Just dropped $100 taking 5 people to eat at Automatic. Cool place, and I will admit the food was good, but not worth $20 per person. Part of the problem is their policy of charging double for toppings if you split toppings. In all my days, no where in the pizza eating world have I ever encountered that! And it's not on the menu. And when I asked, "can we split topings" they said sure. So, for example, one was a large ($18) with 2 topings, split half basil+tomato on one side and spinach+sausage on the other side. We were charged for 4 topings at $1.90 each instead of 2. Same happened on a second pizza. To my mind, I was overcharged 4 topings or about $8 with tax. When I asked the server about the charge he said that was how they did it and he could not refund the overcharge. So, I'll give 4 stars for the food, 1 star for parking and comfort, 1 star for value, and 1 star for customer service. That averages out around 2 overall. I won't be going back. $100 for pizza for 5? Save your money and get better on all counts at DePalmas, Pepino's, Little Italy, TransMet... read more

This place is awesome. Great food and atmosphere. Kids love eating on the picnic tables and picking out the animals for table markers!

Oh man! One of my favorite places for pizza and Italian subs! The prices can't be beat and the Neapolitan style pizza has a nice crispy crust all around. The pizza isn't soggy and chewy like other places in Athens. The Italian sub is so good! Put the pickled peppers they give you on the side and stuff them in the sub, and you'll never regret it! The draft Abita root beer is also very good with the pizza and subs. read more

My son and I were hungry/hangry and wanted pizza so we saw that and stop. I was so surprised at how good it was. I am from NY and have had the best pizza! Automatic pizza is right up there. read more

This review has needed an update for a while, my bad. My review was done right after opening and they had some kinks to work out for sure. Consistently improving and now the only place in town we get pizza from. Great thin crust, toppings generously applied but not overkill sauce is pretty good. I lived in jersey for a long time so I know what good pizza is. This is good pizza. I have leftovers heating up as I type and I am happy about that. read more

Staff was friendly and toppings are ok, but the crust was so soggy it was falling apart in the middle and it was limp everywhere else. Not easy to eat and not pleasant at all. The large is giant, be forewarned. read more

My friends come here way too much since we live close by and just walk (so we don't have to deal with parking). We always sit down at Normal Bar and have the pizza brought to us, which is a nice feature. The pizza is thin, floppy, and greasy (ideal to me, maybe not to others). One time it took a really long time, so they comped us a round of drinks at Normal, which was awesome. I'm a fan, but I can see how if you didn't like that style of pizza this place wouldn't be for you (you can ask them to cook the crust more than usual if that's your thing). My only complaint is that the big pizzas are a little expensive, but split between a group of people, it's not too bad. read more

I am shocked by the poor reviews! This place is the best! I walk to it at least two, probably three times a week. It definitely caters to the Normaltown crowd...thanks! Bad reviews likely coming from college students. Order the "double Dad pour" next time! You won't regret it. read more

Give this place a shot. It's weird right now because of COVID and not being able to dine in, but the pepperoni calzone with their white sauce is amazing. Only $9 (I think), and tough to finish on your own. We come here any chance we get. read more

I ordered the pizza to be delivered by bulldawg food. The pizza arrived on time which was great! The pizza was very greasy and there was only like 1 pepperoni per slice and their slices are huge on a large. I was like, where are the pepperoni's??? They really skimped on the pepperoni's. Overall the taste was just ok. I'll buy Domino's next time. read more

Automatic Pizza - Greasy & only 1 pepperoni per slice if that. You can see 0 pepperoni's on 1 of the slices. The other half had both mushrooms & pepperoni's - Pizza Near Me - Athens, Georgia

Wasn't expecting how good this would be. The Italian sandwich and captures reallly hit the spot. It automatically hooked me. read more

Automatic Pizza - Digging in - Pizza Near Me - Athens, Georgia

Stopped by after a workout and found easy parking on the side of the building. Alas, leaving that spot was a nightmare but I'm jumping a bit forward. Had a salad (large one with mixed green and some general salad veggies) with a citrus vinaigrette but nixed that addition of chicken for extra $. Got one slice of cheese pizza to snuggle up on the side. Both items were good but not noteworthy. The wait was about 20 minutes and I was the only person there. The spot is tiny and it has lots of right angles. They're trying to make the most of the space but it isn't the best layout. I ended up taking up a huge picnic table outside because there isn't any smaller seating out there. Maybe a table for 2 or something? Service was friendly. read more

This pizza is made on spot and tasted great! We did the create your own. We did traditional sauce, it was very good and not overly put on the pizza. They also have pesto or white sauce The crust is very good and freshly made. Medium was plenty for two. The large is humongous! Indoor and outdoor seating. It's a restaurant with atmosphere from previously being an old corner service station. I will definitely go back. Parking is limited but other than that, all I can say is positive for someone wanting pizza. Very friendly group working there, enjoyed it! read more

The atmosphere is authentic Athens...eclectic enough but completely welcoming. The large pepperoni pizza was much bigger than the 20" advertised. It is, though, fabulously foldable and delicious. We also ordered a specialty pizza called a Thunderbird, white sauce, chicken, green peppers, and artichoke hearts. Order extra sauce. It was a bit dry. The overall experience was exceptional and I look forward to another visit. read more

Delicious pizza and even better service! The renovated gas station made for an interesting environment with character. We were just steps in the door when we were welcomed by Eric from behind the counter. He was a ray of sunshine. We decided to order a small thunderbird pizza and were not disappointed! Fresh green pepper, artichoke and onion were delicious with the huge chicken chunks and white sauce. The crust was thin and had a nice little crunch. I would definitely come here for lunch again. The outside picnic tables would be great to sit at and people watch from on a nicer day. read more

See all

I've been here twice now. Both times, we lucked out with a great parking space in their tiny lot, but if not, I'd imagine the parking would be a little annoying like most places around Normaltown. Here's the thing. The first time we went, it was the first week they were open so I wanted to cut them some slack. The space is cool but tiny, so all the tables inside were full. The line was at the door, and it moved very slowly. After I ordered my slice and my bf ordered a calzone, we were given a plastic animal in lieu of a number, which was a nice touch. It was just a slightly stressful situation. Even with the slow-moving line, all the tables were occupied once we placed our order. There were tables outside, but it was freezing and the outside area wasn't covered and there were no heat lamps. My slice came out, and we were still standing awkwardly by the door with a slice of pizza and our plastic dog, scanning the room for anybody who looked like they were about to finish up their meal. We finally snagged a table with another couple after 30 minutes of waiting. Onto the food: the pizza was good but not great. It looked slightly anemic, like it needed a couple minutes more in the oven. The calzone was good but the ricotta was really watery and seeped out of calzone as soon as you cut into it, and it was served with cold marinara sauce which was off-putting. Our second visit was a little better. We got a prime parking spot, the line moved faster, but all the tables were filled again. Once we got our animal, a table was open and we grabbed it immediately. It was exhilarating, to say the least. I got a slice again, and my boyfriend got the calzone again. The food was also improved this time. My slice still needed a little more time in the oven. The calzone seemed like it had more color, but still had watery ricotta. This time, the marinara sauce was warm. Overall, I would come back to Automatic if I happened to be around Normaltown. Pizza and calzone were fine, not the best I've had, but it's cheap. Hopefully, they invest in some heat lamps and cover up the outdoor area in the fall and winter so it's a little less crazy trying to get a table. Or just get it to-go. read more

Cool little pizza place. You can order whole pies or by the slice. Very good prices and very tasty pizza. Limited seating inside and outside. Small beer and wine selection but a neat little place to grab a bite to eat. One of our go to places for a last minute dinner solution. Thin sliced, brick oven fired. Also delivers to the Normal Bar next door, which is awesome! read more

Automatic is a great addition to the neighborhood. I love sitting in the old gas station, watching traffic on Prince Avenue. I love how they have vegan pizza. The other day, when I somehow neglected to order vegan cheese, they remade my pizza. That's customer service for you!! read more

After reading in an Article online about how I could get a vegan slice for $2.00 I was super excited. I came here and they said they only preassemble their pizza for slices with mozzarella and they could "scrape it off". This is unacceptable to me. I had to spend $12 on a calzone which is the next cheapest option. All I wanted was a slice which was advertised. Why they couldn't just make a vegan pie to give me a slice from is beyond me. I would have waited since I had to wait for a calzone anyway. read more

I went here today for the first time and I have to say I wasn't impressed. First of all, I ordered a small whole pizza while my friends both ordered slices. While I can understand the slices coming out first, I had to wait at least 20 mins longer (maybe a total of 30 mins) for my pizza. And once I got the pizza, it was ok, but too much cheese for me. I at least prefer equal cheese to sauce, but more so more sauce than cheese. And the pizza was overcooked! read more

The pizza was pretty good and the large is huge! We ordered the El Camino, it comes with jalapeños on it, so we asked for it be on only half. They had jalapeños on the entire thing, which was disappointing for those in the group who can't handle too much heat. I've also never seen so many pepper seeds on a pizza before, it was slightly uncomfortable when you bit down. read more

Automatic Pizza - El Camino - Pizza Near Me - Athens, Georgia

Best pizza in the city. I love this place. I used to be a Little Italy's junkie until I discovered automatic. Awesome environment, awesome NY pizza, awesome crust, awesome music, awesome staff. Maybe they could expand their beer selection. Pizza is perfect; best I've had outside of New York. read more

As someone who moved to athens recently from new york. This place is a god send! Your not eating "real" pizza unless your getting it here!

Great pizza, great price, very consistent. One time I called in a to-go order and they gave me the wrong pizza. (Someone else with the same name, the orders got swapped.) When I went back they apologized, gave a full refund and made me a new pizza. A+ customer service. Love this place. read more

Cool place to grab a pizza. Atmosphere is great and the setup of the diner is cool. Food was great and a super friendly staff. Will definitely be stopping back in next time I'm in Athens. read more

We waited for almost an hour for our pizza. Pizza was pretty good but nothing special. I guess it's worth going when it's not busy.

I love this place. However..... Since it got a soda machine I feel... heartbroken. They took away a main component of its allure, for me. They used to have a water dispenser you could get water from when you first walk in. Now you're forced to go into that ... Ughk... Hallway. I don't want to be in that hallway. I just don't! read more

I go here multiple times a week. Best slice in town. I usually go for Literally's Pizza downtown on Lumpkin St when I have my slice hankering, but Automatic Pizza is top of the top notches. It caters to the neighborhood and people walking first and foremost, so year, if parking it a factor for you in how good pizza is then I can see how you wouldn't like this place. I love it though. Dinosaurs and attractive employees always helps. read more

This place has the best pizza and prices in Athens. Delicious subs and calzones if you're not in the mood for pizza either. I just say I've had outstanding service there as well. My last visit was nothing short of perfect. read more

Good change up from where we normally eat in Athens but nothing mind blowing or spectacular. Pizza is huge which is cool and you can eat it next door at their sister restaurant where there are tvs which is good during football season but the pizza itself is average to good, a bit on the greasy side for me. I will go back again but it won't be the first dinner option for us the next time we're in Athens. read more

Best pizza place in Athens. I make my own dough and sauce, but when I want good pizza out, this is where we go. The crust is tasty, crispy, and can hold up to the toppings. Sauce is also fresh and well seasoned. Love the staff and the fact they deliver to one of my favorite bars in Athens! Sometimes it's a long wait, but when we order on the way it's usually ready by the time we get there. read more

We thought the pizza was great and the service was stellar! We grabbed a pizza and took it out to Terrapin!

Great calzones! I'm an anchovy person and they have amazing anchovies too! Worth the price, which starts at $6.50 for a cheese calzone. Haven't had their sandwiches yet. read more

I went for the first time to Automatic Pizza last night after hearing great things about the food. I heard the wait is a bit long and they were correct. I called in a pick-up and took my time getting there and still had a good wait ahead of me. I noticed the limited space in and outside of this very hip establishment and wondered how they accommodated on busy evenings/days.....I think if they replaced the 4 huge outside tables with more smaller patio tables they would benefit from the extra sitting. The pizza was the best I have had in Athens in a long while....of course everyone has their on preference but it was to my liking .....it was a little salty and the crust was thin and chewy....and who doesn't like lot's of cheese (please don't answer that)!! Great topping options and they even accommodated me with my special request. The prices are a bit on the high side but a great pizza splurge! I will for sure be CALLING in more orders but not sure I would want to sit and wait. Great job guys!! read more

Loved the cheese pizza! Thin crust tasty sauce nice amount of cheese.....I am from NJ and I would say this is like Yankee pizza! Very yummy pizza! read more

Just ate lunch here, and our order was screwed up a little bit but they fixed it didn't charge awesome customer service and wonderful pizza.

Good pizza but shady business. We've had our credit card numbers stolen multiple times after eating here. So pay in cash!

Pizza has improved immensely in the past year. Nice and wide variety of ingredients. Great salads.

First time and I was impressed ! The toppings on my slice were fresh, delicious, and plenty of them. The crust , that thin "melt in your mouth" crust , is what you come to Automatic for !! It was a great overall experience and they have beers! I tried the new Creature Comforts Automatic and it was a very tasty brew. Great place! read more

It's a really cute restaurant with really great food. Their pizza is the best in Athens for sure. The service is great and the wait time is short usually read more