We had a 17-person party at Anatolia and everything was just great! We had individual orders but the way they catered the food was perfectly timed. Bulat was the master of the ceremony and he was super friendly and courteous, while ensuring that all would workout smoothly. And it did! But thank you to Bulat and the rest of the Anatolia team for giving us such an unforgettable experience. read more

I came here for friends birthday twice and even ordered take out from here once. The food is consistently delicious, and I highly recommend their service. Everything I tried on the menu was a 5/5 read more

See all

I have to say this time I went to Anatolia was pure disappointment. My family and I always come to this restaurant for any occasion or celebration, and it's always been a great time with great food. My family and I went last weekend for lunch, and from the beginning it was a disaster. Waiter coming back and forth for FOUR times, let me repeat that FOUR times to repeat the order, mind you it was only 6 of us so not like we had crazy amount of orders for the waiter to come back and forth regarding this matter, besides what's the point of writing it down in the first place? The sad part wasn't even this, once the food came the waitress dropped all the sauces all over our pants of my husband and me and not ONCE apologized, instead kept asking where should she put the remaining food that didn't fall on the floor, at that point I felt like letting the staff know to put the food on my head. I have never experienced this kind of hospitality from Anatolia. We celebrated multiple birthdays, my cousins engagement in this restaurant and always had a great time, so I don't know what is wrong with the afternoon staff there, but being courteous to your customers and apologizing to them especially when you have ruined their clothes should be common sense or please properly train your staff. read more

Food was great but service was very slow. Had to wait for a long time to give our order and the food took long to come out.

Great food, friendly service and highly recommended! I was part of a party 7 and this was out first time at Anatolia. We will 100% be back. The cigar borek and babaghonush were really done well. I had the delicious chicken curry with rice and my wife had the Manti lamb dumplings which I can also confirm is a great choice. The rest of our party had kebab and lamb dishes. We'll be back to try those! It's also worth repeating how great the staff is. Super welcoming and accommodating read more

This place is beyond excellent. This restaurant offers the best Mediterranean food in the area Every dish bursts with authentic flavors, Their grilled meats are tender, juicy, and cooked to perfection, with just the right amount of seasoning. The atmosphere complements the meal, creating an inviting and comfortable dining experience. If you're craving Mediterranean cuisine, this place is truly unmatched in quality and taste. The service was unmatched as well. read more

The Staff is great!!! Food is tasty! They are Really friendly and the atmosphere is really cute

Absolutely mind blowing! I was impressed by their atmosphere, and most importantly the QUALITY of their food. Let's start off by saying thank you to the lovely staff that took care of the party of 11 from last night, you guys did a great job dealing with us and making sure we got everything we needed. I ordered the Lamb mixed grill and it included their delicious, mouth watering lamb Adana, lamb Shish, and lamb chop! Everything was perfect from that first bite of their signature Turkish rice to their salad, which I was impressed by because some restaurants usually serve lousy salads but this one knocked it out of the park! Thank you for a fantastic experience, most definitely will be coming back! read more

I took my family to Anatolia in January 2025 and expected a good meal. Unfortunately, that did not happen. From what Anatolia used to be 4 or 5 years ago not much is left, except the nice physical setting. The good food is no longer there. My wife, my daughter and I were served food far below the expected quality. For example, I ordered a simple lamb Gyro sandwich. I was served a roll-up sandwich which was 80% vegetables (salad leaves, a small amount of cucumber, a touch of onion, etc.). The meager amount of meat that was there was awful. It was small trips of lamb and most of it was white fat. After clearing out most of that fat, there was not much left. It is as if I had a vegetable sandwich. I did not even eat half of the sandwich. I left it on the table along with the pile of fat that I had taken out. My wife and daughter also gave up on eating their meals. We were very surprised by how bad this restaurant has changed over the last few years. It probably changed ownership and the new boss is just trying to make a profit at a great expense of quality. The pictures on the website showing good food are mostly from 4 years ago. We do not recommend it at all to anyone wanting to eat a descent east Mediterranean or halal meal. Try some other place. read more

Went to Anatolia last week and my experience was great! Food and service was exceptional. Prices were reasonable and the quality of the food was pretty amazing! We ordered 2 different appetizers and 4 main courses and 2 desserts. And we also had complimentary turkish tea. Each dish was very flavorful and fresh. Only disappointment was the kunefe, it was a bit cold and the cheese was not "melty" at all, kind of like a cold cheese in the middle. Overall, I highly recommend this place! 10/10 read more

See all

I can't believe I just discovered this restaurant. Let me just start off by saying the service here is 10/10. The servers (especially Valentina) were SO sweet, accommodating and attentive. Anytime we needed anything she was there with a smile. We came here to celebrate my sister's birthday and they even brought out a dessert and sang happy birthday to her before I even asked! My sister was so happy and felt so special. On to the food: DELICIOUS. We ordered a few dishes of lamb doner, lamb adana, chicken adana, and mantu. Everything was so flavorful. They also gave us naan to start and it was so fresh and crispy. Honestly the best Turkish food I've had here in the US--all of us were genuinely impressed. Also, the portions were great. Left full and satisfied. Staff were all gloved and wearing masks, and they also offered us hand sanitizer. We felt very comfortable dining indoors seeing their safety protocols. I absolutely will be back here! Hope they keep up their stellar service. read more

Anatolia - Lamb doner gyro, mantu, chicken adana - Mediterranean Near Me - West Hempstead, New York

Flavorful and good portions! The lamb doner hands down was delish and didn't need any sauce. The homemade bread was fresh light compared to eating it with a pita. The pizza was great but I would have love some more tomato. read more

See all

I was going to post a google review but then I realized that the owner is going off on people who don't agree with the quality of his food, so I decided to Yelp instead. Food isn't bad, servers are super nice, mezes (appetizers) are delicious but the lahmacun is horrendous though. I grew up eating lahmacun and it's probably my favorite thing to eat. We ordered about $70.00 worth of food back in November and threw out the 6 lahmacuns we purchased unfortunately, I'm a person who HATES to waste food, I grew up better than that. Please fix your lahmacun's crust as well as its filling, because after having such good appetizers, the lahmacun just really really let me down. My husband back in November convinced me NOT to write a review, but ever since I saw those google reviews I decided to bring my truth. We like to support small businesses, and especially those who are in our communities, but this doesn't mean they're exempt from the truth. People leave reviews to better your business, not to bring hatred to it, if someone disagrees with the way something is being cooked, you remain a gentlemen and respect their opinion, the hardest part but the most telling part of being an owner. read more

Great place! I randomly stopped here and I am glad I did. I was seated right away, service was great food was amazing. I will definitely come back! read more

I had high hopes for this place, when you walked in the place looks good and gave night club vibe. it should have set off warning bells when this place was empty during lunch time, but I continued. we order the chicken shish and chicken chop with two appetizer. The wait time wasn't bad at all food came out we thank the service and took the food to go. we got to the car and dug into the bags. My order of chicken chop had a single small chicken thigh over a little Bed of rice that didn't fill the container. one of the two side that came with the meal was weak salad no dressing. The most egregious thing was the COLD mashed potatoes that tasted like it was left open in the fridge. The second order I got which was the chicken shish, had exactly 5 pieces of nugget size chicken bites with a little bit of rice and the same side cold mashed potatoes and weak salad. Overall the food wasn't anything special and was way too overpriced for the amount food given. I would recommend this place to people who have too much money and not enough ways to spend, and done mind getting mid food for it. read more

We had a wonderful time celebrating birthday in a private area. Food was delicious. Portions were big. Service was excellent. Highly recommend this restaurant. read more

So I ordered some food from this place around 7:10pm. It's currently 9:13 PM and the food still hasn't arrived. So I learned if you order through DoorDash, this place delivers their own food!! So they have the option to accept your order but not deliver it! And guess what? You can't complain to DoorDash! Everything gets routed to them! They actually put that they delivered the food and stole the money. THIS SCAM Restaurant STOLE the money!! Kept the food and probably sold it to someone else. read more

Anatolia - My order from DoorDash that they accepted and said they delivered. Smh - Mediterranean Near Me - West Hempstead, New York

Absolutely horrendous customer service. I was charged for food that wasn't provided! Be mindful of your bill. The host I spoke to said the owner would reach out, but he never did. I'm still waiting to hear back... Will update here if I hear back from them. Horrendous behavior! read more

I ordered lunch through Uber eats. I had the baba ganoush which was way too salty, but the rest of the food was excellent. Delicious and soft pita. The Lamb doner was perfectly cooked and the pita was stuffed! Baklava was amazing read more

A hidden gem. Tonight we started with an order of falafel with hummus. The falafel was delicious and the hummus was nicely spiced. I had the chicken shish kebab plate with salad and white rice. The chicken was moist tender and delicious. My wife had chicken Adana with bulger and roasted vegetables. There are so many tempting dishes on the menu, yet we continue to order our favorites because they are so good. They have an eggplant with tomato appetizer which comes spicy but you can order it mild - again delicious. I'm gluten free so the Kazandibi custard makes a great dessert to share! It is a little off the beaten path, and it has its own brightly lit parking lot. People are catching on to this flavorful spot, but you can still easily get a table on a Friday night. read more

Ordered almost $80 worth of food for myself and family this evening . Spoke to a woman to get delivery info so we can stand outside for their driver-it was dark out and wanted to assist them in finding our house number. She aggressively replied with, "what do you want? whats wrong with the order?" After I re-explained why I called she said "he's on the way already". I decided to just leave it as is. Halfway through eating our fish we noticed this at the bottom of the take out tin. There are still some labels that contain barcodes that will still have BPA (a carcinogen) on them. (You're probably thinking-'you're ordering takeout, you're worried about the health risks of a label being present in your food?' Well yeah, one is a health-conscious made decision and the other is following basic public health policy.) In addition, the bread was stale and the other items we ordered were dry according to family members who ate it. The kunefe was pretty good though! Probably the best I've had on Long Island. Makes me miss home! read more

Anatolia - Torn and wet label in serving tray - Mediterranean Near Me - West Hempstead, New York

See all

bad service the food is good but their delivery service sucks. I ordered through Uber eats but they don't use Uber delivery service they have their own and they suck. ordered and 2 hours later they still did not deliver I cancele the order and was still charged $29.00 cancellation fee. read more

Went for dinner this evening and everything we ordered was AMAZING!! We started with the hummus/falafel and fries. Their house bread was fresh and warm--so good! I got the chicken adana/chicken shish platter with brown rice--wow! It was probably the best Turkish meal I've ever had. Each bite packed so much flavor. My bf got the falafel sandwich and my mom got the grilled salmon--both of them loved their meals as well. We then ended our meal with the baklava, rice pudding, Turkish coffee and tea--all delish! So happy we found this place. Jay our waiter gave us the best service and was really nice. We will be back again soon! read more

Service was great. Ambiance was welcoming but seatings were for larger settings. All workers were great. Food came

Do not waste your money and eat here. They scam you and overcharge you on your bill. Their customer service lacks empathy and urgency for customers. Their food portions are extremely small compared to what they charge you. Although the ambiance looks nice but not worth the amount you spend here. read more

Food is great. First time ordering and with all the miscommunications of Uber eats, I would still say... great good. The mixed appetizer platter was delicious with their home made bread. Their mixed grill was perfectly grilled and allowed us to try different meats in one selection. The lentil soup was okay. If this place wasn't so far, I would definitely order them often. read more

The Anatolia Special Mix is def worth the $30! Consisting of lamb shish, lamb Adana, 1 lamb chop, chicken Adana and chicken shish. A lot of meat!! Only complaint is that the lamb shish was a little over cooked and hence dry. We ordered white rice but ended up getting bulger rice which was ok. Wish I had actually gotten the white rice. Salad was decent. The meat was definitely the star of the platter. Wish they gave a grilled onion instead of tomato. Chicken shish was 10/10 super juicy and flavorful read more

Anatolia - Anatolia Special Mix - Mediterranean Near Me - West Hempstead, New York

The food was good. My only complaint is the overcharging! We went there for dinner; We ordered the Lahmucun ($10) on the menu ($14 charge on my check) the mixed appetizer it says $18.95, I was charged $22.95! I wish I can have a logical answer! Gratuity was included and I am certainly ok with that but overcharging customers is not the best way to build a good reputation! read more

Excellent food and service. The lamb doner was amazing. Thank you Osma for a wonderful experience! We will definitely be back. read more

Anatolia - Lamb Doner - Mediterranean Near Me - West Hempstead, New York

Had a great time. Very nice decor and ambiance, spacious restaurant. Friendly service. Food was overall excellent, didn't take much time to get ready. Started us off with some really warm, soft turkish pita. Ordered the Lahmacun, Mix Grill and Mix Pie. Mix Grill and Mix Pie (essentially turkish pizza) were on point, flavorful, not overly greasy. I could have done without the Lahmacun which was just ok, but didn't have much flavor. Ended things off with knafeh, which was great, and turkish tea which is a must have. Would go back again! read more

got delivery via grubhub, chicken shish pita, feta, kunefe, and chix soup; the chix shish pita was awful! the chix very rubbery and the pita u couldn't even hold without it falling apart-threw most of it away-so damp- waste of money side of feta and kunefe were yummy although kunefe is traditionally topped with pistachio not walnuts in my experience likely would not order again read more

Anatolia - chix shish sandwich or just mush, no white sauce or flavor! - Mediterranean Near Me - West Hempstead, New York

See all

Came here for the first time tonight and the food was amazing. Jay was our server he was great. Friendly staff good food great atmosphere. Would definitely come back here soon! read more

Best Turkish cuisine in Long Island! Wonderful, fresh and delicious Mediterranean food. Service was Impecable and friendly. Will be back again soon. read more

Anatolia - Mediterranean Near Me - West Hempstead, New York

See all

Ordered a couple of dinners and soup for Uber delivery. The special mix dinner was over $30 and a chicken shish kabob dinner was $21+. I ordered two different types of rice and hummus on the side. The portion sizes were very small and we were missing a rice and hummus. Uber Eats does not take responsibility and despite two attempts at contacting the restaurant, there was no resolution. The food was relatively tasty but based on missing items and the small size of the portions, given the price, I would not recommend. read more

I love Anatolia turkish grilled chicken close to authentic flavor. I say this because I have live in an arab country and this is the close I can get. read more

I really like the food and customer service, Aleyna was outstanding in her service. fantastic area nearby to my home. I highly recommend this place. read more

See all

Really good, I mean really really good Turkish food. I like to stop here for Turkish breakfast occasionally as well as getting some doner sandwiches or doner platters. Have not gotten the chance to eat at the restaurant but will definitely try to soon. read more

Wow Anatolia caught us by surprise tonight! We went for iftar and each dish that we ordered came out better than the next! Highly recommend! The vibes and aesthetics of the restaurant reminds me of my recent travels to Istanbul. read more

See all

Hidden gem. Went in for a quick bite but ended up staying there for 2 hours. Exceptional service and amazing food. Perfect for large parties. Definitely going back. read more

If it was possible to give no stars, I would. Firstly, they claimed that they had no white rice at 7:30 pm on a Saturday and didn't bother to tell us when we ordered. Instead, they brought our food to the table with brown rice and waited for us to point out that we had ordered white rice and, only after returning to the kitchen to change the rice, returned to the table to ridiculously advise that they had run out of white rice. Before that, they had only brought out one of the two appetizers we had ordered. When I pointed out how absurd it was for a restaurant to claim that is had run out of a staple such as rice. The owner apparently operates in a shoestring and didn't possess enough business sense to come to our table to apologize. The only saving grace was the waitress, who was nothing but charming and professional under such trying conditions. read more

Anatolia - Mediterranean Near Me - West Hempstead, New York

See all