I cannot believe it. I called around 4:30 pm for dinner pickup. They told me they were so busy that food wouldn't be ready until 7:30 pm. I guess will not be going there or ordering from them on weekends. They have no online order system either. Terrible. I miss them in the old Maplewood location, they had all the order system setup, and now they are so close to our house, but I cannot go there because they are so busy... So sad. I drove by last Friday night around 5 pm, and the line outside was crazy, with the parking full. I tried again on Sunday at noon time. I called again around 10:30 am, and they had it ready by 11:30 am. Much larger place, and it was not crowded like Friday night. We picked up some freshly baked pastries as well. I ordered Boar pasta which was excellent, and margarita pizza, which was good as well with fresh mozz cheese. I would go back there for lunchtime for their pasta dishes. The pizza was okay, but nothing that was striking about it. So I learned that this place is good for lunch, not so much for dinner. The price was average as well. Personal pie 11" was around $17, and pasta was about $18. I recommend this place a try. The pastry with blueberry was so good, very fresh blueberries. We also got one with ham and cheese. Both are great. We will return for parties, too. read more

Our lunch experience at Arties was THE BEST! We ordered the delicious smoked salmon and Italian American sandwiches, and the Margherita and Santo pizzas were perfect for takeout for our dinner later. We couldn't resist taking some pastries home--they were just as amazing! And we LOVED the Arties lemonade The service was exceptionally warm and attentive, from the hostess, Ellice to the manager, Amanda and our server, Adam. They were awesome! With top-tier hospitality and delicious food, Arties has definitely earned our repeat business. A must-visit spot! read more

Artie's - Artie's Lemonade - Pizza Near Me - Maplewood, New Jersey

I used to go to Arturo's Pizza in Maplewood Avenue that became with the expansion of a bakery, Arty's. The painting food at Auturos was simply sublime. It was worth waiting on line to eat there. The new restaurant is far bigger but much noiser making conversation difficult. The menu consist of lots of appetizers and pizza but only four pasta dishes. There's also many mixed drinks. Most people order the crostini and ricotta for the appetizer and it's great. The pizzas are good but not as good as they were. It is not excellent, I'll stand online good. Where the menu really falls down is having four pasta dishes. While some reviews said they would let you order other dishes like the mushroom pasta, a favorite that's still being asked for and not just by me, you can't. None of them were appealing, so rather than have a the crostini a small pizza and sharing a pasta, we shared a larger pizza. Service was prompt, the ambiance was "this used to be light manufacturing and is now a restaurant", which means no baffling. It's just really noisy. Is it worth going to? Sort of a toss-up. Food is good but no longer excellent while the offerings are more limited. read more

Previously Arturo's, Artie's still caters to their beloved customers with a modern and bigger space and still keeping the same great food they would serve. Our hostess and servers were friendly and amicable, just worth mentioning that because of some reviews saying that they had a bad experience with customer service. We had a party of 15 and were sat on 3 different tables which we were told of beforehand. Didn't mind this. It is a pretty large group and we weren't the first in line for dinner, so diners will be staggered on their way out. For starters we had the meatballs, crostini, and kale salad. Such simple dishes but so good! All seasoned simply yet well. Would def do the crostinis if you were to pick one. For pizzas, we had the margherita, corn and shishito, arugula and prosciutto, half pepperoni/half margherita. The crust was perfectly charred for all the pizzas and the undercrust held its shape and crunch. Pizza sauce had just the right tartness and flavor. For pasta, we had the wild boar ragu and the daily pasta (corn, tomato, zucchini) to change up the palate. The daily pasta was refreshing and light, and the pasta noodles were cooked perfectly. The wild boar ragu was creamy and heavy and filling, perfectly seasoned. Because there will always be a line, there is an outdoor waiting area with some benches and chairs for customers to wait at. There are also serves to take drink orders as you wait if you wish. Parking is a problem as it's street parking. There are side streets available but it would be nice to have a bid dedicated lot since the resto is pretty big and can seat alot of people at one time. The resto rooms are clean and smells nice- this is always a point for me to notice because I just hate skeevy restrooms. Must come back for their pastries and coffee in the morning. That'll be soon :) read more

See all

Kinda confused about the high ratings. Came here for lunch and was greeted by a sweet hostess. Once seated our waitress was pretty unfriendly and not very attentive from the start but we made the best of it. We ordered two spritz's and we loved them..followed by the Cesar salad and meatballs. Loved the Cesar salad but the meatballs although super fresh could use some seasoning. We got a pizza with bacon onions and chilli oil..mediocre. Actually I'm still waiting to taste the chilli oil. This all was surprising because isnt the pizza here suppose to be the star of the show? I found it overall to be expensive for the quality. I kinda get why people like it here as it kinda doubles as a cafe and has some outdoor seating but I just wasn't impressed. I wont be back ever. read more

Can't get better than this brick oven pizza spot so close to the locals! Service and food were good for the 10th plus time. But the prices are very high and seemed to keep going up. read more

You will find Artie on a side street. Lots of people have found it. So the noise level is pretty high. But the food is pretty good. We shared a Kake Caesar salad to start. It was a nice start. There are only 4 pasta entrees. But several different pizzas. We opted for the individual size mushroom pizza. It was very good. The knives are not sharp enough to eat the pizza with a knife and fork ( believe me, we tried). But it was crisp and flavorful. The service is split to several people. The first person takes your order and another person delivers it. They were all very nice. It was crowded for a Monday evening. read more

Outstanding service, beautifully prepared dishes, and a warm atmosphere made this visit exceptional. Every plate was flavorful and fresh. From start to finish, the experience exceeded expectations and felt truly special. read more

The old adage when a place expands, it loses its touch is sadly true here. When it was "Arturo's" they offered two kinds of pizza - both margarita and traditional. The margarita was very good but the traditional was off the hook. For some reason, now that Arturo's has expanded and became 'Artie's', they only do Neapolitan style now, and axed the traditional. Imo, it's a big mistake, but Artie's is clearly getting the last laugh - as you easily face a two hour wait on weekends. The fact they don't take reservations is great for them - i.e., guests are 'trapped' and almost always order drinks and apps while waiting. However, you'd think stuffing us in like cattle - without so much as a text when your table is ready, they would at least serve you a martini in a proper glass. The 'half size' tiny glasses are extortion. As far as the apps, we tried the beats and chickpeas. both were just okay - the beets are great but could use more flavor. they use cheap balsamic. Same for the chickpeas. just okay. The main attraction- the Neapolitan pizza is very good - great crust and consistency of dough, but overall they could use a bit more flavor. even just a bit of kosher salt, like razza does, would help. again, I'm sure they don't care as they're packed 24/7. But the new spot definitely drops them down a notch in my book due to the lack of parking, the 'every man for himself' vibe to get a table, and the nixing of their best imo pizza. read more

Artie's - the old 'traditional style' they stopped making. #Awesome - Pizza Near Me - Maplewood, New Jersey

See all

Love the new location; there's a parking lot in the back and a lot more seating. Best part is the food is still top notch! We ordered the Orecchiette Piccante, wild boar pasta & farmer's pie. The wild boar pasta was definitely the best; it was creamy and savory. The piccante was excellent to, love the ricotta flavor on top of the tomato sauce. We've really enjoyed the new location. Definitely will return! read more

See all

First time at Arturo's, and so glad to have tried it ! Nestled in the heart of Maplewood, has both indoor and outdoor seating. Luckily went there early, but the restaurant filled up so quickly. Service was good and relatively quick, it has BYOB ! We ordered the traditional margarita pizza and bread basket. Both so good !!! Will definitely be coming back and recommending the place to my friends too ! read more

Artie's - Bread and oil dip - Pizza Near Me - Maplewood, New Jersey

See all

The pizzas I order to go on Martin Luther King Holiday 2026 weren't good at all because they were burned, I couldn't eat them. I can't recommend this place my reputation will go down. read more

This place has everything. There's a full bar, coffee shop, baked goods, and Italian. The red and green pizza and the farmers salad were amazing. 10/10 service, very attentive. If you blink you might this place. read more

Artie's - Red and Green Pizza with Arugula - Pizza Near Me - Maplewood, New Jersey

See all

The pizza was very crispy and burn naked however I enjoy it like that so please note that if you like your lighter ask for it. As far as the bread and oil oil I was not impressed at all, bread is amazing but I believe that's my fault they gave us pure olive oil. No seasoning or nothing on it just straight up olive oil. Maybe it's because I'm Portuguese so I'm used to the oil oil being season but plain oil was crazy to me how people enjoyed that. As far as olives they was fantastic, I love them so much are they taste more pure like more tree is that makes sense. The cola was okay it's not that's tasteful as the regular coke however it's more syrupy but it's drinkable. Lastly the chocolate crossantis were good. As well I recommend asking for a side of Marianna and dipping the pizza in it, it made it 10 times better. As far are the ambiance it was great there was tables and high tables as well as Botha they had everything read more

Excellent pizza and ricotta crostini, loved the atmosphere and the service was excellent. read more

See all

Pizza is delicious and amazing. Sometimes there's a wait but you can get a drink or snack while waiting and the food is good and a fun place to hang out at! read more

Artie's - Pizza Near Me - Maplewood, New Jersey

See all

One of the most authentic pasta dishes I've had outside of Italy in a super casual "cafe" type environment. My drink was also fantastic and the service was quick and friendly. Based on my experience today I couldn't recommend this place enough. read more

Artie's - Orecchiette pasta & Negroni bianco - Pizza Near Me - Maplewood, New Jersey

Wow! How do I give more stars? Since it is packed evenings and weekends we went at 5, when they open for dinner. Had the kale Caesar (I don't even like kale and it was delicious), meatballs, wild boar pasta, and pizza with pork sausage. WOW! Every single thing was delicious. Beyond delicious. Highly recommend. The only closest competitor is Locale in Little Silver. Oh wait! There's more! There's a bread/pastry counter! Croissant and chocolate croissant are DELICIOUS! read more

We got here an hour early and left, but wish we hadn't, because when we came back it was packed! We had to wait and additional hour but they came around taking drink orders while we waited outside. The pizza was so good and came out quickly. I liked the white pizza more than I expected, it had a nice touch of salt. Definitely recommend, but it's super dark inside, so we ate quickly and lefty read more

See all

Service is awful, a long decline from Arturos. Menu is stale with no specials, could not be more disappointed . We got two pizzas, had a full one left over and they jammed it into a small box! Sad. read more

Artie's - An entire pizza jammed into a small box. Either complete morons or too cheap to use a standard box - Pizza Near Me - Maplewood, New Jersey

We came here last week for lunch after traveling to NJ and we loved our meal here! The restaurant is an interesting mix of wood-fired pizza and Italian food and a bakery and coffee shop, which was very fun. Our service was good overall and we had no issues throughout our meal. We had the roasted broccoli for an appetizer and it was absolutely delicious; the ricotta salata and the lemon were a great combo and we could have eaten just a big bowl of that. Our pizza was also delicious (we got the Santo) and the sausage and chili oil were a great combo. The baked goods also looked amazing, but we were too full to partake, so that'll have to be on the next visit. This place was great and we would definitely come here again! read more

Artie's - Delicious roasted broccoli - Pizza Near Me - Maplewood, New Jersey

See all

Had dinner here a few days ago. Usually I stop in get some pastries and coffee and head out. I decided to check out the evening ambiance on a weeknight. I came just when they opened (5pm) and was quickly seated. A few other patrons were there as well. I ordered the beet salad and an individual Margherita pie. I also ordered a cocktail, which surprised me that they offered. The decor is cozy rustic farmhouse. The beet salsa was delicious and the pizza was also. The cocktail was quite good. This place has been a standard for me and doesn't disappoint. I've not had a bad experience here. read more

See all

Cool ambiance. Little dark. Service was extremely good. They had the waitress taking drink orders outside. Make sure to allow for wait time. We got here 30min before opening the went away until open. We arrived 10 min after opening and there was an hour wait. We missed all the people waiting in their cars 30 min prior. Food was excellent read more

We had been meaning to order from here for quite some time. We ordered and I went to pick up and then the adventure began. They had moved and I had to navigate to the far end of Maplewood to find it. The new space is nice and looks like a great place to dine in. We ordered a Santo (sausage, fresh mozzarella, tomato sauce, onion, and chilli oil. Delicious pizza! I'd definitely order again or dine in. They had a nice selection of baked goods and desserts as well in the case. Located kinda far for me but plenty of parking. Industrial area. Guessing space and lease were much better than downtown Maplewood. Give it a try you will be glad that you did. read more

If you're on the hunt for pizza that breaks away from the usual, look no further than Arties. I checked them out a couple of times with my family and wow, what a treat! They have really creative and delicious pies. Only downside is the parking. There is limited parking in the back for the crowd that frequents this establishment. Otherwise you'd have to find street parking. Overall, Arties is a must-visit for any pizza lover looking to try something new and delicious. We can't wait to go back. read more

Had a feeling this spot might be good just from the number of cars and people walking in when I was trying to find park. There's a small parking lot (gravel) in the back, along with street parking. Staff was super friendly and food was delicious! Grabbed a pastry on my way out from the coffee bar. read more

Artie's - Orecchiette piccante & Bosco pizza (individual size) - Pizza Near Me - Maplewood, New Jersey

Came here for a quick bite and to chill for a bit in the morning with my girlfriend while my car was in the shop nearby. Brioche Danish cream cheese (dine-in) & cinnamon morning bun (to go) and an iced latte my girlfriend had. I had an iced coffee and a Brioche Danish chocolate. Both Brioche were very hearty. The iced coffee could've been better, but it was okay. The iced latte my girlfriend described as delicious and her Brioche was very good. The cinnamon morning bun was good it can be compared to a better version of Cinnabon without the glaze. read more

See all

Bread stand was a fav since moving to Maplewood. I haven't tried the pizza yet, so there will be an update(1star). The coffee and pastries give life! Service is always with a smile and kind. I live thé outside of the new location, it's giving small town chic! read more

The food and atmosphere were great. The service was good. I would definitely recommend going.

Keep trying to go to this place without success. You go at night and it's an hour long wait. You go "midday" and you find a pizzeria without pizza on their "midday" menu. Don't think I have seen a "midday menu" - very silly. The host has to say "please review our midday menu to make sure it's ok with you" because they know people get upset to go to a pizzeria that doesn't serve pizza. Someone came to the host as we were looking at it and said "we didn't see the midday menu, we are leaving." Seems like this place is getting a bit too cocky with it's success and overthinking things with its multiple day part menus which will catch up with it. read more

Stopped in for bakery and was not disappointed . Although I like my almond croissant stuffed with almond paste, these did not disappoint, flaky and nutty licious .and coffee drip was perfect! read more

Artie's - Almond croissant - Pizza Near Me - Maplewood, New Jersey

FOOD: SOOOOOO many pastry items to choose from. I loved the peach pastry puffs, corn pastry puff and croissants. They are so crispy like the ones in Paris. Honestly, I was tempted to get the bread too, but I'll be back for it next time. There's dine in with delicious pizza as well. DRINKS: good selection of coffee and lattes to choose from SERVICE: someone greets you upon entry and directs you to the bakery/ to the restaurant. AMBIANCE: Bakery seating is only upfront, it's perfect with the front windows/garage doors open. Can totally enjoy the fresh air on a nice day. Good for morning routine drop ins or brunch on the weekend. read more

See all

That's it, I'm done with Artie's. Fourth time there since they moved from their old location (when it was Arturo's), and the pizza is never even close to the amazing pies from the old spot. I don't know if they moved the oven from the old place and just can't get it working the same, or got a new oven. Either way, they just never get the nice light crisp on the bottom that they used to get. It's always just a floppy mess. And this time it was underbaked to the point where there was raw dough in spots. The flavors were good, but that's not enough to save a mushy pizza. We used to also love the roasted veggie appetizers at the old spot, which used to have such great, bold flavors. The ones at the new spot are just bland. read more

Pizza and bread are delicious! Really nice crust on the pizza and flavorful sauce. Service was good. The location is pretty random - it looks like a converted garage? In a part of Maplewood I don't usually frequent. Inside it was loud and I kind of felt like I was in an NYC lounge circa 2003, but with families everywhere. But that said, I would probably go back for the pizza! read more

Had dinner at Artie's with my sisters last night and looooooooved it!!! Such amazing food and kind, attentive waitstaff. We loved the ceci, bucatini, maple bacon pizza, kale caesar, and meatballs with ricotta. A1 cocktails! Good music and atmosphere, too. Thank you! read more

What a wonderful find in NJ. Be aware it's a Bring your own bottle and the nearby liquor stores close at 8pm on Saturday. So stick up when coming. The food has continuously been delicious. This was the first time eating in and Yums. All the smells, the service. Everything was lovely. It's very romantically inside too. We ordered the ricotta toast, teléfono, the Meat balls and the truffle ravoli. Wowowowo. My friend returned the next day for another other of the truffle ravoli. Being steps from the train station was perfect for me, to just jump on the train back to the city with my to go container. I look forward to returning. read more

See all

A modern Italian restaurant that is a NJ suburb staple - a must visit if you are in the area. Restaurant - the restaurant itself gets extremely busy and is quite a small place, only has a few tables inside and a few outdoor seats available. I would recommend doing take out vs. eating in as it gets crazy. Has a cozy casual vibe and the restrooms are located behind the kitchen in the back. Food - everything you get here is good. I recommend getting the ricotta toast to start which has Black Sea salt and olive oil drizzled on top, a perfect starter to the meal. Pizzas are all good, but keep in mind they are wood fired so they have a semi "burnt" or charred flavor to them. In the past their pastas and pizzas used to come with a complimentary salad but they sadly do not provide anymore, however I still ask for their balsamic vinegar dressing and use the pizza crust to dip into the dressing. Yum. I usually love getting their farm pizza which uses whatever is in season, and the arugula prosciutto pizza. For pasta, definitely get the mushroom ravioli and wild boar pasta. The restaurant is BYOB so feel free to bring wine! Overall a must- visit place if you're looking for modern, rustic Italian place, this is not grandmas homemade Italian cooking! read more

See all

Always fresh and prompt service,the pastries and the cakes are delicious.Very spacious and bright inside and the bathrooms are spotless. Always fresh and prompt service,the pastries and the cakes are delicious.Very spacious and bright inside and the bathrooms are spotless. read more

Food was amazing. I got the meatball appetizer. Best red sauce ever. The bread rocked the earth. Kale salad was wonderful. Perfection. Service was very good. Ambiance was pleasant . read more

LOVE me some Artie's. Big, cool, modern space. Very friendly and attentive staff. Food is delicious as are the cocktails. The only downside is how popular it is. Makes it difficult to get a spot. Just had one of the best pizzas in recent memory (see pic). read more

Artie's - Italicus spritz. Italicus liqueur, Prosecco, olive brine, olives on ice. Yes please. Can I get it by the pitcher? - Pizza Near Me - Maplewood, New Jersey

See all