I've lived just down the road from Amores for the past five years, and unfortunately, over the last two to two-and-a-half years, the quality and consistency of the food has steadily declined. What was once one of our go-to spots has become a repeated disappointment. I want to be clear that the front-of-house service has always been excellent. One of the longtime managers, who has been there as long as I've lived in the area, is consistently friendly, outgoing, helpful, and professional. Unfortunately, great customer service can only do so much when the food quality continues to suffer. We've received credits multiple times for poor-quality orders, but at this point, we no longer want credits--we simply won't be ordering again. Our most recent order was the final straw. The pizza crust was extremely soggy, likely from sitting too long while other items were being prepared. The toppings slid right off when we picked up a slice. The calzone was leaking greasy liquid, and the marinara sauce, which I once raved about, was acidic, bland, and lacking the flavor it used to have. After discussing it as a family, we all agreed that the food has become consistently bland, low-quality, and unappetizing. It's frustrating to spend $30-$50 on dinner for a family of three only to regret the purchase every time. I genuinely believe better training, stronger oversight, and a renewed focus on quality could make a significant difference. It's disappointing because Amores used to serve consistently great food. As a longtime local customer, I'm saddened to see how far the quality has fallen. read more

Their pizza is the BEST. Friendly staff, great garlic knots, and the atmosphere is nice. I highly recommend this place.

This is not a very good pizza place. They serve slices by having cooked cheese slices sit around. Then they microwave whatever toppings/ingredients you order, plop them on top, and put the slices in the oven. The sauce is pretty bland. The cheese tastes old. And the slices are small. For two slices and an iced tea it was $8. Not an unreasonable price.... If it was tasty. It wasn't. The slices looked sad. I took two bites and then tossed them right in the garbage. The cashier saw me do it and didn't seem surprised. The staff is courteous but dim.... Not their fault. They're kids. If you're really hungry and cannot drive a mile down the road... I GUESS this place could do the trick. Maybe. The atmosphere is bland an forgettable. They have tables but you don't really wanna sit here. It's within walking distance of the high-school. You'd think they'd do a better job here. Oh well. I won't go back. You probably shouldn't bother either. There are a bunch of way better places nearby. read more

Best pizza in the area no doubt. NY style. Great sauce. But recommend no toppings for single slices. They add the toppings to a plane cheese slice then heat it. read more

Best pizza in the area and staff is very friendly! Highly Recommend, you won't be disappointed!

this review is only in their pizza. being a true pizza lover, i need to try pizza where i visit. Yet it's very hard to find good pizza outside of the ny metro area. I have to say Amore Pizza serves one delicious pizza. First off the place was clean, and the staff was very friendly. There were five of so we ordered two pies. one was just as good as the other. i'll be returning read more

Let me start this by saying Amore has excellent food. Their pizza & wings are seriously one of the best in the area and the staff is friendly. We order on nights we are both getting home around dinner time (not much time to cook) but delivery is almost always over 45 mins and it's cold when it arrives despite us being less than a mile away. I would say around the 4th time receiving cold food (I'm not talking stone cold food, but you can absolutely tell it's sat there) we, unfortunately, decided to go with another pizza place that's double the distance with not as good pizza because it's always hot when it gets to us. It sucks to feel like I have to give this place under 5 stars, but when deliverable food is the reason you contact the restaurant, you want it to at the least be warm when it gets to you. read more

I'm giving you guys 2 stars not because of the pizza. Pizza is pretty good. I live 7 minutes from you guys in QB and you don't deliver in my area which I found out when the driver arrived. GPS says 3.7 miles away! How do you guys find new customers? I'm new customer and this is a complete bummer honestly. Its weird enough when you go there are no pizzas to display on counter. Its an awkward pizza counter for sure. read more

Amore Pizza is a staple in our household, once a month we get to order food, and every single time, we choose amore's without fail. the service is absolutely wonderful, always incredibly friendly and quick, not to mention the quality of the food which my younger siblings and i would literally kill for. if you're looking for a great pizza joint, this is 100% the place you need to go :) read more

Cheese pie is ok, but if you get toppings they don't put many toppings on it at all. Wings are also very rubbery.

I'm from Western NY and saw Tomato Pie on their menu so I was anxious to try it. Don't see it much around here. be sure to order specify Sicilian style or they'll give you a thin crust. It is very good. Light and airy, not greasy, but I remember tomatoe pie as being a very moist, almost creamy dough. The sauce is delicious and just enough Romano cheese. Very good read more

If you're going to charge twelve bucks for a sub would you please put more than two slices of ham on it. REALLY!!

22 dollars for two sodas a large cheese pizza and 10 wings. Soda from fountain was okay Pizza was good Wings were good Everything was as expected from your hometown pizza restaurant. If your looking for a place for some good pizza at a decent price, this is a good stop. read more

Didn't realize at the time that I ordered 3 slices of cheese pizza and was charged $17. A large cheese pizza (8 slices) is $14. WTH Amore?! Got me once, shame on me! read more

Great pizza...order it well done! Mediocre subs. Bad wings. Not what you expected in Upstate NY? Me either. But that's what you get. If you're in range, this is where you should be getting pizza....no excuses. read more

One of our favorite places to order pizza in the area. We've tried several places and so far no one can beat them. We haven't ordered anything else yet but so far it's our go to pizza place. read more

I ordered 2 pizzas for dinner the other day they must have ran out of cheese because it was hardly any on the pizza very disappointed for the price read more

I ordered a pizza for delivery at 8 pm I was told it would be delivered in 30 min. But 45 min went by and no delivery. I called and was told they don't deliver here so it was running late. I told them they delivered next door yesterday. They then told us that they only deliver in a 3 miles radius. I live 3.3 miles away from store. They have good food but bad service . and when we placed order they said nothing about not delivering to us. They took our address and everything. They didn't even have the courtesy to call us and explain why. A young man showed up at 913 pm with cold food. We sent it back. Very upset with this extremely bad service. Not worth buying..... read more

We ordered on Sunday the 26th of January we ordered a cheese pizza a meatball parm sub garlic knots we picked up our order. The pizza had very little cheese on it I almost would have though it was 2 days old. Very disappointing won't be ordering again. read more

This my go to pizza shop Great wings my brother from long island says they are worth the trip. read more

My family and I always order food from Amore, and we never have been disappointed! Pizza, wings, subs, salads - all always great! Staff is very friendly as well and they are super quick with delivery. read more

I love this place! It's nothing fancy but it hits the spot. The pizza is good but I love the subs. I recommend getting the full so you can eat half for dinner and have the other half for lunch the next day. The calzones are massive btw and taste great. I always go here with my friends for lunch in the summer and it never disappoints! read more

Pizza was good the first time I ever ordered, but customer service was terrible. The person answering the phone and then at the counter was very rude. Gave it another chance, second time customer service improved, pizza was good, but wings were bad. Third shot, and probably final was a delivery order. I live within 10 miles and when the pizza was delivered it was cold, so disappointing. read more

I'm giving 5 stars because I've been frequenting this place since I've arrived to town for close to a month now. They've been under the same ownership for 25 years so they're apparently doing something right!!! I love their New York style pizza - it's spot on every time. I almost always order the Chef's Salad to go along with a side of meatballs. Turns into two meals for me. I've also ordered a few of their hot subs. So in a nutshell, after eating here or ordering take out I have yet to experience any disappointments. Amore's isn't anything fancy - just your friendly neighborhood pizzeria. I'll definitely continue to support them while in town for the summer! read more

Service is good. Other than that the food is bland over prized and small portions for what you pay. They only have cheese slices premade and add the toppings before they heat it up. read more

Ordered two slices, took forever, tasted like they had been sitting there all day then heated up way too hot to try and hide the fact that they should have been thrown away hours ago. Very disappointing, this place used to be awesome. read more

Friday Pizza Night! Need we say more? Amore' never fails to meet the needs of our hungry family each and every Friday. Kids, grandkids, friends and neighbors all enjoy the food and watching for "the pizza guy". Paying for the delivery has become a right of passage for the lil' kids. Thanks for being there! read more

Very chewy pizza crust,ordered extra crispy wing hot,they came soggy and mild. Average pizza for glens falls area. read more

Best pizza in upstate New York

Bought a meatball sub yesterday and it was cruel. the meatballs seemed to be not homemade tasteless and taken out of refg. heated and cause on top terrible. the way i know meatballs put in cause until served to absorb flavor. it was again terrible I have ordered from other restraints and they put meatballs in sause. I will say the pizzas are great not subs. read more

If you're longing for a slice of pizza like they make on Long Island or the five boroughs, Amore delivers. I usually stop at two slices but went for the third. read more

Great pizza and wings! The pizza was delicious and the wings were nice and juicy. The delivery was timely and the staff is very friendly! Have only know about this place for a couple weeks and have ordered food at least 5 time! I highly recommend! read more

The pizza was great! The crust simply delicious and flaky. The pizza sauce was just the right taste. Will be back again. Nice employees with always a smile. read more

Bland, overcooked pizza and stale sub rolls is not my idea of a good meal. The prices are a bit steep to boot. The atmosphere of the place looked tense so I can say I'm not coming back for sure. read more

Pizza is ok, service ok, and that is all... "Garden salads" are literally a LARGE base of lettuce and 2 THIN slices of tomatoes and a large quantity of THINLY sliced onions.All of there salads are like this throw on a FEW other crappy toppings and that explains it. They need to step it up. Wings are sub par.. They are EXTREMELY expensive for what you get. With the Tavern right next door go there..Possibly the only thing keeping them going is they deliver and they jacked their prices to compensate... read more

very good pie. top 3 pizzas in upstate ny. i know having worked all over northern ny and eating at every pizza shop along the way for over 20 years! thats a lot of pizza and i still "love" going back to Amore! read more