Excellent cheesesteaks. Good service Yummmy and fair priced Great lunch spot or takeout dinner read more

Nice little dive spot, I spotted in here while on break for work and it was great. the food was greatly priced and it was served fast. We got a large pizza half cheese half mushrooms because my coworker is a psychopath lol and a side of fries. New York style pizza was great it was exactly what I was looking for. Nice workers and I enjoy the non-corporate minimalist decorations it's refreshing. 9/10 will come back next time I'm in town read more

Little Anthony's Pizza - Large cheese and mushroom pizza and side of fries - Pizza Near Me - New Castle, Delaware

There's nothing there that I ordered that I didn't enjoy. When I'm in the area I always stop to have my slice or hot sandwiches

Little Anthony's is tucked into the corner of a shopping center. They seem to be very a "no nonsense" older generation but very friendly. The staff does prefer you to pay with cash (if you can)! I got a tuna salad and it was HUGE. Enough for multiple meals. The tuna had good flavor and it came with extra dressing. You can dine in or take out, good spot! read more

See all

Went here for the first time and ordered two slices of pizza. The pizza was delicious and reminded me of NY thin crust style pizza. The decor is dated but I had no problem dining in. I will definitely be back. read more

A couple weeks back I was with some Neighbors and we had Little Anthony's Pizza for dinner. Excellent pizza pies! Great tasting, looks appealing, well cooked, heartily eaten with no leftovers. That was a bummer but we all ate well, and the pizza really was a crowd pleaser! ‼ read more

i love little anthony's. this is the only place i get my cheese steaks from. Pricing is decent ! they always have soft bread not soggy bread. it's always fresh and pleasant to walk in the establishment. read more

I ordered two large extra cheese pizza's one with pepperoni, & it was absolutely horrible. They refused to remake or give me a refund. Manager stated it wasn't his problem. read more

Little Anthony's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - New Castle, Delaware

See all

Little Anthony's may look like a hole in the wall pizza place in a strip mall but they have some really great food. White pizza is amazing, sometimes pizza can appear a little greasy but the taste is superior to a lot of pizza places in the area. The crust is worth eating and reminds me of the NY style pizza. They make great cheese steaks and mozzarella sticks as well. I usually don't get their fries because they are just mid to me. The stromboli is pretty good here. It's the closest food to the pizza place we loved (Pizza City in Mayfair) when we lived in NE Philly. Staff used to sound a bit rough/rushed on the phone when placing your order. They now have more staff to answer and that was a good addition. This is a place you should know what you want before calling! They are always busy and the wait time sometimes is longer than told on the phone. Parking is abundant and you can get a spot in front of the place. You can eat in but we never have. There are plastic booths and chairs in the back but I never see anyone in there. They take Apple Pay. Definitely a place to check out for a fresh made pizza with good crust/sauce ratio. read more

Best pizza in New castle, prices are reasonable and food is amazing can't go wrong going there

Awesome. Felt like I just joined an Italian family! Delicious, personal, will return!

Great place for grab and go slices of pizza. The restaurant is family owned and has been in the area for years. Restaurant also serves, cheesesteaks, subs and other pasta dishes. Be prepared to wait a little if you go during lunch hours. Located in a shopping plaza, there is plenty of parking. read more

Little Anthony's Pizza - Pizza slices - Pizza Near Me - New Castle, Delaware

See all

Nice, pleasant and attentive staff every time I visit. The pizza is excellent. The new dessert choices are very good as well. read more

Excellent Sicilian pizza. I couldn't believe how heavy the box was when I picked it up. So good

I purchased 7 pizzas at Little Anthony's to donate to our wonderful Christiana Fire Company for their dedication and service to our community a few weeks ago. The pizzas were ready on time and they brought them out to the car! Everything was excellent! read more

Little Anthony's has good pizza and Eggplant sandwiches. I was happy when we visited here last summer. We ordered a Pepperoni pizza, and it was good. I also tried the eggplant sandwiches, and they were better than i thought they were going to taste. Place is cheap in price, nothing over priced. People are cool here and friendly. Ill be back for more. read more

The wait staff seats you right away. Never a long wait to be seated. The food is excellent. The staff is very friendly. The atmosphere is great. I highly recommend them. read more

Upgraded a star, they got rid of some of the rude staff, the older guy is still real rough, not pleasant. The food is better too, the last time I got fries, they seemed refried, not cool. So now I'll know to ask for fresh ones. They need to upgrade the decor. read more

This is a very busy place for a good reason. The pizzas, steaks and subs are great. Phone your order in advance, and it's usually ready in 10-15 minutes. read more

Tired little Anthony's afford wanting to eat here for a few months. I ordered a large cheesesteak sub. I have to say this was a pretty damn good cheesesteak. The entire roll was filled with meat. The portion size was awesome and the price point was reasonable. I'm always skeptical about trying foods I really like in new places but I'm really glad I tried this place. I'd highly recommend trying a cheesesteak sub if you haven't already. The large was WAYYYY more than I needed. I think my eyes were 10x bigger than my stomach that day oh well, I enjoyed it ‍. Next time you're craving a cheesesteak, dial their number, order a large (lol), & indulge in its yummy goodness. Enjoy! Until Next review, @kickinitwithki on IG read more

Little Anthony's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - New Castle, Delaware

This place use to have pretty tasty cheesesteaks. I just went and purchased one, got home and started to eat it and it has significant less meat on it and had like a mushy wet texture. I got it with fried onion fried sweet peppers but the texture was like they put it in a food processor. Even the fries were hard and nasty, no salt. Did they change owners or cooks.i will not go there again..I could of just went closer to home, but their cheeseteaks use to be very good, but not anymore. $17 wasted. Should of just went to grocery store and bought something and cooked. read more

it was stale and dry and I found not one, but two pieces of hair in the cheese of my pizza

Fantastic Pizza...definitely rivals any NY or Philly pizza I've ever had. Best in all of Newcastle, DE. I was already a fan, but feel like they needed a shout out! My dogs beg for the crust which I find hard to give up because it's just SO GOOD! Quick service with lots of seating. read more

Amazing pizza for cheap. This is a great local pizzeria to stop at for a quick lunch. The staff is nice and the service is quick! A slice of pizza is huge and only $2.50-$3.00 read more

Little Anthony's Pizza - Pepperoni pizza - Pizza Near Me - New Castle, Delaware

Ordered take out of a cheese pizza for me, stuffed shells for my wife, and tenders/fries for the kids. The cheese pizza is 10/10 perfect NY style pizza. Exactly what I was in the mood for. The stuffed shells were excellent and the serving size was huge! 5/5! read more

A long time local tradition. Little Anthony's is an Icon of good food and fast freidly service! read more

Little Anthony's Pizza - Great food! Awesome local establishment! - Pizza Near Me - New Castle, Delaware

Food is good. The place was packed for lunch but we didn't have to wait too long. Overall, I would come back for lunch!

Super yummy! Great Taste! Me and my boyfriend would definitely god back! Everything was at a great price and the owner was super cool! Great service read more

Wish Yelp did half stars bc this place is more like 7/10. Very busy on a Friday night. Ordered pickup and when I arrived there was about 5 people in line. Typical pizza shop setup not the cleanest but not the dirtiest. If you're looking for a good Philly cheesesteak I'd prob pass on this place. Cheesesteak meat tasted more like roast beef and I wasn't in love with the bread. Great size thought for a med sand they didn't skimp on the meat either. I'll prob return to try their pizza read more

Little Anthony's Pizza - Cheesesteak with mushrooms - Pizza Near Me - New Castle, Delaware

See all

Food is always fresh, price is reasonable and service is great. This has been my go to place when I want to taste real Italian food. It's what we call a hole in the corner, the decor is not the best but it's clean and that matters! read more

They have great food! So many different things! Not only pizza but, sandwiches, salads and dinners and more! Very nice people

Growing up in northern New Jersey with a dozen Italian-run pizza places right by my house, I became a pizza snob. When I moved to Delaware for school, I accepted that I wouldn't have good pizza for a while, which was true. The other night my boyfriend and I tried Little Anthony's, and I was so pleasantly surprised. The crust was sort of thin, so the pizza wasn't too doughy or chewy. We ordered fresh tomatoes and pepperoni as our toppings - flavorful and fresh. The grease was dripping off the slice as I held it in my hand, which points to quality mozz. The sauce was good, too. All around, quality pizza. Probably one of the best in the state, based on my last five years here. Even the house balsamic dressing on our garden salad was good. I'd just recommend leaving some time for your order to be ready, because they were quite busy when we called - we had a 45 minute wait for our food, and there were half a dozen people waiting for their food once we go there. Other people must like it here, too! read more

One of the best, if not the best places in Delaware to get a cheesesteak. Order your cheesesteak with American and provolone cheese. You can thank me later. Also, they serve really solid pizza and fries. This is definitely a local gem and a place to try if you haven't done so already. read more

What I love about Little Anthony's is also what I don't love about Little Anthony's. I got the steak special; fried onions, mushrooms and peppers. The fried onions, mushrooms and peppers were grilled together magnificently in oil. They spent time together with the meat. The Oily Marvelousness of the extras overpowered the meat. Plus, it made the Cheesesteak a little mushy. Still a very good cheese steak. Nice place with plenty of seating and a bathroom. Nice hard-working people behind the counter. The pizza look really good. Very good overall experience. read more

See all

Little Anothy has always provided Good quality food and outstanding customer service. No matter what time, day or month!

Very mediocre pizza. The prices are good and the menu is very big. Service is very good.

If I call in, why does it still take you another half an hour? Just to make a simple cheesesteak And then when I ask you what the problem is you have a whole attitude!!! read more

I moved away from the area some years ago but every time I go back, I make sure to stop here to get me a cheesesteak. I love how the cook the cheese perfectly inside all mixed together. The customer service is always good. Our wait was a little long last time and he gave us a free soda I wish they could update the tables and spruce up the place but it definitely doesn't change the quality of the food. read more

We LOVE this place. Authentic. They truly take pride in their food. Pizza is simply the best. Subs are over the top. We live in Virginia and make this a stop on our way back home. You can tell most of his customers are regulars. Just a great place. read more

We ordered 3 pies and they were all excellent new york style thin crust large plain, deep dish scillian, and some vegetarian white sauce. 100% worth stopping in here if you're in the area. Love the old fashioned pizzeria decor as well read more