Kind of a hole in a wall place. Nothing fancy but good food, friendly service, clean and comfortable. We ordered chicken cheesesteak and cheese burger. We added mushrooms and fried onion to our orders. The fries were lightly breaded, very nice. Burger has two patties by default, delicious. Chicken cheesesteak was good too, lots of chicken and cheese. The whole thing was like $16. read more

See all

Ordered a Medium Pizza for Pick-up. Did not immediately notice the box wasn't as hot as it should have been. When I got home (around the corner) the pizza was cool, cheese was hard and had already turned from bright to dull yellow. I called and had no problem having them acknowledge the pizza was bad, should not have been allowed to leave the premises. I was promised a FREE PIZZA, now the Store Manager will not honor it...... THIS IS NOT ONLY THE INTEGRITY OF FOOD, BUT ALSO THOSE WHO PROVIDE IT.....WHAT OTHER "SHORT-CUTS ARE TAKEN??? I am a senior citizen, retired veteran, I was Basically Scammed...... read more

Look at the rewards program. It is not what it says it is. Instead of a ten dollar credit after $100.00 you actually receive 10% off your next oder and only get $10 if your order is $100.00 or more. TOTAL LIE. READ THE RULES POSTED! read more

Best pizza around. Their pizza has that old fashion taste and the staff is always courteous

I have never tried Amore pizza but always heard it was the best in DE. Last night I was at Autumn Arch Brewery and decided to place an order for delivery. when I asked The person taking the order if they knew where AAB was she replied "yes", so I did not give an address. 45-60 for delivery. No problem. Over an hour later, the delivery driver calls me telling me he's at 674 Pencader drive and can't find the brewery. I then gave him the address (810 Pencader drive And told him it literally 1/4 mile down the road on the right, just before the light at Pleasant Valley rd. "ok" he says. 10 minutes later he calls back. Tells me he's at 801 Pencader Drive. This goes on and on. Not only did I not get my pizza, I never even saw this guy! I finally Called Amore and cancelled the order and had my card refunded. The girl I spoke to told me they were having a problem with that driver ( no kidding) and were sending another driver to find him. WTF? I drove to Wawa and got something to eat and just fit the fun of I put the address of AAB in my GPS and what do you know? It took me right to 810 Pencader Drive. Maybe it was Door Dash or Uber eats, but come on, screen your people. it can't be that hard. anyway, the experience has made me decide to stick with Amalfi. They have the best pizza anyway. I won't go out of my way for Amore. I might not even try it if I'm passing by. Ridiculous. read more

Small whole in the wall with barely there service. Grab what you need and go. Pizza is good enough for me to return. read more

See all

944th different cheesesteak eaten in the last 4 years. This cheesesteak had a great old school pizza shop old grill baked in oily onion flavor. It ate well. That's the good news. The roll was big and bready. It needed more cheese and better cheese melt. I didn't like $12.99. read more

See all

This place used to be good... The building is falling apart and it's dirty. The wings are so-so, the pizzas are overpriced, and the burgers are made with low quality meat. I hope they turn it around because they're close, and used to be one of my go-to's. read more

Food has fallen off and there delivery service sucks! When I called in the employee on the phone with me was very rude and could care less about my order read more

First time trying, OMG I don't regret it!!!, Pizza is amazing. If they did stuff crust, I wouldn't bother with Pizza Hut . Lol I got the XL Hawaii with 10 wings for $32. Domino's & Pizza Hut was charging $10 more for this order. I definitely will return read more

Amore Pizza - XL Hawaii, Slices are Big, I only had 2 slices, - Pizza Near Me - Newark, Delaware

Service is always nice but I do think they either changed the recipes or just have a cook that does not care about the quality of the food. I ordered a chicken quesadilla and I'm sorry I wouldn't do that again. Chicken had no flavor and it looked like it was just thrown in the box. Their pizza it's ok but it use to be so good again could be a change in recipes or cooks. Still order from here simply for the convenience now. Kinda sad bc this was a good place for a while. read more

I asked to be notified when my pizza was delivered but no, they just dropped it on the ground like trash and never notified me of delivery. If they had rung my doorbell and handed it to me, they would have got a nice tip. As it is, I don't tip for food that was placed on the ground and forgotten about. I wil NEVER ORDER FROM THIS PLACE AGAIN!!!!! read more

Hello my fellow Yelpers, I have a FRAUD ALERT!! Last night my wife ordered a Stromboli from this place online and picked it up. When she got home she noticed that they added a 20% tip that was unauthorized. and my wife is burnt right now because she should not have been charged a 20% tip without her knowledge. even though they have a good pizza but still be charged without authorization that is very very bad. FYI if you buy a pizza from this place make sure you pay in cash. amore's pizza get two thumbs down read more

This place has been amazing sense I was a 10 and I'm an 34 yr old adult now! Consistently the best in the whole area! Please come to Middletown read more

Bitter disappointment. There is nothing to love about the delivery order I received. A cheesesteak that was ordered with extra provolone came with barely any. The steak itself Had hardly any meat, was on a stale roll and extraordinarily dry. read more

Amore Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Newark, Delaware

We have been ordering from Amore for over two decades. They have great food and great specials. The meatball pizza is a lot of my friend's favorite pizza. The 2 slice and soda combo is great. $5 for 2 big slices of pizza and a fountain drink is my son's go to. You can't go wrong with the chicken cheesesteak specials $5 for a cheesesteak and my favorite fries. They also carry milk and some other pretty random items that come in handy for me because it saves me a stop when I'm on the way home. read more

Quick service, big portions, great taste. Best local pizza shop around! Burgers are also excellent choice.

I have been getting Amore's pizza since I was probably 5 years old. It's always been my go-to, favorite pizza ever. Goes above any other pizza places in my opinion. Their single slices are enormous and the french fries are always nice and crispy. read more

We love Amore! We tend to order from here every Friday night. We frequently order the white special with ricotta and the chipotle wings. Man alive they are the best tasting wings and pizza in Delaware. The online ordering is simple and fast. The delivery is always 25 minutes faster than they say they will be. read more

I like this place. Small spot but lots to offer on their menu. The manager makes sure everyone is on top of getting orders out and getting them right. He's always friendly when he delivers orders as well. Their ingredients are fresh. The importance of supporting small business in our communities is important now more than ever. This is one small business I recommended to do so. read more

Not sure why people haven't raved about this place on here! You walk in, and they greet you and the smell is lovely! Like city pizza! Pizza is amazing & cheese fries too! Prices are so low as well! My go-to pizza place for sure! read more

Amore Pizza - Cheese fries soo yummmyyy - Pizza Near Me - Newark, Delaware

Not only did I see a rat in the corner of this establishment. The two people at the front are rude as hell and display no customer service skills. read more

Order an Extra Large if you want a large!!! So this place was around the corner, but non of us had an available car to pick it up. With that said, Our Pizza was delivered warm and tasty. Cheesy, which I like. I have no complaints, however I'm not on my way back to DE for some pizza. It was very satisfying. My one issue though is that the pies run small. The large pies are equivalent to your typical medium sized pizza. Which came up to $19 and change. I ordered this as a pre-new year's gathering "snack" in addition to the other food. I wish I knew I needed to order an Extra large! Oh well!!! read more

Really good pizza at a great price! Always an easy go to in the neighborhood for its many fresh and reasonably price options. Staff is friendly too. read more

Amore Pizza - 10" pizza for $7 very good - Pizza Near Me - Newark, Delaware

See all

This place has the freshest ingredients and you can't beat their daily specials. The cheese steak special is what I usually order and it's always fresh veggies with no gristle in the steak like most places. They also offer a extra large pizza which is only a few more cent more than the large. The pizza slices are extra big. You have to call ahead to order. read more

The food is downright delicious. The staff is welcoming and friendly and make the process of ordering food easy. 10/10 would eat there again read more

See all

It's was OK but my girlfriend had the BG's, I mean her butt keep having to go the bathroom. She was just straight dumping yo like she was the queen dumper. I was OK. The food did a little number on me. We had cheese pizza and pepperoni pizza but she must of had a "I gotta let my booty evacuate" Pizza. The pizza was good was fairly hot, but my girlfriend was hot because she keep emptying her booty butt. The dough was a bit to doughy would recommend cooked longer, but not longer than my girlfriend was in the bathroom " She was taking lots of poops". So eat at your risk you could end up like my leaking bum bum girlfriend. read more

Great pizza that reminds me of NYC. Really great people who know how to support community.

To date have not found any place in Delaware that makes a 'Great' pizza. That being said we've exhausted our search in the Middletown area thought we would try Newark / Bear area.. Reviews for Amore seemed promising so we drove the 30+ minutes for a pie. Ordered half Pepperoni and Half Sausage, Green Pepper, and Mushroom. First look seemed promising though I think could have used just a tad more Pepperoni. Immediately noticed the Sausage, well, looked like "Kibbel and Bits" type. Crust was nice unfortunately was overly cooked on the bottom.. not burnt, but extremely brown. Taste included generous portion of real cheese which was a plus. This came with just he right amount of Sauce. Pepperoni slice was fine, but there is a definite salty taste to the outer crust and the brown bottom influenced the overall taste as well. In regards to the other side if your going to put sausage on a pie use real sausage.. maybe something like a fennel pork sausage. In general the toppings were generous. Wouldn't go out of my way to go there again but if I was local I'd put it in the rotation as it were. read more

This is probably my second favorite pizza place in the area for one simple reason, cheese! They use the best cheese I've tasted in a pizza and it is what has me ordering from there when I get in the mood for that cheese taste. Clearly I am a fan of their cheese, which covers many items on the menu, what about the other factors of a good pizza place? Well all in all their menu is tasty, I just prefer the sauce at Ciaos a little more (heaven if they merged). The customer service is friendly and efficient. Deliveries I have had are on time and accurate. For me it's a toss up between Ciaos and here, but Ciaos usually wins based on I'm usually more of a sauce guy, if your a big cheese lover though, the scales may tip in Amore's favor for you. read more

I stop here a lot for antipasto salad which is huge and really, really good. It is Lettuce, Tomatoes, Onions, Cucumbers, Green Peppers, Hard Boiled Egg, Provolone, Ham, Salami, Cappicola, Pepperoni and Anchovies and comes with garlic bread (I get it without anchovies). I have also had their Cranberry pecan chicken salad which is Spring Mix, Cranberries, Pecans and Chicken. I have had the italian hoagie. It was ok, but I would only order that if it was a hoagie emergency and a real sub shop wasn't open. Their plain cheese and pepperoni pizzas are fantastic, as well as the meat lover Pizza Sauce, Cheese, Ham, Bacon, Sausage and Meatballs, and the white veggie Cheese, Tomato, Black Olives, Broccoli, Fresh Garlic, Onions, Green Peppers and Mushrooms, and the Veggie Pizza Sauce, Cheese, Tomato, Black Olives, Broccoli, Fresh Garlic, Onions, Green Peppers and Mushrooms. read more

We order there about once a month. The steak calzone with mushrooms is really good, ordered it several times. we also like the steak fries. Didn't read the description so didn't realize it was fries with cheesesteak toppings and gravy but was pleasantly surprised. The Amore turkey is my favorite item. The wings were soggy so won't order them again. Wished they had calamari. read more

How hard is it to make a good, no, decent at best, pizza? Really...someone explain it to me. Make a simple crust, put on some toppings and bake...how FREAKING hard is this? I decided on this place, because it was close and supposedly not chain pizza. I had it picked up to save any issues in transport, no such luck. There was so much cheese on it the bottom crust was soggy, so much so I couldn't even put it in the oven to crisp it. Now, I can eat plates of cheese, but this was ridiculous...there was so much cheese, parts of the pizza looked as if the cheese hadn't even melted all the way. Save your money, this place is horrendous...and the teenie bopper answering the phone has definitely smoked all her brain cells. read more

Ok. Maybe not the most authentic New York style pizza in Delaware, but truly not bad at all. It's worth asking for extra sauce, though. Easy online ordering, fast delivery, and one cool online feature most stores don't offer -- the ability to request extras like paper plates, utensils, etc. Skip the seafood -- it's frozen, heavily breaded and fried. The subs are small but fresh. Sadly, they only offer one size in their special. With Capriotto and Casapula locations so close, Amore needs to step up the hoagies to compete. The Bear/Red Lion location, in particular, is run by two really cool brothers. A little hard to find, it's worth finding. The owners recently unveiled something new they created called Toasties. Sound like Grinders; could be interesting. We'll try them soon and let you know. read more

These guys are amazing. No other way to describe it. Any of their specialty pizzas should scratch any itch you need, and their online ordering is pretty convenient to boot. Anyone who loves buffalo stuff should try the Buffalo Chicken Pizza. The carb coma will be totally worth it. read more

There is a term called "regression to the mean". While more commonly used in statistics lectures it does have a place in eating out. Remember when you ate at a place and the food was awesome, then next time good, then finally just average? Over time eating at a place will tend to get you to an average feeling about the food and the place. i have eaten at Amore Pizza multiple times since my first review over a year ago. Since then my opinion of Amore Pizza has settled into an average of 4 stars. The pizza remains one of my favorites for all the reasons I have mentioned in my original review. They continue to rate 4 stars each time I eat there and I enjoy eating their pizza. read more

My boyfriend insisted this place had good pizza, but I guess things have gone downhill recently. I think I would have rather had Dominoes. Food was literally cold by the time it got to us. The medium pizza was what I would expect a small pizza to be. The mozzarella sticks were something you would get at a school cafeteria (I didn't know it was possible for mozzarella stocks to be gross). read more

Very reasonable prices for the amount of food you get. Love the chicken bites and broccoli bites. Pizza always has good amount of toppings. Good service too. read more

Thank you Amore pizza on old Baltimore pike for making it's EASIER to NOT choose you or your establishment ever! Not for lunch delivery (or pick up for that matter or if driving by on the way home, or to a friends house, or to a baseball game ... so anywhere) for not using you for office catering, here, or NOT using you for our OTHER location super close to you with 50 employees.... for NOT reccomending you to anyone.. did I mention the over 100 employees who also have friends, and businesses and needs and events... thank you for being rude to my co-worker and telling her to "never order again because it's too far" (those 4.7 miles must be hard on you) thank you for making sure we NEVER have to include you in a choice of where to order. THANK YOU !! One less choice. It MUST be amazing that you have sooooo much business you don't need any of ours.... don't worry I'll pass it on.... read more

When they're good, they're REALLY good! But when they're not, the food is just average. It's surprising that a place that's been open for so long would have a problem with "food taste consistency" but here you go. Everytime I go here I feel like I'm gambling! When they do it right though I really like their cheesesteaks, chicken cheesesteaks, fries, and gyro platters. My family in general is a fan of their pizza as well, but for me personally I prefer pizzas with crispier crusts. read more