Ordered the French toast, eggs over easy and beacon. The French toast was excellent. The eggs were cooked perfect and served hot ( usually never ) and the beacon was perfect. The service was excellent as well. read more

This was my first time to this establishment. I had to wait a bit for a table. There was plenty of seating for those of us waiting. I was greeted by friendly staff and the food choices were so amazing, I had a tough time deciding what to eat or drink! I settled on a mango-kiwi mimosa and boy was it good! I went with the BlackBerry French toast plate with eggs & ham..it was the most delicious breakfast ever and since I was a party of 1 I never felt rushed to hurry & finish. I hope to be back soon. Still dream about that blueberry stuffed french toast! read more

See all

Everything was amazing! From the blackberry mimosa to the beignets to the Mardi Gras omelette to the Crab cake Benedict to the banana foster pancake and peaches and cream pancake. We will be returning. read more

Another Broken Egg Cafe - Mardigras Omelet, Banana Foster pancake, Crab cake Egg Benedict, and Peaches and cream pancake. - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Siesta Key, Florida

I saw good reviews of this place so my wife and I decided to try it this morning. The restaurant was easy to find and had ample parking. The atmosphere was great, the service was great, and the food was outstanding! To start the breakfast off, we ordered beignets that were very tasty. For my meal, I had the supreme omelet and it was probably the best omelet I have had in a long time. Also, their country potatoes were delicious. My wife had the banana foster french toast and she loved it. Another small thing I liked was their take out boxes. They didn't give us some flimsy plastic/styrofoam thing. Their boxes are more of a sturdy cardboard material. It was a very nice touch to an amazing breakfast. I would recommend to anyone! read more

Another Broken Egg Cafe - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Siesta Key, Florida

Found this gem while visiting Siesta Key on a quick off season vacation. Very lovely servers and had a good menu for brunch not just on the weekends! I got an omelette with home fries and it was the best brunch I had out of all four places I had tried in Sarasota + Siesta Key. My friend got a really good burger with an egg on top plus home fries as well which she truly enjoyed. I would definitely come back! read more

Another Broken Egg Cafe - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Siesta Key, Florida

See all

Best breakfast place of all time. Pristine in every aspect of breakfast. They've perfected their craft and constantly create a meal straight from heaven. The Lebron James of breakfast places. Although the scrambled eggs are average. read more

Other then being nosy... this place was amazing!!! Food was great!!!! Mimosas the best I've ever had!!! read more

Another Broken Egg Cafe - Lemon blueberry mimosa!!! - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Siesta Key, Florida

Good parking, excellent service, really really good food. Our waitress guided us through the menu like a pro - we told her what we like to eat and she was a HUGE help! Omelette was wonderful. read more

Another Broken Egg Cafe - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Siesta Key, Florida

Wonderful staff, pleasant outdoor and indoor seating, and an extensive menu of interesting and tasty food. We came for a late breakfast (930ish) and waiting ten minutes for a table. The hot coffee is very bold (I enjoyed it) but patrons at another table believed it to be "too burnt". I believe a Kenyan roast was also available and was said to be lighter. We ordered a lobster Benedict (seasonal special) and smoked salmon Benedict. Both were delicious, filling, and exactly as described on the menu. this was our first visit to Another Broken Egg and it will not be our last. read more

See all

Delicioso Omelette with lobster was exquisite , the broken egg biscuit sandwich was amazing! Pet friendly, they even gave my puppy a bowl with water and ice. read more

Stacy our waitress is absolutely fabulous! The food was amazing too! We will be back! Thank you!,

Love this place for breakfast and lunch! Accommodating menu that fits my preferences. Food is very fresh. Great outdoor eating.

Could be better, could be worse. Service was medium, but i cant fault them, they're short staffed and packed! I expected better food, but it's still good. Overall decent read more

Delicious food and drinks! James was very attentive and offered great food suggestions!

Went there with 4 in my party. Wife had eggs Benedict and I had lobster & grits. Both were amazing. Service was exceptional. Establishment was spotless clean. What else is there to say? I'm here for a week and will be there EVERY MORNING for breakfast!! read more

It's busy spot but well worth a wait. I had the smoked salmon Benedict (I think that's what it's called) and shared the berry pancakes. Eggs were poached perfectly, pancakes.... My mouth is watering just typing this. Will definitely return every time I'm in Siesta Key. read more

While on vacation we always love to try a new place. We have friends in Sarasota and we come to Siesta Key quite a bit. Can't believe we haven't come here before. Seated quickly and Jennifer waited on us right away. It was fabulous service. I had the chicken and waffles. The chipotle honey sauce was fabulous! We also had an iced coffee that was great too! All of us enjoyed our meals and next year when we are back in Siesta Key we will be eating here again!! read more

I was already disappointed that the original Broken Egg restaurant chose to sell their Siesta Key location, but this feeling was compounded after my experience at this restaurant which replaced it. Upon our arrival we were informed it would be a 15-25 minute wait. This quickly transformed into a 45 minute wait. On top of that, I heard the hostess informing others about a first come, first serve breakfast bar inside. We were never made aware of this or we would have tried to get seats there. Upon being seated, I was not impressed with the menu. There was nothing special and a lot of the items contained seafood elements. I personally do not like seafood, so this was a big change to the menu that limited my choices. The people sitting next to us sat with their dog, who was pretty crazy and wouldn't really sit down. Usually servers go nuts for dogs and our server was no exception. I have seen many servers pet dogs and go right back to working without washing their hands. Happily, however, our server refused to pet the dog. All of that being said, the food was good. It's nothing I would come back for, but it was good. We started with the biscuit beignets. They tasted like biscuits, just a little lighter and covered in powdered sugar. They were tasty and it was an interesting idea. I got the cinnamon roll french toast. I ordered the Bananas Foster sauce on the side, but there was a little on the side and a lot on the french toast. This was good, but I didn't really like the sauce. My mother got regular french toast with bacon and eggs. She thought it was nothing special and ended up stealing a lot from my plate. She liked the bacon, but the eggs were cold when they got to the table. Overall, it was okay. The food was good, but the disorganization at the hostess stand was a turn off. I don't regret checking it out, but I probably won't be coming back. read more

Another Broken Egg Cafe - Biscuit beignets! - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Siesta Key, Florida

The breakfast was amazing. It is a little bit of a wait but other than that it was perfect. There are kids menus and very friendly staff. Many different flavor of mimosa as well. read more

I have to give this place 5 stars. Small, quaint, good service, yummy food...I really can't complain. I look forward to coming every year during our family vacation to Siesta Key. Although, I believe it was previously just "The Broken Egg"; this new version (possibly a buy-out?) is equally as good, if not better. I found the dishes to be not only high in their "yummy factor", but creative as well, especially with regards to my Skinny Omelet...impressively flavorful for a "healthy dish". Sweet Potato pancakes were also good, with spicy pecans (or perhaps they were walnuts?) Either way, very good. Why not 5 stars? My cheddar hash bake came lukewarm (more on the "luke" side than "warm".) They did heat it up right away, but 5 stars get it right every time. Bonus: Friendly service and they sell the adorable coffee mugs! A little steep in price but this quaint gem holds a special place in our vacation hearts so worth the splurge, in my opinion. read more

See all

This place is AWESOME! The food is delicious and the service is great. If you are ever in Siesta Keys you better try this place. read more

If you enjoy burnt up english muffins this place is great. Waiter never checked to see if our food was ok until we were already done. At that point its too late. read more

Another Broken Egg Cafe - Burnt up muffin - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Siesta Key, Florida

See all

Good food, very pleasant place, we love to go there on Tuesdays, after 11:30am you need to pay for parking or drive around to find free parking, what can be difficult in the village read more

Amazingly delicious food. Huge portions. Nice selection/variety of dishes. Kind, helpful staff. Comfortable seating indoors and out.

Walked past this morning and saw a sign promoting their online ordering function. We were very excited to be able to order our food ahead of time. We went out the website took the time to fill out our order to only find out at checkout that the online ordering was unavailable. It would have to been nice to know that function was not available at the time, instead we spent a lot of time getting orders for our group only to be disappointed. They should not advertise something that is not available. So I can't comment on the food because we couldn't get any. read more

Biscuit Beignets with Honey Marmalade??? So delicious!! This cafe was such a great surprise and Matthew (our server) overwhelmed us ( in a good way) with superior service, offering up great suggestions for different food options and was friendly and informative all at the same time! Located in beautiful downtown Siesta Key, Florida, Another Broken Egg is open everyday from 7:30a-2:30p for the best Brunch you will ever have!! HANDS DOWN!! Their menu is so diverse and jammed packed full of so many delicious choices! I guarantee that there is something for everyone here including vegetarian's and of course gluten free options are available too! Choices of Crab Cakes, City Grits, Chicken and Waffles, Louisiana Crawfish Skillet, Black Bean Eggs Benedict, Bacon and Jam Biscuit Sandwiches, Skinny Omelettes, Award winning Bloody Mary's, Banana's Foster Pancakes, and Cinnamon Roll French Toast! Whoa! Just to name a few mouth watering choices, and there is SO so much more! Huge Kids menu and great for families! Their menu also includes so many different types of Burgers, Panini's, Sandwiches and Salads too! Again, so many great choices!! And now you can understand why it took us all so long to make our final decisions! Thank God we all got to share a few bites from each other's plates! Had to!! Everything was so good! Fresh! Served hot! (my standard) And gave us all the opportunity to really taste and sample so many great dishes they had to offer! Kudos to the chef!! And thank you to the whole staff for making us 'out of towners' feel so welcomed and serving up such delicious food! A true Southern treat! read more

See all

Food is delicious & the service has always been the best. My family & I look forward to coming for breakfast every year when we visit.

Excellent service and food. Our party had french toast, the biscuits and gravy, and the apple toffee pancakes. Everything was delicious and our server was so pleasant. We will definitely return the next time we're in Siesta Key. read more

Hands down the best shrimp and grits. Every single thing our table of four ordered was fantastic!

if you like fancier food this is great for you! If your a basic omelette and toast guy it's not.

I just had a great breakfast at Another Broken Egg Restaurant in Siesta Key Village. our food was excellent and the service was great. Denice was our server. She was attentive, informative and fun . What a super person to have serve you first thing in the morning! Every restaurant should have such a super representative of their business. Did I mention the food was excellent? You have to eat there!! read more

Amazing brunch with my ladies! Great food, amazing drinks and the best staff! Thank you to Carmen!!!!

Yummy breakfast. Lots of options. Beignets were yummy too. I overheard another waiter ask if guests were 1st time visitors because beignets were free. We had omelettes and ice coffees. Would like to try bloody Mary's next time read more

Another Broken Egg Cafe - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Siesta Key, Florida

The service and food was incredible!!! We had "country fried steak and eggs Benedict" and a lump crab omelette, with a delicious pitcher of blueberry, lemon mimosas. Our server was sweet, helpful, and shared her joy with us. This was definitely a food highlight of our vacation! read more

My favorite place for an actual sit down breakfast on the island. The biscuits and gravy are to die for! They make their own breakfast sausage patties that are out of this world! The service isn't the best. Twice I had a rude waitress (the same one) and once I called to place a Togo order which was a disaster. Management could be better. Good little place though! read more

Another Broken Egg Cafe - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Siesta Key, Florida

On our last morning here we decided to try a place we'd never eaten at, and boy were we glad we did. Our server, Jennifer, was wonderful. She took care of our needs quickly and made some good suggestions. The food was top notch. I had the biscuits and gravy based on another Yelp review and loved every bite. The star for me, though was the house made sausage patties. Best breakfast sausage I've ever had, hands down. Wife had the chicken and waffles-phenomenal. Our friend had the lobster and Brie omelette and loved it. They even brought us complimentary beignets. Fabulous place and we will definitely be back. read more

Always a treat. Wait list on website keeps wait to minimum. Food and service was great

Definitely hold your place in line before you leave- use the Yelp feature to predict when you will need to put your name in! Super busy because the food is great and the servers are nice! read more

Another Broken Egg Cafe - Breakfast tacos with grits - delicious and so much flavor - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Siesta Key, Florida

See all

This is a nice little restaurant in siesta Village on Siesta Key that serves breakfast, brunch and lunch. We were there for brunch. The wait wasn't horrible, maybe 20 minutes. You can get on the waitlist from their website. I ordered a special, Lobster Benedict for $17.99, expecting at least a few chunks of lobster. What came was a scramble of little pieces, that while tasty, was not at all what I expected. It looked what was left on the chopping block. My husband had the Supreme Omelet, whack was pretty standard, but he enjoyed it. The potatoes were great! We would go back, but with lowered expectations. read more

I had an omelette and it was fantastic. Excellent service and fun environment. The wait in line was short as they were very organized.