Scrumptious delicious Birthday week at our home and we started with Escargot, calamari & mondeghini. Everything perfectly cooked, the calamari tender, not chewy and the pomodoro perfection. Main courses: braised short ribs with roasted potatoes, Paparadelle 2085, and My Way. Again, everything perfection. Seasoned perfectly, not overly. This is a restaurant for your palate, your pleasure. read more

Andrea's Restaurant - Obi Wan Cannoli (made in house) - Italian Near Me - Sarasota, Florida

See all

There's a reason Andrea's has thrived for more than a decade: quality in cuisine, wines, ambiance, service. We greatly enjoyed the calm atmosphere that encouraged conversation over a dinner that met or exceeded everyone's expectations. The first impression sets the tone: intimate setting , quiet yet not stuffy atmosphere. Attentive service. Impressive wine list. And regional specialties prepared and plated to please. We (party of 4) found full enjoyment in the eggplant parm, the mondeghini, the arancini, the flounder, the gnocchi and... and ... all the way to exceptionally light canoli. Unhesitatingly flawless dinner with food with just the right amount of saucing and seasoning (Nothing dripping mozzarella or drowning in red sauce) and unobtrusive yet on-it service. In sum: Andrea's goes on our short list of fine Italian dining in Sarasota. read more

Great first evening! Superb wine list and great bottle recommended by Andrea. Wonderful caesar salad. Wonderful pasta, octopus. All topped off with the very best creme brulee I have ever had and a delicious expresso. Fine service by Matti. We will make this a regular event! read more

Hidden Gems: quaint little restaurant, everything we ordered was amazing, I had the ceaser salad with anchovies and Andrea's short ribs with potatoes. The steak tartare was delicious. Our waiter was excellent, thoroughly explaining everything. My daughter took us out for my birthday. Will definitely be back. read more

See all

A very good choice We finally dined at Andrea's with friends last night, and had a great time and meal. The experience wasn't quite what I expected, starting with the restaurant itself. From the outside, Andrea's looks dark and easily overlooked. Located in a strip mall across from Aldi's, Andrea's and Rick's French Bistro seem out of place. But once I stepped inside for the first time, I found a well-lit upscale welcoming place. I consider places upscale if there are tablecloths and lots of glassware, and menu prices on the high side. You can spend money at Andrea's, our total was about $60 per person, but there are also less expensive options. If you do want to spend money, they offer an extensive wine selection. We found Andrea's a comfortable place, not pretentious. Andrea is a real person. He stopped by a couple of times to introduce himself and to make us feel welcome and appreciated. His two sons provided excellent service throughout our visit. I love eating at locally owned and operated places, a family business. As for the food, I started with their Cesar Salad and included anchovies for an upcharge. It was a good size but did lack any noticeable Ceasar dressing flavor. Light and fresh, for me the saltiness of the anchovies saved this course. For my entrée I had their Tagliolini Sunday Style. It was tough to decide, they offer 3 or 4 entrees I really wanted to try, a good reason to return someday. This pasta dish was large and very good. I did some research and still don't know exactly what Sunday Style means, but there is a tradition by Italians to enjoy pasta on Sundays. Perhaps there is an extra effort to make that a special meal, and perhaps Andrea includes an extra effort for this dish. The flavor was mild, the pieces of braised pork ribs while not melt in your mouth tender were still very easy to eat and provided some texture. Others at the table gave high marks to the Pappardelle 2085 entree. We made a very good choice when we selected Andrea's for dinner. read more

Andrea's Restaurant - Cesar Salad - Italian Near Me - Sarasota, Florida

See all

My girlfriend's and I sat for 30 minutes while our waiter walked by us many times actively ignoring us (we tried many times to flag him down). After 30 minutes, he asked ONE of us what we wanted to drink, and ignored the rest of the people at our table. Five minutes later, he brought the wrong drink. Another waiter came over and brought us bread and took our full drink order, but this was 45 minutes into our seating! There are too many good Italian restaurants in Sarasota- don't waste your time visiting this one. The food isn't even that good. The tiramisu was gross. All five women tried it, and found it inedible. read more

Excellent food and excellent service! I had the chicken Milanese -it was delicious, tender and perfectly cooked! We'll go back!!

Fantastic! We tried this place after it was recommended by another local chef. We can't stop talking about how good it was. We had the special ravioli, the Gnocchi and the beef and mushrooms over pappardelle. The house salad was simple and tasty and the tiramisu and creme brûlée were fresh and really good as well. Have patience when you go there and definitely call ahead. They had 12ish tables. The weight staff is young but gave great recommendations. We will definitely go back. Highly recommend! read more

This is my favorite Italian restaurant!! The wine selection is outstanding and for every price point. The service is top notch. It's a once a week spot for us. We either have a meal or a pizza. read more

Need two different star ratings, would have given 4 stars for decent food but everything else? 2 stars. Dirty looking restaurant, there were flies flying around. The servers were young inexperienced, shabbily dressed, their clothes looked dirty. The main server didn't even bother to come to our table to greet us. So, now to the food, the pappardelle with a beef sauce was tasty, the veal Milanese was crisp, topped with fresh arugula, I enjoyed it. Also the starter zucchini parmesan. Deep fried, in a roll very nice. The place needs a renovation and the service personnel, training. Typical restaurant in Sarasota, pricey and overrated. read more

Andrea's is our go to Italian restaurant in the area and there are many choices. We ate there again last night. I say " again" because we keep gravitating there and walk away each time extremely pleased. Their octopus starter is the best ever and I've tried them all in the area. So tender. My absolute favorite dish there is the zuppa de pesche OMG is it great., My wife had the linguini with seafood. Tremendous . Wine list has solid choices at every price point. . The young waiters are outstanding. They know their products and are so personable . We love that the restaurant is not pretentious., It's all about the food in a very welcoming and appreciative cozy environment. One suggestion would be to add a fresh fish special from time to time . read more

Fantastic Italian food !! Another hidden gem in sarasota . We will definitely be frequenting here for upscale Italian food . Nothing disappointing at all. Came for our 33rd wedding anniversary. All around great night . read more

Andrea's Restaurant - Long Bone in veal chop! - Italian Near Me - Sarasota, Florida

I would have ranked them higher except they charge 7.99 and 2.99 if you want to split entrees and appetizers respectively. Just eat off of each others' plates or use your bread plate to share. And no split checks for parties of 6 or more. Harumph. However, the food is wonderful. I love octopus and they serve it as an entree. Some places overcook their octopus but not here. Gnocchi: yum. Several in our party enjoyed the veal and lasagna. There's a bonus restaurant affiliated with A's next door: Malmosto. Quaint and charming wine bar/ pizza place. Pizzas made in seconds in wood burning oven. Malmosto is small and tucked between A's and a doctor's office. Really good! read more

I wanted to try this joint for a while and tonight we finally gave it a shot...I ordered the Flounder Meunière which came out hot on a bed of fresh veggies ...No complaints, pretty damn good... The Wife went with a Pasta dish in a carbonara sauce which wasn't impressive in any way , shape or form...We like our pasta cooked Al Dente but this was just plain undercooked...A weak dish , no excuse for that...Not even hot when it made it to the table...Unimpressive bread basket as well... Sorry Andrea, but it is what it is .,,,, read more

We had a beautiful and scrumptious dinner on Tuesday night! We had appetizers, salads three different entrees and desserts! All FANTASTIC!!! The waiter was extremely attentive and the Chef came out and asked how the food was. We had the Veal Piccata, Flounder Meunière, and the Chicken Napoleon. The desserts were so delectable also (crème brûlée and a dessert of white chocolate and chocolate mousse with a raspberry drizzle and a cream sauce -sorry but I don't remember the name of that dessert but it was scrumptious). We are here for vacation and will definitely be having dinner there again before we leave! read more

100% an epic experience. The food and wine pairing was a hit. The 5- course dinner was interesting, authentic and left everyone wanting " more please"...it was quite filling. The courses opened with Exec. Chef Andrea presenting the dish, ts ingredient composition, regional history...and often colorful stories from Andrea. As he left to prepare our 5 courses, Michael, (enter stage left), our sommelier for the evening, carefully crafted the purpose, varietals, and regional "geo" of each wine that was poured. [Extra bottles of wine are for purchase after your meal to take home] but the wine with dinner is included in the pre fixed seating charge. These dinners are unique, limited seating, fun, educational and delicious... . Stay tuned ....and follow them on FB for more fun dinner dates coming soon. * plenty of free parking. Book a reservation in advance- pay at the end of your evening. Reservations here fill up fast! read more

Excellent food! For starters my husband and I shared the Caesar salad. For his entree my husband had the gnocchi in a mushroom cream sauce and I had the polenta appetizer for dinner which was more than enough for two people. We ended the evening with a cappuccino. read more

Andrea's Restaurant - This is how a cappuccino should be served - Italian Near Me - Sarasota, Florida

Andrea's is the most authentic Italian restaurant in Sarasota. We have eaten the the finest restaurants in this country and many parts in the world, so we have some experience with food and we know when we are getting a quality dish or if the chef cheapens the ingredients to save money. This is an over the top find for us. The Chef himself is very attentive and is passionate about every detail, the wait staff is well informed and work together like a well oiled machine. My favorite of the menu is the handmade pasta with short rib. I'm obsessed with it. Chef has a wine cellar and will gladly assist in a wine selection to fit your taste. Bravo, Chef Andrea. We will be away until Fall now can't wait to return. Restaurant is small so please make a reservation read more

Andrea's Restaurant - This beautiful dish is a handmade papparedelle with short rib - Italian Near Me - Sarasota, Florida

We were so disappointed!!!!! We were expecting an authentic Italian meal. Really hate to write a bad review.. but it just wasn't what we expected. Do not buy a bottle of wine without checking the price outside of this restaurant .. our wine was 65.00 a bottle and at Total Wine it's $19.99.. buyer beware! read more

Fried Eggplant degrades the vegetable. Escargot was a 3 on a 10 scale. Cesar Salad with anchovies was good, lasagna was good. Service was mediocre and the kids didn't know the menu. Has to ask twice for the pepper. Wouldn't go back. read more

LOVE LOVE LOVE! We had an exceptional meal with a fantastic Super Tuscan wine. This restaurant is beautifully intimate with top notch service! Andrea's gives meaning to the word perfection. read more

Had a reservation for 2 at 7:15 We were unfortunately unable to make so I called restaurant before they opened to cancel and was told to never call again because they are a small rest and I should have called sooner.. the gentleman on phone was very very rude It's one restaurant I will never eat at or call again !!!! read more

Over priced and bland. This place is not what it once was. No longer our go to for fresh pasta.

The service was friendly and great. I had the pappardelle with shortribs, and I was looking for the meat. For $29 I do expect to have a reasonable amount of meat and there was maybe 4-5 small thinly sliced bites. I ordered off of the full price menu, not Savor Sarasota. read more

Amazing!!!!!!!! We drive up from Englewood at least one or two times a month. Andrea's food is always and fresh, amazing, authentic and consistent. We have also attended some of the wine dinners and picked up several new favorite bottles of wine. Each bite is worth the trip! read more

A Find ! Lovely ambiance warm owner Andreas & son Dom who was serving tonight & did a fabulous job serving the entire restaurant! The Savor Sarasota Menu was great, many options! We had the linguine with seafood one tomato sauce one with garlic & olive oil- both awesome! Others had the flounder special of the evening which was so tender & light! One had Lasagne which was one of the best ever he said!! Love this place will becoming back very soon!! read more

Just when I thought I found the best Italian restaurant in Sarasota. This pops up. Certainly the best I've had. Service. Food and wine selection is at the top. You won't be disappointed read more

We had a wonderful family dinner last evening at Andrea's. We all enjoyed tasty and homemade pasta and fresh fish dishes, wine, salads, varied breads, and authentic desserts. We highly recommend this local, independent Italian Ristorante. They only offered a few wines by the glass, thus forcing full bottle sales. The salad was unremarkable mixed greens (ala bagged from Publix). Grazie mille to our server Betty, our bus boy, and the creative Chef Andrea. read more

VERY authentic Italian cuisine. The service was fantastic and the food was delicious! Servers were professional, courteous, and attentive.

This was a great find for us last night. We were driving around cedar and siesta key and became hungry. I called ahead and was told they would have room for the 4 of us in 45 minutes. We loved the crab cakes, lasagna, cacio e pepe, flounder and a special plate of chicken fingers. Service was very friendly and attentive. Too bad we live a few hours away and can't visit more frequently. read more

Had a fabulous dinner tonight on Savor Sarasota. Service was prompt and friendly. I had linguine diavalo and wife had veal Milanese...both were fresh and delicious. Can't wait to come back. read more

One of Sarasota!s tiny Italian restaurants. We waited nearly 10 minutes to be offered water. Once we were waited on the service was good. The food was good but unmemorable. Ambiance consists of random photos. Like many local Sarasota spots, I suspect if you are a regular you love this spot because you are smothered with positive attention, but otherwise not so much. read more

Great Italian food, the Savor Sarasota menu was a hit. Service was excellent. I recommend to all.

My husband and I have dined at Andrea's several times. Each time, the food was delicious and service was attentive. I had the Veal Marsala, and it was probably one of the best I've had, which is my 'go to' meal when I go to an Italian restaurant. I wish I'd taken photos. It is currently offering monthly special menus to extend Savor Sarasota. The special menus offer many choices, and his regular menu is large. From our first experience, Andrea greeted us and made us feel welcome. read more

still one of the best anywhere consistent excellent food wine and service charming and friendly read more

The food was outstanding. Great wine list and super service. Only reason I didn't give 5 stars was the ambiance. Restaurant could use a makeover. It was very dark and the decorating left a lot to be desired. read more

Andrea was great doing take out during the pandemic. He's food is consistently good and service is wonderful. It feels like a small Italian restaurant right out of Italy. Love to support our local business. read more

We loved this italian restaurant. Upscale feel, server was amazing and the food was authentic. Fresh home made bread and butter were delicious! read more

We love Andrea's! Intimate setting, impeccable service, and creative Classic Italian cuisine. This local gem is a consistent favorite. During covid, they offered pickup and (limited) delivery in order to help their many loyal customers. His wine dinners are always well attended. Reservations required. read more

See all

We love Andrea's. We have eaten there during this Covid crisis up to 4 times per week. Andrea is so careful about social distancing, cleanliness, and wearing masks, that we felt very safe. The owner Andrea does the cooking himself and he takes great pride in making sure that every guest in his Italian restaurant gets the best and freshest food possible. He is also very flexible. I have been going through extensive dental work that requires me to eat soft food. He has made certain that every time we come for dinner he has my favorite meat ravioli. His veal Milanese is pounded so thin and is so tender that I have been able to eat that as well. My husband loves Andreas light hand with his fried flounder so much that he says he could eat it every night. However, frequently Andrea has a newly caught fish dropped off and he will do something special with it that night. His specials are worth ordering. The wait staff is great. They really want everyone to be happy. Michael and Robb and their assistants are friendly, professional, and helpful. We really cannot say enough good things about Andrea's. Try it for yourself. And, if you have extra room, try his wonderful cannolis. Oh, if you like the wine, which we do, Andrea will get you bottles to take home at an excellent price and personally choose them for you based on what he knows you like. read more