Cancel

Open app

Search

BaCalls Cafe

3.8 (125 reviews)
ModerateNew American
Closed • 11:00 am - 10:00 pm

BaCalls Cafe Photos

Business Info

BACALLS CAFE ATMOSPHERE

What's the vibe?
Casual
Quiet
Happy hour specials
Good for kids

You might also consider

Recommended Reviews - BaCalls Cafe

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

Reviews With Photos

Tamika T.

Bacalls is located on Hamilton Ave in the College Hill area. It is part of a DORA also. It is adult and family friendly. They have weekly food specials in addition to their regular menu. The food is decent, sometimes hot or miss. Music bingo every other Saturday, trivia Tuesday, wine Wednesday. Lisa is the best bartender you'll ever meet. Street parking and the lot in the back, they share that lot with different businesses that can be explored while in the area.

Avocado chicken club with Parmesan fries
Erin E.

Super conflicted with this review. The food was decent, but the service was so terribly slow. Came for lunch on a Monday and it took over an hour to get our food. They seemed under staffed. Super friendly people and great atmosphere, so I will come back and give them another try! Hoping we just caught them on a bad day?

Cheese steak au jus with onion straws
Walter B.

Our group from the Y had lunch at Bacalls Cafe today. The service was very efficient, though lacking any warmth. The food was very good. Their specialty is their burgers, but surprisingly, no one ordered one. We decided to try them on a Friday, when burgers and a side are only $10.

Burger week burger
Michael B.

Thank you Burger Week for allowing me to find another hidden gem in Cincinnati. This place is a classic diner/cafe with so many items to chose from with a great selection of drinks also. The staff was so nice and helpful, they greeted us and when we left they said hurry back so you can enjoy many of our other dishes. Can not wait to go back. Thank you BaCalls for a great experience.

Lauren F.

I was so hungry I forgot to take a pic of my food. lol. I had the buttermilk fried chicken sandwich with onion straws on the side. Sandwich was delicious. Add the house made ranch and it was the best. I wasn't impressed with the straws Definitely a diner feel, but service was friendly. I'd go back.

Cheese Nuggets
Alex D.

Classic diner experience! Just get The Burger with the onion straws and you will thank yourself.

Entrance.
Tyanna M.

Stopped in Bacall's Cafe for Cincinnati Burger Week. Thought I would pop in here for lunch and when I went in I said I can sit at the bar and I was told that there was only two servers so they were trying to seat everybody on the same side of the restaurant. They did a great job for only having two servers. The Bacall's Southwest Burger was the one they had at the burger price of $7 so I ordered it and supplemented it with onion straws on the side and a Bahama Mama cocktail. They brought me a water quickly followed by my cocktail. Great Bahama Mama. The burger was wagyu beef with pepperjack cheese, onion straws, lettuce, tomato, pickle, and southwest ranch sauce. I loved the big basket of onion straws with catsup. Nice little place.

Buffalo chicken wrap with Parmesan fries
Alan G.

We haven't been here in years and decided to try them again. Walked in and it was crowded but we were seated right away. It was loud from people talking and the air was blowing cold air so if you get cold you may want to bring a sweater. I had a cup of chili which was tangy and it wasn't bad. I ordered the buffalo wrap with bleu cheese and hot sauce. The wrap itself was good but lacked the taste of bleu cheese. The fries was good but didn't wow me so I may get something else next time. The service was excellent and we will be going back as they have a lot on their menu to choose from.

Me getting ready to chow down!
Daniel K.

Bacall's is a retro diner that is well supported by the local community - the service was amazing - even though they were super busy our server made sure our drinks were topped off and gave us some great suggestions for an appetizer to start our dining experience - the Zucchini fries paired with an amazing aioli for dipping was just what the doctor ordered - the atmosphere was definitely the sign of satisfied patrons - it's always nice to frequent an establishment that is full of happy, and well fed patrons - I had the Wagyu burger and it delivered all of the beefy, umaminess you would expect - delicious!! The dessert offerings were great - I had the bread pudding - more please! All in all a place to enjoy a refreshment from their wide selection of draft beers, wines and mixed driI will definitely be back!

Appetizer fish and chips
Devena S.

The vibe is 100% NY Soho diner. Totally comfortable for the whole family but services a mature crowd. Morghan, my server analyzed and matched my energy spot on, recognizing that I did indeed deserve a bourbon slush. They have a valentines special right now with steak or salmon dinner for 2 plus a bottle of wine for $65. I need one of my besties to slide in with me the 14th or 15th. Just saying. 5 stars because though this is very much classic diner, they have an appetizer that's dish and chips. Long cod fish sticks (not pollock or some other cheap cardboard box whitefish) and a healthy serving of fries with tarter and ketchup. I was shooketh. Almost demoted to 4 stars because the soup of the day (roasted red pepper with Gouda) was a little in the cool side, but it was warm enough. And I received the bourbon slush I deserved. 10/10 or 5 stars out of 5 I'm definitely coming back if I need some solo time out of the house or with a friend.

Bacall's Burger
Mike J.

I've been going here for decades and it has always been great. Kind of a classic American menu but done insanely well. It is definitely upscale compared to standard diner affair. The hosts in wait, staff are always great. My only complaint is that it gets pretty noisy in there when it is crowded, but most places do.

the hours of operation

See all

Reviews are mixed. Many praise the fresh, flavorful food, especially burgers and specials, and enjoy the welcoming atmosphere. Staff are often friendly, and people like the drink specials.

Read the full review summary in the app

9 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

9 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of B H.
0
6
0

12 years ago

First time coming. Pot roast, mashed potatoes and brussel sprouts I recommend. Found out each day they have dinner specials. I will be back

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

14 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

9 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

Page 4 of 4

Ask the Community - BaCalls Cafe

You might also consider

Verify this business for free

People searched for New American 14,670 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

Verify this business

101 Craft Kitchen - Street Corn & Ricotta Dip

101 Craft Kitchen

4.3(75 reviews)
14.0 mi

First and foremost, Olivia was absolutely phenomenal! She was one of the best servers I've had in a…read morevery long time--sweet, personable, attentive, helpful, and genuinely a pleasure to talk to. She made us feel completely comfortable and truly made an already wonderful meal even better. Exceptional service from beginning to end! The restaurant itself is adorable, modern, beautifully decorated, and has a lovely patio. But the service and food completely stole the show. We ordered several appetizers, including the bruschetta, fried green tomatoes, corn and ricotta dip, and pimento croquettes. I'm VERY picky, and I genuinely wouldn't change a single thing. Every dish was flavorful, perfectly balanced, beautifully presented, and cooked exactly right. The bruschetta was so good that we ordered a second round! The fried green tomatoes were perfectly crisp with a delicious sauce, and the pimento croquettes were crispy on the outside, creamy inside, and paired perfectly with the sauce and pickles. The corn and ricotta dip was delicious as well. Nothing was too salty, under-seasoned, overcooked, or missing anything. The flavors were spot-on across the board. For dessert, we had the peach butter cake with everything on the side. The cake was delicious on its own and even better with the ice cream. It's rare to try so many dishes and not want to change a single thing, but that was the case here. The food was top-notch, and Olivia truly made the experience. We will definitely be back and will absolutely recommend this place to others. Amazing food, amazing service, and an overall experience that went above and beyond.

I went with a group here and it was great! The service was fast and our waitress was extremely…read morepleasant. She was friendly and knowledgeable about the menu. I loved how she verified food allergies with the cooks. The food was great! The wings were a good size and the sauce was nice. The asparagus was cooked well and the aoli accompanied it very well. The star was the peach butter cake! The first bite tasted like a cinnamon roll and kept pulling you back in. I'd 100% give this place a shot in you're in the area.

Photos
101 Craft Kitchen
101 Craft Kitchen - Blackened Grouper Sandwich

Blackened Grouper Sandwich

101 Craft Kitchen

See all

Northstar Cafe

Northstar Cafe

4.4(106 reviews)
9.1 mi
•$$

Northstar has figured out the balance between a relaxing lounge and upscale restaurant. The service…read moreis friendly and attentive. The leadership is impeccable. We've been to the Kenwood and Liberty Township locations and the consistent nature of their excellence is impressive. From the bright Pad Thai with grilled chicken to the comforting banana pancakes Northstar is Ohio's benchmark for elevated hospitality. Ps Great taste in music Sufjan Stevens was a nice touch.

Northstar Cafe never disappoints. Seriously, this place is stamped in our book…read more The service is almost always A1, and even when the food takes a little longer than usual, they usually make up for it somehow or throw us a comp card, which we definitely appreciate. I also LOVE the setup here. You pay first, get your food second, and everything just seems to run smoothly. No unnecessary waiting around trying to figure out what's going on. My wife and I usually rotate between the pancakes, the hash, the Northstar Burger, or the potato hash. Honestly, you really can't go wrong with any of them. The food is always fresh, portions are good, and everything comes out looking like somebody actually cared about what they put on the plate. We probably go once or twice a week, especially for brunch. At this point, Northstar is basically family. And if you're like us and pretty picky about where you eat, this is definitely one that gets the stamp of approval. Great food, good atmosphere, and consistently solid service. One more thing: I believe they play jazz after 6 PM Monday through Friday, which is always a nice little bonus. Overall, definitely recommend if you're looking for good food with a nice ambiance. Northstar has a permanent spot in our rotation!

Photos
Northstar Cafe
Northstar Cafe - Cast-iron steak and enchilada

Cast-iron steak and enchilada

Northstar Cafe

See all

Kitchen Social - Chicken sausage pizza with tomato sauce

Kitchen Social

4.5(294 reviews)
10.4 mi
•$$

We were told this place was great and I would say it was just okay. Our server was very sweet but…read morehad a full section and then was sat with a huge party. They did have a dedicated Gluten Free menu but I noticed that some of the items just didn't come either some of the sides of the regular menu items - so I was nervous to order them because I wasn't sure if I would be full. I ordered the sushi bowl and it was really good though. The chicken tenders were hand battered and looked really good. So overall I'd say it was good, but just not great. PS avoid the sangria unless you like yours tasting like sweet fruit juice.

My husband and I just visited here for the first time three weeks ago and have already returned…read moretwice. It is the best value for a sit down restaurant we have found in the area recently. The service is really good. Seated promptly, waters come out promptly, minor order modifications handled easily. We have really enjoyed the variety of food. My husband loves the salads and the bowls and pizzas are also good. Probably the favorite entree we have had is the fish and chips. We find the drinks particularly reasonably priced and the cocktails are good. We really like the blueberry one. The space is sunny and open. We have been with our kids and see lots of friendly groups dining there. Free parking in the garage is another plus.

Photos
Kitchen Social - Bar and high top tables.

Bar and high top tables.

Kitchen Social - Kids pizza

Kids pizza

Kitchen Social - Street Corn Nachos

See all

Street Corn Nachos

BaCalls Cafe - newamerican - Updated October 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...