So far so good. Brooklyn style crust- slight char, crisp and chewy goodness. Owner and his awesome assistant (his daughter I think) were quite busy busting out the pies. Set up was nice, I took a large pie home and devoured half of it...(took my pepperoni's off and saved them for my girls) Hopefully I have some left over for when my daughters get back.. If not, that's a whole lot of burpees to burn calories for some delicious NY style pizza. His other expert pie maker will be coming by in 2 weeks so they can get to normal business hours and we are looking forward to that! I equate this pizza up to my favorite place in New York, and also Florios in San Antonio. The family there is from Brooklyn (I think) and has their dough shipped in also. Editor's note: When eating your savory NY pizza, please fold in half to capture all the greasy goodness. No forks or knives allowed. read more

Anthony's Pizza - Large pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Hutto, Texas

A good and honest pizza. Fantastic pizza. Anthony is a gentlemen and a scholar. Pizzas come down to ingredients and technique. He's got both down to a science. Hutto is blessed to have this guy grinding out pizzas here. Love his pizzas. I'm a fan. read more

the best pizza in Hutto. The large is actually HUGE. We love thin crust and that's what it is!

Went there for lunch after hearing so many good things. We went during the soft opening to try out some pizza. Man this place is delicious. I ordered 2 pepperoni slices and wife got 1 cheese pizza and they both were amazing. The pizza passes the cheese stretch test with flying colors and the sauce is robust with so many flavors. When I was done eating the pizza, I immediately wanted more. I will definitely being going back multiple times and cannot wait until they are open fully so that I can go late in the evening. THIS PIZZA IS AUTHENTICALLY NY PIZZA. He even calls them pies! We finally have a great pizza joint in Hutto. C'mon Hutto flock, head over there and have some great 'zza! This place needs to stay forever! P.S. I will be going here to order my pies from here on out. No more Pizza Hut or Dominos for me. read more

Anthony's Pizza - Great Service, even better pizza! - Pizza Near Me - Hutto, Texas

Highly recommend Anthony's pizza. Been going here for a couple of years. Other pizza places in my Round Rock area are good, but Anthony's is amazing! The pizza crust is chewy yet crispy. The sauce & cheese ration is wonderful. I love how the pepperoni holds as a pocket of greasy goodness! Don't let this hidden gem slip through your fingers! Added bonus, the owner is friendly, welcoming, and great customer service. read more

Anthony's Pizza - Pepperoni Pizza & Garlic Knot - Pizza Near Me - Hutto, Texas

See all

Not only is this the best pizza place in and around town, the owner has the biggest heart. I was on my way to pick up dinner and got into a fender bender. I tried to call and cancel my order to no avail. I get a call back stating that they are going to still help my family get fed for dinner!!!! What a great pizza joint we have here in Hutto. We are lucky to have them here. read more

This place has good pizza, but it is missing a business manager. Out of ~10 times I have tried to order pizza, I was able to get it twice. Besides being randomly closed, they are always way behind on orders, to the point that they stop accepting orders pretty early in the night. I tried going in person once and they said it would be 3 hours before I could get my pizza. There were two teenagers standing behind the counter with the owner, with a huge stack of orders, but there were no pizzas in the oven and nobody was making a pizza. I suspect the owner struggles with training people and delegation. He makes a good pizza - if he could find someone to run the business, then they'd make a lot more pizza (and money). read more

Amazing pizza and, what I can only assume is the owner, he is always super nice! I know they are always jam packed with orders, which puts them a little behind, but I'll go back to this joint over and over! I love supporting a local small owned business that puts everything into it! read more

Best pizza I have ever had. I have not been lucky enough to try true NY style pizza before. I understand the hype now....You can taste the quality of the ingredients in this pizza. My friend and I came in on the 4th, were treated very well. We got two slices and ordered a whole pie to go. We chilled inside for about an hour, and played with the pac man console he has in there. (Yes, there is a pac man arcade console, and its low enough for small children to play on). Cesar was kind enough to ask me when I would like my pie made, so by the time we left it would be nice and hot still. Very laid back pizza place. I personally will never waste my money again on fast food pizza. Will definitely be back. read more

See all

Excellent pizza. I love to fold my pizza, but I usually have to fight the grease that rolls of my pizza. Not with this place. Ingredients taste fresh and fun atmosphere. read more

Amazing pizza!! Coming from an Italian too! Like delish for real! The kids love it and actually ask to go pick up so they can play the cute mini video games in the dining area!! read more

Have been trying to go to this place forever! The first time we realized they are closed on Sun/Mon, no big deal, our fault. This time I double checked 1/5/2023 before we got the baby in the stroller and walked over because we live in the neighborhood near it. It was 12:11pm when we got there. We were so sad to find the lights all off and door locked. No sign stating why they were closed either. I even checked their Facebook which is not active and no Instagram. It's be nice if they could at least have somewhere regularly updated so people don't waste their time. Hope to try again because we love pizza and it's be a great regular for us. Definitely will amend my review upon trying it. read more

First time eating here but not the last time coming back. I am a major pizza snob especially with myself being from the East Coast growing up on this style of pizza. Let's get into this review. Location: Located on 409 W Front St in Hutto, TX and not the 109 W Front St location Yelp has up. I would know because it pulled me somewhere else. There is a little strip mall with a meat market right at the middle corner. This location was easy to find. Atmosphere: Not a lot of seating space but definitely an open room. This space is good for the perfect get-in-get-the-fuck-out experience. Limited seating and tables is what I meant. Standard pizzeria with pizza smoke in the vincinity. I would say to have more vents to suction that smoke out. Otherwise, this is a very straightforward pizza experience. Similar to NYC pizzerias for sure. Menu: Small menu. Perfect menu in my opinion. Not overbearing nor confusing. You pick what you want and go from there because it is PIZZA. Food: Ordered like 8 slices total. 2 Cheese, 1 Half Texan, 1 Supreme, 3 Sicilians, 1 Bacon Ranch. Also ordered a Pepperoni Roll too. I will tell you right now that this place IS the hype. Keyword "is". That scrumptious bite was there. If you know pizza, you know about the 'bite'. The dough was close to perfect where it was thick enough to not break on itself but thin enough for the bite. I would only say my gripe is that the pizza dough could be a millimeter thinner and it would be pretty much perfect all the way around. Now another big plus was the sauce and cheese used. Close to also perfect. Only gripe? Too much grab on the cheese. Slightly less cheese and again, it would be just perfect. The Sicilian pizzas were absolutely perfect. I couldn't find anything with the Sicilians that I would change. The Half Texan was amazing. The cheese pizzas were great. The bacon ranch was nice too. I wasn't as fond of the Supreme. With all of this being said, officially I will crown Anthony's as the BEST pizza joint in the Austin area. Now I saw people ordering the Hawaiian pizzas and I almost threw the hell up all of the pizzas I ate. For all those sinful Hawaiian pizza lovers, I think that's disgusting. Service: Excellent. They threw in an extra slice of Sicilian. That's love right there. Respect. Value: This place is a major go. You'd be buggin' if you didn't want a good slice of pizza from this joint. This place does it right with great pricing. Best pizza in the Austin area. No questions asked. Homeslice may win with their tenure in the area for a Brooklyn styled pie but Anthony's is a Brooklyn's pie. Also, I read this stupid ass review where one guy complained about too much pepperoni on a pizza. Why is you buggin' for? That's like saying, "Oh I won the lottery but you gave me too much money." I'm not kidding about this place being similar or exactly like a Brooklyn joint either. If you want an NYC pizza, this is the spot to go to. My Rating: 5/5 - No regrets. Will definitely come back. Keep doing what you're doing. read more

See all

Forgot tomatoes in our margherita pizza. Not cool. Then when we asked about it we were brought a plate of raw tomatoes with a fork. Uhhhh...what!?!? Who does that!?!? I guess this place does. Terrible customer service...didn't even apologize for their mistake. Totally not cool. Not consistent with their menu. Last time we were here the pizza was perfect....time to move on. read more

Anthony's Pizza - Margherita pizza-they forgot the main ingredient...the tomatoes!! - Pizza Near Me - Hutto, Texas

Initially, I was impressed with the pizza presentation, because the slices looked dry. I decided to give it a try anyway. What could go wrong? I'm glad I got past the look, because the flavor was on point. The chicken wasn't rubbery or fatty, but well done, just the way I like it on pizza. Chicken bacon ranch was my favorite. Buffalo chicken was a close second. The crust has a great chewy crunch, another way I like my pizza. The owner is very conversational, which is a plus to establish rapport with your potentially repeat customers. If you're in the area, stop in for a quick bite of pie. You won't be disappointed. read more

Nice crust and just the right amount of toppings - a really solid pizza, and very tasty. Ordered a couple of slices to-go, but couldn't wait and ate them both driving 4 minutes back to my hotel! They also have calzones on the menu, but if you're eating for one, be aware they sell only 18" (or by the slice). No middle ground, so if it's for take-away, order wisely! On the minus side, they don't offer beer or wine, which is almost a necessity with pizza, right?! Definitely will be back next time in Hutto. read more

The best pizza that tastes the closest to New York pizza in Texas. Highly recommend.

BEST new pizza place in town! I was VERY skeptical when they announced it as NY style, because me and my husband are from the NJ/NY area and really have been missing that style of pizza. Everywhere else we went in Austin area did not measure up. But this place is AWESOME and reminds us of the place we had near our house in NJ. Pizza is AMAZING! And the owner is super nice too, even gave us free garlic knots to try first time we came. We already went back like 3 times in a week. LOVE IT! Finally good pizza near home :) read more

Just know that this man is solo. so if you're looking for a restaurant experience go to another place that doesn't have as good of pizza as this place so that you can be serviced. BUT if you want the ABSOLUTE best pizza in Texas, this is it. PERIOD. good luck out there! read more

This pizza is bomb. Hella big. One size. Omg the crust is the best and its loaded with cheese which I love and put on almost everything I eat. Owner is supper attentive and makes sure customers are happy and he explains what's been going on w the shop and how things are comin along. He's not afraid to talk and be friendly. I'll be back here soon read more

Anthony's Pizza - A box full of deliciousness. Black olives & red onions/cheese - Pizza Near Me - Hutto, Texas

Taste like I'm back in New York City!! Easy menu and drink selection. Also have a grandma pizza that is marinara and thick crust, delicious!! read more

Came in for lunch today. Great new york style pizza and good lunch specials on pizza by the slice. I really didn't expect much but as soon as I tried it you could tell the ingredients and the crust were far above average. Not to mention even though every seat was filled the service is extremely fast. I was in and out in less than 5 minutes. read more

Anthony's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Hutto, Texas

Really good pizza. You can purchase by the slice or purchase a whole pizza. The employees were friendly and great. Would definitely recommend this place. read more

Yum! Great NY style pizza. As a Lifelong NYer this pizza passed the test. My 4yo daughter said it was the best pizza ever! I'd have given them five stars if they did the following: 1) have a delivery option 2) Had wings, it's hard to get good crispy true Buffalo wings around here,that would have knocked it out of the park for me! 3) a more pillowy outer crust would make the pizza PERFECT in my opinion, but cheese and sauce flavor and crust thickness were on point! They are a small operation, 3 people, and everything is made by hand. Overall very good, I hope they are able to grow to provide those extras I'm looking for as a customer! read more

This place is great. It is by far the best pizza in Hutto!! It's even better the 2nd day. read more

Anthony's Pizza - Pepperoni and beef pizza. - Pizza Near Me - Hutto, Texas

This place used to be an amazing ossis of pizza excelltence but it seems it recently and that special touch is gone. We went recently and it went from one of the best to one of the worst unfortunately. read more

Pizza is pretty amazing my personal favorite is the chicken bacon ranch! The owner has experience running pizza places in the north east New York and New Jersey if I remember correctly so he has brought that time of pizza to the south. read more

So happy to have come across this place. It's a small family operated business with attention to detail. The pizza is authentic and the flavor leaves you wanting more and more food. Cesar made me feel like family and took care of me. It was my mom's birthday when I went, and he customized a pizza with her name. It was so unexpected yet so memorable. Thanks again for making us feel right at home. I'll be back!!! read more

See all

We tried this place once and the pizza was very good, but every time we have tried to order again they have been closed even if the hours stated they they'd be open. :( read more

This is some of the best pizza we have ever had! Authentic New York pizza at its best! Our family has tried all kinds of pizzas in many different places and the pizzas we tried here were exceptional! We love how the pieces are reheated in the oven before being served, which crisps up the bottoms a little. We tried pieces of cheese, pepperoni and sausage, Grandma's pizza, and bacon chicken ranch. We had a hard time deciding which one to order a whole pie of because they each had their own great flavor. The Grandma pizza is our favorite, with the extra sauce and the basil mixed in with the cheese flavors. And we love the thicker crust. And their sausage is phenomenal! We were taken care of by the owner, and he was incredibly friendly and he showcased a great variety of pizza choices! A great place to pick up a few slices to eat there or to take out. We will be back! read more

Anthony's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Hutto, Texas

See all

Best pizza in the area. I prefer a standard pepperoni pie here, however don't be scared to get adventurous. They get busy on the weekends so you may have to go in to order carry out but it is so so so worth it. It's become a Friday night staple. Support small business owners, this is definitely a place of quality over quantity. Not that the pies are small, because they are quite large honestly. So yummy! They also sell by the slice, at least stop in for a quick slice none the less! read more

Heck yes. If you can't get through the phone, just stop by instead. They are busy, and as we know the pandemic has really hurt local business keep staff on... that being said, the taste, quality of ingredients, and texture of bread were spot on. I had family visiting from California, and they wish they could get this pizza out there! Lucky me, its right in town! I recommend the grandma, we also got a plain pepperoni and it was the best. read more

Anthony's is awesome sauce!! His pizza is yummy and his service is even better! Very good guy and super good pizza! #huttolovesanthonyspizza read more

Anthony's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Hutto, Texas

I love that you can purchase an entire pizza or by the slice. Best pizza in Hutto. Anthony knows what he's doing! read more

Anthony's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Hutto, Texas

Hands down the best pizza I have every had. Reminds me of being in NYC with every bite. His pizza is always consistent and I crave it daily. Anthony is so down to earth and puts his heart into his food. He is a one man army and a father so bless his heart I don't mind the wait it's worth every bite! read more

Great NY style pizza by the slice or pie. We had the supreme slice and it was excellent. Service is fast, pizza served hot & the crust is awesome. Highly recommend you drive out to Hutto and give this a try. No liquor license yet, so BYOB. read more

Anthony's Pizza - Supreme pizza slice. - Pizza Near Me - Hutto, Texas

My son and I stopped in here on the way back from a football game. They were near closing time and did not have much left by the slice and we didn't want to ask them to cook a whole new pizza so we had limited choices. They reheated a slice of pepperoni, a slice of cheese and a few pepperoni rolls and brought them to us. There was not a fountain drink station, only cans, which is a downside for me. The pizza was just fine, a little on the greasy side, but I would order from here again and get it to go. The pepperoni rolls were good but lacked much substance. The tables were dirty (again, it was near closing time) and they had a pac man game in there that was sooooo loud we had to almost yell at each other. The mom and kids that were playing were cute and she was just trying to entertain them but we could hardly stand it after awhile. All in all not a bad little place. The girl behind the counter was very friendly. read more

The pizza is really good, the right crispy crust and the sauce has a sweet almost wine taste! The garlic knots are good I love the bottled sodas! Had the pepperoni rolls are super good too! Really friendly staff! Definitely a great Hutto addition! read more

Anthony's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Hutto, Texas

Delicious pizza!!! Our family's new favorite Pizza! Great Pizza and Great Customer service! read more

Anthony's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Hutto, Texas

See all

I really love this pizza. The problem is it is never open. I don't understand how this guy stays in business. This is very unfortunate because his pizza is really delicious! read more