My husband loves this pizza - adoration would be a better word. He has eaten pizza from Florida to New York to Cali so I would grade him as an A+ pizza connoisseur and he says Angelina's is, "The best I've ever tasted!" That's good enough for me! So I had to make the trip with him to Elyria from Cleveland's East Side to try a double pepperoni extra sauce pizza. Three Words - Worth the Trip! Wish I could give it 10 stars! read more

This pizza is absolutely delicious. I highly recommend this place. It's a little expensive but you get what you pay for. I give it 5 stars for taste and customer service read more

Angelina's Pizza - This was a double pepperoni with extra sauce. I must say that the sauce was amazing - Pizza Near Me - Elyria, Ohio

Pizza is good but it's very expensive could offer your free pizza for people who go there a lot and other pizza place do this like donations pizza place read more

When I eat a pizza, I usually grade the taste by the crust texture and taste, the taste and consistency of the sauce and the amount of ingredients on the pizza. I do grade also if they tell you " we're out of this or that". Not acceptable, I ordered a pepperoni, thin crust with green olives, extra cheese and sauce and other veggies. It came out in record time, thoroughly cooked and delicious. I would definitely buy from here again. I want to try other items too read more

The best pizza and very close to home. The service is very good and very fast. Basic eatery and no real atmosphere. But just love the food.

Last time we went, and picked up our food writhing the 15-20 minute time frame, our pizza and breadsticks were room temperature if not cold. The place was just filled with a bunch of teenagers sitting around on their phones or talking. Not really what you want to see as a customer. Today I ordered a pizza, breadsticks, and some cannolis and arrived within 15 minutes exactly if not a little sooner so that my pizza would be hot. All was well with that, but my cannolis aren't even filled all the way. Not to mention that the filling tastes like nothing read more

Angelina's Pizza - Almost empty cannoli - Pizza Near Me - Elyria, Ohio

Okay, so we like Angelina's Pizza. Sometimes it's great and sometimes just a little less than great. Like any place, depends who's makin the pizza that night. But, all in all, this pizza is very good. Gladly would recommend this place to anyone who's tired of all the other cardboard pizza from those "1,000 locations with one near you" type of pizza joints. I repeat, the pizza is good. Would give them a 5-Star rating if not for there stupid dining area. They should cut the size of this place in half. Just create a small foyer to wait and pay for your pizza, then leave. I may just be going up there at the wrong time, but since they've opened, I've NEVER ONCE seen anyone eating inside. Really, not once. And why would you want to eat inside at this place (or at the one in Olmsted Falls which has the same decor - or more accurately, a lack thereof)? I would really like to ask the owner of this establishment, exactly "what kind of dining experience are you trying to offer your customers?" Here, sit at this table and watch as everyone comes in to pick up their pizzas. Or hey, while you wait for your order, check out and see this nice Deli counter. It'll take you back in time and bring you sweet memories of going with grandma to the old butcher shop; before the fire and before they boarded up all the shops and stores downtown??? Seriously, I've seen shoe repair shops with more atmosphere for eating lunch or dinner. Who are you guys going to attract with that dining area; little league teams, drunks, road repair crews? It certainly can't be couples or families. What a total waste of space. If you own that building, good for you; but if you rent it your crazy. Commit to take out only, which has to be 95% of your business anyway and stick to making good food (which you do). Should you decide you'd actually "want" someone to eat inside your establishment, I suggest you hire someone to do it right, cuz you guys haven't got a clue. The current layout screams "Don't eat here." read more

Delivery was fast however the pizza was so bland, the cheese sticks were cold and dry and lacking flavor, the wings are baked and had hardly any sauce. The sauce is not good on the pizza. Spent $50 and regret it. read more

Been getting delivery from here for years and finally giving them their credit on Yelp! Their pizza has always been great (some of the best in Cleveland), but the latest one I had had me contemplating if it's my favorite of all time. Perfect amount of sweetness in the sauce, great crust, perfect chewiness, and the pepperoni and cheese are well suited for everything else that's going on. There aren't too many good locally owned joints right near me, so thank God for Angelina's! Cheesy breadsticks are great too! read more

Angelina's Pizza - Large pepperoni, half green pepper! - Pizza Near Me - Elyria, Ohio

This pizza is pretty good. The crust is great and the sauce tastes so good. It has a little sweetness to it. The price per topping for a half sheet was a little pricey at 3.00. The delivery was really fast. They delivered a half hour early. The wings were okay. They were sauced nicely. For our first time ordering this pizza I will definitely be ordering again. read more

Place is a circus. Olmsted Falls closed down and ordered from North Ridgeville, waited over an hour and i had 8 staff members repeatedly over and over ask me what my name is. It's Bob, not a hard name, kept hearing that the pizza was about ready, after all the chaos, they gave my order to a woman who they thought was my wife, completely bizarre experience with the North Ridgeville store, other patrons were really mad just sitting endlessly to try to get a pizza made. read more

Don't know about those other locations, but every time we've visited or gotten delivery from the Elyria location, it's been GREAT. The sauce, the crust, the generous toppings.. and their fries and cheesy breadsticks are also terrific. I have nothing but compliments. Nice people working there as well. Highly recommend! read more

This place has great tasting pizza! I gave them 4 stars because they got my order wrong and asked for my pizza back that they delivered to me, BUT they corrected the order immediately so Great customer service and great pizza! read more

We stopped over in Elyria, Ohio on our way to Canada, and we were hoping to order something in since the kids were tired. This place advertised all of these awards that they received locally for their pizza. Our hopes were high as we were hoping for some decent pizza and pasta. When the food arrived I am sad to say...it tasted just as it looked, bad and probably not freshly made. The onion rings were identical to the frozen ones you get in the store, and the pizza was sadly awful. The pasta noodles were decent, but the Alfredo sauce that came with them was ridiculous. The sauce was a watery mess with zero taste. I cannot imagine it did not come from a can. So please do not waste your time on this establishment. For a small town like Elyria it may pass the test, but it fails when you look at actual taste. read more

Great pizza! Fast and simple good crust and I liked the sweeter sauce ! Defiantly would recommend stopping in and take out or delivery is fast too. read more

Angelina's Pizza - Nothin better on the pipeline the. Some Angie's pizza! - Pizza Near Me - Elyria, Ohio

We've stayed in the area several times and we are still searching for a great pizza. Unfortunately, this wasn't it. We ordered a large...some slices were gigantic, some were slivers. The pizza itself was awful. It was so soggy you could not pick it up without everything sliding off. The sauce was sweet... and not pizza like. The cheesy bread was ok, but that's it, just ok. read more

LOVE it. crust is perfect. the sauce is so yummy. kind of on the sweeter side, if you dig that. i think their cheesy breadsticks are fabulous. this is my go to for carry out pizza. quick, hot, delicious! check angelinas out! i think some of the best pizza around! read more

horrible service tonight & wish we would have called another pizza place. we have always received the very best service from angelinas in north Ridgeville and in olmsted falls, but I called the wrong number when I placed the order, but the lady on phone said they could deliver to our address. didn't feel like calling the other location, so I just placed the order with elyria's location. HUGE MISTAKE. took over an hour to get to us (we were told 45 min when I called), and when I called after 60 min to request status, rude person on phone said the driver's car broke down and it would be there shortly. received the order - no sauces on side which was what we requested, AND food was Lukewarm, borderline cold.  can honestly say it was the worst tasting Angelina's pizza I have ever had, and the bread seemed like it was weeks old. very disappointed. read more

My Favorite Pan Pizza in NE Ohio! I love everything about this Pizza! The sauce is rich and sweet. Quality toppings and cheese applied generously (especially love their meatballs). The crimped outer crust looks great and tastes even better being flavorful with a perfect chew. Their House Special is my favorite - sausage, mushrooms, onions, and those awesome mini meatballs. read more

Angelina's Pizza - The House Special - Sausage, mushrooms, onions, meatballs - Pizza Near Me - Elyria, Ohio

This WAS my favorite pizza until they delivered some an uncooked pizza. They did make it right by delivering another pizza but offered no discount. I went to order a pizza online today and the only option to pay is credit. I call them to express my concerns about the last delivery and they provided no customer service. At first they told me the last pizza I had was picked up. Wrong! Then went on to tell me they made it right last time. Where is the courtesy that I am afraid to pay for another pizza upfront and have it delivered undone? No customer service whatsoever. I'll never order from here again because they can't even have the decency to show face value and show they won't deliver me an uncooked pizza for my next visit. Just terrible!!! read more

I tried, on five different occasions, to call and order a pizza. I could never get a call through. Mainly, it rang busy. When it did ring, it was not answered. I went there in person to order and was told that, when they get behind, they turn off the phones!!! This is the DUMBEST thing I've ever heard of in a business. All they have to do is tell you your order will be ready in one hour, ninety minutes, whatever. You do not frustrate the life out of your customer. Their pizza is wonderful, but it's just too hard to do business with them. Their pizza is five stars, but their customer treatment barely makes it to one star. read more

Well. Ordered a mushroom banapepper pizza from here one time and they gave me pepperoni. Today I thought I'd give them a second chance so I ordered small cheesy bread with extra sauce on the side and no sauce at all...so I'm going into work now so I don't have time to go back so I guess I will eat this dry cheesy bread read more

My husband and I just bought a house in North Ridgeville and we received a coupon for a free large two topping pizza from Angelina's. We had family over and used our coupon plus ordered a few more pizzas, we picked it up and they were very friendly and gave us a few more dollars off after they found out we had just moved here. Pizza was amazing, everything about it was good. We had been looking for a good place to order from for now on and we definitely found it!! read more

Very good pizza. The sauce is a little too sweet for me, and I do like sweet sauce. Added some parm cheese and crushed red peppers and it was delicious! read more

Angelina's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Elyria, Ohio

They gave us a welcome the neighborhood coupon when we moved in and now I am hooked. Their pizza is very good, and I love that they sell their dough for make it your own pizza nights. The pizza was high quality, good toppings, and the salad was great. The only reason they are getting 4 stars is I did not like their wings. I prefer non-breaded wings so they were a little soggy in my opinion, however, the flavor was great. They are a little pricey (but all takeout pizza places are in my opinion) and delivery was a little slow, but that's how you know it's being made fresh. We order from here often now. read more

Been here a few times and really enjoyed the pizza. Prices aren't that bad compared to most pizza places (minus maybe the big chain ones). Only complaint is some of the pizzas are excessively greasy...only a complaint unless you're looking for a lot of greasiness. I like it and whenever i'm out in that area Angelina's is my choice of pizza provider. read more

Best delivery pizza in Elyria! Homemade dough & sauce. No need to request extra cheese. Good delivery times and priced well. Their calzones are to die for. read more

Well...this is Elyria after all. We always get the pizza here. Great sauce, pretty inconsistent though. Wraps and greek salads are good. It's worth a try! read more

My favorite pizza place around! Our family does not order pizza often but when we do we only get the best. Pizza: Top notch! Just tastes fresh. Good crust and sauce recipe. My favorite is the Hawaiian pizza. Delivery: a little slow but most of the time I order is during the busiest times so I can't knock them for that. Price: You get what you pay for... they are more expensive than your traditional chain pizza joints, but nothing unreasonable. Overall... good pizza, right value. Been to the N. Ridgeville branch as well and the same could be said. read more

Angelina's Pizza is the best pizza I've found in NE Ohio. Their take 'n bake pizza is my go-to since I can pick it up and then take it home and bake it off when convenience so it's uber hot and fresh. Online ordering is a breeze. My fav is the deluxe with extra sauce. Substitute the sausage for meatballs and you won't be disappointed! read more

Angelina's Pizza - The take 'n bake can't me beat! - Pizza Near Me - Elyria, Ohio

Pizza is pretty good but when it takes two hours for a delivery and they act like they don't care I'm done.

I totally get this isn't a typical "restaurant setting" but if you're going to advertise that you have a dining area where patrons are going to be greeted and orders taken... maybe you should follow up on the process. I just got off work from working a 12 hr shift. Was talking to my friend who raved about their pizza. She said it was to die for. I called and asked if they had a sit down area or if it was just a typical pizza place where you have pickup or delivery. The gentleman that responded to me replied with "we got whatever you need"... Strike 1. I pulled in and stood at the front counter and not once did I get greeted or told someone would be with me shortly. Finally I just said "excuse me should I just take a seat if I want to order and eat here" some guy with a hat backwards and his pants around his lower thigh (while wearing a belt) told me someone would be over to take care of me shortly... I waited for 8 minutes. Nobody came over with a menu or even a glass of water to introduce me to their menu. I got up to get my own. Strike 2.. Now as I got handed a menu I asked what was good or a recommendation and the guy with the hat backwards and the pants down at his lower thigh (with a belt on) replied with "shiiiit, everything's great here. I take something home every night ‍. Strike 3.. I'm out. Maybe I'll catch a sampling at my friends gathering next time since she thinks so highly of this preposterous establishment. read more

It was fast and simple i did carry out pizza was hot and tasted great i will be eating there again

This place has amazing pizza, my parents used to drive to their other location when I was a kid to pick up dinner. The location wasn't close to us but it was definitely our families favorite and then came an Elyria location too. Don't always have to many deals but I'd say it's the best in the area hands down!!! Probably been eating their pizza for 15 years or more between the two locations. A little pricier then other place but I'd say you get what you pay for. All I know about is their pizza, never tried anything else on their menu. Definitely worth giving it a try if you've never had it. read more

Angelina's is a good pie. We got a delivery to our hotel (Ramada Elyria) and it was right on time. Good crust and toppings. Sauce was a bit on the sweet side but I can manage that. Overall a good place to order in Elyria. read more

We received a welcome package to the neighborhood in the mail. We figured we would give it a try. We ordered a large cheese and a large pepperoni and sausage. The sauce is fantastic, the crust is amazing and the toppings were perfect. We have been sticking to Marcos but I am glad to have found a local pizza that is FANTASTIC!!!! read more

Warning there pizzas are addictive. great service, great pizza. love this place. They make the pizza old style with little crust piched beautifully. The sauce and all the toppings fresh and soooo taste. Really it's ADDICTIVE. Bet you can't eat just one slice. read more

I ordered the Greek salad and added a chicken breast...possibly the grossest salad I have ever had...it came out cold,pre-packaged, chicken included. The chicken must have been a JTM because it wasn't a "real" chicken breast (think McDonald's processed chicken). My husband and kids had the pizza, which albeit greasy, was pretty good. read more

Ordered pizza and a Caesar salad. Delivered. Everything exceeded our expectations. Delivery was told 45 minutes. Arrived at 30 min. The pizza was hot and delicious!! I love pizza and can be picky. The crust was the best dough I've had in a long time. Ceasar salad dressing tasted homemade...delicious. I'd highly recommend. read more

I was not impressed with there pizza. Did not like there sauce and the crust was not all that good. I would not order from there again.