Great spot overall. Everything I tried was good, but the hash browns really stood out, better than…read more99.9% of the places I've been to. This is exactly how hash browns should be made. I've had a lot of disappointing ones in the area, but these were excellent. The space is small, but it's a bagel shop, that's expected. The bagels themselves are very good, not oversized, but just the right size for a sandwich (which I actually prefer). The owner, who I believe is an older gentleman, is very kind and accommodating. He also has superb phone etiquette, which goes a long way. Would definitely recommend.

We're visiting from out of town and we really wanted a great New York bagel and we happened by this…read morevery small storefront late in the day. We bought some everything and he threw in some additional flavors as it was near closing time. Long story short, the bagels toast up crunchy on the outside and chewy on the inside and have a great flavor. And their "homemade" green onion schmear is a must. We'll be heading back next week to restock!

Went to Bagel Nosh on March 16, 2026 for breakfast. The overall place gives you that classic deli…read morevibe, which I liked. There was a large assortment of bagels to choose from, so you've got plenty of options. I went with my go-to -- a BLT on a plain bagel. The total came out to $7.90 with tax, which honestly isn't bad at all for today's prices. They were generous with the bacon, and overall the sandwich was really good. One thing to keep in mind is parking. You won't really find parking right in front since there are signs posted, but I was able to find a spot around the corner without too much trouble. Overall, if you're looking for a quick bite at a decent price, this is a solid choice.

Great bagels!! Loved my interaction with the staff. Inside was organized and easy to get in and out…read moreof. I would definitely recommend if you are in the New Brunswick area!

We stopped here to get a bagel sandwich and a couple bagels with cream cheese. The last time we…read morewere here we were pleased with the quality and service (We visit once per year with family in the area). Unfortunately this visit we had a couple of issues. First was in payment. They charged us $19.48 if we paid cash. I gave the cashier $20.50. This means we should have received $1.02 back. Instead they gave us only $1. I was very confused. The cashier told me they are no longer giving away pennies, yet there is no sign saying this. Coming from North Carolina.... this type of thing would have a sign at the cash register. I could have given exact change if I knew they were going to short me 2 cents. It's not the amount, it's the fact there is no notification. The cashier did eventually return the 2 cents owed. Another issue with the payment is we were charged $1 additional for a jalapeno cheddar bagel. The charge was listed as "custom" on the bill. I asked what this additional charge was for. The cashier stated it was for the jalapeno bagel. I asked her if she could show me how I would know I was going to have an an additional charge for this bagel ? She pointed to fine print on their menu board that said *prices are subject to change. So is she saying we cannot trust the prices that we see on the menu board ? What I assume to be the owner stepped in and said they have been here 25 years and "everybody knows". Well, we are from out of State and do not "know". We especially don't know why a business would not simply avoid confusion by posting a sign in front of the "custom" bagel notifying that it will be priced differently than any other bagel they sell ... which says $1.50 each on the sign directly above the bagel bins. There were several different flavors, so how are we to know there are different prices if the sign above says $1.50 each ??? Instead of simply saying "Oh yes, we should probably put a sign there to avoid confusion." when I made this suggestion to add a sign to notify of the difference in price, the owner Instead got very upset and started complaining about the prices of everything going up. I told him I understand that it is very difficult; but all he needs is a sign so there are no surprises for the customer at the cash register. The owner remained upset and offered to take the bagel back instead of simply saying "that's a good idea" to help their customers avoid surprises such as this. Perhaps upon reflection the owner will see the benefit of clearly stating prices. However, his reaction is the reason that many folks avoid bringing up issues to management.

I showed up 30 seconds late for pick up and the place was already closed. I understand that they…read moreare not going to wait for me, but really? 30 seconds? Went back the next chance I got and I mentioned it to them, they told me to speak with the owner. Complete douche. Not going back. He can keep my $5.

I've been here a few times and it usually is very good but today, I ordered a bagel with scallion…read morecream cheese. I bought it home and my wife took a bite and spit it out because the cream cheese was spoiled. I tried calling them several times to let them know but no one answered and their mailbox was either full or not set up.

Obsessed with this place. Have been coming here for years and they truly have THEE BEST bagels. So…read moresoft and chewy!! So many flavors to choose from etc and the staff are so nice! Their omelette are big in size and flavorful too. Haven't tried any breakfast sandwiches yet, but that's next on my list. Most importantly, I've never had to wait more than a few minutes for my order either.

Ordered delivery and tried a few things from Kettleman's Bagels and overall it was a decent…read moreexperience. The Chicken Salad Sandwich was really good, fresh, flavorful, made exactly to order, and probably the standout here. Also grabbed 1/4 lb each of the egg salad, tuna salad, and chicken salad, and all three were tasty. I think the Egg Salad was probably the best one and reminds me of a deviled egg. The Steak Breakfast Burrito was just ok, but it was definitely heavy on the potatoes and pretty light on the steak which was like shaved steak meat in Philly sandwiches instead of chunks of steak. I think at least half the burrito are potatoes. Still flavorful overall, just not quite balanced the way I expected.

Keepin in real out here in Jersey Random bagel spot i just…read morelooked up and went into cause I needed breakfast. Everything is typical, bagel didnt quite hit the spot for me idk why

If only there was a way to give this dirty place a negative star. I walk in and sit down at a table…read moreto scour the very large menu to decide what to eat. I don't know if he was just a cook or the owner, but this old white man starts shouting at me (mind you, I'm not in any line to place an order). I politely tell him that I needed just one more second to make up my mind. When the time comes for me to order, he rolls his eyes, and I ask him for three Taylor ham, egg and cheeses. Before I could even finish the sentence, he's asking me what kind of bread I want them on, but like an aggressive asshole who thinks I've never walked into a shitty bagel shop before. When my order is complete, he tosses the sandwiches on the counter and tells the young woman to ring "these fuckers" up. He completely fails to tell the young lady what she's supposed to ring me up for. She actually asks me what it was that I ordered. Based on looking at other reviews, I've come to the conclusion that, unfortunately, this man might actually be the owner. I feel so horribly sad for the nice people who have to work under him. He also smelled like shit.

Fast service for simple and filling breakfast. I order from here as a treat because I can't eat…read moresandwiches every morning. After finishing their pork roll egg and cheese I am left satisfied and content. Will keep coming back for more

I got a bacon egg and cheese everything bagel which was super tasty. The bagels are yummy and…read morefresh, and the staff were nice. Good local place

French toast bagel goes crazy Steak egg sandwich gas…read more Nice service Good TVs and not loud Coffee taste like bean water tho

This place is a stone's throw from my in-laws, and we finally stopped in to grab some breakfast…read morebefore heading home to Boston. There were lots of orders and it seemed as though we might need to wait a while, but it turns out that the service is ultra fast, so we got our bagels within a few minutes. I got a plain bagel with veggie cream cheese and it was delicious. My sister in law got a bagel with lox and she said it was a bit too salty, but otherwise decent. Fast service and tasty bagels... we will be back next time!

We love going here. Honestly, these are the hardest working people. We came in the morning of a…read moresnowstorm and they were ready to assist us. Super nice and friends. I always get the BEC and my bf gets the cheese steak on a roll. We recently tried their french toast and it's absolutely BOMB. They are very generous with the syrup and butter. Love this place, def recommend.