a good pizza. When I entered, I asked if they had any specials and they had the two pi one topping special. I went ahead and got that along with 20 wings. I wasn't sure what kind of wings to get and told the employee what my taste was and they let me sample several flavors. Everything was delicious and I will definitely be back again. read more

Tony's Pizza & Subs - Pizza Near Me - Eustis, Florida

See all

We ordered a pepperoni and a deluxe pizza for carry out. The pepperonis on the pizza were really good but the pizza itself was mediocre. The crust was bland and dry. I would possibly try one more time with eating in the restaurant but I'm not sure it will change the taste of the pizza. read more

Take out calzones, anti pasto salad, and eggplant parm were fresh and homemade/ excellent in every way- large portions/ for 40 bucks it was enough for 4-6 people! read more

Tony's is great find! Awesome service from the staff. Dad and my wife got a pepperoni pizza and I got the House Calzone. $2 difference to go from small to large. It was 2-1/2 meals for my wife and I. Large is huge with great sauce. We got the Greek salad and the 2 garlic knots came with it. Lots of garlic. You won't be disappointed by this "hole in the wall" Italian restaurant read more

Tony's Pizza & Subs - diners sitting at tables - Pizza Near Me - Eustis, Florida

See all

We've been to Tony's four times and each time, the food was excellent and the service was friendly and attentive. Their garlic knots are outstanding and the portions are more than generous. I love the stuffed shells Alfredo and my husband raves about their meatballs and meat sauce. We will be back very soon. read more

Tony's Pizza & Subs - Stuffed Shells Alfredo and Riga Tony with Meatballs & Sausage. - Pizza Near Me - Eustis, Florida

First time customers, will be back...ordered delivery pizza and was not disappointed! Deelicious, filling and hot when it was delivered. We will check out the rest of the menu soon!! Delivery was right on time, and driver was friendly! See you soon! read more

Absolute garbage customer service herr! If you are the manager and see this please work on that. The pizza is okay ON A GOOD DAY. Not something to write home about. There have been.. about 2 or 3 times that they have messed up my order entirely and then refused to give me a refund!!!. The last time I called to place an order they flat out refused me because i wanted to pay with cash and not over the phone. To any one who has not tried this plsce yet do not give ut a shot. There are a ton of better pizza places around with better customer service!! read more

Two very rude men at the togo register the other day. I walked in and they were both on the phone so I patiently waited. When each of them got off the phone, they looked at me, no hi, no hello, nothing.. just turned around and started working on something else and the other one waited a few seconds and answered another phone call. After waiting for 5 minutes, a nice lady asked if i was being helped and I said no. The men there clearly need some kind of customer service training because that experience made me not want to go back there. Sucks because I'd like to call tony's my go to italian place but I refuse when the staff is rude. Side note, two guys were arguing with what seemed to be a new employee about how much cheese to put on an item. He berated the poor young man in front of all the customers in the to go area. Treats customers like trash and clearly treats the employees even worse. Maybe that's why the men had such a stank attitude. I wish I had something positive to say other than the lady who finally helped me being nice but I don't. read more

The Bianca pizza OMG. This is the BEST Bianca pizza I've had yet! It is the perfect combo of cheese, garlic, and ricotta! #ChefsKiss The Club Royale. Ask for the honey mustard on the side and get an extra one. This isn't bottled honey mustard. It's LEGIT! That sandwich makes you feel like Royalty! Tony's Pizza & Subs - you get a 10/10! read more

Mandy and Wanda were the best! Always great to eat here, food is good, staff is exceptional. Always a pleasure to eat here. Kudos ladies!

Thank you to Wanda and Mandy for awesome service! We thoroughly enjoyed our pizza (The Spicy Grigliata) and Greek flatbread tonight!! Always enjoyable here. read more

Will green pizza was delicious , if you were hungry before walking you'll get a blast a pizza as soon as you walk in. A homey location with great service. read more

Tony's Pizza & Subs - The wild green - Pizza Near Me - Eustis, Florida

Not the same since they changed ownership. Just like Dominos. Overpriced and poor quality. read more

Food was great as always and so was the service Mandy and Wanda were on top of everything I never had to wait for anything I needed. Definitely the best pizza place in town! read more

The best in terms of food and service! Would highly recommend. Thanks Mandy and Wanda!

Steak calzone is exactly how a Calzone should be! Hand tossed pizza! Delicious! Hospitality plus and very clean! read more

Tony's Pizza & Subs - Small Calzone! - Pizza Near Me - Eustis, Florida

See all

I called Tony's to order food for my mom's 80th birthday surprise party about a week or so in advance. Catrina was so sweet and helpful when placing the order and following up the day of to confirm everything. She was so pleasant. She also helped set up delivery which was a blessing for sure. The young man delivering the food was equally as nice and personable. For 22 people we ordered from the catering menu: 36 garlic knots, large Greek salad, large lasagna, large lasagna blanca and 2 tiramisus. Let me just say it was way more food than we needed but I wanted to make sure we didn't run out. That was so far from being an issue...so.much.food. The Greek salad and rolls are regular items for us and were amazing as usual. Both lasagnas were fantastic! The tiramisu is a must for dessert and it's truly the best there is. Just get it! Most of our group was visiting from the northeast and they all raved that this was some of the best Italian food they'd ever had. They are still talking about it the next day!! Thanks Tony's for making the day even better than expected! read more

Just wasn't good. We had pizza and the crust wasn't good, sauce wasn't good,pepperoni was good but wont go back. Many other better options.

the Biancha Pizza was delicious and our server Mandi was amazing. They have a great lunch menu for the price.

Everything is great, and they have the best homemade 1000 island dressing ! The pizza was tremendous

Awesome food. Great service. Sandwiches are fantastic. Nice people. Don't miss the cannoli!

Tried Tony's pizza & salad and loved the experience! Pizza was fresh tasting with an incredible sauce. Salad was also fresh & very large...enough for two to share. Place was packed and now I know why. We will be back read more

Tony's has been one of my favorites for years! The food is always delicious. It can get very busy especially on the weekends but the service is friendly and consistent. The restaurant is small so we get take out more than eat in. The calzones are very good but our go to is the fried pepperoni pizza! The Greek salad is one of my favorite. Everything they serve is fresh and tasty. You can't go wrong. read more

If you want the best chicken wings in town...They're the absolutely the best. I've tried many others from all over town, and nobody makes them as good, in my opinion. read more

Tony's Pizza & Subs - Garlic Parmesan Chicken wings. - Pizza Near Me - Eustis, Florida

Been eating Tony's pizza for over 20 years not anymore went there. Ordered a pizza. Yesterday was the worst pizza we ever ate nice Black ring around the edge of my crust one big gallon of grease soggy in the middle can definitely tell you it's different people running the place read more

New owners have ruined this place, very sad. Don't waste your money. What a waste of time new owners have downgraded ingredients flavor, and the restaurant as a whole. won't be back. read more

Been going to Tonys for years.......Had'nt been there in awhile but went last week, not happy with the extra large pizza burnt on the bottom and soggy on the top, Meatball sub used to be the best but now with new owners its much much smaller. Not happy....and can honestly say I wont be back! read more

We have been going to this establishment for several years and food is consistently delicious! We especially enjoy the barbecue bbq flatbread, any of their pizza, antipasti, lasagna read more

Fabulous Extra Cheese Pizza cooked to perfection and the cheese was yummy gooey. Baked garlic rolls with olive oil and garlic to die for. Our waitress and several staff members were attentive and compassionate! I even went by on my way out of town for dessert read more

We have frequented Tony's for years but since the change of ownership the quality and portions have noticeably decreased overall.

Pulling into the parking lot I was skeptical... luckily my husband is very persistent and insisted we try it. AMAZING food! Very friendly staff. The coconut crusted chicken salad was absolutely delicious, so was the pizza and garlic rolls. Definitely our new 'Go-To' for comfort pizza night! read more

My husband and I have been going to Tony's for 25+ years. We go once a week and eat the same thing every time. New owners took over within the last year. In the beginning they said nothing was going to change with the menu/products used. WELL...let me tell you that was a lie! First they changed the sub bread, then sub size and salad size then they went to "cheaper" sliced provolone cheese they use on their subs all the while raising prices a little at a time.The cheese is AWFUL! It has a strong sour taste. That being said we asked for them to put a different kind of cheese on our sub because that cheese they now use ruins the taste of the sub. Tonight when we went in for our weekly meal they decided because we asked for a different cheese on our sub they charged us an additional amount for our sub!! Regardless of the amount charged it is WRONG! Asking for extra cheese I can see being charged but just asking for a different cheese definitely not! I don't know if I will return there or not after all the years we have enjoyed eating there. I hope the new owners realize they will not retain customers doing things like this. By the way I spoke to the manager and she stated that one of the owners was there and they would not allow for the charge to be removed. Great way to treat faithful customers! read more

We absolutely love Tony's pizza the crust is just right the pizza is not greasy the garlic knots are delicious. The cannoli and carrot cake is yummy nice family owned place read more

Visited Tony's Pizza & Subs for the first time this evening, I went with a good friends who lives in the area and has visited before. You can tell it's a mom and pop type of joint, which I love to try those. We walked in at about 4:30 (Saturday) and wasn't busy at all, we were greeted and Seated right away. We wanted to start with a cup of their lobster bisque, but they only do bowls, no cups, so we figured we'd split a bowl to kinda make a cup each, but did quite work out like that. The lobster bisque was served in two of their regular size bowls which weren't that big, and the amount of lobster bisque was very little. The soup was not as hot I'd like it to be but the flavor was definitely on point! I ordered The 44 Flat and it was everything I expected and more! The flatbread was toasted just right, and all the toppings fit in perfect together, so glad I chose it! The flat break was a good size too, My friend ordered 8" Jerk Chicken Sub, and that was also delicious! It was the perfect size and alll of the ingredients meshed so well! We also ordered a slice of their brownie cheesecake for dessert which was recommended by the server and goodness it was definitely worth all the calories that thing must has! It was such a perfect finish to our delicious meal! I don't live near Tony's pizza but I will definitely visit again when I'm in the area. read more

Tony's Pizza & Subs - 8" Jerk Chicken Sub The 44 Flatbread - Pizza Near Me - Eustis, Florida

My first time to this rather nice little place and man it was great! I've eaten in nice Italian places all over the beautiful USA and Tony's has put many of them to shame! We ordered the pepperoni pizza, Tony's rigatoni with meatballs and sausage, the wife had the stuff shells. Everything was superb! The garlic bread with fresh garlic and olive oil are to die for a must have! We are staying in the area for a couple months and will be back for sure read more

Good ma and pa Italian food. Great garlic rolls. Fair prices. Nice menu Good service. Fast take out

I really love this place.. The garlic knots are Amazing.. The pizza is really good.. It's really close to where I live and have not been disappointed by their food.. Keep doing what you are doing.. It's great!! read more

I eaten better frozen pizza. Not sure how they call it a pizza place. We have tried the pizza twice and both times just blahhh.