Cancel

Open app

Search

Bagels On Bartow

4.1 (82 reviews)
Closed • 6:00 am - 12:00 pm

Order Bagels On Bartow Takeout or Delivery

Bagels On Bartow Photos

Business Info

BAGELS ON BARTOW ATMOSPHERE

What's the vibe?
Loud
Good for kids

You might also consider

Recommended Reviews - Bagels On Bartow

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

Reviews With Photos

Bacon egg and cheese on an everything bagel
Simone S.

This place is very easy to miss but I'm glad I found it. I called to order and then went to pick up. Btw it's the sidewalk portion of the mini mall near the Dunkin' Donuts, not inside near the parking lot. *for anyone else like me and can't figure it out * Anyways, when I found it there was a line outside, despite it being bone chilling cold. That's always a good sign. I picked up my order, bacon egg and cheese on an everything bagel. So simple but so easy to mess up. I'm glad I was not disappointed. The bagel tasted fresh, chewy but not gummy, and the everything seasoning was everything with that hint of salt that so many others miss causing them to fall flat. The bacon ratio was perfect cause we all know places tend to be stingy. My only complaint was the egg ratio was sparse. It looked like there was literally one large egg on it, not 2 or even a jumbo or something. But I was satisfied. I'll definitely be returning.

Tuna
Renee K.

The ordering is great. Sanitary etc. That's what the three stars are for. Bagel was a regular bagel. Reminds me of ordering off the coffee carts in the city during the 80's and 90's before going to school. What you put on a bagel MATTERS. The tuna had no veggies. No powdered seasonings to make up for lack of veggies....not even a lil garlic powder and onion powder. Also it's was a lil smear of tuna. I could not finish it. That's not a NY tuna on bagel. The veggie cream cheese tasted good, it was just missing half the serving size. Great for kids grabbing something before school or the older folks grabbing something to gab over. I will give this a pass.

Amanda G.

When I lived in Co-op City, I loved stopping here for a toasted buttered bagel brekkie before heading off to elementary school. Their bagels are so fresh and they prepare your order exactly as you specify. Asking for extra butter will definitely get you a heaping portion of butter. They have everything from cinnamon raisin bagels to mini bagels and even bialys. They also have breakfast sandwiches and beverages. It's a small establishment but better than the Dunkin Donuts around the corner.

Scallion cream cheese, mediocre and little scallion flavor
Rose L.

Rude, unfriendly girl at the register aside, the bagels are just ok. They're not inedible or anything, but they're very fat, doughy, bready, soft bagels and lack the flavor and chew I personally prefer in NY bagels. The scallion cream cheese I got was almost all cream cheese with only a little scallion mixed in. It has very little scallion flavor, and I would not recommend. I can understand that people would go here bc the bagel options are scarce in the area, but in my opinion, it's def not a 4 or 5 star bagel by any stretch of the imagination.

See all

10 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

10 years ago

Business owner information

Photo of Julie P.

Julie P.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

Page 3 of 3

Ask the Community - Bagels On Bartow

You might also consider

Bagels and Cream - Pancake

Bagels and Cream

3.8(104 reviews)
1.7 mi
•$

The food is good but they're gonna make it however they want to make it regardless of your…read morepreferences. You order with ketchup they'll bring you with mayo. you order with olives? They bring you with jalapeños that is how they're gonna do it and most of the time you order will be wrong. this is a good place if you were incredibly indecisive and really easy-going kind of like everything. if you happen to like what they get you you'll like it it'll be great.

I saw this place as my friend and I drove by; we're new to the neighborhood. We walked over and…read morewere excited to have lunch at a new spot that we could patronize in the future. We were roundly ignored for about 15 minutes. Finally, we went to a different register thinking we just weren't being seen. We were still ignored. Finally we asked what we needed to do to order and a guy snapped "Can't you see we're busy?!!" Honestly, no. It did not look busy at all. And couldn't he have been more professional and said something like "Sorry, we're busy but will be with you in a few minutes." ??? We will obviously not be returning. Note: To the manager below, that is EXACTLY what happened, as two of us can attest. For what reason would we make up a false review? Unless you are willing to show us your video, you are incorrect and you very well know it. Not to mention, you come in here and argue with every negative review. Not a good look!

Photos
Bagels and Cream - Muffins and croissants

Muffins and croissants

Bagels and Cream - Catering Wrap Platter

Catering Wrap Platter

Bagels and Cream - Veggie Panini

See all

Veggie Panini

Utopia Bagels - 2/5/23

Utopia Bagels

4.1(1.2k reviews)
6.5 mi•Bay Terrace
•$$

When I'm in Queens I usually just get my bagels from a grocery store, but I think I found my new go…read moreto place with Utopia Bagel. The baker's dozen (13 bagels) is worth it because you can choose between regular and specialty bagels and it still comes out to $24. And if you get the dozen on a Wednesday, you can actually get 16 bagels! The bagels are big, and airy. The combinations and variety of options go on and on. Excited to be try a new one every time. They are pretty precise with the weight of spread you order, as well. We ordered the egg salad, tuna salad, and scallion cream cheese spread. The egg salad and tuna salad were mild in flavor, not heavy, tasted healthy. I've only come on weekends, so there is always a line out the door, but there are many staff members, so the line moves. If you are ordering a lot of bagels, be prepared for back-up options because although they are constantly making the bagels on the premise, popular options do run out and you may have to wait 15min for a new batch.

A staple of the area. Utopia Bagels has been around for a long time and has a multitude of flavour…read moreoptions. They are quick, efficient and reasonably priced. Small coffee is the same price has a large one at 2.75. Taste: 4/5 Service: 4/5 Ambiance: 3.5/5 Value for money: 4/5

Photos
Utopia Bagels
Utopia Bagels - The Dude

The Dude

Utopia Bagels - I guess this explains all. Found few hair on my bagel. Waited almost a hour and having this kind of issue is not acceptable.

See all

I guess this explains all. Found few hair on my bagel. Waited almost a hour and having this kind of issue is not acceptable.

Bagels On Bartow - bagels - Updated May 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...