Quick easy and very tasty. Took the oder over the phone. Order was made exactly like I ask and tasted great. read more

This was easily one of the most disorganized restaurant experiences I've had. Despite the store being empty when I arrived, it took 5-6 minutes before anyone took my order. About 10 minutes later, I was told the bagel I ordered didn't actually exist because their "Everything Bagel" is wheat, while the "Wheat Everything" is multigrain. Confusing, but I changed my order. Another 5-6 minutes later, I was told they were out of peanut butter, so I requested a refund instead. I was told I could keep the bacon that had already been cooked. After waiting several more minutes for the refund, I was handed only $3 back on a $12+ order (plus a $2 tip). When I pointed out the refund was incorrect, they took the bacon back before refunding the rest. I understand that mistakes happen and no business is perfect. Unfortunately, this experience was frustrating enough that I can't recommend this place when there are several other excellent bagel shops nearby that consistently provide better service and a smoother experience. One thing worth noting: allof the positive reviews here appear to be from the previous bagel shop that operated at this location, so I'd encourage anyone reading reviews to keep that in mind when deciding where to go. read more

Best and my favorite bagels in town! Great ambiance and friendliest staff. We always get a big bag of bagels for the family and get a pork roll with eggs and hot sauce to eat in the car. THE BEST! read more

See all

Decided to do a New Years Day Brunch at my community and called the day before to see if they could handle a small order based on their ad in The Clipper magazine. They were very happy to help and the food was ready on time and everyone thoroughly enjoyed. Several at the party were so happy asked where we ordered from. Was very happy to share read more

Chicken BLT sandwich was wonderful. Very tasteful and fresh. Loved the pickle on the side. It also came with a side of coleslaw but not pictured. read more

Bagel Express - Chicken BLT Sandwich - Bagels Near Me - Milltown, New Jersey

Picked up an assortment of bagels here. First time trying. The woman at the register was friendly. Took the bagels home to cut added a smear of cream cheese and it was delicious. Bagels are crispy on the outside and chewy on the inside. Nice size also. I'll definitely have to try their bagels with meat and egg next time read more

Man, have I missed bagels from NJ/NY. I'm so glad I was able to try out this local bagel shop in East Brunswick, which serves not only bagels but also other breakfast items. I got an Everything bagel, plain & toasted, and it was the fluffiest, best tasting bagel I've tasted in a long time. Pricing is very fair, with 3 bagels (2 of which had cream cheese) and 1 omelette totaling a little over $20. The store itself had an intimate, cozy vibe, with the aromas of bagels wafting through the front door. At 10am, they still had a good selection of bagel varieties and had even added freshly made bagels to the display case. The wait was reasonable for the food that we ordered, since it included an omelette. But if you only get a bagel, you'll be in and out of the store within a few minutes. read more

See all

Elegant, its owner is very handsome and the food is increidible. I love the tuscan Magic

My colleagues and I order breakfast and/or lunch from here 1-2 times per week. I highly recommend Bagel Express! read more

Bagel Express - tuna salad sandwich - Bagels Near Me - Milltown, New Jersey

This was my first time going and i ordered egg white sandwich with bacon and American cheese on a wheat bagel. I don't think there was enough egg though, but the bacon was on the crispy side which i like. The bagel was great too it was fresh and soft. The service was great they were nice and didn't wait long for my sandwich. It's a nice spot with tables inside, but no outdoor seating. read more

See all

Staff are friendly and menus are diversed from breakfast to lunch and dinner. So lucky to find this place next to the auto repair shop. Awesome experience here. read more

Bagel Express - Bagels Near Me - Milltown, New Jersey

See all

I was so excited to hear that they have gluten free bagels but so disappointed after trying it. The gluten free bagels are pre-made and individually wrapped which are a plus and you know its safe. However what they do in safety they lack in flavor. The bagel is very sweet and has a strange texture. read more

Breakfast sandwich on a gluten free bagel was absolutely delicious! Thank you for having a gotten free bagel option! Our new go to spot for breakfast sandwiches! My husband got an egg bagel and said it was the best next to those he typically gets in NYC. read more

Good bagels! Didn't have to wait long at all either. Think I'll go here instead of Bagel Baazar read more

Bagel Express - Everything Bagel with scallion cream cheese and bacon and tomato - Bagels Near Me - Milltown, New Jersey

See all

This is definitely my go to bagel/breakfast spot on weekends or my days off when I'm craving breakfast. I love that I can call in and make my order over the phone and then pick it up. It's located in the strip mall on Ryders Lane. The parking lot can get busy, but it's not too chaotic. Definitely phone your order in because sometimes it can be a long wait. They have a great selection of bagels, of course, croissants, sandwiches, and other things for breakfast and lunch. The staff is really nice and they're quick about getting your orders. I've never had any issues and I always look forward to coming here! read more

We switched to Bagel Express from Boomerang Bagels because Boomerang's quality went down significantly after the new ownership. Bagel Express makes solid bagels, my only complaint and request is to stop being so cheap with the everything seasoning on everything bagels, come on load it up. The everything with it's minuscule amount of seasoning tastes just like a plain. So, BE you heard? read more

Year's and new management change everything in this case for the worse. When it comes to bagels I'm a 'everything'' type of a guy and I love white fish spread with red onions slightly toasted so, that's what I ordered. Unfortunately, when it arrived the spread of white fish was unacceptable. I've had peanut butter and jelly sandwiches with more peanut butter on it than the super lightly spread of white fish they put on it. The bagel was bland and I had a chalky taste to it, the people are friendly and the place is clean but I will not return especially with a better option just a few tenths of a mile away. If you can't get a basic staple bagel right with a generous portion of spread then that place ain't the place for me. read more

Bagel Express - Where's the whitefish? - Bagels Near Me - Milltown, New Jersey

Good food but they cannot seem to get an order right. Twice I ordered a toasted everything - NO BUTTER - with baked salmon salad, lettuce and tomato, to go. Both times it was DRIPPING with melted butter that stained the wrapping, through the paper bag and stained my clothing! The second time there was tomato but no lettuce. I returned to the store to speak to the manager. I was told he'd be in after 3pm. I phoned at 3:20 and they said he's be in the following day. Not a happy camper to pay for food and not get wgat i ordered, and no one seems to care. read more

In town on business and was looking exactly for this kinda spot. Food was amazing and really reasonable. The owner and the entire staff were cool and were a well oiled machine. Loved it. I live 3k miles away and will make sure and come someday! Nova lox sandwich on an Everything was my deal. Respect!! read more

Great customer service! And bagels are good. We had a large order we needed fulfilled for Christmas morning and Bagel Express came through

I really didn't see what the fuss was with this place. Sure, it is convenient. Yes, the bagels are good. So why am I knocking it? To be honest, I am not so sure why myself. Maybe because overall it was just, okay. There's nothing to this place. The pork roll I got was good, but I know you could get better elsewhere. And while it wasn't bad customer service, there's other bagel shops that treat a customer better. Maybe it was also the lack of options, but it is a bagel shop. I don't expect a lot. I guess what I'm trying to say is that you could find better, but this is not special. Just run-of-the-mill. read more

Bagel Express - I'm on my way... I'm on my way... - Bagels Near Me - Milltown, New Jersey

I purchased breakfast this morning as I normally have in the past, hot pastrami with cheese and spicy mustard. The cost is usually around $7.00 for a decent sized breakfast sandwich. Today, I ordered the norm and was charged $11.00. I questioned the cost and was told by one of the employees that I needed to say breakfast sandwich when placing an order. I told him that it was 7am and I usually pay $7.00. He said with the breakfast sandwich you only get two slices of meat which did not used to be the case. I spoke with the manager who explained that if I had ordered online that I would have the option to choose breakfast but my thought was that the person who took my order should be asked if I wanted breakfast or deli. The manager refunded me the difference and when I got home I found this.... read more

Bagel Express - Does this look like a $7.00 sandwich to you? Hot pastrami, with cheese and spicy mustard. - Bagels Near Me - Milltown, New Jersey

Followed Yelp advice and went here to get some bagels for home in New England area. Bought a dozen, which on Wednesday was $10. Had 4 sesame and 8 everything. Excellent bagels, crunchy when toasted. Nice and chewy and great flavor. Next time a cooler to get some homemade cream cheese with scallions. Definitely keep on my list for future purchases. read more

Have been a customer for a long time. Something has changed....recipe, ingredients? Bagels are no longer good. Gummy and tasteless with practically no toppings. I ordered a habanero cheese bagel and the paper thin slice of cheese totally peeled off in my hand. The 'everything' bagel was almost a plain bagel. Not good. read more

My fiance and I were looking for a local deli on Yelp and we were pleasantly surprised by what this place has to offer! Friendly staff and quick service. (came here on a weekday around 1:30p) AMBIENCE - 4 stars - Small place with a couple tables. There was a decent amount of people coming and going or eating there. Cozy and clean. FOOD - 4 stars - LOTS of options and everything we ordered was fresh and delicious! Decently priced and good portions. [Cream Cheese flavors] - scallion, veggie, lox, olive, jalapeno, walnut raisin, strawberry [Bagel variety] - plain, salt, garlic, sesame, blueberry, chocolate, onion, poppy, cinnamon, french toast, raisin, egg, whole wheat, multigrain, egg everything, wheat everything, and more! *Can place order online at BagelExpressMilltown.com but there is a convenience fee. There's also a lot of customization available online which they do not ask when you order in person (egg style, type of cheese, etc.) So make sure you know what you want! *Wednesday Special $7.99 for one dozen bagels* Will be back! read more

See all

This place is a gem! 2 years and I haven't been disappointed once, I don't usually do reviews but this one here deserves it. Chef and staff are all great! read more

Bagel Express - Grilled Chicken Panini - Bagels Near Me - Milltown, New Jersey

GOOD BAGELS!!!!! NY style bagel but they don't give extra when you order dozens like other bagel shop. Bagels are fresh daily baked and service is fast. I order 2 dozens at a time for my company. No extra!!! read more

So I've been here many times and really haven't ever had a problem..the bagel is always fresh. Today I got a BLT on an everything bagel. As always the bagel is fresh but it's more like I'm eating a "lettuce tomato" sandwich considering on the entire bagel there were two slices of bacon. I have never experienced a bagel place give that few pieces of bacon on a sandwich that is based on bacon....really disappointed in it for almost 5 dollars. read more

Bagel Express - Bagels Near Me - Milltown, New Jersey

So this is our go to spot for bagel sandwiches. Usually, I call in and pick up my sandwiches, no problems whatsoever. Somehow this morning it took 20 minutes for two turkey bacon, egg whites, and cheese bagels. 15 minutes of which they were done and BEHIND the counter the ENTIRE time. WTF?! When I mentioned this, the owner didn't say anything, no apologies, nothing. Since the sandwiches were sitting on the counter for so long, the bag was greasy and did he even offer to put my order in a plastic bag like he did for everyone else? Nope. Thanks dude. Just because I look young and am not white doesn't mean that you should provide me with lesser service. Also, get a better AC because I was sweating more in there than in the power yoga class I came from. read more

Sausage Egg and Cheese on a Super Cinnamon Raisin Bagel. Oh yeah I love me some super cinnamon raisin. It's kind of a workout on the jaw but mmmm mmmm especially if you get there early enough for them to be warm. I used to come here EVERY morning and they would make my food for me without even ordering. This would upset people waiting in line that did not even order yet when I would be standing in the back and suddenly my foods ready. I actually used to pass several bagel stores on my way to Bagel Express when I lived in a different part of town. Now I live less than a 1/2 mile away and can take a early morning walk if I'd like. (I usually drive....don't judge me.) Over the years I've steadily watched the prices go up while some of the less favorable competition has managed to keep prices consistent. I've never had a cup of coffee in my life so I have no weigh in on that. read more

The worst sandwich. Hardly any meat and bacon and charged me 9.50$ for 2 breakfast. I will not be coming back here and will definitely tell all my friends they charge too much for a sandwich with hardly any meat. The owner should be ashamed of themselves to charge for nothing. read more

Bagel Express - Bagels Near Me - Milltown, New Jersey

I love this place. No matter how busy they are they are so friendly and efficient. Best bagels! Staff is super nice. read more

See all

Good Breakfast Burrito. Lady was friendly and quick. Small place. Stopped because I was working nearby. Cheap as well.

The Bagels here are delicious! Absolutely spot on perfect Bagels! Crunchy on the outside and soft in the middle and all taste like their description. Just perfect! The bacon is always cooked how you ask, I like mine well done and they do it! They actually DO it! Unlike most places that do not seem to understand the intricacies of cooking bacon as requested. Well, these guys do. Lol ‍ They have an exceptional drink selection with lots of probiotic choices and teas and juices. It is always packed with people too, so you that speaks for itself. The only thing missing is the popular coffee syrups, (Chocolate and Caramel would be a good start) but the coffee counter is small so I get it, and Half and Half.. I like actual cream in my coffee. But they do have cinnamon out, which I like. I love this place. It is my new favorite breakfast joint. read more

I placed an order for delivery. I ordered a poppy seed bagel with butter. I received a bagel in a bag with nothing on it. The bagel was also bland. I also ordered a hazelnut coffee, light with regular sugar. I received a coffee that was dark brown and no sugar. I paid I think $5 for 3 pieces of bacon. I gave an extra star because to be honest, once I put milk and sugar in, it was the best hazel nut coffee I have ever had in my life! It was so good that I would go back there just for the coffee. read more

I order I brown sugar cream cold brew and it was good full of cream. And sugar one of the best coffees ever

Love their sausage egg and cheese on everything! Tomato and bacon on everything with veggie cream cheese also awesome! Highly recommended! Best bagels in town and beyond. Owner is great and very friendly read more

AMAZING, fresh bagels! Quick and friendly service but more importantly these were some of the best New Jersey bagels I've ever tasted. I highly recommend this little bagel shop. read more

Very simple order, yet they managed to get it all wrong!!!!! When I called they pretty much said they can't do anything for me. All I asked was for them to deliver the right items!! Never Again!!! Bad customer service!! read more

Unfortunately I was not a fan of this place at all. I ordered a whole wheat bagel with vegetable cream cheese. The bagel was hard on the outside and chewy on the inside which I did not like. I thought I was going to cut the roof of my mouth off biting down. The vegetable cream cheese lacked flavor and vegetables and was not super cold. Next time I am in Milltown, I will try Milltown bagels down the road to see if they are any better. read more