Called and ordered pizza here for the first time the young lady on the phone was very nice. We got the meat lovers pizza, the Alfredo, and some hot wings. The pizza was great although the meat lovers was more my husbands choice next time I'll get half cheese or something because it was a tad too much meat for me but I am not as much of a meat lover. The Alfredo was delicious I opted for no meat since we got wings and meaty pizza. I could taste the butter and Parmesan in the sauce I loved it. The wings were good they had a good flavor we will be back ! read more

I enjoyed everything from the pizza to the people when we went here for the first time. The service was fabulous, the pizza was amazing, our food was fresh , and I had a family orientated atmosphere. The price was pretty decent as well . We got to drink an extra large pizza 20 wings and 24 deep fried mushrooms. And all that was under forty bucks. I really liked that the owner (I believe that was the owner) came out and was talking to us. And makes you feel comfortable when the owner or the employees come out and talk to you. Asking you how your food was and just talking to you. We would definitely go here again. I even told my husband and one to come here next weekend maybe for lunch and try one of their sandwiches. read more

best pizza in buckeye! always fresh and amazing service. they accidentally forgot our salad so I called them and asked if it was possible to refund and the owner literally brought the salad with a free soda. he was so kind and amazing. will 100% always recommend argentos. loce the fact that they support the police department too! read more

Was visiting from out of state and didn't want the normal pizza places. Found this place on yelp and it didn't disappoint. We had Calzone, Pepperoni Roll, Chicken Parm sandwich, Chicken Alfredo along with some salads. The salads are just ok but the hot food was so so good. The only issue is the lack of paper plates and silverware since we were going to eat it in the hotel. If we are ever back in the area we will be back here again. read more

I don't know what the other reviewer is talking about- I'm wondering if that review wasn't written under a bogus ID that is a front for a competitor of Argentos. The fact that he reviewed three pizza places in one day, and then reviewed two others on the same day 34 days later seems fishy to me- who orders pizza from two or three places in the same day or even the same week? Anyway, Believe me, if you've read my review of Landini's Pizza in San Diego, then you understand that "I know from pizza" as the saying goes in NY. Pizza is one of the trinity foods of the greater NYC area, the other two being bagels and authentic deli. All three are frequently imitated but seldom duplicated accurately outside of a 50 mile radius of Manhattan. I moved to AZ for a variety of reasons, and specifically to Buckeye in order to be in proximity to family plus for a great deal on a house. Why else would I subject myself to the hinterlands of Maricopa County, the epicenter of AZ? Never in my wildest dreams would I imagine that in a sleepy town best known for farms and rodeo (as well as the only way to LA prior to the completion of I-10) a pizza man from NYC would decide to relocate his family and business. The owner, who is ethnically half Italian and half Albanian (a country across the narrow Adriatic from Italy) cut his dough tossing chops in NY for over twenty years and it shows as soon as you walk in the door- the old school style menu over the counter using plastic letters to detail the numerous subs, dinners, and even Sicilian style pies are a throwback to every neighborhood pizza joint I've ever patronized in my fifty plus years. There are no conveyor belt ovens, no round pizza grates or pans, just pumice lined pizza ovens fired up over five hundred degrees. Relatives from NJ just departed after a family wedding; last Thursday one of them had a yen for pizza, a food I normally would not recommend they order away from home because the quality would be dicey at best. Not only could I recommend Argentos, but I encouraged them to order. The Jerseyites were not disappointed, and in fact they proclaimed the pizza to be excellent and delicious. What better validation could a pizza shop get? read more

I've lived in phoenix for 10+ years and I must say this is the best pizza and their wings are amazing. I live on the opposite side of buckeye but will drive here anytime I want pizza. read more

Argentos definitely has the best pizza in valley. I've had pizza all over the world and this place has truly made an impression on me. I ordered vegetable pizza and wings, the pizza was so fresh and vibrant blending all the delicious flavors, and the wings had an amazing tang and the sauce was out of this world. I recommend this place to everyone especially to all California travelers going in and out of Phoenix to stop by Argentos Pizza as it really will be worth your time...The people are friendly and the place is so clean. I'd give this place 10 Stars! read more

I have no idea what Barry G is talking about..I checked and Channel 5 has no such violations on any show for this establishment. Check his reviews and you be the judge..competitor or just permanently dissatisfied? I went there tonight. The owner was there and as previously said by others, he is very friendly , nice and customer oriented. I was waited on promptly and ordered a meat lovers pizza. While I was waiting the owner went to the cooler chest and brought me a FREE bottle of water...who offers you that in the valley?? The pizza was delicious..loaded with quality meat and cheese. Crust is freshly made and hand tossed, a true NY pizza at its best! VERY reasonable price and you can add some great wings for a few bucks more. An XLG 1 topping pizza and 25 wings for $22.00..hands down the best bang for your buck in the valley. Great for a family meal on a Friday night AND offers 10% Military, Police, Fire and Senior DISCOUNT!! I guarantee you'll be back for more, I know I will, its a keeper! read more

We've gotten take-out twice now and each time was excellent. First experience was a pizza with white sauce, chicken and mushrooms..... Awesome! The other day we got lasagne that was really good too. So far, so good. The owner (I assume) that took the phone orders and handled the whole thing was very friendly and efficient as this place was pretty busy both times when I went in to pick up. I feel that the price is very fair for what you receive... Quality and portion wise....good value. Gonna try another pie tonight, so I'm a return customer! read more

Tommy is a great guy and he makes amazing food. End of story. Try it. He really puts his heart into this and makes everything himself. This is as local as it gets. This place will make you come for more. You will like it. read more

Pretty solid Calzones!!! Can't go wrong with this place. Always excellent service and always a great dinner! Thanks Jimmy for the best pizza in Buckeye!!! read more

Argentos has speedy delivery and is never skimpy with their toppings. A solid pizza choice for where you are out in this neck of the woods. I particularity enjoy how their crust is firm, with a bit of softness. Their sausage was lean and there was tons of it. This isn't some mass produced sausage, this is the real deal. I hear the owners came from NY and brought their recipes with them. It shows! Great wings and fair prices make this a winner. read more

The owners are always friendly, they remember you and what you like, and the food is terrific. Best pizza in buckeye. wings made to order and cooked to perfection. Pasta dinners are huge, and include salad and bread for dine in. read more

This place is AMAZING!! The food is top notch and the service is excellent. The owner has a passion for his restaurant and it really shows. I absolutely love their chicken salads here and their pizza is mouthwatering. Everyone we have introduced to this place has nothing but great things to say!! read more

Great pizza!! Efficient delivery and service - best pizza ever!! Thanks for the delivery at our track meet!!

This place is great! Best Pizza I have found in the west. My husband and and I are from queens, and only here on a short term basis for work, so we are always on the search for what we call "Real food". This place fits the bill. The guy who runs it and makes the Pizza is from Staten Island, and understands how to make a pizza correctly. The crust is very crunchy and the sauce is just a little sweet. This is a NY pizza. Best way you can tell with out even trying a slice, ask them how they make their White Pizza. If they have no idea what you are talking about, no NY, if they put extra crap, not NY. This place, they do it perfectly. Eat here, you'll be glad you did. read more

My favorite pizza place ever!!!! The owners always treat you like family and will even cook dishes not on the menu on request. The crust is perfect and very tasty. The ingredients are all fresh as is the dough. The portions are huge! You will not leave hungry and the prices are very reasonable. The place is very comfortable and will accommodate big parties on short notice. read more

Hands down best pizza in Buckeye. Their eggplant supreme pizza with added ricotta is excellent

Stopped by to pickup lunch and had a great meatball sub and garlic knots. Very friendly service they really are there to serve you great food and you can tell it is not a fake attempt at good customer service. read more

I've been to Argento's twice - nothing personal against them, I just don't go much for pizza. Their calzones are huge and the pie is very tasty and, AFAIK, authentic (absolutely nothing compares to a slice hot off the cart in Manhattan). Their two-slices-and-a-Coke lunch deal looks like a winner. Prices are reasonable and service is fast and accurate. read more

I love this pizza! I don't know what "Jerry Q" has been eating or who he has been talking to, but this place is the best around! The owner is always friendly and the food is excellent. I have had the privilege of dining on Manhattan pizza several times and this is as close as it gets out here! This is definitely a paralell to the other pizza place I reviewed in Goodyear. Yum!! read more

Absolutely fantastic pizza, stromboli and pasta! My daughter and I had the traditional stromboli which was generously portioned, was filled with delicious meats, phenomenal mix of cheeses and amazing sauce and encased in the most perfectly crispy on the outside soft and the inside dough! My wife had the ziti: perfectly textured pasta and sauce made with grape tomatoes that beats any sauce I've ever tasted. My son had two slices of pizza - one pepporoni and the other, per the recommendation of our server there special buffalo chicken topped with in house made ranch which is now probably my favorite pizza of all time. If I lived there, I'd be a regular. We were passing through on I-10 travelling from Texas back to California. It's well worth the short drive in from the freeway - don't pass this absolutely fantastic restaurant up! read more

The pizza is great! The toppings taste fresh and authentic. Friendly staff and a warm environment. You can also watch the game while you eat! Enjoy! read more

I have traveled all over the united states, eating a lot of pizza along the way. these guys can really make a pizza similar to a brick oven style. however I have never had a better Stromboli roll in my life then at Argentos. They have the mom and pop restaurant feel. I have gone there a few times now and the food and service have been great. read more

Our go-to pizza place! Recently tried the margherita and it was really different and tasty. Love their fried zucchini too. The owner is so funny and friendly too! Great small town feel. read more

Argénteos has great pizza and I come here often but forget about it when it gets busy , I waited 45 minutes to get my order to go .

For a growing place like buckeye we need a great pizza place and this is it! I read the reviews about the calzones so I decided to go try one. I got the calzone special and it was HUGE! I shared it with my husband and us together could not finish it. Very tasty. I'm excited to try the rest of the menu. The restaurant was very clean and inviting. The workers were very friendly! read more

They have excellent service. One of the friendliest pizza places in buckeye. The pizza might take a while but trust that the wait is worth it. The slices are huge and cheesy and will fill you up with 1. The wings are delicious as well, not as spicy as I'd like it to be but it's good enough. I'd highly recommend this eatery. read more

Great food and broad selection of things besides pizza on the menu. But the pizza is really good, freshly made dough and a good amount of toppings. fast and friendly service, it's worth the trip. read more

Great food! Superior family attitude ! Truly a wonderful dining experience. We had a calzone (feeds 2-3 people) pasta (feeds 2-3 people) and a phenomenal pizza! We will be back as often as possible. Oh and the cannoli is true NY it's to die for, love this place! read more

Best food best service. Everything is always fresh and is super authentic. The owner is the nicest guy and is always in a great mood. I often add ingredients like sausage to some of his plates and he never complains about it. The salad dressing is amazing. read more

Finally a calzone to make me stop missing Chicago! Bathed in fresh garlic butter- your senses start to enjoy it before it even hits your table. The pizza is standard fair but better than most in the west valley. We definitely will be back! read more

Argentos Pizza has secured my business! We found this pizzaria about two months ago and have ordered from them three times (we rarely eat out so three times is really sayin' somethin!). The food is always really good quality for the price and is absolutely delicious. We have our family over for the holidays and we didn't want to make a large dinner so we ordered from Argentos on Sunday night. We always order their sicilian style crust because it is AMAZING. My mother ordered over the app Slice for the first time, and purchased two pizzas sicilian style. We got a call from the owner a bit later that they only had one of the sicilian style crust left, and he wanted to make it up to us. When I tell you this man goes above and beyond! We opted for delivery and when they arrived we were handed drinks and an extra pizza. He definitely blew our minds. If I could give him more stars, I would, but I guess we'll just have to settle for being their customers for life. read more

Food was okay, but very average. It definitely was not worth the price we paid. If there food were a little better it the price was more reasonable it would be a good option. read more

Pizza lovers dream!!! I've had a lot of pizza in my time and this is by far the best I have had. Everything on the menu is fantastic. Great customer service and the staff was great with my kids. I love supporting small local businesses and it's a must try. I will be returning for my pizza fix. read more

I would say they are one of the best Pizza places in the West Valley. With so many of the chains using substitution ingredients, aka fake cheese ect ( I'm looking at you Papa Johns) this one stands out with their real sauce,cheese and dough. read more

Awesome place....pizza is so good....staff very friendly...you all should try this place....Fresh Authentic ingredients. ...

I've been going to Argento's for quite a few years. Since it's been open actually and we have loved the pizza there. My husband is the biggest fan and he would eat there everyday if he could. It's delicious and you get a lot of food for not a lot of money, but doesn't lack in taste. read more

THE best Italian food in Arizona! I come from Boston, so I know pizza. Tommy makes the best pizza I have ever had! Good food, friendly atmosphere, outstanding service and reasonable prices; just a great place to take the family. Try everything, it's all excellent! read more

Large qualities at an extremely low price. The pizza is slightly tasteless and the crust is crunchy and hard. However, the boneless chicken wings were great with the homemade ranch. read more