If I could give zero or negative stars, I would. From start to finish, this experience of ordering and eating from Sambinos was downright appalling. First off, the workers could be more customer-friendly and nicer. I had to repeat myself at least three times when ordering. I placed my order for delivery, not pickup. I had to call back to check on my order, which the person answering didn't even seem like they knew which order mine was. It was written down as pickup, not delivery, which explained why it took forever to get to me. When my food FINALLY arrived, the gentleman that dropped it off was very nice, which was the ONLY positive from this entire experience. I ordered chicken parmasean. Normal chicken parmasean is a crispy chicken breast with cheese and sauce. The one I recieved was cheaply made noodles with watery sauce and two chicken tenders. The fact that they market this as chicken parmasean is very sad. I also ordered chicken alfredo. It was made with the same cheap noodles and watery alfredo sauce with minimal amounts of chicken and mushrooms. If you're going to put mushrooms in your alfredo sauce, it would be nice for you to make that known to your customers. This place was downright disgusting in every way! I had high hopes for this place but for the amount of money that I paid for two incredibly sub-par dinners is sad. read more

Ribs don't even have any meat on them and the price for them is not even worth it i will never have them again

If you like a soft not crisp crust, this could be the pizza for you. I don't. The sauce is sweet that's overpowered by the garlic. We won't be back. read more

Great thick Cleveland style crust. One of the best pizzas I've had in Cleveland, with good prices.

I've tried this pizza two times. First time it was great. No issues. That's why we decided to go again...boy was I dissatisfied. They put way too much sauce on the pizza which makes the dough soggy. The pizza was too large for the box which in turn smushed the pizza. And the bottom was over cooked, almost black. I may try one more time for a redemption try. Because over all their pizza is good. read more

When prepared correctly the food here is top notch but tonight I'm rather unhappy. I ordered a small cheese pizza. I did not order it overcooked, yet it is. I also didn't order it folded over.. yet it is. Being busy isn't an excuse. Tighten up read more

Sambino's Pizza - two slices of pizza in a box - Pizza Near Me - Elyria, Ohio

Pizza not bad but a little skimpy on the toppings especially for a Deluxe. Pretty good for a strictly take-out joint. Only complaint, they also raised their prices........ AGAIN. Even their coupons which they send out every other week don't save you much. Guys, how about having a weekly-special or an early-bird special before 6:00 pm. Something like that, or anything where I don't have to search for and bring you a coupon. Save a little on your advertising costs and lower your prices. I'll bet you more than make up the cost in more orders. read more

I would give 0 stars if I could NEVER AGAIN ...... I will not be back at this place, I orderd the x large taco pizza, went home the sour cream, beef, and few other ingredients were missing, the pizza was a sloppy mess, I called the business and complained about my pizza saying it was shit and I was rude cause I was mad, the man that seems to have a low iQ is very rude with me, I walk in place the pizza on the counter he said u have to dispute it with ur bank, and told me to leave, walked saying there pizza is shit, literally the pizza looked like someone threw up a taco and pieces of lettuce, I couldn't even pick it up the topping sauce and cheese fell right off. Train your employees or pay them enough so they actually give a fuck to do their job, right. read more

First time having their pizza. Having moved here from Chicagoland recently, I can say their pizza lacks a good sauce, plus better cheese, and overall taste. The pizza was flat, no taste at all. Crusted seemed too salty. I ordered a pie with certain ingredients...pie lacked pieces of sausage and pepperoni. Had the pie delivered...which was uneventful. Normal. read more

I ordered a 1/2 sheet pizza and it was burnt on the bottom. I was very unpleased with the purchase, but I proceeded to take it on the chin. When I went into the establishment the workers were just standing around like it was some time of clubhouse, not really prepping themselves for the next mission at hand. read more

This place is fabulous! I just moved back to the area and boy I was so excited to order Sambinos. I was nervous though because I wasnt quite sure if it would taste amazing like it did before I moved away. It did not disappoint. IT WAS AMAZING! It was just like yesterday! The pizza was so delicious and arrived to my front door piping hot. The wings were great...meaty and with that little bit of crunch on them. Customer service was great...thanks Sambinos for making my homecoming so much better with one of my favorite go to pizza joints. It was nice to finally get a hot chicken wing as opposed to all the tiny pigeon wings I have been eating since I had left. I cant wait to order again and again. My kids love pizza so I am really excited to introduce them to some really great tasting pizza and wings. read more

I ordered a small extra sauce mushroom and sausage pizza. I got a pizza with no sauce and the cheese and toppings slid to one side of the pie. Extra sauce doesn't sound like no sauce or lite sauce...strike two read more

The subs and pasta dinners are very large, filling and delicious! My brother, who is hard to impress was blown away by the meatball subs, saying that they are double the meat and flavor of local sub shops. We also ordered two Chicken Parmesan dinners with garlic bread...two were enough to feed 4. They use chicken tenders, but they were fork tender and juicy...also cheesy. The only thing we didn't like was the burnt parts off of the aluminum foil that we picked off of our food. Otherwise, a great family dinner, a tremendous value, and enthusiastic service and delivery. Thank you! read more

Brother and I tried Sambino's Pizza for the first time last week. Wow !! What a great pizza ! We absolutely loved it ! We'll enjoy it again this weekend and try the wings that look so good in the picture! read more

My husband I got Sambino's Pizza the other night. It was my first time trying it out. We got a special for 23.95 sent to us in the mail for a large 2 topping and a large specialty pizza. We got an onion and mushroom and a taco pizza. Not overly impressed. I wouldnt recommend the taco pizza. I feel like it was missing sour cream for one. read more

Drove 20+ minutes to try this because of some reviews I read on here. Did not disappoint. Was very tasty pizza. Got the Big Sambino special which is XL 2 topping pizza, 10 wings, cheesy bread and 2-liter. Great value for this special. The pizza was very good, not greasy at all and the toppings were generous. The cheesy bread was 5x better than chains who advertise cheesy bread. The wings were decent- nothing spectacular and realistically if you are anywhere near this place and need wings, head over to Cookies. I will definitely try again, possibly the taco pizza as those are not too common anymore and it sounded amazing read more

great place if you like Your food cooked with no gloves & in a unsanitary area cmon .

I was a little worried, you know a pizza place in elyria. It's always it a little scary. We braved it and tried it. Listen it does not disappoint. Costumer service was excellent, it was quick! ThE pizza was amazing we got a deluxe and it was sooooo good! It will definitely be our go to spot from now on! Definitely mad we didnt try it sooner! read more

Place always hits the spot my favorite pizza in all Lorain county There' taste is like nothing else

Ordered delivery and service was fast. Got a half-sheet pepperoni pizza and salad. The price is inexpensive. The food is just OK for me. The flavors were underwhelming and a bit bland. No zing to the pizza sauce. The cheese on the salad was plentiful, but no flavor to it. You can put out a cheap spread with this place though. read more

Sambino's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Elyria, Ohio

Best salad around along with the hot buffalo boneless wings nice timing on the delivery service friendly drivers

Love love love the crust of this pizza. The sauce is also tasty. My kids love their wings and my husband always tries a different sub sandwich. Awesome food and service is quick read more

This place has some great pizza and wings. I haven't tried any of the other menu items but I'm going to assume they are probably just as good! I've driven past this place a million times and always think, "I need to try that place one time." But then I always forget to think of it when we are ordering a pizza. I won't be forgetting about it anymore! The prices on the menu were very reasonable and the food was great- what more could you want? read more

Order from here if you dont want what you order. Terrible phone service. Couldn't even correct the order properly and forgot food on the second trip. Is good pizza but doesn't mean jack if the service sucks. read more

My husband went to get a pizza from the Elyria location on Cleveland Street, and I happen to have a 6 year old son with Type 1 Diabetes. This is an autoimmune disorder and not caused by what he has eaten in the past. He does, however, need to know the number of carbs in EVERYTHING he eats so we can dose him correctly with insulin. To little insulin, he could die, too much insulin, he could die. When picking up the pizza, my husband asked for nutritional information; specifically carbs per serving. No one knew anything. No one knew how to find out. This is the FIRST place I have ever encountered that cannot give this type of information. It may not seem serious to most, but it can be very life threatening for my son. I have now spent $22 for my child to not be able to eat. He is crushed. This diagnosis is hard enough as it is, on him. Now we have to explain to him the best that we can, that he can't eat this pizza. I am baffled that a place that pretty much serves carbs on a platter can't tell me what the carb count is for their pizza. Diabetics beware - no one in the restaurant will be able to help you. Stay away. This is the first place I have EVER encountered that can't help with carbohydrates per serving(s) read more

Sambino's is the best pizza in Elyria. My husband and I recently moved to this community and, as pizza fanatics, have been trying lots of local pies to find our favorite. Once we had Sambino's we knew the search was over. Their wings are badass too. I've also had occasion recently to discover, in two unrelated venues, that Sambino's actively supports student athletes throughout Lorain County. This is great pizza from a company that gives back to the community. It's a win-win. read more

This is our second time ordering from Sambinos as we are new to the area. This place is AWESOME!! The pizza is delicious, the wings are perfectly cooked and the mild wing sauce is just about the best I have tasted! The pizza and wings arrive piping hot and the delivery drivers have been happy and friendly. This will definitely be our go to pizza place from now on!! read more

Sambino's used to make great pizza! Sadly, that's changed. We ordered the Great Sambino which included an xlarge 2 topping pizza, cheesy bread, 10 wings and a two liter of pop. I added cinnamon sticks to the order. First, they forgot the pop. Next, the pizza was so spicey we couldn't finish it. Really needed the pop! The wings were "quite" well done and the bottom of the cinnamon sticks were burnt. Still waiting for the 2 liter to be delivered as I'm writing this. For a $40 meal, I expected better. read more

Good place for take out. The pizza is pretty good and had no troubles with ordering or pick up. I will return here in the future i am very sure. read more

The pizza is awesome. We have ordered all different kinds. Delivery is fast and all the people we have encountered have been very pleasant.

Very very good service from employee, hot fresh food. 4 1/5 star pizza experience, could have been 5 but need to suggestive sell.

This place is terrible!! First they sent me spaghetti with sauce and no meatballs which I asked for ( Also asked for sauce on the side ( they didn't get that right) I asked for two salad dressings and got one (which I was willing to pay for extra). On top of this they sent no forks. The spaghetti taste worse than canned spaghettios and very processed under plain tomato paste (Don't waste $9.00 on that ..When I called to ask why no forks he replied " Maybe you should have F-ing asked for a fork!" The pizza was in a box smaller than its size so they folded the sides to smash it in (gross) Trying to find a place where I can post a pic to back up my claim so I can help others. Most good reviews has to be from owners as bad as the service and food is here. Can't believe they have a business..Wonder how long it will last. read more

Excellent delivery service, ask for Myles

I was on lunch break and came here to grab a bite. They were so attentive! They gave me the wifi password, which isn't advertised, so I could continue working! The prices were great too! read more

We have been customers for years and have had every item on the menu. Haven't found anything we don't like, service is good, food is good. Occasionally make a minor mistake but we usually order @ their busiest times, and usually don't say anything but if we do they always make it right. Suggestions for improvement: use romaine instead of iceberg for your salads, and include tortilla chips with taco salad. If not for this would give them 5 stars. Thank you for the good food and good service from long time customer. read more

Always the best! This is professional pizza. Not chain pizza place rubbish! Priced well for the quality.

This pizza place is nasty all Dominos are nasty but they have some banging crust!!!!!!

Staff was very nice, food was done on time and hot when I picked it up. The food though, could be better. My sub was wet, and tasted like a gas station made sub. The pizza tasted like carnival or gas station pizza with more cheese. Not very good. Overall the experience was fine, but the food was not to my liking. One detractor was that they do not have jalapenos, which for me is essential for pizza. I'd much rather go to Marcos. read more

Very tasty pizza with relatively quick delivery. Only issue is they delivered to us knowing we're at a hotel, but included no napkins, silverware, etc read more

Hands down best pizza ever. My family orders from Sambinos at least once a week- not to mention it was one of my top cravings when I was pregnant with my son. Fast delivery, food is always hot, fresh and good. Affordable prices and quality food. Make sure you get the cheesy bread- it's unlike any you've tried before! read more