Tasty bagels with a few interesting varieties, although I usually just get a breakfast sandwich on an everything. Everything bagels don't really have "everything" but they have a bunch of stuff on them like salt and poppy seeds. I recommend their scallion and bacon cream cheese as well. On the downside the bagels are a little small, and they microwave their eggs which is a little weird. I say just get a griddle and fry them, right? Anyways they have some nice baked goods too. Also they have day old bagels, and "doggie" bagels which are like older bagels that are really stale. I would say stick with the fresh ones though they are easier on your teeth! PS if you were wondering, its not in an actual mill, they just call it that because they make bagels there sort of like a mill makes stuff like cloth or paper. I am not really sure though, I've never been in the back. Anyways its good so check it out... read more

Rude. When a customer says they got the wrong order, listen. Don't look at them like they are evil.

Here's the issue. The young lady behind the counter is so focused on taking orders she is unable to stop and fulfill orders placed. This morning I ordered breakfast with a coffee. The coffee pots were empty. Instead of taking 30 seconds to grind the beans and start a pot she continued to take orders. I ate my breakfast then went back to the coffee dispenser. Coffee was brewed behind the counter but the young lady didn't bother to come fill the dispenser even though I was waiting in plain view. She then walked away and began to talk with another employee. I then asked for a refund. Another person, assuming it was the manager or owner, then said the coffee is right there we can fill your cup. I said I would prefer a refund as I had an appointment to go to and needed to leave. This is when this person told me in a sarcastic tone that it would take longer to do a refund. I told her I prefer a refund. Management is not easy but it's not rocket science. I would have offered constructive criticism here but after the rude tone I decided it was best to just leave. Employees taking orders should prioritize orders taken. If this means 30 seconds of time away from the register that's acceptable. This isn't the first time issues have occurred here. Every time I order the same young lady behind the counter never gives me a cup for the coffee. And when I say never it's never. I get my food and have to go ask for the cup. read more

Delicious bagel sandwiches. Generous with spreads and contents. Stuff are friendly and welcoming. You can certainly sit and enjoy your food, but most tend to take out. read more

I have never witnessed less professional and customer friendly employees. I was in a hurry and I saw this what seemed to be convenient bagel shop and cafe. Was I wrong. I didn't leave the store until 23 minutes after my order. I watched 5 employees behind the counter make their own lunches before making my bagel. STRONGLY DO NOT RECOMMEND. read more

It deeply saddens me to write this as it's been a town staple for years. Today I ordered an everything with veggies cream cheese. The bagels have been getting smaller for years now. This one was tiny and hard. Like day old hard. For a minute I thought they gave me regular cream cheese as I didn't see veggies at first. Upon inspection I found them. Barely there and no flavor. I paid $8.15 I think for a bagel and cream cheese, that's it. The original Bagel Mill was much higher quality for much lower price.You could see so many veggies in the cream cheese and the bagels were much larger. I don't think I'll be going back. read more

Bagel Mill - Everything bagel veggie cream cheese - Bagels Near Me - Peterborough, New Hampshire

See all

Very disappointed. Bought a dozen bagels at $20..which is fine if the quality is there..but nope, hard as a rock and flatter than flat. read more

Bagel Mill - Maple bagel - Bagels Near Me - Peterborough, New Hampshire

See all

Lovely ambiance, nice sunny space with live music in the morning. Good bagels, extremely generous and delicious cream cheese schmear. Service, on the other hand, was slow and the gaggle of young kids who work here seemed confused about people's orders. The person ahead of me said she'd been waiting 20 minutes for her sandwich, her first order somehow got "lost". Ours came out in about 10. Don't be in a hurry. read more

The Bagel Mill has been our go to bagel place for years, like 20 years....so I was very disappointed last week when I picked up 2 dozen bagels to go. There was some sticker shock about the price which was $19 dollars + change per dozen. That would have been ok, with prices being what they are are these days. However the quality of the bagels seemed to be more of a "day old vibe" than fresh. Just saying that if you charge top dollar then people expect the best that you can offer, not something that even your dog can't chew. read more

Delicious! I never have high hopes for bagels in New England, but my friend assured me that Bagel Mill would be different. He was right! Our order was ready quickly, with no mixups, and the bagels were fresh. I got an everything bagel with lox, tomato, capers, and cream cheese - so good!! Highly recommend this spot for breakfast. read more

Bagel Mill - Everything bagel with lox - Bagels Near Me - Peterborough, New Hampshire

Staff is basic and you'll have a normal experience. I got a tomato and cheese on an everything bagel, the bagel was great just wish the tomato I got was a thicker cut( definitely ask for thick cut tomato). The coffee and peach tea were solid. And the inside of the restaurant is very nice and cozy. read more

Great service. Great employees. Bagels are okay, but I am from New York. Their vegan cream cheese was tatsy!

A staple delicious breakfast or lunch when we are in Peterborough. A large variety of bagels and the menu has something for everyone. The staff is friendly and service is quick. read more

Best bagels, good variety and you put a lot of different toppings on the bagels. Also my dogs love there bagels. read more

Bagel Mill - Spinach garlic with chicken salad. - Bagels Near Me - Peterborough, New Hampshire

32+ bucks for a medium coffee 2 scones and 2 bagel sandwhiches. the bagels were rather hard to bite into , i got an avacado BLT and which it tasted good it was small. his was a lox and cream cheese , there was only cream cheese on half of his sandwhich and he said the lox tasted better at the cheap local grocery store vs this sandwhich. the scones were alot drier than most n had almost no flavor as well. as for the size considering the price its a massive disapointment. the photo's on their website and facebook page show picture's twice the size as what we got when we ordered , to me thats false advertisement. i could have spent the same amount or less at a local subway and got a more filling lunch. read more

Brooklyn style bagels. Occasionally more like bread. Good coffee. Lots of toppings. Clean and neat dining area

Came in to get a latte and a bagel. I ordered an everything bagel with cream cheese and it was delicious. Honestly the best bagel I've had. I definitely recommend coming in. They have so many breakfast and lunch options. read more

A real kosher bagel in NH! This place is to die for... My favorite is an everything bagel with garlic and herb cream cheese.... it is SEX in A BROWN BAG.... Great atmospere... on a cold day with my bagel in front of the stove... oooh! I will say the price is a little high for a bagel and smeer... BUT IT IS WORTH IT! Think it's about $3.25 without my tea. THIS IS A MUST FOR THE MONADNOCK REGION... it puts any donut chain to shame! read more

Every visit home includes a visit to "the mill". I have stopped many places along the road and cannot find bagels that compare. I did not get to take a picture of my bagel sandwich because I devoured it in seconds. The spinach garlic bagels are to die for...even the plain bagel and plain cream cheese are great. If your looking for a bagel, look no further! read more

Bagel Mill - My sons cinnamon raisin with plain cream cheese - Bagels Near Me - Peterborough, New Hampshire

The bagel mill has been a staple in my home since we moved to Peterborough in 2004. We get all our bagels for the week here, and don't get grocery store bagels as they pale in comparison. The bagels have always been top quality, which I guess is rare in New England. Do you like a lot of everything on your everything bagel? Definitely give this place a visit. The coffee isn't that great, but that's not the point of your visit to the bagel mill. It's a fresh baked bagel with delicious topping and cream cheese choices. Get there in the morning if you want to pick up more than a few. It's wildly popular and they always sell out quick. read more

I love the cinnamon bagels at the Bagel Mill. They are tender on the inside with a sugary cinnamon crust that is divine. It sounds funny, but I spread them with peanut butter and it is to die for. Great coffee, tons of freshly made bagels, and WiFi makes this a perfect spot to settle in with my laptop and enjoy a lazy weekend morning. read more

Great place to wait while your car is being serviced at B-C Auto, right across the street. Friendly, relaxed place - free wifi. Nice doggie treats [stale bagles!] and excellent fresh [baked on the premise] site. Great critter-cam on their FB site - ever see a Fisher eat a bagel? read more

Solid bagels. Very flavorful. I had a sausage egg and cheese and it definitely filled me up. I knock a star off because the latte I ordered was pretty much just hot milk and the WiFi while available is super pokey. Still, not many options in town and I am quite happy this is one of them, I would be pressed to find a better bagel in a larger town/city. read more

Nicely situated near our route between home and relatives, this stop got the nod once before today. That visit ensured a return. A good selection of well made bagels, foundation for ample cream cheese or one of many considerable sandwiches, makes it a smart choice for lunch. It's got plenty of seating, friendly service, varied beverages, nice art, and a local feel, but it's slightly tricky to find for being a minute off the highway. We haven't sampled the soup, but the salads we've picked have been unimaginative-- discouraging for the gluten-free dietee. There are good choices in town, but this off-the-beaten-track bakery is easy and relaxing... kid-friendly, too. read more

Ordered their "out of the box" on a wrap. Advertised as "hummus, cheddar, veggies Dijon mustard", the wrap came sans hummus, sans cheddar, with a few slivers of iceberg and tomato. For $6.95, this was a rip off. I called them to alert them to this mistake, to which the employer said "we don't give you the hummus and cheese if you don't ask for it." What??? Say if you went to another restaurant and ordered a Cobb salad. Do you have to list everything you want from the menu? "Yes, I want lettuce on my salad, as stated on the menu." The employee obviously copped out to get out of apologizing. Flabbergasted. Never going back again. read more

Bagel Mill - Veggie "out of the box" supposed to have hummus, but did not, and was $6.95 for a really slim wrap. Ugh. - Bagels Near Me - Peterborough, New Hampshire

During my trip to Peterborough last week this was my favorite place I ate at. The atmosphere is so cute and relaxing and they have a vegan cashew cream cheese option which was amazing. The first time I got the pumpernickel with cucumber and tomato and it was really good. The only thing is that the other reviewers are correct on that the staff is likely to mess up your order. Just double check if you're taking it to go and they will happily fix it :))) read more

Bagel Mill - Pumpernickel with cracked pepper cashew cream cheese, tomato, and cucumber!!! So good - Bagels Near Me - Peterborough, New Hampshire

Try the Spinach Garlic Bagel w/ Bacon Scallion cream cheese, it's the best. I'm from Massachusetts but whenever I go to visit my friends in NH or when they come and visit me I gotta have the spinach garlic bagel from Bagel Mill. I would say it's better than Dunkin Donuts for bagels. Plenty of room to sit and eat, hang out with friends or just grab a quick bite and be on your way. Since I haven't physically been there in awhile I can't remember what the prices/service is like but I believe it's decently priced and that the service is pretty friendly and efficient. read more

Very slow service. The staff are on their phones way too much. Food was tasteless and smelled a little moldy. I'm almost positive that my friend had mouse dropping on his bagel sandwich. Try at own risk. read more

This place was my favorite breakfast spot in Peterborough for over 20 years but it has gone way downhill recently. I have tried to get an everything bagel on six occasions in the last two weeks and every time they are out! Today I wanted a dozen bagels, everything, plain and sesame but when I walked in at 11:30am they were out of all three. I'm not sure how you can run a bagel business that never has any bagels to choose from. Don't waste your time going here unless you call ahead. They told us to call in the morning, a few hours ahead of time if we want to pick a dozen bagels up! read more

Every time of going there, I found the bagels were very fresh, the people very enjoyable talk to. I love the coffee love the environment I love the atmosphere. If I have time in the morning during my hectic schedule, that's the place that I go to focus and set up for my day. These guys are really great. read more

Wit the amount of chatter you hear of these bagels, you'd think they're something special. Sure, they're better than Leder's any day, but is that really saying a lot? I will say that while their seating is something to be desired, and the atmosphere is a bit self-indulgent, I can't name a better place in the area to get a bagel-sandwich that compares to what the Mill offers. If you've been around and are used to other bagel stops, this would be nothing to write home about. Lucky for them, New Hampshire doesn't offer much for competition - especially in Peterborough. If you're in the mood for a quick bagel on the way to work, you're better off at Dunkin Donuts. If you've got some time to kill on the weekend and want a place to got to chat with friends over juice and a bagel, unfortunately, there's nowhere better than the Bagel Mill. read more

Well, I am in the area for a week of relaxing visiting a friend. Decided to go here for some coffee and use my laptop. As I do many times in NYC and other places around the country. This place is the first coffee house that told me that my stay of 1:30 was to long due to reserve tables for regular customers. "Regular Customers" what!! At a coffee house offering free Wi-Fi.. Did not know that I had to make reservations, and what constitute a regular customer since I just spent $10.00. I was outrage with the owner coming over to my table and mentioning this to me, and how I did not read the folded piece of paper on the table. Which was on the floor when I got there. This was my last visit to this coffee house, and my friend also will no longer visit. Now, being a minority hopefully would not have anything to do with this event in today's world.. read more

The owner of this place treats his employees like crap. There's always a think layer of grime on the floor behind the counter behind the counter.the coffee is standard. The bagels are tastey. But the toppings for the bagel sandwiches could be a lot fresher.mushy sprouts? No thank you. read more

One of a kind place. Grew up locally but have since lived in Virginia, Washington, DC, and currently Boston and still have not found a bagel that compares to the Bagel Mill. Growing up, going to the Bagel Mill was our reward for behaving well in church or doing our chores. As a freshman in college in Virginia, my parents brought down two dozen bagels with a couple different containers of cream cheese for my dorm floor and everyone was hooked. I started getting requests to bring back a dozen bagels with cream cheese every time I went home. My go-to bagel/sandwich has changed over the years due to them having so many quality options but my current choice is the "Out of the Box" on a toasted Everything bagel. Loaded up with all the veggies on a solid humus base topped with cheddar cheese and honey dijon mustard. The atmosphere is a great spot for everyone. In a single visit you'll see a family with young children, a group of college kids home for break taking over the couch and wicker chairs, an elderly couple sitting at the fireplace, and a businessman on his laptop in the corner using the free wifi. The Bagel Mill really is a Peterborough staple and the first place I tell people to visit when they're in town. My mother doesn't even care that I stop by the Bagel Mill before coming to the house to see her when I visit. Her only request is that I pick up bagels for the entire family as well. read more

My only complaint would be the wait, 6-7 people in line in front of me or standing around in front of the counter are always a deterrent that send me walking the other way. The wifi is great, I don't have a complaint and the seating area is plenty for the customers here. On one occasion i have observed someone waiting for a sandwich that was never made after 15-20 minutes. A list of apologies and reasons were provide but for me that would tell me if there is more than 3 people in front of me in line that i wouldn't even bother placing an order at the chance that what i ordered wasn't made. Still I personally have never had a bad experience and have always enjoyed what i have got, how quickly my order came up and how friendly the staff is. The reality isn't really another place like this in town so one might say the wait is worth it. A better variety and better quality bagel than anyone else in the area and then some. read more

Not what it used to be. New owner I think. The bagels are kind of pathetic while the price has gone way up. Still, the only bagels around. read more

Food was great, bagels here are really original. But the servers behind the counter are rude and seem to rush you while your making a decision. read more

First time stopping at this nice little spot. I ordered a toasted plain bagel with cream cheese, smoked salmon, tomato, capers, and red onion. They were fast making it and the sandwich had a large amount of salmon, tomato, and cream cheese. The bagel itself was really delicious in of itself. Overall one of the best smoked salmon bagel sandwiches I've had. I also ordered two different iced expresso drinks, a latte and a mocha, both were very nice coffee drinks. The staff is very polite and fast with their orders, and they often go through the donning room to make sure it is tidy. I'll be coming back soon for lunch. read more

Don't order the hot sandwiches here. They are about $8. They are just microwaved, and the kids running the counter don't know what they're doing. Ordered a pastrami sandwich. It came cold...on white bread...with provolone (not Swiss)...and no mustard. And this is one of their SPECIALITY Sandwiches. Sent it back twice. The first time, they just toasted the bread and slapped on one piece of cold, thick pastrami. I sent back. They popped it in the microwave. I opened it up. The provolone cheese was kind of melted. But, no mustard. After looking at it, I decided it was not worth eating. I left and went to the Flipside Grille in Fitzwilliam for a real sandwich. read more

Loved the bagels. Had a salt bagel with bacon and scallion cream cheese. Delicious!!! Service was great and friendly. Loved the atmosphere. read more