Decent ny style pizza. Had a good taste. Was a tad undercooked. If you fold the pizza, it shouldn't flop. This did. Which could be for several reasons. Seemed like a bit more cheese than normal. Sauce was very good. read more

See all

The food here is delicious and reminds me of New York. I usually order pizza and wings, and it's always delicious. The wings are seasoned well and cooked to perfection. The pizza is served by the pie or the sloce. The staff here is also very kind. This is my go-to-spot for pizza, for sure! read more

Anthony's Pizza - Cheese slice - Pizza Near Me - Apopka, Florida

See all

Diamond in the rough Italian joint with such sweet service and even better food. Pasta was good and they even offered more sauce if you wanted. Pizza was crispy and just a slice is pretty big so you get your moneys worth. Would eat again! read more

Best pizza in the area. Friendly servers and great service. Nice spot to either get a quick bite or order a big box to go.

Anthony's is consistently very good. Good to have excellent Italian food in the neighborhood. read more

I first moved to this area about eight years ago and tried the pizza then. It was pretty good but after trying different Florida pizzas and then coming back to this I realize this is horrible. First things first I came here on a Monday or Tuesday and I was told that you can't seat yourself on those two days, that was kind of ridiculous. Just didn't even make sense to me. But whatever I decided to order two pepperoni pizzas, and take the order to go. So I ordered the pizza and after looking at the pizza, I realized that it looked pretty decent just from the looks. Them from looking at all the other reviews here I realize that this has truly declined and I realize it was bad as far as quality was concerned. The cheese and pepperoni were literally falling off the pizza as I was starting to eat. And then just from a taste perspective, it was just below average, I've certainly had better in Florida and would rather go to dominos or Marcos before I return here. read more

Anthony's Pizza - Pepperoni pizza - Pizza Near Me - Apopka, Florida

The pizza is wonderful! The people are always nice! I like the big booth in the front for a group of people.

The food was great a lot of pizza was tooken out so it was a little slow for the pizza to be ready. We just watched a sit com. There was no real ambiance. read more

Anthony's Pizza - Coke - Pizza Near Me - Apopka, Florida

See all

Just can't believe it was our 1st time..and loved it great service, quick for Friday night..we got take out large pizza, black olives, mushrooms, peppers and pepperoni on HALF, FRESH HOT AND DELICIOUS, they even added crushed peppers to it before baking it (SPECIAL request) BIG THANKS to the crew at Anthony's Pizza , we'll be back!! read more

Anthony's Pizza - Looks great, tastes amazing - Pizza Near Me - Apopka, Florida

See all

Never have had a bad pizza from Anthony's. Probably order twice a month. Not sure why the ratings are low.

Reviews had me skeptical, but the food and service were very good! Lunch specials were affordable and in line with neighborhood pizzerias. Lunch Calzone was very good and had just the right amount of mozz cheese, Ricotta and pepperoni (in my case.). Service friendly and efficient! read more

Anthony's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Apopka, Florida

See all

purchased a large order tonight that included a meat lovers pizza. The pizza was burnt. I called the store and complained to the manager and all their response after I proved we purchased the food was "Sorry" and offered 50% off on the next pizza purchase. First we could not believe they would allow a burnt pizza out the store especially on a purchase over 80 dollars. The least they could have done was replace the pizza. But since their offer was lame, we will never purchase there again. Very low food standards. Never Again read more

Better than any of the chains. Phone people are friendly and polite and know the menu.

Gross. That is all. Pizza knots went right to the garbage. Pizza tasted like cardboard.

When hurricane Ian hit our neighborhood, it was downgraded to a tropical storm or cat 1. Nonetheless we lost power and internet. After two days without both we were looking for food and a place with internet. We decided to go to Anthony's Pizza, we got here alot. On Friday we went in and ordered pizza slices and I got chicken wings, we were excited to just have internet access. When the wings came out, I ate some but they tasted alittle strange, I didn't say anything at first,however when my boyfriend had one he too said they tasted strange, it seemed like they were on the edge of being spoiled or freezer burned, so we sent them back. The cook however did not like that and started making rude comments, at one point my boyfriend went and said we'd pay for them, but the cook started swearing and being argumentative and yelling at us. We have never been so insulted in our lives! The cook should not throwing f bombs and insulting customers, whereas the whole restaurant can hear him,his excuse was ohh well there are no doors. The cook has glasses and a beard, he said he hated fing people,especially like us who complain. We've come here for years, we don't complain but even so, it's no reason for him to take it out on us and the server. read more

Been relentlessly looking for some NY style pizza in Lake County for some time. I finally came across this place and had high hopes. looked like a decent spot from the outside driving by and advertised NY style pizza. However, when attempting to order some take out it was complete crickets... I called multiple times on separate occasions to order food and even attempted their online ordering service request and wasn't able to get anyone. Not sure if the food is good or not, but the work it takes to even find out doesn't seem worth it. read more

Don't waste your time. Will mess up your food and refuse to take responsibility. Kody the manager will cuss at you, hang up on you, threaten to send you raw food, and then call you over and over again until you have to call the police to make him stop. read more

Anthony's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Apopka, Florida

I don't know what it is... maybe the sauce? The cheese? Pepperoni? Crust? This pizza is BY FAR my favorite NY style pizza in all of Central FL! Great prices, great service but most importantly--dang yummy pizza!! Add a side salad for under two bucks?? Whaaaaa :D Sometimes during lunch when you order a slice or lunch special it tastes like it was just a pre cooked slice of cheese with toppings added and recooked. Not here! These individual slices taste like you just pulled it from a freshly made pizza pie. To me, that makes all the difference! It's a small lil place but it's worth the stop! read more

Anthony's Pizza - Pepperoni by the slice! The BEST! - Pizza Near Me - Apopka, Florida

See all

Don't have pics as the food wasn't in the boxes long enough. Great pizza. Best garlic rolls. Such friendly staff. We picked up but they do offer delivery. read more

Antony's is that pizza joint you go for a quick slice or two when you are famished after all that grocery shopping.... or should you go eat first and then grocery shopping? All depends on what type of shopper you are on an empty stomach I guess. I would be the one that would buy everything in sight! Yikes! Any hoot, Anthony's does offers Italian eats, but I wouldn't venture outside the pizzas. Each time we tried something new, that wasn't pizza, we were utterly disappointed. That being said, we are regulars at Antony's. We love the two slices deal. If you are coming for the slices just make sure you come before 5pm. Unless you don't mind having just pepperoni slices. The full pies, however, you can get whatever you want on them, anytime. A little tip, if you don't like your dining experience on the nippy side, bring a small jacket or sweater. For those you that do, you will be in heaven! read more

Anthony's Pizza - VIP stuffed pizza, that's just half of a slice! - Pizza Near Me - Apopka, Florida

See all

Horrible service burnt my food last night and had to come back the next day. I understand they want to go home last night when I ordered the food, but how can you serve some food burnt like this. When I went back the next day the lady was rude and they said the dining room was closed but there was still people eating inside. The customer service from the lady was the worst I ever had. read more

See all

Called to place an order and someone hiding deep in the wine cellar answered the phone whispering. Couldn't hear a thing and she was extremely rude so we asked to speak to someone else just to end up with the person who taught her how to speak to people. Wouldn't recommend unless you feel like losing brain cells and getting a headache read more

Pizza was as expected, a freshly made vegetarian pizza took 20 minutes. It is conveniently located right next to the Publix grocery store so you can do all your shopping while you wait for the pizza to be ready. That being said the lady a the cash was grumpy and impatient in summary the food is good but the staff could be improved. read more

Horrible service! Called in to place an order and the young lady was rude and condescending. I then asked to speak to someone else, a gentlemen then get on the phone and said "cash or card"?! There's plenty of restaurants around and I feel maybe they're getting too much business because clearly they didn't need mine. My husband and I have ordered food literally every other week from this place for over a year. read more

Unable to dine inside yet due to Covid, but from the moment you walk in it's like little Italy. The garlic smell surrounds you as you choose from a large menu selection, with way too many options to choose. We have eaten there three times now, and each time even better than before. Currently eating our way thru the menu. LOL Worth the time and expense to try it out. read more

The worst customer service I have ever come across. Id rather suffer and eat frozen pizza than eat from this place. Avoid this place.

My husband absolutely loves this place for pizza. He is from NYC and he loves to be able to purchase two or three slices instead of a whole pie. He likes the thinner crust and the big slices. He goes for the cheese pizza and it does taste good. They also have a big variety of other pasta dishes and salads. We like to order for pick up and never actually sat down to eat there. I would certainly say, that this is the best pizza Apopka has to offer. read more

Omg I ordered chicken parm and was highly disappointed by the MYSTERY Rubber MEAT I received!!! I get it that cheap is the way to go for your bottom line but I rather be charged more and know that I'm getting real chicken!!! Terrible- such a let down -breaded rubber -step up your game people. Restaurant Impossible!!!! read more

Anthony's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Apopka, Florida

It was great for some time and then service just took a nose dive, crust coming over cooked and over do in the extra cheese. It might be the new kitchen people. While eating in great customer service for the waitresses. read more

My husband and I came in one night last week and we had great food and the best service we have ever had before from Audrey. Seriously, she was fantastic. Last night, we decided to go again and take a friend with us, as we are all new to the area and still looking for good places to eat. The closing time said 10pm, we walked in at 9:14pm. Upon walking in, a shorter, slim, dark haired girl said "ohh no were closed" in a joking manner under her breath, but it was loud enough that I heard it. Hearing that, I looked to my husband who was about to be seated by Audrey and said I think they were closing. He asked Audrey, who told us that they closed at 930pm, but we were welcome to stay and eat. We opted to leave because we aren't the type of people to come in within minutes of closing. We understand everyone wants to go home at their scheduled time. However, the door and website clearly say 10pm and when my husband called to verify that, the manager said the dine in closed at 930, but they do deliveries and take out until 10. It would have been nice to have been told that, as opposed to hearing an exasperated quip upon walking in and feeling like our presence was a burden. We would have simply placed a to-go order. The manager also told us that she was not allowed to give out her superiors name. I wonder how the owner feels about not being able to hear customer feedback in order to improve their establishments business? I would love to be able to add stars to this rating, but as a consumer I cannot until given the proper outlets for complaint resolutions. 3/15/18: Round 2. Decided to give this another try, big mistake. Just as rude as ever, and we are are eating the subpar food we picked up while waiting for the replacement pizza and the salad they forgot to be delivered. Pictures of the pizza attached. We did eat a piece of the pizza because we were starving, but when we called to complain because we could not think about eating the rest, we were told to bring it back up to the store and they'd replace it.... read more

See all

We stopped in for a slice of Pizza and it was delicious! Love their Pizza. If you want the taste of northern pizza, this is the place.

It's convenient.....that's the most redeeming quality. My son and I both had slices for dinner which were $2.65 for a decent size pepperoni and $2.15 for cheese. The pizza is extremely greasy even by pizza standards. My ire comes from the SLOW service. There were only five tables and my son wanted to order a second slice but it the waitress ignored us so we passed. Not sure if I will be back after this visit read more

The last delivery appeared to have been sitting on end in the drivers car. All toppings went to one side. I don't know why I have continued to try them, just wanted a break from the usual. This is the third time we have had poor food from them and it will now be the last. I would not recommend this place even if your options may be limited. read more

i had a great dine in experience here, I was blessed with a great waitress who was very helpful, I had 2 garlic knots was honestly the best knots I've had. read more

Read a few reviews, heard good things about the place so my kids and I decided to give them a try. The service was friendly, though please, when out with the customers, leave the drama or "gossip" outside of the dining area. My daughters and I didn't particularly care to hear about any of it (servers gossiping at the counter to each other). We got for appetizers the garlic knots, alfredo sauce and cheese fries. The cheese fries were good; however, we did not like the garlic not and the alfredo sauce lack good flavor and substance. For our main meal, we ordered a meat lover style pizza. Crust was alright, toppings, not bad, but we can get this kind of pizza anywhere. Not very impressive, definitely not worth the price we paid. I'll happily order Domino Pizza before we come back here. read more

As a New Yorker pizza is a part of me. So being in Florida it was my mission to find the best pizza in my town. Well I have found it. Anthony's Pizza is where you should go. Great service, top-notch food, and at a good price. For my weekly pizza binge there's no question on where to go. When we walk in we always wave to our friendly and carefree server Jennifer. Love this place!! read more

Best pizza place in Apopka! Especially if you like NY style pizza, saucy, crispy, flavorful, juicy, wings, home made Alfredo sauce, and garlic knots cooked to perfection. Enjoy! Let me know how you liked it! read more

Great pizza- nice change from the chains!: We recently moved to Apopka and have eaten Anthony's twice. Both times (once dine-in, once delivery) the pizza was hot and fresh. The crust is soft on the inside and crisp on the outside with a nice doughy taste. The flavor of the cheese, sauce and toppings are wonderful (try the meatball as a topping!). We had the garlic cheese bread which was also good. Average service with a small dining area that reminded me of the old Sbarro's at the mall you could sit down in. The price is decent ($18 for a XL pie with 3 toppings) and the slices are so large that you have to fold them in half to eat them. I really wish Anthony's would offer more in the dessert department, maybe a canoli or cinnamon-type bread with icing. read more

I love a good stromboli, and Anthony's does a pretty good job with their version. It is rather straight forward, a good size for the price, and plenty of cheese and other toppings you choose to put in there. I can't vouch for the pizza, but if it is as good as other Anthony's Pizza restaurants around Orlando, I'm sure it's better than average. My only real disappointment here was the garlic knots. They were overly doughy, and really not very garlicy at all. I've been to other Anthony's and these just seem to be below average. I would not order them again. Overall, a good place to eat at for me every once in a while. read more

I normally have great service here from the waitress who says "thank you" all the time. But this time we had the waitress who was very rude. My friend's meal came with a salad and he asked for a Caesar salad. She said "no, no, I know the owner he would never allow it." He offered to pay extra and she still said no. (Even though every other time we have been there they have no problem with this). She never refilled my drink, nor came to see how our food was. IF* we go back we will make sure she is NOT our waitress. read more