3/6/17 early dinner. We were the only people in the restaurant when we arrived though throughout our meal, a few more groups came to eat in and a couple folks arrived to pickup carryout. There is a half dozen booths, another half dozen 4-top tables and a bar to sit at. We sat in a booth. The seats were an little tired with some cracks and tears but the place is clean. Our waiter Dawson was very friendly. He asked if we had ever be there and we hadn't. He's words "you are in for a treat". Throughout the service he was attentive and kept our sodas refilled. We ordered a medium with pepperoni, sausage and mushroom pizza. I loved the crust. It's a thin, crispy crust. It's my style, for sure. The toppings were plentiful. I am not sure why their menu says us New York Style. It certainly is not the chewy, fold over, saucy pizza I've ever had in NYC. We will certainly return when we are in Eustis again. read more

The Great Pizza Company - Medium pepperoni, mushroom and sausage. - Pizza Near Me - Eustis, Florida

We just ordered a pizza to go. Brought it home for dinner and this was the worst pizza we've ever had. The ingredients tasted bad, like moldy cheese. Barely any sauce and overall just horrible. So disappointing, we will not be back. read more

If you never been here, go before god calls you home. Best pizza in central Florida. Gpc special is amazing and the burger pizza will make your mouth water 4 days later wanting it again. read more

Stopped in with a friend for lunch. They have about 5 tables outside but they were all taken so we ate inside. It's small but cute. We each got a small salad. The server got confused twice on my friend's salad, but it did come out correctly. The salads were average tasting. We paid in cash and she kept the change (cents) for each of us. Financially that's not a big deal (56¢ and 36¢) but it's the principle. She didn't say she was out of change or anything. Seemed very odd and presumptuous. I'm not sure I'd return. There's a much better place around the corner that I prefer. read more

The Great Pizza Company - Greek salad - Pizza Near Me - Eustis, Florida

Pizza was great and appropriately priced however the service was horrible. The server was very short and rude to me and my friends never even asked what we wanted to drink. Fast food had better service than this place. When we paid my friends were never handed back their change I'm guessing our server assumed that was a tip? Still a weird and rude assumption. Overall this restaurant is nothing special ( not counting the dog ) much better place around the corner will not be returning. read more

Good pizza, nice clean place, plenty of variety. Came on got fresh pizza in no time. Service exceptional.

I love supporting local small businesses and always try to buy from local family owned businesses when I can. I looked forward to trying this pizza even though the $30 price tag was a little daunting. Unfortunately this was the worst pizza I have ever had. And not just bad, but it was terrible. I would've preferred a frozen oven-bake. We ordered a large pepperoni with double pepperoni. The crust was hard and chewy indicating the dough was likely left to rise for too long or sat in the fridge too long. There were parts of the pizza that were not sauced, yet the edge near the crust had large clumps of sauce. We ordered double pepperoni, paid for double pepperoni, yet the pizza had the same amount of pepperoni as their Google photos. The "garlic" breadsticks did not have any garlic on them and only a smidge of Parmesan. Our kids who typically love breadsticks each took a bite and didn't want anymore. We tried to stay positive and eat the pizza, but even the kids remarked that it was terrible despite our best efforts to be positive. I hope this company consider revamping how they cook their pizza, or perhaps we just caught them on a bad day. read more

The Great Pizza Company - Parmesan breadsticks which were advertised to have garlic (they didn't). - Pizza Near Me - Eustis, Florida

See all

Great Caesar salad, excellent pizza. Quick service. Good music and energy in the place. Thank you Great pizza Co. read more

Absolutely love this place in Downtown Eustis! The food is delicious, the service is friendly, and the vibe is really inviting. It's a great spot for a relaxed meal out. Don't listen to the negative reviews! read more

Enjoyed our first visit to The Great Pizza Co. We sat outside to people watch and there was an awesome breeze as we watched the sunset. Server was very friendly. We had the Greek salad to split with our pizza. Both were great. We will definitely be back! read more

The Great Pizza Company - the entrance to the restaurant - Pizza Near Me - Eustis, Florida

Perhaps the worst pizza I have ever had. Absolute garbage! I ordered a small cheese pizza, took 20 minutes to make...you read that right-20 minutes! It was about 10" across, way over-cooked and dry, and thinner than a saltine cracker. A generic brand supermarket, frozen pizza would have been a vast improvement over this ultra thin trash. And get this...they charge $14 dollars for that disaster! First and last time I will EVER go to this place. Major rip-off, terrible quality. Go to El Marie instead, your wallet and your tastebuds will thank you. read more

While attending first Fridays in Eustis, my family and I stopped here after I selected them in error from a yelp search (it was another pizza place with phenomenal reviews, not this one and I was so mad at myself). Pros: The waitress was nice and accommodating and the pizza was ok. Cons: The owner! We ordered a 20pc and a 10pc wing and requested that they be cooked crispy. Well when they weren't according to our paying customer preference, we shared it with the waitress who apologized and said she put it on the tix. She asked if we wanted to recook them which we declined because they already had sauce on them, so she insisted on send the owner out. And that's when it went further downhill...the owner comes out and we share our concern with her and she says...that is crispy and we literally get into a back and forth conversation with her telling us (the ones eating the food) that its crispy. So I kindly ask, if we come back what should we say if we want them crisper. She says "I wouldn't do it, I am not going to cook wings any crisper than that." Huh?! My husband and I look at each other and say but thats how we like them and she says oh well I cooked them two mins longer and will not go any longer . No acknowledgement of the food not being to our requested preference just arrogance and disregard for the customer. The waitress was so embarrassed by the owner/cook's behavior and kept apologized. The ower was later overheard saying I'm done cooking, the kitchen is closed don't take anymore orders and someone said we're not closed yet and she said she didn't care. It was literally 30mins before their closing time. We will gladly support another local business in the area. read more

We happened to stumble upon this spot as we were exploring the Christmas lights displayed around the town. The restaurant is like a hole in the wall type of place that's very dainty. We had a half meat lovers/half cheese pizza and an order of wings with medium sauce and ranch dressing. They were both great. The pizza was nice and toasty and the cheese they used was rich in flavor, it really owned up to its New York style name. The wings were fried to a perfect crisp and were fresh! The servers were friendly as well, my dad asked if they had any coffee or tea, which they didn't but the waitress offered to heat up some ice tea for him and he actually enjoyed it and warmed up. It was nice to see that she offered some type of solution for him. I would definitely come back and also recommend this place to others. read more

See all

This is a fabulous older building and is spacious and comfy. The lady that waited on my party was phenomenal.Friendly and down to earth and was truly engaged in the customer experience. The pizza was thin crust/crust was good,but pizza itself,not so much. I will go back and try something else as I really did enjoy the atmosphere and the staff. I'm not so much looking to " replace" the pizza experience,but I would like to find a new pizza experience where I feel can be my pizza go to. Once I get back and try a different dish,I'll update this review as I really want to rate higher.Just can't on this experience. read more

Called to put in a order and lady who answered the phone sounded like she did not want to work today. When asked questions about what was on the white Bianca pizza she got irritated. Then she followed with you have to pay on the phone before you can pick up your order. Told her we had the money what did she think, we didn't!?? She said I think you need to call somewhere else and hung up the phone. Totally uncalled for. We will definitely take our business somewhere else. Close your restaurant lady if you don't want to work or take orders! Racist maybe who knows. Calling Mellow Mushroom. Should've done that in the first place. sorry no stars for you. I don't know what's great about your pizza! Had to give one star or I couldn't post. ‍ read more

The Great Pizza Company - Nothing because lady refused to take order and hung up. - Pizza Near Me - Eustis, Florida

I absolutely love this pizza! We love to go and sit outside and just enjoy the lovely atmosphere of old downtown Eustis while eating the best pizza around!! Melissa is a wonderful server and takes great care of us! We highly recommend!! read more

See all

I am truly sorry to post a bad review. First, you have to know I am from Nassau County New York. NYC, including Brooklyn, Queens and Nassau counties are known for New York Style Pizza. Let me describe one for you. The resulting crust is indeed thin and firm so it can be neatly folded from edge to center point, but not wafer thin so it cracks upon folding. The edge must have raised at least 1/2 inch. It has to have browned blisters. We call that the bone. You eat the bones when you want a treat after eating the pie, or when you order ziti and your family orders pizza. It has to be that good. The pie surface is layered with pizza sauce, not pasta gravy (sauce). It is not a sweet sauce. Next comes the high quality cheese mix. (I'm not a chef, so don't ask what mix!) and oregano or other Italian seasoning. Then the toppings, enough toppings so they touch each other. Even if it is just pepperoni. A slight drizzle of high quality olive oil, including the edge. Not so much that you see puddles in the cooked pie or pepperoni. A high temperature pizza oven is definitely required. The crust bottom has a dusting of semolina flour. I guess it decreases likelihood of burning the crust. Or maybe it's residual from laying dough on semolina dusted marble preparation counter. The pie is done when blisters have formed and crust is browned. By then cheese is completely melted and toppings are baked. Anything else is imitation. The Great Pizza Company makes imitation New York style pizza. The pie edges are not soft, do not have blisters. The bottom is crusty hard like a stale cracker. (The ingredients are not stale). The pie itself is a very small pizza, just a little larger than personal pan pizza from Pizza Hut. The pepperoni is 3 slices per piece. If you come to GPC expecting NYC Style pizza you will not get it. But you will pay more than NYC price! It may be gourmet, but not NYC style. Again, I am truly sorry it was not NYC Style pizza. Was disappointed. Will not return. read more

Sad State of affairs when your pizzas comes burned to an unnatural crisps. We mentioned it to our server. The cook came by to explain that it would be very difficult to cook this particular pizza without burning it o.0 Not going there again. Sorry. read more

See all

The best pizza in the area. Quality ingredients, attentive staff, and quick service. The owner is very concerned with providing a high quality thin crust pizza and she delivered! We will be returning in the future. Nice location with great character located in the Historic District of Eustis. They also serve ice cream. read more

Wonderful! Several of us went for dinner and ordered Thin crust pizzas. Each was cooked to perfection and delish! The fried green tomatoes were excellent as well! Worth a trip to Magnolia Avenue. We WILL be going back. Good read more

I was expecting a good experience here but unfortunately having a Autistic son made it hard to enjoy a pie of pizza it's unfortunate this pizza place is not one to deal good with special needs children and for that reason I will never come back where my son gets looked like he's a spoiled brat but he's not he's trying his best to cope with this mess up world !!! read more

This fad of taking your dog to a restaurant is bad enough, but I walked into this place to look at a menu and the owner has its German Shepherd behind the bar with its fore paws up on the bar. You dog lovers have a ball. I'm never going here again. How filthy. read more

This is probably the only place around here I will ever got to for pizza. The dough tastes like it's made in NY and the bottom is perfectly cooked! The owners are very kind and down to earth, and the restaurant itself is adorable. It's got that real family-owned vibe with neat little nick-knacks, cozy bar and dinning area, and a side garden by the alley way. The service was great, but the food is was really counts! read more

See all

Went in around 8:30 to be greeted by the sweetest dog upon opening the door. The employees only 'greeted' us from behind the counter with an, "excuse me we're closed". No kindness or apologies for closing at least 30 minutes early. Never ate here before and have no intention of trying again after a terrible first impression. read more

It would help if they renamed this "The Worst, Overpriced Pizza Made by the Most Miserable Woman" Company. That is exactly what you are getting when you are foolish enough to come here. Ultra-overpriced "pizza" that tastes like a big cracker with condiments on it. Prison pizza or school cafeteria pizza is probably better. Then you get the bill and think they made an error. Don't dare complain about anything as the Chinese lady that owns it will further insult you with her childish bad behavior. Any positive reviews here MUST be friends of the owner or fake. We no longer will return after consistently getting bad food and a horrible attitude by the owner. If you live out here or are here and MUST have pizza, go get a frozen one at Publix and make it yourself at home. It will be much better and a fraction of the cost. read more

Small and quaint pizza place in the heart of Eustis. Service is great, pizza is a great thin crust with lots of topping options. There are subs and salads if you aren't feeling like pizza. I left one star off just because it could use a little updating with the kitchen/bathroom situation. read more

The Great Pizza Company - One page with sandwiches if you don't feel like pizza - Pizza Near Me - Eustis, Florida

**1/11/2020 UPDATE: I have to say this is my favorite pizza place in the area. We ordered carry out tonight and both the Sausage Mushroom pizza and the meatball sub were very good. The pizza wasn't quite hot enough for my liking As newbies to the area (3 mths) this place wins the prize for best area pizza! I appreciate the fresh ingredients firstly. You CAN taste the difference. We ordered a large sausage mushroom pizza. I also ordered two sandwiches to try... a meatball and the Italian sub. Both were very good! I can say in this pizza desert of Central Florida, this place will not disappoint. We had carry out, so I can't speak to the service, friendliness or much about dining in. I do plan to stop in for a meal and take advantage of the outdoor seating area. Very nice to enjoy for people watching. Stay tuned. , but no biggie ... a warm oven can fix that. Meatball sub was very good... meatballs taste like meat instead of fillers. The sub roll was soft and chewy but firm enough that it wasn't soggy. A bit more sauce or offer it on the side would be my only suggestion. I'm sold on this place! read more

The Great Pizza Company - Sausage mushroom pizza - Pizza Near Me - Eustis, Florida

See all

We decided to try this place on a date night and we were pleasantly surprised! My husband and I love thin crust pizza, not a ton of sauce and creative twists (as long as they are good lol). There are some unique "owner created" variations on the menu and they are delicious! We also tried the pork egg rolls and they were very good. The waitress is always nice and the owner, Sandy, is a gem. She really likes to chat with her regulars and new customers as well. You can tell she cares about her food and her customers. This place is now one of our favorites! read more

Sandy did a wonderful job making our pizza and Aleah did a terrific job of getting our order together. It's amazing pizza with a thin delicious crust! We love The Great Pizza Company! Thanks so much! Buddy & Kathy read more

Delicious thin crust pizza and pork egg rolls. Just what we were looking for. We'll be back for sure. Next time we'll try the wings!

The first night we found ourselves here, it was while out wandering through downtown Eustis looking for something to do after having filled our bellies. We happened by and noticed a flyer on the door promoting "Primo" beer, imported from Hawaii. Hanging out for an hour or two, enjoying cold Primos and engaging with the local flavor, we weren't able to eat there but promised ourselves we'd give it a try after they talked up their crust (shipped from New York). Well, the first two times we tried they'd closed early. The first night we drove out and they had closed an hour and a half early on a Saturday night; the second night they'd closed an hour early. Small town economies let one get away with that more easily, granted, but it's still frustrating. Speaking of frustrating, it REALLY irritates me when any business owner talks down to their employees. Sandy, the owner, came off as being pretty mean. While she was in the building the employees scurried around with a stressed expression, afraid to stop any longer than several seconds to check on our drinks. We overheard her talking to one of her employees in a very condescending tone over something trivial. Boo for that! After she left for the night, everyone opened up and really started sharing their southern hospitality. Also to be noted, she came off as snobbish when I saw her out and about in Eustis. But, as far as the food is concerned, when we finally got to sample the pizza it WAS good; good enough that we had it twice. The crust is crisp with a nice crackly bite, though some of that is lost when it's delivered. The ingredients are good quality (maybe not the pepperoni), it's not greasy, the pies are pretty good size and the toppings are spaced well. It could use a bit more marinara, but otherwise it was an above-average pizza. I wanted to rate them higher because the other owner seemed like such a sweetheart and the employees were really nice once Sandy left. Plus, finding Primo was quite tasty and a rare find. However, in good conscience I can't overhype their wares when I'm not impressed by certain practices, like being rude to your customers or turning away business. I'd say it's really a 3 and a half stars. read more

The Pizza dough doesn't taste very fresh at all. Not to mention the owner claims in a printed article posted all over the restaurant that they haul the water in from New York to make said dough. I've been wrong before but I call bluff on the fresh dough with special water unless the water comes from the NYC subway. The dough has the texture and taste of frozen store bought pizza. Overall the pizza is way overpriced for the taste and quality. We ate the whole pie so it's not terrible, just way over stated and priced. PS: Show me the invoice for the water you had hauled in from New York, I'm not buying the story. read more

Doesn't look like much but I have been on my eternal search for the best pizza in Lake County So I decided to bring my family here to try it out. If you are looking for great pizza, THIS IS IT. If you love truly crispy and thin pizza with quality cheese and cooked just right, this is IT! When we visited, the owner was serving tables. She was so nice and so apologetic for the wait and delays. I was more than happy to wait for this pizza goodness! Stop reading these reviews and go try it! read more

The best thin crust pizza in the area! Here we are enjoying our onion pizza. I would have included the fried green beans in the picture, but they were gone too quick! read more

The Great Pizza Company - Great thin crust onion pizza from The Great Pizza Co! - Pizza Near Me - Eustis, Florida

Love the thin crust pizza. Thai basil is the best one! Everything is made fresh. By far the best pizza in Lake County. They have a pizza cooker and you can watch them make it. :) read more

The Great Pizza Company - Menu - Pizza Near Me - Eustis, Florida

Great New York style pizza. Thin and delicious. Give it a try! Our current favorite pizza in the area

$48 for 2 medium pizzas and an appetizer? Plus, regardless of what Yelp says, they don't deliver. I couldn't tell you if the pizza was good. I cancelled the order when they gave me the total. Forget it. Too many other options. read more

We happen to come across this pizzeria which reminded me of the pizzerias back in New York! I have to say that this has to be the BEST pizza that I've had in Florida a long time!! I highly recommend coming here as you won't be disappointed!! read more

*cough cough* this shit was not bussin I came here for the car meet and tried this pizza place the medium was the size of a personal there was no crust it was very thin and for the small pizza it was 15 dollars please save your money but the cafe right next to it was pretty good tho I got a hat read more

They close for two hours half way into the day (stupid) then I try and call after they reopen and no answer the really don't like money apparently read more