‍ After our mountain bike ride in Allaire, we headed over to Belmar for lunch at Anchor Tavern--and I definitely recommend giving it a try! They start you off with a basket of popcorn, which was such a fun and unexpected surprise! I started with the coconut shrimp, and I absolutely loved them! Great coconut flavor and the dipping sauce was really good. Definitely recommend ordering these! For my meal, I had the half chicken with Brussels sprouts and a Caesar salad. The chicken was a little dry, but not terrible. I definitely needed the gravy and asked for more. The sides were good, though. My husband had the spicy vodka rigatoni. He really liked the portion size--it was large! The chicken was fried and also a little on the dry side. He thought the vodka sauce was a little too spicy for his taste, but overall he enjoyed it and gave his meal about 3 1/2 stars. 1/2 I had the fresh brewed iced tea, which was good and refreshing. Overall, I'd recommend Anchor Tavern. It's definitely a down-the-shore kind of spot, and while the food was just okay--not anything spectacular--it was certainly not terrible. The coconut shrimp were the highlight for me! read more

See all

It's a Tavern. We stopped in for a quick bite. The food was just ok. The rotisserie chicken was very dry. Great service though and the live band was awesome. read more

This was our second time here and the food gets better and better. I'm pretty sure the chicken in general is the star of the show here starting with the buffalo wings which are grilled to perfection and have a sweet hot sauce unlike any other. The first time I got the chicken street corn bowl and OMG. This time we tried the spicy vodka rigatoni and the onion burger, both were phenomenal. Can't go wrong with anything honestly! read more

See all

Awful. Food was mediocre. Waitress was not with it. Average atmosphere. If you do go sit at the bar. Better service there. Get a burger or half chicken. read more

While we're not locals, we've visited several times over the years on vacation. The service at first was quick, but fell off when one member of our party got their second beer when one of the kids hadn't gotten a soda. Food was overall bland. The kielbasa and pierogies were not fresh. When I asked for our our appetizers to be taken off because they didn't arrive, they instead came out...piping hot...after so as not to be taken off the bill. They were actually good, saving the review from 1 star. read more

Umm no. The only reason for the two stars was because the server was so nice. A forgotten appetizer, Cold fries, lukewarm burger and sub par chicken. I was wondering why it was almost empty on a Sunday. Oh well live and learn. read more

My wife requested to go to Anchors Tavern in Belmar. We've been before. Simple Americana Bistro food. Good chicken. Consistent. Good prices. Staff is attentive. We came in Saturday afternoon, and got the happy hour wings. Sat at the bar. Two attentive fast moving bartenders. Wings and drinks were good. Bartender talked me into a different beer, like a mango Guinness, half and half. It was surprisingly good. Problem is, one of the managers, came storming in and screamed and cursed at the bartenders in an unhinged manner. It was very strange and unprofessional. Something about people Waiting for drinks and you (expletive) suck. You need new bartenders. My wife grabbed my arm, and said don't say anything . You don't talk to people that way, let alone employees. They just looked at each other and shrugged it off. Not a good temperament for a manager at a family place . read more

BELMAR: we are so excited that Anchor Tavern now welcomes leashed, friendly pups on their outdoor patio! It is the perfect spot to relax with great food, refreshing drinks, and your furry friend by your side. Dogs are welcome at the tables along the fence and should stay near the fence for everyone's safety, since this is a popular restaurant. With an eclectic menu, lively vibes, and a prime downtown location, it is a great place to enjoy a meal out with your pup! read more

Anchor Tavern - Bars Near Me - Belmar, New Jersey

I've always been a fan of this place. I try to go at least once, or twice a summer, when in Belmar. I've been getting the roasted beet salad with goat cheese for years. Stopped in the other day to pick it up after ordering over phone. Added grilled chicken to the salad. $28 !!!!!! C'mon!! That's gouging. No excuse for that salad to be that much. Not coming back, and that's a shame. Great atmosphere, always wonderful staff, but can't do it. read more

Debbie is our favorite bartender. Always so friendly and we never pay a dime! Food is good. Highly recommend this place!

Hands down, for years this has been one of my favorite places to eat of the surrounding towns. Why, you ask? Well, the answer is simple, it's really just good bar food, but nothing that would change your life. It's comfortable, but no more than any other bar/restaurants. What makes this place so great is that it consistently has a great vibe and really nice people who actually seem to care about their jobs. Everyone is polite, and does what they can, to accommodate you in whatever way they can. The food also alway above average. Anchor Burgers are great. Very good fish and chips. Lovely steak salads...just goods food and no stress. Love this place. read more

(in the style of Minecraft Movie "Chicken Jockey") CHICKEN BURGERRRRRRRRRRR The food here is great when they get your order correct. I have ordered takeout over 5 times from here and they have never gotten the order completely correct once, which literally sucks. The servers are always so nice when you dine in. Real beautiful redhead girl at the front that my buddy has a huge crush on. They put the Yankees on every TV and tell you to "kick rocks" if you ask them to put on King of the Hill or Adult Swim on any TVs at the bar. But whatever. read more

The service, atmosphere and beer were excellent. The happy hour food was marginal. Smaller and better quality would be nice. read more

What a surprise! My sister, who has so many food allergies and sensitivities as well as being a celiac, had her own menu filled with options that delighted her. She had a Baja bowl without chicken. She ordered a small cup of chili on the side to add to her bowl. She loved it! I had the pulled pork bowl, which was delicious, especially the bbq ranch sauce! Our friends went with the burgers and were licking their fingers. To finish off, we shared one slice of absolutely fabulous flourless chocolate cake. I must mention our server, who said she was subbing in the bar today. She was so good & treated us so well even though we waited for a long time for the rest of our party to arrive. I regret not catching her name. She was great! We will make a special trip to Belmar soon. We want to try those burgers! read more

Our bartender, Becca, was rude and inappropriate. She blatantly ignored a member of our party, thinking she was underage. After serving a drink (that another party member ordered) she rudely stopped her from drinking and asked if she was 21. No issue with the question, its the manner in which the customer was ignored then rudely asked instead of the bartender doing her due dilligence. It left our friend embarrassed and upset at the way she was treated. Do better next time and avoid this as a whole. read more

First, our server, Rachel, was very pleasant and attentive. Everything was downhill from there. Ordered fried zucchini. It was soggy and greasy. Also ordered sweet potato tots which were equally soggy and mushy. A 12 year old can make a decent chicken quesadilla, but not the chef/cook at this place. On the plus side, the place is very nice in general. Nice outdoor seating. With better good the place could be great, but as is, it's far below marginal. It's on a very busy corner and there is lots of honking due to heavy traffic, but that's not the restaurant's fault. I felt bad for the band, who was playing outside. They were very good. Lots of great songs but card and buses honking kind of ruined the vibe. We won't be back. read more

Service was great. Blue cheese for wings was good along with onion rings and horseradish sauce . Nothing Else!

Braving the whipping winds, cold temps and rain going sideways as quoted by Ollie Williams, we stopped in to this wonderful gem. Upon entering this fine establishment the cozy atmosphere warmed us to the core. Friendly staff were also nearby to chat up and talk life. To take nourishment we ordered the cowboy sliders. Perfect flavor of bbq sauce, Mac and cheese and bacon on great patties. Each bite made me feel more and more like I was becoming Butch Cassidy and I was looking across the table at the Sundance kid. Highly suggest ordering this tasty chow, just be aware afterwards you may be putting on your stirrups to mosey on out! What do you call a pig that gets injured stretching? Pulled pork.... The flavor was smoky and the bun was toasted to perfection. Portion size was large and filling. Fries were plentiful on the side. Pork tacos and sweet potato fries. The tortilla was fresh and the pico delicious. The pork had great seasoning and juicyness in the cook. Definitely try it and enjoy your meal. Good place with great staff. Must visit! read more

very nice staff. fish and chips. disgusting. the texture of the fries - chewy? not good. the fish inedible. discolored! some grey, some off-white. sunken in from the overcooked batter leaving you with just batter. wasn't interested in trying something else. what the hell could be going on in the kitchen management to put out that kind of a meal. said nothing, just won't eat there again. PS PLEASE turn off the large screen t.v. behind the band! thanks. read more

I have a nostalgic like for Anchor, been coming for awhile. Last night wife and I sat at the bar for dinner, which was 'tails and 3 apps. Just great attentive service by our barkeep. Fried pickles...ok I'm kind of a connoisseur of this dish...I will give props for originality and taking a risk...but horseradish sauce just doesn't work. Buffalo wings are slow cooked over a flame and they are every bit as good as the traditional deep fried variety, and much better for you...actually healthy. Steak bites? The menu claims they are pieces of filet. Dude you're not fooling anyone. Stop insulting me. What is the worst cut of steak? Chuck? London Broil? These things are for the most part unchewable, inedible. read more

Bar tender service was beyond slow it was painful. She kept disappearing for long times and then ignored the patrons. Took forever to get my check . I won't be back any time soon! read more

Good service, food was awesome, and the music was blasting an amazing place to go to have some weekend fun. read more

Best burger in New Jersey nice waitresses great greeting when you walk in seating outside yummy drink you have to go delicious, love the ambience and the bar area has lots of TVs read more

See all

Best chicken burger anywhere! Great spot for lunch during workday or dinner! Outside is great they also have heaters in the cooler weather. read more

Drinks are great. Food was even better. We got the nachos and they were pretty good. They come with red bean salsa which kicks it up a notch. The wrap and chicken sandwich were great. Fries were crisp and salty. read more

Anchor Tavern - Bars Near Me - Belmar, New Jersey

See all

This restaurant serves American food. I liked the cheddar cheeseburger, and the brownie a la mode. read more

Anchor Tavern - Brownie a la mode - Bars Near Me - Belmar, New Jersey

This is one of the most consistent restaurants I have been too. In addition, the quality is the same even when you order delivery. Typically Mac and cheese is sub par at restaurants but this is creamy and delicious. The chicken is good but sometimes it can be a little dry. The gravy is home made and always tastes fantastic and the short rib grilled cheese is a must try!! This is my new favorite spot around and I don't say that lightly. Absolutely go and try it!! read more

I live locally and finally stopped in for dinner last night. We were seated outside right away and the service was very good. We both had the rotisserie chicken which is what they are known for. I must say I was not very impressed. The chicken was on the dry side and nothing on the plate was hot including the sides. It was lukewarm at best. I'm not a fan of corn bread but I've definitely had better. The brussel sprouts had good flavor but tasted like they were reheated. The broccoli side was steamed perfectly but it was also not very hot. Perhaps this was just an off night and the food is usually better. I don't know but it seems there are mixed reviews here. read more

Anchor Tavern - outdoor dining. - Bars Near Me - Belmar, New Jersey

See all

This review is just for the outdoor bar. Kona beers were cold and refreshing. Bartender was affable. Awning shielded us from the sun and the rain. Abouy 10 chairs at the bar top. Across from other awesome spots to eat and drink. $8 per draft...America. read more

Anchor Tavern - America. Freedom. - Bars Near Me - Belmar, New Jersey

Another review that's been in the pipeline for a while. A friend and I stopped in one foggy evening. Sat outside. Very comfy. Good service. Our usual post adventure drinks. Absolute, grapefruit, splash of cranberry and a lime and a Margarita. Excellent. Fish and chips. Salmon. The food came right out. The fish and chips suffered from too much time in the fryer. Very dry. The salmon suffered from too much time under or on whatever it was cooked in or on. But we were starving and did not complain. Definitely an excellent drink spot. The food is secondary in my view. read more

Anchor Tavern - Cedar planked salmon - Bars Near Me - Belmar, New Jersey

See all

Great vibe, nice outdoor space and friendly staff. Burger night is a must, and the apps and salads are very good. Drinks are strong. The rotisserie chicken is perfect in the Fall and Winter seasons. I hope they extend their happy hour times during the off season. read more

Rating wings along the Jersey Shore. Scores from 0.0-5.0. Good ratio flats to drums. Not too greasy or oily. Smokey flavor with a spicy after taste. Could use more crisp. Wood fire aftertaste is great. Great day drinking wings at the outside bar. Wings rated: 3.8 read more

Anchor Tavern - Wings - Bars Near Me - Belmar, New Jersey

Sam and Deborah are amazing happy belated birthday Sam from d&L. Have a great time everytime I step into Anchor tavern

Great vibe. Nice selection of brews and cocktails. Typical bar food with a few specials. Great inside and outside seating areas. Awesome servers and bartenders. read more

The bar overall is average. The main problem is watching sports with dated televisions. Almost all televisions have many burnt out led's and has ruined the watching experience. They are the original televisions. Many people I know pointed out the problem but it was laughed at. It's been two years since they've been aware and ignored it. Chefs international has deep pockets, so money isn't an issue. We won't be going there for sports until they rectify the problem. read more

Really enjoyed my first trip to the Anchor - we arrived for lunch on a Friday and they did a great job with social distancing protocols. It rained like the end of the world during our meal, and the team was quick to move umbrellas and make sure we were all good. The beer list was solid, and the cocktails all looked good. We enjoyed appetizers and I thought the turkey club was exceptional - the turkey was perfectly prepared and the sandwich was a huge winner. Outdoor seating was great, staff was awesome, can't wait to go back! read more

Anchor Tavern - Turkey club was a fabulous choice! What a sandwich! - Bars Near Me - Belmar, New Jersey

See all

Very good food and service. Recommended We got seated quickly and the entire staff is very welcoming. read more

Anchor Tavern - Shrimp Basket - Bars Near Me - Belmar, New Jersey

Went for lunch with the grandkids. Server was excellent with the kids and very attentive. Food was great- burgers, pulled pork, quesadillas. Everyone was happy. Kids get a one price meal which includes soda and ice cream. Right up their alley! I would recommend Anchor Tavern!! read more

I kept coming to the Yelp page for the Anchor and saying ehhhh since the reviews are sort of bad. However, we finally decided to try it. Much to my surprise, it was a very good experience all around. The food portions are large, and you will leave full. My personal favorite is the white meat portion of chicken that comes with your choice of two sides, plus cornbread. The appetizers are also good, we've tried the nachos and quesadilla and both were on point. Outdoor seating is cute and relaxing, and there is an outdoor bar as well. read more

Aesthetically this place is pretty cool. They have a great outside area and a cool interior. Televisions galore are available to watch whatever sport might be playing that day. There is a good beer selection to choose from. You won't be disappointed. Unfortunately where the disappointment did click in for me was over the food. It just wasn't as good as I had anticipated for a place like this. I ordered the Bacon Blue Burger and it just didn't taste right to me. There wasn't anything wrong with it per se, but it just wasn't that good. When I go to a bar I typically expect to get an amazing burger ... and that wasn't what I had here. In reading other reviews post my experience, I'm seeing Anchor Tavern is known for its rotisserie chicken ... wish I had known that prior to stopping in as I would have ordered that instead. Shame on me for not checking Yelp first. With that said, because I wasn't in love with my burger, I probably wouldn't go out of my way to come back here again. read more