Great local place with the freshest ingredients. Service is VERY friendly. Atmosphere is modern…read moreand cool. Beer Cheese - $6.99 - Very good and very filling. It may cause you to have leftovers of your pizza. 5/5 stars. Chicken Bruschetta Pizza - $13.35 - I thought the balsamic vinegar would be overpowering, but it was not. Good balance and good amount of toppings. 5/5 stars. Mushroom Medley - $13.35 - Love this pizza, but I'm also partial to mushroom pizzas. 5/5 stars. Cheese - $11.25 - This one is just fine. Not a whole lot of cheese pull and it's boring to me, but hey, people seem to like that. 4/5 stars. They get their cheesecakes from Pixie Pies: Neapolitan Cheesecake - $7 - Very good cheesecake. Similar to an In-and-Out Neapolitan milkshake. 5/5 stars. My only complaint about this place is that sometimes the dough has a nice fluffy crust and sometimes it's flat. I do prefer the fluffy crust. Not sure why that consistency is overlooked. Highly recommend this place.

Walked in with 8 people not realizing they closed in 12 minutes and was greeted with "can we help…read moreyou?" Yes we came to eat like everyone else in the restaurant and the employee very sarcastically says " at 850, yeah sure let's do it" So we asked if they had any other recommendations and she says "sorry not from here but go ahead and sit down." I let her know she was very rude so we wouldn't be sitting down and went somewhere else that was very eager to take a table of 8 and a 200 dollar check!

Drop Zone is always our go to for pizza/wings. The pickle…read morepizza and hot honey pizza are my favorite. The pilot bread is good too!

One of my favorites. Wood fired crust. Think I prefer it over Firedstone. First discovered it at…read morethe Chamber Reverse Raffle. Had a taste of the pickle pizza. Really good, but not sure I'd like an entire pizza. I prefer the pepperoni. Only concern is the limited hours. Closed Mondays and closes pretty early even on Friday and Saturday by many standards. So get there early and enjoy!!!

I've been here twice now - March 2025 and June 2025. Definitely one of the top 5 best pizzas I've…read moreever had. Neither trip did I slow down long enough to get any photos... but I order whatever their version of the meat lover's is & you can bet I'll get it next time too. The service has been just fine both times and the order comes out quickly (as quick as it takes to make and bake a pizza)!

Really like the baked spaghetti, taco salads, and of course the pizza. Good variety of different…read moretypes of pizza to try. They're generous on the toppings and you won't leave here hungry. Very spacious restaurant for your large family gatherings. Highly recommend

Nestled in a quaint little small little America town in Warsaw, Indiana, you would never guess that…read morethis hip and oh so delicious little pizzeria would exist. With progressive atmosphere and absolutely friendly staff our waitress Tish was fantastic. She absolutely made the experience so worth it. Also open for brunch on the weekends, which is a very unique concept. This establishment serves only the freshest ingredients, beware of the cherry tomatoes on the goat cheese pizza because the juice trajectory is insane!! You can tell that the dough on these pizzas is freshly made every day, and do not visit here without ordering the garlic knots they will change your life!!

Fantastic NY-style pizza. Tastes fantastic, from the cheese, to the crust, to the sauce. Top…read moreingredients and cooked perfectly. Very similar to what you would get at various pizzerias in NYC.

For a lakeside bar, I guess it's okay. It isn't horrible, but it also isn't going to blow you out…read moreof the water. We went during trivia, and before you continue to read, the trivia was FANTASTIC! The dining area is slightly dingy, with sticky tables and run-down seating. The dive-bar aesthetic is cool, but don't expect cleanliness. The bathroom had all types of broken things, but again, it's what you sign up for. Service is always awesome (expected at a place like this). People are super nice, and even helpful during trivia! As far as the food goes, we ordered pizza. It is your typical bar pie, with nothing pushing it to the "above-average" mark. If you are expected fine-dining, this is not your place to go. If you are expecting a lakeside bar, friendly people, and a crisp, cold beer, then Portside Pizza is the place for you.

We get pizzas here quite often because it is the closet place to get pizza if you live in Tri-Lakes…read morearea. Pizzas are always good and packed with cheese. There are many kinds of pizza and other food. Highly recommend!

I called at 4:05pm on a Saturday 5 minutes after they opened. Busy. My buddy told me they're good…read more We both called on separate phones for around 20 call attempts before I got through. We ordered a 12" pepperoni, mushroom and cheese pizza. Advised cash only. Told pick-up at 5pm. Sounds good. We arrived a few minutes early and the parking lot was packed! This is a pick-up only restaurant. My buddy went inside to pay and came back out stating it would be a few more minutes. He waited inside. Around 5pm he came out with our pizza. The pizza wasn't in a box. It was on a cardboard circle put in a paper type bag with another paper type bag over that bag. As for the taste? Up there with one of the best pizzas I've ever had. Price: $17.50.

Jim's is a great place to get your fresh made pizza. Made the same way for over 40 years. A take…read moreout pizza only. Call early the phone lines start early and they book up fast.

Great pizza! The sauce is fantastic. A nice, cozy place. Good, friendly service. This is a must try!read more

What an amazing place, great food, great service, great atmosphere!! Got the Jerk Pork chop and it…read morewas insanely flavorful. The Deviled Eggs were on another level, definitely not your grandmothers. Christian was our server and was impeccable.

We had a pepperoni and sausage pizza delivered on a Friday evening. Pizza arrived hot in the time…read moreframe they quoted. We like the pizza from Pepperoni's better than anyone else's in the area. Delivery to our home is an added bonus!

Food was amazing! Arrived right at open and phones were already ringing off the hook. I knew I made…read morethe right decision when the woman behind the counter went above and beyond to make us feel welcomed. I drive past this place often and finally decided to pop in when the snow was getting bad. I ordered the chicken spinach deluxe pizza and it was so cheesy and delicious, the seasonings on top were a really great touch. My partner got the slammer sandwich, toasted to absolute perfection! He said it was fresh and savory with a nice touch of spice from the pepperoncini. This place was off the hook! Will 10/10 be returning.

Food = fantastic. I thought the pizza was really good…read more Service = okay. Our server came over a few times to check on us, but wasn't entirely friendly. Ambiance = diner vibes. I could see it getting loud in there for sure. Thankfully we went at a time during middle of day/week to where there wasn't hardly anyone in there.

Came in for the first time on a Saturday around one. The dinning room was empty. We walked down a…read morehallway and there we found employees. We didn't know if we were to order at the counter or a table. Employee said table. We sat down and noticed that the table top looked unclean and greasy, like it had been wiped with a dirty cloth. We changed tables. Not much better. The server was nice, but not too informative. She said they were out of Pasta, Meatballs, and no olives. We are not from here so we assumed they had a busy Friday night. The server went on to say that it was not busy at all on Friday night and that Saturday was turning out just as slow. We were not told of the lunch specials. They were not on the menu. So we ordered the Pizza Forum Special pizza. The Pizza came fairly quickly, and was fabulous! The crust was perfect, and the toppings were fairly generous. The only thing was I don't think there was ham on the Pizza as stated in the menu. Out of that too? But it was still a very good pizza!!! We will give them another try when we go back to Kendallville. Hopefully they'll have all the menu items.