Voted "Best Pizza in Town" is an aggressive stance but that's what the sign says. Well, as a self proclaimed expert pizza eater and a reviewer of over 135 pizzerias in Broward and Palm Beach counties, the pizza is without question worthy of a top five "Best Pizza" award. They offer plenty of lunch specials, but I was here for only one task, to try the NY style pizza. The ambiance was perfect for a pizzeria with the intent to display a nostalgic NY theme. The oversized pizza slice was at a very reasonable three bucks. Lifted the firm "No Flop" slice to my awaiting mouth, thankful that oil from the cheese was not dripping down my hand. So happy hearing that crunch from the thin lightly charred undercarriage. Pleased with the zesty garlic sauce covered lightly by the cheese. The cornicione did not have charred air bubbles, but had an honorable crunch. The gender assigned bathroom was clean with black painted cement flooring complemented by a poster of the original 1972 Godfather's movie starring Marlon Brando and Al Pachino - now it was evident that this was a legit old school Italian pizzeria. Great job - easy five stars... read more

See all

I ordered pizza and wings. The owner came out with a bowl of penne ala vodka. Whoa... so good and he tells me that he makes the sauce in the pan when it's ordered. You can't get any more fresh than that. The place is cute and it through me off when I saw paper on the tables. It's not awful big and not too small. The ambiance was perfect and the food. Can't say enough about how it tasted. The food was off the hook, service was beyond great. The price was reasonable. You definitely can not go wrong here. I'll be back time and time again. Super great place and hidden in the shopping center next to Duffy's. read more

Amici's Pizza Cafe - Bowl of Penne al a Vodka - Italian Near Me - Coconut Creek, Florida

The pizza for me is the Best! The crust is not like other pizza places, Their crust is not heavy i guess is how i can explain it. Its lite and crispy. All fresh ingredients are used . Garden salad was great, and one salad served two of us. I cant say enough about the garlic parmesan chicken wings. They are not exactly breaded its more like crunch bread crumbs and they are perfect Enough garlic and oil to really flavor them, and the brownie was the perfect amount of chocolate taste crispy like how a brownie should be on the outside and moist and delicious on the inside with bits of chocolate or mini chocolate chips not sure but it was divine to eat. Would definitely order all of this again. Our waiter was great and spot on in service with everything we needed and even friendly conversation. He was a young guy but I am sorry don't remember his name. We loved him checking up on us to make sure we were good. The ambiance in the place is nice but can get busy and loud at times as its a small restaurant. There are folks coming and going with pick up and delivery orders, but it smells divine there, like Italian in the air. I highly recommend read more

See all

Heard Amici's has great pizza, so a friend & I decided to try it. They offer a wide variety of specialty pizzas with several types of toppings ranging from chicken, meatballs, veggies, Hawaiian (pineapple & ham) to upside town pizza with the sauce on top of the cheese. We opted for the regular cheese pizza. The crust was the right thickness: not too thin and not too thick. People's tastes in pizza are subjective, so I'll just say it was a good pizza, but not the best ever. We paired our pizza with an order of penne alla vodka. The dish was flavorful, but the vodka sauce seemed a bit thin and runny. The accompanying "garden salad" was good. It had a nice assortment of veggies. Nothing fancy but satisfying. In fact, casual would be the best way to describe Amici's. The brown butcher paper tablecloth, clamped down at the edges, clearly set the tone for the experience. I wanted to ask for a crayon to drawn on the paper! In keeping with this casual style, the food prices are very reasonable. The restaurant is small, with about a half-dozen tables. Dining at, or taking food out from, Amici's provides a nice value for a decent meal. The service is also excellent as the staff is very friendly and attentive at this neighborhood institution in Coconut Creek. read more

See all

My wife and I had pizza and appetizers. The pizza was awesome. We added pepperoni, onions, mushrooms and black olives. 10 out of 10! Service was attentive with quick refills. Very comfortable with high Topps and regular tables for inside or outside dining. read more

Amici's Pizza Cafe - Pizza - Italian Near Me - Coconut Creek, Florida

Such a great lunch special! A slice of pizza, salad (Caesar or house) and a soda was around $10. The margarita pizza as shown was SO fresh and tasty. Love the sauce they use and love the fresh basil. Service is great and quick. Highly recommend this place! read more

Amici's Pizza Cafe - Margarita pizza - Italian Near Me - Coconut Creek, Florida

I've lived 5 minutes away from Amici's for years, but never knew it was there until I started going to the chiropractor right next-door. After a session, my friend I walked over to Amici's. Its a small, quaint spot. Warmly decorated and clean. We sat down and were greeted immediately by Kyra who was very quick with bringing drinks and food! We ordered garlic parm fries, a clam pizza, penny alla vodka, a half pint of orzo (to go) and one fountain drink. They first brought out the breadsticks and Caesar salad that came with the penne dish. The Caesar salad was nice, tasted fresh and wasn't too wet with dressing. The breadsticks were fluffy and hot. Next was the garlic parm fries. I known it sounds dramatic, but these were honestly some of the best fries I've ever had! Despite them dripping in buttery garlicky cheesy goodness (you would think they'd be soggy), they were hot and crispy on the outside and fluffy on the inside. I tried to stop myself from eating so much so that I didn't get too full before my entree. Then came the clam pizza, and I was blown away. Pizza is so expensive nowadays and you figure paying for not only a pizza, but one with seafood on it, is going to be expensive. That was not the case at all, this pizza was loaded with clams, and even had three fresh clams still in the shell on top which was awesome! The pizza was baked to perfection, had amazing clam flavor, was nice and cheesy, I can't say enough great things about this pizza. And it was only $19! The penne alla vodka was a huge portion! The sauce had great flavor, the pasta was cooked perfectly. And I can see how the Caesar salad being cool and crisp paired so well with the hot creamy pasta. I had the orzo the next day, and it was really good. I can't say that I would order it again, but it was a nice protein-fueled midday snack. Overall, we paid $55.59 for our meal, which I think is a fantastic deal considering it made 4 meals! (I typically never have leftovers). Well absolutely be back to Amici's. read more

See all

There's not many great pizza spots in SoFlo and especially in north Broward. However, Amici's has to be up there. It resembled what it feels like walking into an Italian pizza joint in NJ. Great ambiance, staff were friendly, pizza was solid. Overall 10/10 experience with them! read more

The food is delicious and there are so many options to choose from The staff is so kind and attentive I couldn't recommend it more highly. A great place to bring the family for lunch or dinner!! read more

Small, cozy, and full of charm, Amici's is a great local spot for dine-in or takeout if you're craving quality pizza in a relaxed setting. We ordered a cheese pizza, Pizza Rustica, and Margherita for takeout, and all three were delicious. The crust was crisp, the ingredients tasted fresh, and the flavors were well-balanced. The Rustica was especially hearty and satisfying, while the Margherita was light and flavorful. Service was friendly and attentive, and you can tell this place is family-run with care. It's the kind of spot where you feel welcome as soon as you walk in. Definitely worth a visit if you're in the area! read more

Amici's Pizza Cafe - Margherita Pizza, Pizza Rustica, Cheese Pizza - Italian Near Me - Coconut Creek, Florida

This place was great but going downhill. Today was a disaster. 2 slices of cheese pie. The grease was so much. Don't get me wrong I love some grease. But 5 napkins worth. Disgusting. I will let the videos speak for themselves. read more

First off, this place is extremely friendly. We received a Welcome to the Neighborhood welcome from Amici's with a mailed in coupon offer for a free cheese pizza. Picked up on Halloween late afternoon and it was cooked to perfection. Definitely will be stopping by and ordering more Italian take out dishes from this establishment! read more

Excellent - Food was really fresh and delicious. Our party of 2 had a arugula salad, and Rice balls, and vodka Sauce Pasta. All three were spectacular. The wait staff was so friendly and did a great job taking care of us. Its a classic hole in the wall, with chalkboard menu panels that have cute jokes. Next time we come back to the area we will definitely be back. read more

This is a special place. The slices are huge and delicious. They have fun flavors, and it seems like you can't go wrong! The service was awesome. Very homey and personal. 10/10 would recommend read more

If I had came earlier I would have dine at Amici's Pizzeria. Since I arrived an hour before closing time, I quickly decided to get take out. Located in the Westcreek Plaza next door to Duffy's, Amici's Pizzeria reminds me of those family owned pizzerias in The Bronx where I used to stop in for a pizza slice and a can of soda after school. It's a small business with a casual ambiance and limited seating. Other than pizza, Amici's also offer: * Specialty pizzas/calzones/panini/wings * Hot & cold subs * Entrees & pasta dinners * Salads/antipasti/sides * kids meal/desserts * Daily lunch specials * Hot & cold beverages/beer & wine I approached a friendly female employee and asked if pizza slices are sold at this time. She replied "yes" and showed me various pizzas in the display case where I can make my choice. I didn't get the name; yet I chose a no sauce slice topped with ricotta, spinach, and plum tomatoes. Waited a few minutes while the slice got heated. Never had a pizza with no tomato sauce before...it was unusual and something I would have to get accustomed to, but it was tasty. The crust was hard but I didn't mind. Prices are moderate, but their lunch specials are reasonable. Have to come back on one of my days off. read more

See all

We were very happy that we found this place - had a meeting in the area, and needed some lunch. This turned out to be a great find. We will return. The pizza was simply the best. The crust was thin and crunchy, the toppings were very flavorful. Our salad came with a delicious house made dressing. The beer was cold. The menu had a wide choice of pizza types and toppings. The two men working, Tim, and Steve (?), where very welcoming and friendly. They were very present and attentive. The great service complimented excelent food. Ambience and price were tipical for a neighborhood pizza place, but the food and service elivated this "pizza joint" above most others I've tried. read more

Wonderful little Italian restaurant with a very extensive menu. The food was presented well and the portions were definitely ample. The taste was close to homemade since their marinara sauce is prepared locally in the restaurant. They also have some lunch specials that I might try if I have the time to go there during the lunch break. The only drawback is their selection of very flimsy napkins. The coke product selection is also limited. read more

Amici's Pizza Cafe - Chicken Parmigiana with Penne - Italian Near Me - Coconut Creek, Florida

Great friendly place. Really good food. I love the pizza, nice crust. Always like going there. Marc Anthony Lamorte read more

Ordered pizza via app. Crust was ok ..a little soggy. Got half meat and half veggie. read more

Everytime I come here the food is constantly amazing! The garlic parm wings have the perfect crisp, but are juicy , and have soo much flavor! 10/10! The staff are all so friendly and are very attentive! Pizza is delicious! Their cheesy bread is out of this world! You can tell everything is homemade! Nothing here is bad! You have to try it! read more

Amici's Pizza Cafe - Italian Near Me - Coconut Creek, Florida

See all

I did takeout they do a family meal package which includes a large pizza, baked ziti , a garden salad and garlic rolls. I added another large pie as well are a family of six. Service was prompt. The place is clean and on the small side inside. Pizza here is excellent. I drive from Boca to come here. read more

I have been going here for months, Rated it 4 stars at one time. Don't know what happened. One month ago ordered a pie they screwed up the toppings threw out the pizza. Called them, next time came in gave me the right pie for the mistake. Ordered another pie today, burnt horrible couldn't eat it, called said they were sorry want to come back for another tonight, I said no to far away, oh well tuff luck. Looks like I have to find another place, quality just isn't there anymore. This is what happens without quality control, the customer gets screwed. Look somewhere else. read more

Zero stars! I've been getting pizza from them for years. It was good. Tonight I got the worst pizza I've ever had. It was discussing. I called them and asked if they changed their recipe. And said the dough was not good. They didn't offer any apologies or concerns. I won't be getting pizza from them again. DISGUSTING!!!!! read more

Another on the whim visit and was more than pleasantly surprised! Pizza was tasty, but I could have used a little less cheese. But the wings were on point. Fried well but not over done. Might have like a bit more garlic for the garlic parm wings, but non the less tasty! Next time I'm seeking stress comfort food, I'll be back! read more

Amici's Pizza Cafe - Pizza! With prosciutto, Roma tomatoes, arugula, and EVOO also added mushrooms. - Italian Near Me - Coconut Creek, Florida

See all

We love the food, service, and staff here! Never disappoints! The pizzas always has a nice crispy, light crust. Our favorites are their calzones (absolutely ginormous), garlic bread, fettuccine alfredo, chicken forestiere, and pizza bianca. read more

Pizza was good. Could use a little more cheese. We picked up because they only deliver 3 miles and we were 3.3. It was ready when we got there. Place is clean. read more

I would give zero stars if I could. We ordered chicken francese and pizza, and the food was a complete disaster. The sauce for the chicken francese had spilled everywhere, soaking the salad. The pizza was completely undercooked -- the cheese and toppings were basically soup on raw dough. The salad itself was a joke: mostly arugula with just three small pieces of cheese and one slice of prosciutto. When I called the restaurant to address the issue, instead of offering to remake the food or provide a refund (at least for the uncooked pizza), the man on the phone got extremely nasty, called me a liar, and claimed that this was "great customer service." Absolutely unacceptable. Save your time, money, and frustration -- there are far better places to eat. read more

The pizza was amazing, the service was impeccable, great atmosphere, everyone around us seemed as happy as we were! Did I mention the pizza was amazing! read more

Amici's Pizza Cafe - Pizza - Italian Near Me - Coconut Creek, Florida

I think this might be our office's go-to spot. The food was fantastic and the services was friendly and attentive. I really appreciate the ambiance and the feel of the restaurant. read more

Amici's Pizza Cafe - Italian Near Me - Coconut Creek, Florida

I ordered delivery and got Josh as my driver and the service was nothing short of phenomenal, and not to mention efficient. I look forward to ordering pizza from here again soon! read more

Amici's really hit the spot! The upside down pizza was insanely good, crispy, cheesy, and full of flavor. I also tried the wings and Caesar salad, and both were super tasty and fresh. The whole place had a great vibe & cozy, clean, and perfect for hanging out. But what really stood out was the service, everyone was so friendly and on point. You can tell they really care. Definitely one of my new favorite spots! read more

Amici's Pizza Cafe - Upside down Pizza - Italian Near Me - Coconut Creek, Florida

Gotta bump this bad boy up to 4 stars!!! Yeahhh the mighty cuatro! Why you ask? Eazzzy... their wings, bro their wings are SO DAMN good here it's crazy. We got the Buf-a-Que, which you guessed it, is Buffalo & BBQ sauce... These wings hit mega hard to the dome. If you're gonna battle it out with these wings come prepared because you're about to get sonned like the wings Luke and are your daddy! read more

See all

Had the pizza and rolls and based on that it was excellent. Don't think I've ever seen pizza dough that good. So light and airy. Servers were very pleasant. Another surprise, they have great brownies! read more

I juat went to Amici's pizza Cafe for the first time....and likely the last. I ordered two cheese slices and a soda. Came out to $8 and change, not bad pricing. Cheese slices are $3.00 each which is ok. That would mean though my drink was approximately $2.00 for a fountain soda.(see picture) The pizza was ok at best. I asked for it just warmed up not hot. That's how I like it. 10 minutes later it came out with steam coming off of it!! Not cool! The cheese was very thick, almost as if it were double cheese, it took away from the rest of the pizza sorta! The sauce was very bland, and there was soooo much of it. It was a bit greasy as well. The best part of the slices were the crust. They nailed that. Nice and crispy, not overdone, not soft or chewy. It was just good. The service was ok at best. The girl at the counter was very quiet and not personable at all. There's a few tables inside and a couple outside. If it's not to hot I'd suggest sitting outside unless when you get home you enjoy smelling like a pizza place!! I had to take a shower to get the smell off of me, i was only inside for about 20 minutes The place was very clean, ill give them that. It wasn't a horrible experience, but it won't be memorable one either. If youre in that area and looking for pizza I'd Google options. From a 1 to 10, I'd give Amici's a solid 4! read more

See all

We had a solid good lunch here the other day. They have reasonable prices. For lunch, they have over a half dozen daily specials (during the week) from which to choose. Plus their regular menu, as well. The shopping center is set back off the main road. There is ample self parking. It's a small and very casual little place. Inside are several tables along one wall. On the opposite wall is the self-serve soda machine and the condiments, etc. You order up front at the counter, but they bring the food to you at your table. We both got their salad and slice special which included a fountain drink. The salad came first. It was a quite large bowl of cut romaine topped with tomato, cucumber, carrots, and a black olive. It had an Italian vinaigrette dressing on it. The large pizza slice had a nice crust and the bottom dough was crisp. It was very cheesy. I added oregano and salt to mine. He added red pepper flakes and grated cheese to his. If you live nearby or work in the area, you should stop here to try one of their specials. read more

See all

Great value Lunch Specials! Salad, cheese slice and a fountain soda seems like the best choice. Pizza crust has a nice crunchy bite. Lots of cheese on the slices. Great service! read more

See all

I cannot believe Amici's has been around for 14 years and this was my first time coming in. The food was absolutely phenomenal. The pizza was crispy with a great tasting crust and the wings were juicy as can be. Craig (the owner) came to our table and was one of the friendliest people I have ever met. The whole team was unbelievably accommodating. read more

See all

The prices are too high. $4.50 for delivery, $1.75 for online convenience, $19.00 for a plain pie, plus a tip AND tax= too much money. Industry standards are not an excuse so so many fees. read more

I don't live in the area but if I did I'd order from there multiple times a week. whenever I work in the area I go there for lunch and I must say it reminds of being in jersey. variety of different pizza you're able to get slices of remind me of where I grew up. the staff is also very welcoming and caring. the food is great. a very great spot read more

The pizza is unique and excellent. It's a small family run business and very friendly. The atmosphere is comfortable and casual. The italian dishes are not consistent so it is hard to rate them. It may depend on who's cooking that night. Check out the pizza specials on certain days. read more