I moved here from NJ a while ago, so my judging of pizza is probably more harsh than most haha. But WOOOOW this place makes the best pizza in probably the entire state!!!! Freshest taste, sauce that will make you wish they bottled and sold it and crispy and thin dough!! Absolute perfection all around!!!! read more

Prospero's Pizza - Hot pepper and garlic pizza - Pizza Near Me - New Castle, Delaware

Very friendly staff with quick service. Restaurant is clean and quiet. I had just a slice of cheese pizza. It's large and very cheesy! I personally like more sauce and less cheese but I know I am in the minority with that. The pizza slice was very delicious and I'll definitely be coming back to try other items. It's been hard find good pizza in New Castle and this place is one of them. read more

Good service and very clean operation. Very good wings. They also gave gluten free pizza.

Pizza was hot and delicious! Online ordering was straightforward and food was ready on time.

Definitely better than other local pizzerias in the area and stays open later than most as well. Plain pizza was ok 6.5/10 I would say. Maybe I would come try the cheesesteaks idk. read more

I ordered delivery based on the positive reviews and I was not let down. I ordered a medium pizza with pepperoni, mushrooms and banana peppers and a Greek salad. When the order arrived the pizza was still warm and the salad was fresh. I was able to eat off the pizza for three meals and it still tasted good even heated in the microwave. (I was staying in a hotel‍) Granted, the mushrooms were canned, but that isn't a necessarily a deal breaker. The sauce was tasty, there was plenty of cheese and the dough was thoroughlycooked. I was pleasantly surprised by the size of the salad. Plenty of feta cheese and other toppings and a large cup of oil and vinegar dressing. The salad was more than enough for three people if you paired it with a meal. I would definitely eat here again. read more

Prospero's Pizza - Greek Salad - Pizza Near Me - New Castle, Delaware

See all

I lived in this community for 20 years plus. During covid lock down i ate here religiously. Today, I ordered and to my surprise the streak I ordered was in terrible shape. Split on both sides and bread was HARD! NO WCTRA KETCHUP, NO EXTRA CHEESE, NO MAYO. SO I call, get left on hold for quite a while to be questioned again. For them to say they will be here to get it so they can see the sandwich. MAN..He actually checked at the door. I politely said you can have it. Needless read more

Awesome pizza! My husband loves the cheesesteak as well. This is pizza done right, a solid pie. Not too thick, not too thin, good crust, not too much sauce, sauce has a sweetness to it, good cheese as well read more

Prospero's Pizza - Awesome pie! The pizza here is great! It's a true pizzeria, they know what they're doing :) - Pizza Near Me - New Castle, Delaware

Love how friendly everyone here was, the place is very clean too. Wings were great! Pepperoni pizza was delicious and we had dinner for less then $20.00!! Much better then other pizza places around, in my opinion. read more

Me and my coworkers love the pizza here. The Sicilian pies are DELISH! Plus, they delivered our order within 25 minutes read more

The first time we ordered from here, we were hooked! Best subs in the area. My husband gets the cheese steak and I get the veggie sub. We've also gotten their fries and garlic bread and cheese bread. The driver is always friendly, the food is always on time and hot. Definitely recommend! read more

Customer Service over the phone was unprofessional and rude. The first time we called and ordered (20) wings and a medium cheese pizza, we were being charged 27.99 for 20 piece wings and 11.99 for a medium pizza. We were still ironing out what we definitely wanted and we opted to call back. Upon calling again we were then being charged $30 for wings and I expressed that, that isn't what she proposed the first time we phoned and she just hung up. Very rude and unprofessional. read more

This is my new favorite pizza spot. I love the fries. The prices is right. And the delivery guy is always on time or early.

First time ordering. The pizza and wings were delivered hot and tasty. This is the pizza Ive been looking for the last 3 years. Spinach rolls was nice warm and fresh tasting. I will be trying other menu items based on our meal tonite. Thank You. read more

The pizza was so crispy and had zero flop! The wings and their homemade sauce was undeniably delicious. You might want to give into your guilt and get the deep fried Stromboli because holy moly Stromboli was that good! They just know what they're doing and it shows. read more

Ive only had the pizza's from here but they are very good. The place in clean and the staff is very friendly. I eat here often and have always been greeted politely. This is my go to place for pizza's. read more

Great pizza mozzarella sticks where good loved the tomato sauce. Pizza was fresh and hot when delivered. The only reason it's 4 stars And not 5 is the order was for double pepperoni and it didn't feel like double pepperoni. But I would order again just for taste and freshness. Highly recommended read more

I'm so glad I tried this new place today. This is the second change of ownership from Lorenzo's and these guys make a great pizza. I always judge a new pizza place by how they do with a simple plain cheese pie. This was great. Just the right amount of sauce to cheese and the crust was cooked well and had just the right amount of chew. Please come and give it a try. We need them to get a good customer base and stay in business! read more

Prospero's Pizza - Great N.Y. style pizza! Give them a try. - Pizza Near Me - New Castle, Delaware

We have ordered from there twice now very delicious!!! Salads are fresh and so good everything is tasty. Cheese steaks are so good bread is so soft and just has a great flavor!!! Yummy yummy yummy!!! Oh and the wings were a little on the spicy side for being mild but they were still really good well worth it not expensive at all either new name and new owners love this place it is definitely my new pizza joint!!!! read more

Shortest wait times for pick up or delivery. The food quality is good. Service is always friendly and the place is clean.

Pizza was awesome! Dude made me garlic Parmesan wings even though they weren't on the menu and they were fantastic. If I'm ever in Delaware again I would definitely order from this place. read more