Our server Dylan was top notch! Our visit this morning to the Mesa Amici Pizza was very pleasant. We had the shirley temples, french fries, vodka sauce rigatoni, cheese pie and works pie. I'm from New York, so I'm hard to please, but everything we had was tasty. The french fries were beyond delicious. They were super crispy on the outside, fluffy inside and perfectly seasoned. read more

See all

Don't eat here. Staff is unfriendly and leave "casings " on pizza, pretty sure it was a rubber bad (not edible at all). Staff agreed to remake pizza but chef was super butthurt and started flinging pepperoni everywhere and making a scene. Pizza chef does not wear a beard hair net when making the pizza. I tried getting an apology for our treatment at this establishment but looks like they don't want our business. Guess it is true when they say the worst people get famous. If you keep hiring people with bad attitudes your business will go downhill and all the goodwill you gained will go away. The waiter was nice but unfortunately could not make up for the other staff. read more

Came here after seeing the viral TikTok. There were 4 of us and we ordered a few things to share because we wanted to try multiple things. Rigatoni Vodka was pretty good and I could of had more of that. We also had the antipasto salad, we ordered the small and it was still a decent size. Antipasto is a go to for me and they didn't skimp on toppings. Margarita pizza, fried Raviolis and the garlic knots unfortunately we're not a hit we any of us. Margarita pizza Definitely lacked flavor. One bite was it fir me on the pizza. Garlic knots and Raviolis were just boring. Unfortunately we got the fried Raviolis kind of late in the meal because we lost our waiter at some point. He disappeared. Our drinks remained empty for most of our dinner until we were able to grab another waitress to fill them up and even then she didn't seem thrilled. Our waiter showed back up towards the end but by then it was too late. I wanted to love this place but it didn't work out for us. Maybe it was a off night because they definitely have a huge following. Huge props to the hostess. The door was a constant for her and she was so nice !! read more

See all

There will be a wait unless you hit it at just the right time. We finally got in and ordered some fried zucchini and mushrooms. Pretty tasty appetizer. We then ordered a pizza and it was very good. We purposely got the large pie so we could take some home. To finish, we had a cannoli and it was very good as well. Lovely restaurant and our server, who I think may have been an owner or manager was amazing. Cute inside and I hope they have some room to grow. They won't have a problem filling a larger place. It's not close to home, but if we are in the area, we will stop by. We walked out of Nellos due to poor staffing and service and came here. Can't say it was a bad decision. Keep doing what you are doing. Love this place. read more

Came to Amici's for dinner on the recommendation of my daughter who follows their social media presence. The dining room was full and the wait was approximately 45 minutes, but went by rather quickly. We were seated by a very friendly server, who took our order fast and efficiently. We ordered a basic - Large pepperoni pizza. While waiting for our pizza, we had the privilege of meeting the owner who was very jovial, friendly and easy going. Our pizza arrived hot, fresh and cooked to perfection. The pepperoni was savory and flavorful. The crust was thin and perfectly crisp. The sauce was rich and delicious. We had a fantastic first time experience and look forward to returning. It is obvious that this place is dearly beloved by the local community. Highly recommend! read more

Amici Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Mesa, Arizona

As good a NY slice as you'll find in AZ! Authentic NY east coast vibes inside. Ordered the two slice combo for a little over $10. Super cheap for the quality of their ingredients. Service was super fast. Pizzailos were slinging pizzas inside non-stop. Would definitely recommend. read more

Amici Pizza - Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Mesa, Arizona

We had a plain pie with some garlic knots a couple (super cold and fresh tasting) peroni's and (of course) a grinch Shirley temple to go! Oof we Love this place, consistent, friendly, great food besides pizza (amazing Manicotti, especially for this season) we love you guys, always perfecto for dine in or take out read more

See all

Worth the wait. Arrived around 6:40 and was advised by the hostess earliest seating would be in 45 mins, we were sat around d 7:30. Ordered a Shirley Temple, incredible. Everything was very flavorful and hot, from the moment you walk in to the time you leave you feel at home and taken care of. America needs more pop and shops like Amici Pizza. read more

See all

VIRAL FOR A REASON! Amici Pizza has been a viral hit on TikTok, getting millions of views! I came on a Monday at 11:30 and the wait was about 1.5 hours. You may want to wait a bit for the hype to die down if you don't want to wait. Once seated inside, we got some Shirley temples which were basic yet delicious! The wings were super crispy, I just wish they made their ranch in house, that would elevate it even more. Pizza was good, I love that they have some unique flavor such as vodka sauce pie, or Caesar salad pie. For dessert they have many options but we chose the brûlée cheesecake, as recommended by our waitress. This was AMAZING! Imagine cheesecake with a torch to the top, leaving a warm crunchy brûlée on top. Staff was busy and working nonstop, the owner was working hard using the register, helping to run food, and even cleaning tables. Definitely come support this amazing spot owned by a young woman! Lunch specials are daily, not just week days, FYI. read more

Amici Pizza - 14 inch pizza - Pizza Near Me - Mesa, Arizona

Went with a large group, service and pizza were both amazing! I think his name was Logan? Tuesday night. I had the cheese pizza, more sauce would have been better, but ill give it a 9. read more

Very welcoming atmosphere and great service. Server was absolutely amazing and he was very attentive. Food was great and very homemade read more

I tried out this pizza spot after all the hype on the internet. We ordered the Shirley temple, wings, garlic knots, the grandmas slice, and half all white pizza and half pepperoni, jalapeños. We got there 15minutes before opening and there was already a long line for dine in. The food came out fresh and hot. The wings were very good for a pizza place, the garlic knots were a bit disappointing, dry and lacking flavor. The normal pan pizza was subpar. If I went back I would stick to a Shirley temple and one piece of the Grandma slice which is the best by far. read more

See all

we were able to stop by after a flight before heading back down to tucson, we got 6 lemon pepper wings that were so crispy and steamin hot ! shared a little ceaser that was perfect for the two of us and a 14 in margarita pizza ! Amazing quality. Came out with great timing, we both thoroughly enjoyed it. Our server dylan was awesome, he was running the front while also taking tables and had a great attitude while doing so. We appreciated his enthusiasm and work ethic and was very personable. over all 10/10 would love to come back when we have the chance read more

I came yesterday around 4:30-5:30ish on a Monday . Our server was kinda rude did not catch her name , she gave me a rude look and attitude when I asked to have more time to look over the menu, we felt rushed to be completely honest. There was also something hard on my Caesar salad , I didn't know what it was . The garlic knots were delicious though ! read more

There's a reason why Dave Portnoy didn't post his review of this place after flying here and filming. Just a pizza shop that so happens to have a popular TikTok account. There's quite literally nothing special about it, and is definitely not worth the wait. We got a half white half pepperoni pizza and the pools of oil on top were absolutely insane. Our paper plates were drenched in oil after finishing our meal. I could get the same pizza in literally any other suburb in the country. read more

Amici Pizza - Massive pools of oil - Pizza Near Me - Mesa, Arizona

I was so excited to try this place, but sadly the 3 hour wait was not worth the hype. Don't get me wrong the Shirley temple was really good! And I liked the garlic knots. The pizza was okay it wasn't bad but wasn't that great either. We did try the pepperoni, the cheese and also cheese with the vodka sauce. I do love a NY pizza but sadly for me it just wasn't worth the hype. The service was fantastic and friendly. The restaurant is small and quaint. read more

See all

Great food terrific service. One little quirk is they served the food on paper plates. That is part of their charm.

Pizza is delicious. Great New York style pizza. The wings are delicious as well. Drove all the way from Laveen to try it and it was worth the drive. Would definitely recommend and I will be back. The service was very good and fast and they kept the drinks nice and full. read more

Amici Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Mesa, Arizona

Expect to wait long! We didn't mind the wait at all and knew the wait was going to be a while. I will say the vodka pasta was my favorite thing there, I felt like the pizza was burnt and the garlic knots were over cooked where it was hard to chew. Glad we got the chance to check this place out from TikTok! read more

Amici Pizza - Garlic Knots - Pizza Near Me - Mesa, Arizona

See all

Came to Amici pizza after seeing it go viral on TikTok and it was honestly pretty good. Great variety on the menu with good prices! The garlic knots were a bit too oily in my opinion making the bread a little soggy but adding the mozzarella with it was such a good idea. The vodka pasta was super delicious. The Caesar salad pizza was my absolute favorite. The Italian ice is so yummy and is a perfect dessert. Be prepared for longer wait times but we got lucky and were sat at the bar immediately. Service is great and attentive. Support small businesses and give them a try! read more

See all

The pizza was too greasy and overpriced. We've had it there before several times and it was much better. What pissed me off was for $45 for pizza and wings and you only get one small thing of ranch dressing. Anything extra $.60 when you have a dozen plus wings why wouldn't they put a bigger thing of sauce on there? read more

Found this place because it went TikTok viral however, the food IS good. It's just an average pizza shop really and it is not worth waiting 3+ hours or flying in from other state as others mentioned. Glad we gave it a try but, to continue to come back is a NO. (5 stars ONLY for the amazing customer service from KATIE, such an amazing server checking in constantly and great personality.) read more

I recently had dinner here with my family and wow was this place super busy busy busy! We waited 45 minutes for a table since the inside is not that big and because there were many other parties waiting for a table as well. We were helped right as we were seated and the server was so friendly. She was super busy but yet checked up on us several times. We ordered several different dishes and they were all pretty tasty. We had wings, garlic knots, salad, mozzarella sticks, a vodka pasta, and a supreme pizza. The pizza wasn't our fave but everything else was good. We had a good time and will come back soon in the future! read more

I didn't know there was TikTok hype over this place but it was nothing special. I ordered a lasagna that came with a salad(not pictured) and it was so greasy and oily. They were already putting chairs up 30 mins before closing and I got mine boxed to go. I was outside the door for 1-2mins and realized I didn't have my box to go and went back and asked and they said they already threw it away..?!! read more

Amici Pizza - Fried Mushrooms and Zucchini Combo - Pizza Near Me - Mesa, Arizona

See all

For starters, if I could I would give Amici's 6 stars! We were on vacation in Sedona and before we headed back home we absolutely needed to stop here and I am glad we did! I am actually writing this review as we take the 7+ hour drive home. We arrived at Amici's at about 10:44 a.m. and immediately got into the line that had already formed. There was roughly already 20+ people in line at this time. The doors were promptly opened at 11 a.m. and they immediately started seating people. We were seated in no more than 10 mins and had our drink order taken right away. We ordered quite a few items and were shocked at their amazing specials they offered! To keep this review as short as I can we've ranked the items we ordered below... Fries 10/10 Mozzarella sticks 9/10 Garlic knots 9/10 Wings (honey hot) 9/10 Cheese slice 100/10!!!!!! Buffalo chicken slice 8/10 Cesar salad slice 8/10 Shirley temple 9/10 I also ordered two large pizzas to go for my family back in California, didn't try the pepperoni pizza but it looks delicious! Service was top notch, we had the pleasure of being helped by Kateri and Cole! Everyone here seems so friendly and it seems to be a very family oriented establishment. I hope Amici's continues on with their success and I'm crossing my fingers that I'll be back! read more

See all

Was so excited to try this place after all the social media hype, but wasn't too impressed. Started with a Shirley temple and mozzarella sticks, of course, and both were great. Next up was the wings that were just average and they forgot the bleu cheese dressing. My husband did love the vodka pasta, but I disliked the Caesar salad pizza. It honestly lacked flavor and pizza felt like it was sitting awhile. Lastly, we ordered the crème brûlée cheesecake and it was just a complete sugar bomb. Service was ok, but could tell they were very busy! We were quoted over an hour and our table was ready in 25min so that was a bit confusing. Tables are quite close together, but loved reading some of the memorabilia on the walls. Not sure I'd be back due to wait time and average food, but I hear they are opening a to go option in QC so might give that a shot! read more

Great food, great service, I would definitely recommend this place anytime. Just expect a wait if you're a party of more than one during dinner time. read more

Amici Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Mesa, Arizona

See all

This place is worth the hype! I went with my friend a few months ago, we waited before they opened on a weekday. It is NO JOKE. The line got long QUICK! Luckily we were one of the first few that were in and seated. It is such a cute place, you can feel the love when you walk in the door. The owner was SO sweet. We order the Caesar salad pizza, vodka pasta, wings, mozzarella sticks, Shirley temples, and shaved ice and cannoli. It was all delicious! I think about the food frequently and cannot wait to go back! read more

Drove all the way from California and let me tell you, 10/10. Food was delicious and service was amazing. Hot honey wings were to die for and that vodka pasta was so good. I wish we had one closer so I can go more often but no worries. I also got a super cute shirt courtesy of one of the workers :) Thank you guys so much it was amazing. read more

Amici Pizza - Amici Pizza Shirt - Pizza Near Me - Mesa, Arizona

Amazing pizza and service. I am never disappointed when i come here either for a meal or just a quick snack and drink.

Super yummy pizza nice staff! Cute little family vibe. Burnt cheesecake was also super good. Definitely want to order this sometime. Only small critique is I think homemade ranch would make SUCH big difference:) read more

Amici Pizza - Half bbq chicken half vodka - Pizza Near Me - Mesa, Arizona

TikTok made me do it! Visiting AZ from San Diego and I had to try this spot because of the videos. Not only is the food fantastic but the staff offers great service! DYLAN was our server and he was outstanding! Hustling and making sure we were well taken care of. I'll be dining in every time I am in AZ! Recommend the buffalo wings, mozzarella sticks, pepperoni pizza, and chicken parmigiana! Their vodka sauce is delicious as well, I prefer angel hair pasta but they have options! don't forget the Shirley temple read more

Amici Pizza - Forgot to picture the pasta dishes because we dove right in! The wings were extra saucy which we love! - Pizza Near Me - Mesa, Arizona

The smell as soon as you walk just makes your stomach grumble with hunger, so delicious and the aesthetic of this restaurant just takes you to New York but this place is actually clean lol. The service here by everyone is just phenomenal, the nicest people you'll ever meet, very attentive, they even gave my son his own tray with pizza dough so he could be entertained 10/10. The food was just delicious awesome portions for very good pricing definitely satisfied the hunger you come with, Thank you Amici! read more

See all

I was really looking forward to getting my first meal from Amici pizza. I saw the review from David Portnoy. The pizza dough wasn't fully cooked. I ordered two separate orders of sausage and meatballs, and they added the hot food and three cold desserts in the same bag. The bag barely fit all the food and the desserts got trashed and were overheated. I ordered my food through DoorDash and received it within one hour of the original order time. I called the restaurant and talk to the manager. She gave me a credit so I'm going to give it another shot although my first experience was terrible. read more

Amici Pizza - Undercooked pizza - Pizza Near Me - Mesa, Arizona

The pizza was decent and the service was good. I have had better New York pizza. The crust could be thinner so it's more New York style. Again the pizza is good not great just not worth the 45 minute dine in wait. If the line is shorter then it would be more worth it. read more

Service was a little slow, but it was pretty busy so understandable. They made up for it by giving us tiramisu on the house, which was super nice! The food was really good and not too pricey, definitely worth it. read more

Amici Pizza - Caesar Salad, Stuffed Shells - Pizza Near Me - Mesa, Arizona

This was a let down for me. I saw so much hype on social media and was excited to try. We got there 45 minutes before opening and waited a while. Ut was not worth the long wait in my opinion. I tried the Caesar salad pizza and the margarita pizza. The Caesar salad pizza was okay and the margarita pizza was not my favorite. The Shirley temples and mozzarella sticks were really good. Overall, it was just okay food wise. Very nice staff though! read more

Amici Pizza - Shirley Temple - Pizza Near Me - Mesa, Arizona

See all

Great spot, close to home, yummy pizza. Garlic knots, pepperoni pizza, salad. Shirley temples

Service was good. I would NOT recommend the Shrimp Alfredo Pasta at all. I can confidently say that after trying it twice months apart it has giving me food poisoning both times. The pizza is great, I have yet to try the wings but please save yourself the stomach ache and AVOID the Shrimp Alfredo Pasta. read more

Amici's pizza, is it a bad slice? No, is it a great slice? Also no. Came here with my partner & we split the fried ravioli and got two slices of cheese pizza. We both came to the same conclusion immediately; needed some salt. Service was nice, all the staff are very sweet and overall the ambiance is cozy for a family type vibe but that's kind of where it starts and ends for me. In terms of the pizza I think what's holding amici's back from being great is that they're trying too hard to be general with their sauce flavor profile, it needs a slight zing to it and they're a little scared of driving some people away. Sauce to cheese ratio is good and the dough is yummy and has a slight crunch but stays airy. Overall it's good, just not great. read more