Pizza to crave for!! Limited menu but they do pizza right. I would love it if they offered a salad but maybe next time. Pizza is great! We will return. read more

Anthony's Pizza - Pizza with mushrooms and red onions - Pizza Near Me - Hutto, Texas

Hands down the best pizza i've had in Texas or New York. I wanted to take a picture of both slices but forgot because i ate the first and then couldn't wait to devour the second. This is 100% my new favorite place read more

Anthony's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Hutto, Texas

I'm from NJ and this tastes like pizza from home! I'm so happy we found this place! The Grandma pie is delicious, and the cheese pie tastes like home. We will absolutely be ordering from them again! read more

I am born and raised on the east coast 15 minites outside of Manhattan and i have to say this is the only place I have been that has true NYC pizza here. the food is incredible the service is great and the owner is always cordial. If you havent tried this place you are missing out and if you have I know you have been back multiple times. call in advance and order a grandma or a sicilian and you will not be disappointed. I will bet my east coast card if you love NY pizza and or grew up on it one bite will bring you right back to mid-town manhattan, brooklyn or queens. Stop in for a slice and you will be back for a pie thats my word. read more

SOOOO good! Hope this business pops off! Great pizzas by the slice- HUGE & great flavor/ options Huttos version of Home Slice for sure read more

If you are looking for the pizza go here!! If you want the taste of real New York north east style food this is the best in texas I wish I can give it 10 stars read more

This is some good pizza. I've had the privilege of tasting some great pizza in NY and Italy, this is ranks up there with the best. Family loved it and Pac-Man was a plus! read more

Positively delectable, I say. Great service, nice vibe, and great pizza. Fully recommend! Also goes towards a small business, which is a plus. read more

Pizza was perfectly cooked. Just the way I like it. I have been waiting for a great pizza place and now Hutto has it !! Cesar the owner cooks the pies with passion and love. Try this place you won't be disappointed ! read more

This is some of the best New York style pizza I have EVER had. I'm so grateful they're so close! Support this business!

Covid has been no friend to many restaurants. We were fortunate to have eaten here before the closure and modified hours. We found their pizza very good. Plenty of toppings and cooked just right. Haven't been in awhile due to changing hours but would definitely stop in again! read more

Finally!! Great pizza in Hutto that doesn't taste like a cardboard box. If you haven't tried it yet you are missing out. Yum, yum, yum. Can't wait for more. read more

Born and raised in NY. This pizza is legit NY Pizza. The crust is on point. Their specialty pizzas are so good everyone there is always so friendly. read more

Finally! A great NY style pizza! I'm originally from the East Coast and I've had some great Pizza, but I have struggled to find an equal until now. I highly recommend this place to any fan of NY style, or just great pizza in general. Also; thank you for the extra slice, extra slice of great pizza!' Ron read more

Exceptional pizza and service. Clean and friendly. Pizza is XL and can feed 3-4 avg. adults. This is my new go-to for pizza, yay!

Delicious Pizza!!!! I have been looking for a great pizza place around Round Rock . Georgetown/Hutto since moving here from the East Coast in October 2020. I finally found the pizza I have been hoping to find - Anthony's Pizza in Hutto. Their crust is thin, their sauce and cheese are delicious and you can buy pizza by the slice -which I really like. I had the cheese pizza and my husband had the pepperoni and both were delicious. I agree with the reviews that state that this is the best New York style pizza around!! read more

Great pizza! Worth trying, and I don't say that often! Very generous toppings, just enough oil and cooked perfectly!! We will be back! The only negative- the garlic knots were still baking!!! read more

We just moved here and were excited to try this joint out. I've noticed the negative reviews are because of the inconsistent store hours. I don't think many people know that Cesar runs this business all on his own and can't find reliable help since COVID hit. His pizza is superb; the crust is unmatched. Not too doughy and super flavorful. The ingredients taste fresh. I hope this place sticks around for a long time! read more

I had never had a New York style pie before. My husband and I went in and ordered the cheese pie. So GOOD! Delicious sauce and cheese and the crust was perfect. We've gone back several times! Delicious. read more

New place in Hutto, it's been the hype in Hutto lately. Have it a shot. Pizza is hot and fresh and delicious. Got half cheese and jalapeño. Delicious ! Will be coming back no doubt. read more

Anthony's Pizza - About to give a shot to this pizza! Anthony pizza has been the hype in Hutto lately - Pizza Near Me - Hutto, Texas

See all

Been here twice now and was told they are sold out. Girl at the register was extremely rude about it both times as well. No way to run a business, I recommend driving the 10 minutes to Taylor to New York Pizza. Nice people, great service, and awesome pizza. I will try this place 1 more time to attempt to see what a the fuss is about. Hopefully I'll be able to post a better experience than the first 2 times...I mean how do you sell out of pizza anyway? read more

I am from Brooklyn, NY and I swear that this place has awesome NY style pizza!!! My husband and I are so excited to have found and tried this place and I honestly feel like we are home. Please do not forget to order the grandma pizza. It's AMAZING!!!!! I can't wait to they start delivering. read more

Mark T Harris and anthony Peter was the worst ever the customer service was terrible they never made eye contact with me then tire time I was there waiting for my order know if they would Yasaman working I felt it was a inconvenience for them to even help me place my order so they will never get my money I'll never go to read more

Definitely not expecting this, I'm a truck driver that was passing by this small town and wanted some pizza, so I stomped into this place, boy am I glad I did, there was some wait but definitely worth it, delicious NY style pizza and very friendly staff, I overheard the other customers saying that it's about time that they have some good pizza around, well I definitely know where to stop when I'm around here again, props to the owner of the restaurant (at least I think that's who it was) he still found time to greet and be super humble to his customers. If you ever around stop by you won't be disappointed... read more

Best slice in town. Authentic NY slice. I've tried just about every daily slice and they're all fantastic.

I picked up two pepperoni slices on a whim after visiting the UPS Store nearby. So glad I did! The slices were huge and fresh out of the oven. The pepperoni they use is the kind that turns into grease cups while cooking, which is the best kind. If you're looking for thin crust pizza with slices the size of your head for a good price, look no further. Excellent pizza, will definitely be back. read more

Popped in to check this place out with my husband. Delicious pizza, and the staff could not have been friendlier. Super reasonable prices! We'll be back! read more

Anthony's is hands down the best New York Style pizza outside of NYC. eating a slice immediately took me back to walking down Broadway with a street slice curled up in my hand as pepperoni grease slides down my arm. read more

Good pizza and the owner seems like a good guy. The ingredients all tasted great and my pizza was ready when they said it would be. Can't ask for more read more

We had a couple pizzas from here a few nights ago. A meat lovers basically and a cheese. I didn't have high hopes because it just came in a blank box but the slices are big and the overall pizza was huge! And the taste was definitely better than the chains imo! Would definitely eat from here again and may not even bother with the chains again! read more

7/26/19 Hutto has the privilege of getting a great NY NJ pizza place. Pepperonis are tiny so you are sure to get some with each bite. The crust is perfect - not thin/crispy and not too thick. Tried a single slice there and waited for a pie to take home for dinner. Learned a lot from a recent transplant from NJ as we both waited. Proud & local supporter - we may not like that Whataburger got bought by an out-of-state company. But am glad this out-of-state joint came here! Already busy - so go get it now before they even install their phone line and create a website. read more

I'm from New Jersey and i've tried all the pizza places in Austin. Its all about the New York style. A crunch, chewy and the marriage of sauce and cheese is what makes a great pizza. I live in Georgetown and for me its only 15 mins away. Now if they only sold beer and had some more seating. Give it time. They're still fairly new and have only been open a month. read more

We love Anthony's Pizza, it's the best I've had in a long, long time, and I am a Pizza guy, I am telling you. The employees are also very friendly. Be able to buy them by the slice is a plus, but they can also fix you a whole Pizza to go or eat there, if that's what you want. All the ingredients are also fresh. read more

I am a huge fan of New York style pizza and this is very close. They now have a phone number so that you can order ahead. The pizza was very good. It wasn't the pizza that I ordered but I took it anyway and was not disappointed. The Italian sausage is delicious and I usually don't get sausage because of the heat. My tongue can't handle hot. But this was so good. No complaints. It was very busy at lunch. And they are closed on Monday :( read more

This pizza Is the best around. If you're thinking about eating here versus other pizza places in near by go for Anthony's. Your tastebuds and family will thank you. read more

Ok this is a hard one to review. Pizza best in Hutto for sure. Owner was nice guy. Pizza crunch was right reminded me of street pizza from New York for sure. Dough was crunchy and a good chew for sure. The over all flavor of the pizza, Sicilian slice and garlic knots were just bland. If I'm not willing to drive a bit I might stop in again. read more

Wow! What can I say other than that- this place was amazing! Although the small, they are the only pizzeria that can offer customers a place to sit down and dine-in. Their menu is simple and their prices are very reasonable ($18 for an 18" XLG Pie with $1/toppings- a steal)! I should have taken a photo of their hours and menu but did not. I do recall they have an XLG Pie, Sicilian Square, Grandma's?, and Specialty Pies, along with a few different drink/slice combos. Compared to the other chains, there is no comparison in taste or quality. Even though there were 9-XLG Pie orders ahead of me and the wait time was over an hour, I purchased an XLG myself to see what the hype was all about and so glad I did. They politely told me in advance of the long wait ahead, and I reciprocated saying that I'd order now and come back for pick up, to which I did. When I arrived for pick up, they kindly acknowledged me again and thanked me for the visit. They know how to treat customers and I can honestly say that I think they'll become lifers here in Hutto- fostering community & customer service at their business. The taste was amazing, and I loved the chewiness of the crust. I think what I loved most about this place was the authentic culture and that the staff 'put love into their work' - watching them do everything by hand. I'm thankful for the authentic pizza and staff this business has in operation. I didn't catch any names but it seemed like a family-owned business with dad doing pizza prep, son serving/boxing/cooking/assisting with prep, and daughter as the cashier. They were all super friendly and very accommodating (against my original perceptions about New Yorkers). To be completely honest, I'm really hungry now and can't think of anything else to eat beside Anthony's Pizza. Cheese is a staple in our household and I don't want to eat anything with it for fear that it won't taste the same. How silly. I'm not really that big a fan of pizza (especially since we only had local chains here) but Anthony's Pizza got me turned around- giving me a taste of style from New York. I'm super glad that they chose Hutto because I will be returning every Friday for our traditional family movie & pizza nights. read more

Good pizza. These folks are nice and have a great product. I enjoy going in and getting a slice and chatting. Keep it up guys.

Best pizza in the area! The quality, price and taste is amazing! Being from the New York area, good pizza is usually hard to find, but they nail it. I tried a generic pepperoni and a special chicken bacon ranch with jalapeño...wow! The chicken bacon ranch was ridiculously flavorful and the pepperoni was delicious. The crust had a nice crispy taste and the dough was perfect. Overall this is absolutely our favorite local pizza shop!! read more

Love this pizza place. Reminding me of my pizza in Nicaragua I think the cheese is what did it for me! It's a must try and we will be visiting more often. read more