Absolutely the best Calzones and Pasta dishes this side of Florence. The recipes make up for any lacking in decor or ambiance.... If your'e looking for great food at very reasonable prices, it's definitely worth the drive! You really must check it out - We do - every time we are driving back from Mexico, or even to LA. Save the appetite because the Calzones are HUGE. read more

Worst experience of my life, pizza was cold not cooked all the way and there was hair in my food. Your better off ordering dominos than eating at this place. Never again. read more

I have found myself out in buckeye for volleyball and every time we stop here! Stumbled upon it by accident and now it's our "go to" in Buckeye! Always amazing! Great food never disappoints!!! read more

Love this place.. coming from the East Coast (NJ/NY), I know what real pizza should taste like.. Argento's NEVER disappoints.. the owner is there all the time and is super nice! Would absolutely recommend this place! read more

Pretty chill spot with great pizza and even better wings ! The staff is all very nice. Definitely going to keep coming back :)

Best wings in Buckeye!! Staff is very friendly and orders are filled in a timely manner

I've lived in Buckeye a long time and had never been here. After reading the reviews, I thought I just had to go! It was such a disappointment. The pizza was not good at all. The meatballs were horrible. The staff was just blah. I won't be going back. read more

I really enjoy this place. I decided to try something different (I love their buffalo chicken pizza and Stromboli's) today. My wife order an eggplant parm sub and I got ckicken parm. They were both delecious. The bread may have been the best restaurant bread that I have ever had. This place has great Italian food. The owner is very friendly and takes great pride in the quality of his menu. read more

Delicious pizza, fresh dough and a lot for the money. Chicken Alfredo and BBQ wings are top notch. Everyone is very polite and our order was ready in 20 min. read more

I'm from New Jersey and this is the closest you will get to Jersey Pizza. The owner is from NJ. It's a far drive, but if you're ever on that side of town or you crave New Jersey pizza this is the place. They have slices they're huge their pizzas are big and delicious read more

The food is awesome and the employees are always very friendly, best pizza place in Buckeye! I've been going here for 5 years now and never had any issues. read more

This place is fantastic! The calzones are humongous (one could feed my husband and me, although we will normally get our own) and the wings are good. The owner is so friendly and we just love this place! read more

The best pizza ever I've ever tasted I come from New York I come from the Bronx 80s exactly exactly like pizza from back home it is so good is delicious it's me there's no way so explain the pizza and they're very nice people they welcome you win their price is out rages cheap for pizza I love him very like I said before very good very tasty very delicious and I gave him 50,000 thumbs up read more

Stopped in for lunch when in buckeye ( not much options in buckeye) had the Philly cheese steak. sandwich was nothing special other than the price was in the double digits for it and a drink. read more

I've had their pizza in the past and thought it was terrible. So yesterday I decided to try their Stromboli. What a mistake! Small, greasy, and hardly any filling, the absolute worst Stromboli I've ever had! To top it off, today I can't wander too far from the bathroom! Avoid this place! read more

Pizza had good flavor but the dough was really rubbery it was like chewing steak would not ever go again.

I haven't been here in years. The employee or owners are so kind. They were offering everyone bottled water while they waited for to go orders. The pizza is priced right. It's tasty. The crust, cheese and sauce is all perfect portions. It is delicious. I will now be a regular customer. read more

This place has the best food. Family owned cooked to order and inexpensive very nice folks

My niece recommended Argentos and said it was her favorite pizza and the best she's ever had. And she is right! The family atmosphere and friendly service made this experience even better. Buckeye has a jewel so try Argentos when you're in town! read more

This is the first time coming to this restaurant and I have to tell you it is great. My husband has been searing for a good Sromboli, but this place made a great one. Pizza also is delicious. We love thin crust pizza. They don't only have pizza and Sromboli they have a wide menu of appetizers and pastas and salads. And the service was great too. Tommy the owner came over and introduced himself to us. Very nice and respectful gentleman. We recommend this place to everyone. We loved it. Thank you Argentos you just gained yourself New family members. God bless you. read more

Ordered delivery of 2 pasta dishes. Excellent !!! Food was delivered fast and was piping hot. Would highly recomend. Also ordered cannolies they were fantastic. read more

The best pizza in Buckeye hands down. My son and I love this place. When it's delivered it's hot and fresh. From the oven to my door.

This was absolutely the best pizza I've ever tried. I had their stromboli and it was truly spectacular! My family is en route back to California and my mom wanted some pasta. She found this place and it was SO worth it. The staff was so kind and generous! Thank you so much for such a lovely experience! You all have a gift! read more

Never even got to order. The manager argued with me about pricing that we were looking at online. Honestly, blew my mind that he argues with me about the prices that THEY advertised. Disappointed to say the least. Will never recommend read more

LOVE IT! Great food! Great Service! Wonderful people. My family is hooked on this place! They need to advertise more... we found it by accident. read more

Very friendly team, delicious food, check out their Alfredo pasta - very rich and tasty.

Go to pizza place but it got very old very quickly. We must've ordered from there so much we got tired of it. Or maybe it's because although they have over ten different pizzas, they somehow all taste the same. The menu is huge, which I find makes it hard to make everything on it very good. The larger the menu the more flavor and quality drop. read more

A waste of money...we have gone twice and both times the order was wrong. Instead of them wanting to fix it or offer a refund we were asked to bring it back!! Never waste another penny on that place. read more

Let me qualify this review by stating that I know good pizza. Favorite food. Been eating it for 50+ years. Know all the best pizza places around Milwaukee where I grew up. Don't even come to me with Dominos, Pizza Hut, Papa John's etc.. It's all garbage. Ordered one sausage thin style and one BBQ chicken Sicilian at Argentos. Let's start off without a comment on cheese. Cheese is cheese. Shouldn't be able to mess that up unless you want out of the pizza business. To me, sausage and sauce is what makes a pizza. Sauce on both was tasty, but, in my opinion, should be sweeter. If you haven't tried a sweet sauce on a pizza, you haven't lived. Sausage on the thin had an okay taste but was sliced which is just weird to me. BBQ chicken on the Sicilian had a decent enough flavor. Lots of cheese and sauce. My biggest issue was with the crust on both pizzas. Extremely chewy. And I mean EXTREMELY. My jaw needed a rest after two pieces. They claim the dough is made fresh every day. I'd hate to taste a day old dough. The crust on the Sicilian actually reminded me of the only time I tried Little Caesars pizza. When I picked up the order, the owner said "You'll love the pizza, you'll be back as a regular customer." Sorry, not in my lifetime. read more

Fa-nominal customer service! My family and I are always greeted at the hit of the door and thanked on our way out. This is a place that lives to pleasing their customers. Not only are the associates kind but the owner is super friendly. He's out there waiting on tables and taking orders and really just doing anything he can do to help his restaurant run smooth. Aside from amazing customer service the food is amazing! I just love their pizza and wing special! read more

Anyone who lives near Buckeye HAS to try this place. I strongly recommend the stromboli! Great service and extremely friendly! You can't go wrong here! read more

This place never disappoints. Customer service is top notch, right along with their food. The pasta is a family favorite.

this pizza place has bad customer service was told i was getting a large pizza and 20 wings ,,they sent medium pizza and medium wings...paid full price for the large and 20...NEVER AGAIN BAD CUSTOMER SERVICE read more

I absolutely love this place. I'm so sad that I live so far from it. They have a wide variety of things on their menu. From appetizers. Salads. Sandwiches. Pizza. Calzones. Pastas! They also have bottled beer and a pretty large wine selection for those of you who enjoy a nice cold beer/glass with your lunch/dinner The food is amazing! Especially the Chicken Alfredo! So creamy full of flavor. Olive Garden who?! Great portions. Very surprised to see the amount of food that came all under $20. Came with a small salad and garlic bread. We also got the two slice pizza special with any toppings and a soda for lunch. The crust was so fresh! And the slices were huge! Hubby and I couldn't even touch the second slice after all the food that came with our order. The man at the front, is very knowledgable in his food and takes pride in his ingredients as he should! The food was so satisfying and if and when we are in the area again... We will definitely be back! Looking to try something new as EVERYTHING on the menu looked great! Thank you Argentos for the great hospitality and authentic delicious food! P.S. I got the small cannoli for dessert... YUUUUM! I wish I could fit another one but it was just the right finishing touch on one of the best lunches my husband and I have had in a very long time! read more

Best pizza in Buckeye by far! Owners are usually always on site and very courteous.

First time here. Definitely coming back! I highly recommend it to people who haven't gone. The pizza and wings are delicious and the owner makes you feel special. He greeted us and made us feel right at home. read more

The pizza, salad, and dessert was a great value. We had the thick crust meat lovers pizza. It had a great sauce and a lot of meat while not being overloaded with cheese. The presentation on the salad was awesome. There was so much food, we are looking forward to what we brought home. read more

The best pizza in Buckeye, and the nicest people. We love the Philly Cheese steak subs too.

Love this place! Their pizza and wings are soo good! Staff is always friendly and helpful. You can tell they work hard. Wish there were more locations, but it's worth the drive to me. read more

The pizza is always perfect NY style made by hand with fresh ingredients. The buffalo wings are excellent as well. One of our absolute favorite dishes is the chicken alfredo. Tommy makes it fresh with real cream! Everything is just wonderful no matter what you order. Prices are extremely reasonable and the service is excellent. We go there regularly and we enjoy it every time. read more