Great place to eat! They are busy for a reason! Food is amazing, customer service is wonderful! Everyone is so nice! Food comes quickly and hot! And those garlic rolls are TO DIE FOR!! wanted a salad today and, as usual, they do not disappoint. Order for take out or take a few minutes to relax and dine-in. My go to place when I'm in town! read more

Tony's Pizza & Subs - Menu cover - Pizza Near Me - Eustis, Florida

See all

Location does not look like much but WOW, food was great! I have the coconut chicken salad that was out of this world!. Highly recommend this salad! My husband had the lunch special of 4" sub and salad for only $6.95! It was great. Our friend had the chicken parm sub, it was huge and loved it. Great portions, great service! Must order the Garlic rolls!!! read more

I had a few issues with my salad order-take out and called to speak with the owner. I didn't want to pay $10 bucks for a $5 dollar sized salad. She never called me back after my calling 3-4 times and leaving a polite msg. I always got some lame excuse of why she didn't call. Almost 2 months and she still hasn't returned my calls. How complicated can it be? Great food but always in child sized portions. That is very unusual for Italian restaurants. read more

My first time to Tony's so I ordered all 5 of their flat breads. Loved them all. I also ordered their garlic bread which was delicious. Loved dipping the olive oil with the garlic chunks from the bottom of the plate. ALSO, the staff was very friendly. I'm going to be a regular to Tony's from now on. read more

Service was fantastic. Food was hot and tasty. Why not 5 stars? Lettuce in salad was shredded and tomatoes minced, more suitable for grinder, not antipasto. read more

I did a catering order from Tony's for my daughter's baby shower. The Lasagna Blanca was a so good! I ordered 2 large pans and our guests ate all of it! The salad and wings were fresh!!! Thank you for packing it so efficiently and helping me to my car!! read more

Go to Tony's all the tima very good food and service When you do the take out you need to check your receipt! When a lady takes your order there is not a problem but when the gentleman does he adds $2.35 for a cup of tap water. When asked about it he stated thats normal, I replied no not really then he came back and offered me a dollar and said they moved the buttons! Now that's what got me as a bad excuse, I told him to keep it and I won't be back! Bummer you have to screw repeat customers like that. read more

I really hate writing a downgraded review on this place because in the not-too-distant past it was an outstanding restaurant -- at least among the items I usually order. Today I ordered a cheese steak sub. The meat was dry and scorched, and was lacking in quantity. It also had a somewhat fishy aftertaste, and Tony's doesn't serve fish. I arrived at about 11:30am (just before prime lunch time), so the meat could well have been yesterday's frozen leftover grilled meat that was thawed and regrilled. As I walked in, I noticed a "cook wanted" sign posted next to the entry door. That usually doesn't bode well for the upcoming meal. I think there may be a management problem here. read more

I was rather disappointed after my first impression of this establishment. My boyfriend and I pick random places to order from when we're in a new area so we can get a feel for the restaurants without being too picky at first. We had ordered 2 different style pizzas and mozzarella sticks. We figured that a pizza place so far out in an rural part of the county might be good by simple word of mouth and the skill of the cooks. We placed our order by phone, which was refreshingly easy and quick. However, when we arrived, we pulled up to a sign in the window reading, "We are short-staffed. Please be patient with the staff that did show up. No one wants to work anymore." That automatically sent up red flags that they may just be cheapskates who don't pay their staff a decent wage, especially in today's climate. (People don't leave a good-paying job just because they have a discrepancy.) We walked in, and every last staff member was unmasked (during a pandemic). The blonde lady at the counter was friendly enough in an eccentric-aunt sort of way, which is always fine, and, quite frankly, reassuring, but the guy working with the food looked absolutely miserable and overworked. Anyway, we paid our bill, which came up to 40-something for 2 pizzas and mozzarella sticks (which is kind of insane for some dough, sauce, and cheese, unless it's to-die-for), and headed home. Now comes the hairy part. The mozzarella sticks were... I guess "rubbery" is the word." The flavor was good, but the texture was questionable. In all fairness, the 7-minute drive could have contributed to that, so I wouldn't hold that against them. BUT, the pizza was... lacking. First off, it was a very thick crust, which is fine for many people, and also fine for me if the toppings are equally as thick or satisfying, but this was anything but. The cheese was.... eh... adequate in terms of covering, but stopped short about an inch and a half from the edge of the crust and was quite bland. The toppings were also about the same. That's not to say that they didn't have their own flavor. The toppings basically held the dish together. The cheese was poor, the crust was... basically thick bread. All in all, they need to thin out the crust just a little, use a cheese that at least has a little salt in it, and bump the sauce, cheese, and toppings at least up to the point at the crust where the fingers can grab, and where you don't just have an unwarranted, flavorless breadstick. I would say, if you are adventurous and can follow a Pinterest recipe, try making your own pizza first. The compare them. That's a nice test to see if it's worth spending 40+ dollars on 2 pizzas and breadsticks, or if you can do better on your own. In this case, I'm siding with the Pinterest recipe. Sorry... read more

I ordered pizza today from Tony's I had an extra large deluxe pizza it was phenomenal all the toppings were so fresh and the crust was delicious!! It was bursting with flavor, I couldn't be happier! This is the first time that I've gotten a pizza from here and it definitely won't be the last!!! To top it off the customer service was fantastic! read more

This is my second trip, I really like food and the service is great! Fried cheese ravioli is excellent read more

Tony's Pizza & Subs - Sign Greek salad - Pizza Near Me - Eustis, Florida

This is a really great place to eat. I live just up the road from here and have been there many times. The food and the service is always excellent, the pizza is great though to be honest I prefer the pasta. They also have really delicious deserts and some fine iced tea. read more

Pizza was ok, sauce had no taste and cheese was very light. Service was lame, after drinks were served, waitress never checked on us to see if we needed anything else. It is ok for quick lunch and that's it. read more

This place is GREAT! Fried pepperoni???? Out if this world! Black & Bleu Flat.... I ran home and almost slapped my mother it was so good. Love the place. Very few places still exist like this!! read more

See all

Best pizza in Eustis. Entrees are top notch too. Prices average. Marvelous chocolate cake but very pricy. Yummy.

Pizza place the extra large is 18", good pizza, not the best, I prefer GAPC. The family went for dinner and the we had no trouble getting seated. The staff did a good job waiting on us and the pizza came out quick. The salad was good and the garlic knots were a hit at the table. read more

weitre was very rude and racist food had no taste the pizza crust was hard nd burnt we had a very bad experience wouldn't recommend to anyone read more

So... It's been a long time since I visited Tony's. Not for any particular reason but just hasn't been on my radar. My husband just randomly stopped there to eat a late lunch - it was about 2:30 so they weren't very busy. When we entered - I had a slight feeling that we were interrupting the staff who were all crammed in the kitchen area. But they sat us pretty quickly. We made our menu choices and waited about 15 minutes before the girl - who was not our waiter - came back to take our drink order. Our waiter finally brought the drinks and took our order. Of course we ordered garlic knots as the appetizer because they have always been amazing. TThis time we also ordered Alfredo sauce, not that their rolls need it but because the child wanted it. the rolls are taller than before but still yummy! The Alfredo - watery and no flavor! I won't order it again.... Even the waiter asked it was any good because it looked watery. Our son ordered the Mac-n-cheese and we decided to split a calzone. The Mac-n-cheese looked terrible - not what a child would want to eat and the cheese sauce again was watery! The calzone was really, really good. We very much enjoyed it! The small was plenty for two - we even got a box to take the extra home We were not impressed with the service but it could have just been the one waiter.... read more

First time customer, order sausage pizza green olives. Crust was good but rest of pizza no taste, very little sausage on pizza, sausage was sliced paper thin. Very disappointed read more

Idk how anyone could say anything bad. Everything is fresh and hot made to order. I love the specialty combos and the flatbread. The garlic knots are amazing. Always our go-to!! read more

Love this place! Not only are the pizza pies great, but the desserts pies are fantastic as well!

This place is what we have been looking for small business for a long time that they made the fresh homemade pizzas with your own options for toppings. Their thin pizza is delicious . My family love their the Garlic rolls. They do have old fashioned Root Beer in glass bottles like an old days. I never tried eat the Greek Salad until I tried their Greek salad with homemade ranch. It was delicious! It is all light meal and we don't feel full for the whole meal. It is awesome. We will be back again! read more

This place is great!!! Stumbled upon this place passing through town. Amazing food and great service!!! The garlic knots are soooooo good. Also the fried pepperoni was delicious. Can't say enough about this local joint. Restaurant was impeccably clean and orderly. Thank you for a wonderful lunch!!! read more

My girlfriend loves it here!! Good pizza and the best garlic knots around!!! Very affordable and great service!!

The pizza was soggy mom and I just ate the topping and threw the rest away. We won't be getting pizza here again

Our first time eating here, the appetizer which is garlic rolls which we ordered 6 pieces for 4 of us and holy rolls! They are massive and so delicious and soft inside. Just be prepared for yourselves. Our drinks was quickly refilled and tasty. Our thin pan pizza came and was so delicious! We definitely will come back here soon. Keep up the good work. :) read more

Love this place. Our families favorite place to get good pizza. We eat here regularly. We have never had anything that was disappointing. Local joint that is frequented by many local people. Service is always good and friendly. Highly recommend this place for pizza or Italian food. read more

Best Italian food I've had in years!!! Great service, and super friendly staff. The garlic knots are to die for!!! I ordered the pasta with the house made alfredo and it was definitely worth it. I'd never been to such a great place in a little town like this. 10/10 would recommend and would come back many many times more! read more

Every time I'm home I have to go hear for the knots, desert pizza, greek salad, and the calzone!!! By far the best in the whole country!! The flavor has not changed in 25 some years!!! read more

Best pizza/salads/garlic rolls in Lake County. The staff is the best! Plus, I worked here to save up for my first car. ;)

Another good pizza find! Garlic rolls were a nice treat before the pie. Staff was super attentive, I actually had two servers. Not one taking over for the other, but two people constantly watching over our table. Great place. read more

Tony's Pizza & Subs - Pizza Near Me - Eustis, Florida

This is a great place to eat! Great & friendly staffs and waitresses! Our server was Sarah and she knew signs and communicated with us great! The restaurant is cleaned and fresh. I always get their Philly steak and cheese Stromboli's which are awesome! I get one everytime I come here and always satisfied with a full tummy! The pizza are awesome as well as the lasagna dish! My wife had the chicken Alfredo dish and she loved it as well as the chicken wings too! Always leaving this place with smiles on our faces! They've got our business! Little pricey but it's well worth it! read more

Never again, heard how good it was, drove about 30 miles. Crust was tough and hard, sauce was dry and just not a good pizza for $23. Large pizza. read more

Enjoying the pizza and food. This pizza joint is probably as good as they come. Service is great. Might consider a 5 if it was spectacular. 2 times here this month. We've had blowouts on our pizzas in number of places. Thats where the crust rises up and explodes and dries out. Never here. I could consider a 3 star but won't because they do a really good job all around. read more

Pricey for mediocre food. Garlic knots are the best around as other reviewers stated; I used to take an order of knots to go to dodge lackluster service and sticky menus. read more

The best Pizza I have had in Lake County and good pasta. A little drive from Clermont but well worth it. Good service, Good prices.

Lasagna dinner...nice size helping with salad and garlic rolls. All tasty. Take out order was ready as promised. Only 4 stars as maybe a little on the pricey side but that should really only be a half star downgrade. All in all happy with the meal and would go there again. read more

Pricy lunch special and nothing special at all! Pizza was very small and not that great. Two very small slices of pizza and a sweet tea, not worth the price. read more

Pizza is of course great but we always order Greek salads and don't forget the garlic knots!!!!! Yummmmmm!!!!!!

We went last night and the new pizza they have-white mushroom was out of this world. I have been going here 9 years now and have never had any complaints .worth the drive and worth the great pizza and subs! read more