Oh man is this pizza good! Owners hail from Bayonne NJ, and the pizza captures the NY/NJ style wonderfully. No fountain drinks, mainly Coke bottles in the fridge. read more

Ordered pepperoni and cheese pizza, it was prepared really quick. Great flavor and how the pizza is put together. For a small mom and pop style restaurant, ordering and customer service was great. The ambiance reminds you of an old school pizzeria . Next up will be to try their chicken wings. Definitely returning!!! read more

Anna & Mike's Pizza - Large Pepperoni pizza - Bakeries Near Me - Felton, Delaware

See all

I ordered the chicken parm.....and got spaghetti with 4 chicken tenders covered in cheese and sauce. Seriously? I tossed it. Never again.

We ordered a medium pepperoni and sausage pizza. The pizza was good. But, my wife felt like something was missing with the taste. Otherwise, I would have given Anna and Mike's 5 stars. Anna and Mike seemed nice and were friendly. Our take out pizza was done in 20 minutes and we were on our way back to our hotel with our fresh hot pizza. read more

Anna & Mike's Pizza - Medium pepperoni and sausage pizza - Bakeries Near Me - Felton, Delaware

Got the regular cheesesteak, meat to roll ratio was great. The owners welcome everyone, extremely nice! Quick & easy to order, food is done in a reasonable time. Very cute little restaurant. read more

This place is a hidden gym. The owners are from Naples, Italy and the food they make is absolutely delicious. Their meatballs melt in your mouth. We had them cater my mom's 102nd birthday and they made food for 30 people we had baked ziti with sausage and baked ziti with cheese that was phenomenal. We had sausages and meatballs, eggplant, Parmesan, and garlic bread and everything was absolutely delicious. It just tasted homemade. Anna is a herb cook. I felt like I was back in Naples Italy. I highly recommend this restaurant and I'm a fusspot. read more

Anna & Mike's Pizza - Part of the spread - Bakeries Near Me - Felton, Delaware

See all

I just want to add because I wrote the review when angry. I had the eggplant and it was Very Good Husband had Lasagna that he said was very good.He also got a pie to try and he said pie was also very good. read more

This is best place for pizza , desserts,wings salads, dinner entrees. I have to visit the dessert fridge every time I'm there.LOVE all the food I've tried. Salad so big i could only eat half . There are both nice. read more

Anna & Mike's Pizza - Stuffed shells. I haven't ate it yet, because I was so full from only half my chef salad - Bakeries Near Me - Felton, Delaware

See all

Nice owners Quality ingredients and great flavors My favorite in the area Great stop convenient parking Menu is full of favorites We will be back read more

Most authentic pizza to NY style in the state. It's a small little shop on the side of 13 but we'll worth the stop.

We ordered a Sicilian pizza and wings The pizza was authentic. The wings were good just a little bit small. The sauce was good. I feel this place uses real quality ingredients. The taste of the food shows. read more

Just rude. I called and ordered a Stromboli. The gentleman that answered the phone said it would be a 20 minute wait. I said OK and then hung up the phone. I immediately called back within one to two minutes to cancel the order because I realized I would not be able to get it and go to where I was headed in time. Out of courtesy, I called back to cancel the order and the man did not say "thank you" did not say "OK" just hung up the phone in my face. This would've been the first time trying this restaurant due to the ratings. It left a bad taste in my mouth for first impressions. I will not give it a second chance. read more

I ordered the cheesesteak with the works last night! I am from Milford and decided to try this place for the first time since I love a good cheesesteak and was I surprised!! Not only was it delicious, but a very generous portion for a 12" roll with the best price around! I shall be back and will let others know about your establishment! read more

Let me explain about 5 stars. In NYC & North NJ it would be about 4 stars. Here in Delaware it's 5. For those two states it's all about the water for the crust. We ordered a small cheese pizza to eat there. They do not sell slices. It was worth it for 10 bucks. The owner (Mike) was making the pizzas while watching soccer. He appeared a bit grizzly at first but after we finished our pie he was a friendly "chatty cathy" with his thick Italian accent. The pizza had a relatively thin crust that had a nice crunch. It had a mild flavor & did not compete with the cheese & sauce; rather it did complement. The cheese had a silky smooth & non chewy melt. Not salty either. The tomato sauce was fresh & tasty; again complimenting the cheese & crust. I like to add a dash of pepper & garlic powder on my slice but the spices at the tables seemed old & not wiped down. The tables were clean. I think your best bet is to just get your food to go. Having been from NY I've eaten some excellent pizza and this truly does rank up there. We got some desserts to go & they were pretty good. It states they are homemade there by the Mrs. I got some cream puffs. They probably were slightly over done & may not have been just made but I think they have potential if made daily. My husband devoured his slice of cake. He inhaled it so fast I couldn't tell you what flavor it was. They have many baked goods for sale in the cooler as slices & cookies packaged at the counter. Mike told me he had pizza places in Bayonne NJ but then retired to Delaware. He opened this place with his wife Anna because they wanted something to do. It's become so popular he has to recruit his adult children to help out. It's worth the trip if you appreciate good NY style pizza. We live a few towns north but will definitely come back. I particularly like Strufolli so would like to get some over Christmas. Mangia! read more

Anna & Mike's Pizza - Small cheese pizza. - Bakeries Near Me - Felton, Delaware

See all

Extremely rude! The owner was distracted watching TV and forgot the pizza was in the oven. He abruptly got up when we arrived to pick up. When he pulled it out of the oven it was burned. Rejected taking it and the owner became upset and starting cursing saying, "F*** you! Won't be going back there! read more

By far my favorite pizza. The crust is fantastic. Can't speak for the entire menu but their pizza is the best I've had.

The great taste is so consistent from their pizza, pasta, all the way to their awesome cheesesteak!!! I can't get enough. It's my number one place for food. I always feel great after eating their food! I truly love this place!!! read more

Anna & Mike's Pizza - SO DELICIOUS!! - Bakeries Near Me - Felton, Delaware

One of my favorite Pizzas in the area. Haven't tried anything else yet on their menu, but the Pizzza has great crust with good texture and not too thick. read more

Ordered pizza for the first time today. I don't know why we waited so long, but it's some of the best pizza I've had in a long time! The crust is crucial for me, and this was excellent. It was perfectly baked with ample cheese and toppings. We'll be back! read more

We got 2 medium pizzas and mild chicken wings. The wings we great, for mild. I prefer medium sauce but the kids were eating. The wings were slightly over cooked but I like them like that. As far as the pizza goes, they put a good amount of sauce on it, which I like. Most "mom & pops" places don't do that and the dough soaks up all the sauce, which makes it dry. One pizza was a bit over done on the bottom and made it hard to bite. Even the kids noticed it. But the other pizza was perfect. Their prices are fair. read more

Anna & Mike's Pizza - Anna & Mike's Pizza - Bakeries Near Me - Felton, Delaware

Best Italian food around. Husband loves their pizza and I love the pasta!! Always consistent flavor, portions and appearance.

Fantastic place to go for sandwiches and Italian food. I highly recommend it! Wonderful service with a smile.

Great steak subs and desserts. Owners are nice and accommodating. Pizza also very good.

Owners are always friendly when I go in there. The wings are my absolute favorite, very flavorful.

One of the best pizzas I have ever had. No exaggeration, do yourself a favor and eat here. Don't disappoint yourself by going to other pizza joints in the area. read more

Anna and Mike's Pizza is some of the best pizza around the Dover area, if not the best. We ordered their Sicilian with double pepperoni and it was the best Sicilian we have had. Definitely recommend. Their carry out timeframe from point of ordering to ready for pickup is very quick. read more

Anna & Mike's Pizza - Sicilian pizza with double pepperoni - Bakeries Near Me - Felton, Delaware

The food is always good here. My girlfriend and I always get pizza and fried pickles, but we've tried a couple desserts and a couple other items and were never disappointed. Mike normally answers the phone and he's an old school Italian guy, so don't expect the friendliest service, but he's never rude just about his business. Will definitely continue to give them our business. read more

Great place for pizza. Highly a recommend! The price point is great! Taste is delicious! You wont be disappointed! Okay

Best place around. And the people are great to deal with. Highly recommend this business pizza is excellent and the rest of the food is the same read more

Just average pizza. Not a fan of whatever they use for Italian sausage. Crust was good. Giacomo's is better. So is Grotto's.

The pizza here is really good but only if you eat it right away. It does do well re-heating it in the oven. The lemon powdered sugar dessert they have are outstanding. Have to grab an order or two or three whenever we grab a pizza. Now, Mike, I gather, is not the happiest guy but the pizza makes up for that! read more

This is our favorite place to go for pizza. Their service is fast and the pizza is delicious! We've also had some of their homemade desserts and they are amazing! read more

Ordered a jalapeño and pineapple pizza. Didn't even eat a whole slice I tossed it. TERRIBLE food. Horrible customer service. Who is keeping these ppl in business? read more

old school authentic Italian food. the owners were both there so welcoming and kind. the lady (i wish i knew her name) gave my dad and i fresh cookies to try... SO GOOD read more

Foods ok& the owners are nice&very friendly. Lots of homemade desserts . Service pretty quick. I haven't been in a while but it use to be my go to for a good old Italian Sub. read more

Mike makes the most amazing pizza! Every time I come to Delaware I will make sure I stop by and pick up a couple of his special pizzas! And the desserts are amazing too! read more

Don't let the looks of the outside deter you or you might miss a gem. We really enjoy the pizza and cheesesteaks here. The desserts are also really special. read more

Cool little pizza spot. All the desserts homemade by Anna and Mike. The pizza was good ,not greasy, thin crust good toppings, just a bit over but that could be because I didn't pick up right at 20 minutes. What's great about Anna and Mike's is that it's a neighborhood pizza joint that doesn't overcharge for a one topping pie. I will definitely be going back whether it's for pizza on a school night or possibly my next fantasy football event. Also can't wait to try some of their other menu items as I can see many other people have and absolutely love them. read more

Nice and fresh food, you can taste the quality. The people running it are very genuine :)

Don't let the looks deceive you. Some great wings and their pie can definitely hold its own in taste tests.