10/10! Great service- helpful and kind as it was our first time. We like the atmosphere with people chatting, a trivia game going on, sports on the tv's! The menu was broad enough with options but not overwhelming. I went for two slices and a caeser and my husband did the caeser wrap/pasta salad. We were so hungry I didn't even take photos of most of it! We had cannolis to go! Thank you! read more

See all

Taking a break from the drive, I stopped in here for a beer and a snack. The beer was good, sitting at the bar was comfortable and the pizza looked tremendous. The only problem was the wifi seemed to be a bit iffy, dropping after a while. No worries for me as I had the hotspot ready. Service was attentive and the seating was comfortable. I'd return to Amici. [Review 1268 of 2025 - 837 in Georgia - 24820 overall] read more

See all

The wings were great! They were nice and big and cooked well. The pizza was better than expected and my son enjoyed the chicken tenders More than enough parking all around and everyone was really nice. We had 30 min way but was able to walk around the town because they text us when we were next. I would definitely go back to try their calzone read more

See all

We had the pleasure of having Ashley wait on us today, the place has a nice ambience and it's a place where a lot of the locals come to for a quick bite to eat. If you're looking for a place to eat something quickly and have a cold beverage this might be for you read more

See all

First timer here. It was really good. I was eating by myself. I had a slice of the McDowell cheeseburger pizza. The slice is from the large pizza. The crust was really good. I also had a Amici Cesar salad, it was also really good. The bartender server was also a really nice guy. He explained the menu and was patient with me. Also said this is the first location with the corporate office downstairs. read more

See all

I nostalgically stopped in with memories of Amici's early days on the Main Street in a smaller space with an uneven floor and a couple of steps up off the street level. And, while the new space is much more comfortable and convenient, the food has slipped, a lot. My calzone was cold and while I ordered a cheese only calzone, there was nothing exciting about coldish mozzarella. I was expecting a nice fluffy ricotta with melted mozzarella. I ordered the onion ring basket- they were ok- not as exciting as I thought they would be. Admittedly, I ordered some really run of the mill items so that's on me but the sauce was obviously out of a giant metal can and the special dipping sauce for the rings was ketchup. I thought it would be a more from scratch experience. read more

Amici - Madison - Cheese calzone- I ordered it that way but there was only cold mozzarella in it... no ricotta. - Pizza Near Me - Madison, Georgia

See all

We all love pizza but unfortunately this is bad restaurant pizza. Sauce is very sweet. Overcooked. Greasy. Good atmosphere but the food is subpar. read more

I enjoyed the pizza and I'm very picky about pizza. I would definitely return. The service was excellent even above the food. We will definitely go again JR the bartender was great and extremely knowledgeable about the food and drinks. It was busy but still had a good ambiance. However, the band started towards the end of our meal and it was loud. If you don't like that, plan around it for sure. read more

Empty restaurant at 5 30 pm . 10 minutes wait and an other 10 before some the waiter comes to see us . Very strange

Word to the wise - call ahead to see if any special events or themes are happening, and AVOID comedy night at all costs! My hubby and I ended up here one night for a long awaited date night and unbeknownst to us it was their inaugural "comedy" night. They clearly did not put any research into their selections of comedians for the night, and the entire thing was a flop. An awkward, horrible flop! Even the comedians knew they were striking out. It was so awkward we finally got up and left mid meal which brought our date night to an end a lot earlier than we anticipated. We will probably end up going back to Covington like normal for our dates where places clearly know how to "read the room" and provide fun, after-hours entertainment read more

Great food, full bar, service was great. Great for families, the ambiance is fun! The staff is very knowledgeable and engaging!

Pleasantly surprised at the great taste of my slice of the "Athenian" pizza! Flavorful and generous portion ($6.50). I also had an order of 6 lemon-pepper wings ($10.50). They were ok, IMO, nothing special. Served with celery slices and choice of ranch or blue cheese dressing. Service was poor. Had to go up to the bar to get another drink as the waitress didn't come back to check on us after the food was delivered. Very busy establishment on a Saturday night. Overall, good experience. read more

Amici - Madison - Lemon-pepper wings with blue cheese - Pizza Near Me - Madison, Georgia

See all

I LOVE Amici, so I hate to have to complain. However, this is the second time in less than a month I've had subpar to go orders. A week or so ago I ordered a pepperoni pizza that looked like it had been cooked an hour or so before I picked it up. And it wasn't really cut so I had to reheat it and cut it. Now tonight, I've got a burnt calzone that was already a "remake" (i didn't ask why it needed to be remade, I was just ready to leave with food). I would love some good, and consistent pizza! All the other things I've ordered were great, the pizza is just making me sad as an Amici lover. read more

Amici - Madison - Cheese Calzone - Pizza Near Me - Madison, Georgia

See all

Lunch for 2 took an hour and a half. We ordered an appetizer and it never came (we were not charged for it tho after commenting that we'd not received it). Our food came an hour and ten minutes after we arrived (including the 15 minute wait to be seated). Cobb salad had way too much corn relish like 4 times what I would consider being a topping for a salad. It took over the salad. The fried onions were cold but cooked well and lightly coated and not greasy at all. The blue cheese dressing was weird... like it had too much mayo. Hubs honey mustard sandwich was good but fries were cold. It was a meh lunch. Have had much better experiences at two other locations. read more

We went to the location in Madision, there was a long wait, because it was a sunday it was busy & service was slow. we will try again bc the food was good & the atmosphere was fun... read more

Ate there the Saturday before Mother's Day. Ordered a Philly steak sandwich and honey hot wings. Neither of them came out hot. Practically cold. And had absolutely no flavor ! Waitress was nice. read more

Amici in Madison GA. is a great place for pizza, sandwiches and drinks. Always have had a positive experience. Staff is top notch and some of the best pizza around. Miss Dee our waitress was a gem. read more

Received a Large instead of XL. Hostess said 18inch for pizza and I received 16inch. Paid $21 for pizza with 20% tip. Pizza was very dry. Better pizza at Marco'. read more

Bomb ass food! Pizza deliciousness and you have to try honey hot wings! A must have if you are near a local store. read more

My girlfriend and I had lunch here, it was very delicious. The chicken parm sub was amazing. The service was great and we had a good time visiting. read more

Food isn't real good and you'll need new tires after parking in the "lot", more like a gravel crater pit. Go to The Chop House ILO. Owners need to spend some money if they want customers.... read more

I ate lunch here with a few coworkers today and the experience was alright. We had a long wait, that was the worst part. Our 1 hr lunch turned into a 1.5 hr lunch. I ordered the Parmesan sub and it was pretty good but drowning in marinara sauce. Overall the restaurant is decent but not the place to go if you need to get in and out. read more

First, the people that work at Amici are Awesome! All very friendly and helpful. The atmosphere was terrific. However, the (Philly) Cheese Steak was beyond terrible. The cook did not have a good handle on how to cook a traditional cheese cake in my opinion. If you think that a cheese steak should have tons of minced garlic in it, then you will love this cheese steak. If you love water from thick cuts of onion....soaking up your roll, you will love this cheese steak. I am not sure about this next statement....probably just me....but I tasted soy sauce (again, it may just be me), and it tasted awful. Obviously, I do not recommend the cheese steak. read more

Ate lunch here on Saturday. Our server was nice & attentive with drink refills. We ate outside but they have a very spacious inside with a large bar. I can only give 3 stars b/c I wasn't impressed with the food. We first asked for calamari as an app & then changed our mind to the spinach & artichoke dip. They brought the calamari accidentally so I told them we'd eat it anyway b/c I didn't want it to go to waste. But our server brought the spinach dip as well. I didn't care for either one. The calamari was very rubbery & the plate was about 1/2 calamari and 1/2 fried peppers (maybe banana?). The dipping sauce was like a hot & sour sauce, but it was bland to me. The chips that came with the spinach dip weren't crunchy at all & there weren't many on the plate. They tasted as if they'd been out of the fryer for quite some time & had gotten soggy. The spinach dip wasn't very good either. We also ordered the Woodsman pizza. It tasted fine but the slices were very soggy/floppy in the middle. I visit Madison once or twice a year for a girls' lunch. I won't suggest that we visit Amici in the future. read more

We were here on a Saturday for lunch. We are vacationing in the area, and picked a place at random. We weren't thinking pizza, but I'm so glad we stopped here! The pizzas are delicious, and our server Dee was great! The pizza crust is thin and very tender. They have great specialty pizzas, I had the Blonde Greek and my husband had the Beefeater. The 11" was perfect for lunch! The crust is so light you don't feel like you are filling up with bread, and the toppings were generous. I highly recommend Amici's! read more

Amici - Madison - Blonde Greek - Pizza Near Me - Madison, Georgia

Passing through Madison and the hotel recommended Amici. They were right, great food and service in a nice setting. Highly recommend

Food was very good with a very good selection. Server was very friendly and helpful - experience was better than good. 5 stars. Recommend to all. It's in an old livery stable built in 1895. Great atmosphere. And they brew beer. read more

Excellent food and service for a party of eighty! Had a wonderful wedding rehearsal dinner and was very happy with everything! They have a wonderful menu and everything was very good. The service was super great too. Definitely recommend ! read more

I have eaten at several different Amici's and this one did not disappoint. The food and wait staff were great. I would recommend.

Love Amici! Very good bar food. Service is great as well. Prices are just like most restaurants now, inflation is evident. Always go early so I can't appreciate the entertainment, but I hear it's great too! read more

Dropped into have lunch on a leisurely visit to Madison. We were very impressed with the taste and quality of the pizza here. I've seen the shirts around so I was curious and the food definitely is worth a visit read more

Was visiting Madison and the wife was shopping so I opted to grab a beer and watch some championship football. The place was slammed last Saturday and I barely got in. I can't speak to how good the food was but what I saw people order and devour loooked pretty tasty. Nice spot to dine in or sit at the bar. Experience it yourself because I never saw any of the issues some of the 1-star people allegedly encountered. read more

I love everything about this place! The wings are great, the pizza and calzones are delicious, and the dough balls are addictive! On my most recent visit we had Trinity as our server and she was awesome! She had a great attitude and plenty of knowledge on the menu. She recommended the Dough Balls with the sauce on the side as a dessert and they were scrumptious! If you get the wings get them drizzled with honey, it amps up the flavor! We happened to be there during trivia and everyone seemed to be enjoying themselves. It wasn't too loud and everything was clean. read more

Not a great experience at all. We had a party of six and was told the wait was 15-20. We waited over 30 minutes. Service was terrible and we had to ask for about everything we needed. No side plates, no silverware, no refills on drinks, they got the pizza order wrong and everything took forever. Worst thing to top it all off was that the pizza wasn't fully cooked, it tasted like a frozen pizza and the toppings were all wrong. It wasn't horrible, but it wasn't good enough to come back. Amici's use to be better, but not now. Service and cooks are lacking all around. read more

Amici's in Madison has some damn good Honey-Garlic Wings; that's what we ordered when we stopped by there on our way to Atlanta. These wings are serious; they are bigger than wings I've had at other restaurants and the flavor of the hot sauces mixed with the honey and the garlic complements them very well. The service was great. Our server made sure we were well taken care of. read more

Great food! I would recommend if you are in town. The entertainment was great, we went on trivia night and they also have live bands on the weekends! The pasta and the mixed green salad was delicious Well everything was awesome The Buffalo Chicken Gar Chee Mar was amazing! read more

Amici - Madison - Pasta Salad - Pizza Near Me - Madison, Georgia

See all

The pizza here was amazing!! It was the perfect spot for my daughter & I to meet for lunch & bonus... dogs got to enjoy it with us on patio!! read more

Amici - Madison - Outside patio was perfect place to enjoy lunch with our dogs! - Pizza Near Me - Madison, Georgia

Stick to the pizza, wings and a decent little burger with fries. "Italian" food is really awful. Spinach dip with housemade bread is solid. But really you go here for the best drinks and staff in town! It is Madison's hot spot for food, music and fun. Music every weekend and always something happening on week nights. They brew their own beer too! And Elvis might show up...never know at Amicis read more

Amici - Madison - Whole lotta shaking going on! - Pizza Near Me - Madison, Georgia

See all

We were on our way home from game day in Athens on 9/14/19 and decided to stop to eat at Amici. Bad decision. The place wasn't very busy, but it took almost 10 minutes for our server to greet us and take our drink orders. Five minutes later, I got the beer I ordered, but my husband and daughter were still waiting on their sodas. When our server finally brought their soda, she then decided to take our food other. We ordered standard items, with no special requests. It took over 25 minutes our food to be served. My husband liked his Philly cheesesteak and fries. My daughter liked her chicken fingers and fries. My tortellini Alfredo was lukewarm and grainy, with chewy pasta. I would have expected that an Italian restaurant could at least get tortellini Alfredo right. However, Amici did not get it even close to right. We won't be back. read more

I ordered the chicken Parmesan sub sandwich. It took it a half hour to arrive and when it did it was lukewarm at best. The Breaded chicken was chopped into such small bits there was no breading really left on the pieces that I did eat. the marinara was completely flavorless. And if you get the house salad I do not recommend their creamy Italian dressing. It was more like congealed Italian dressing and was thicker than Elmers glue. I did try a flight of their house peers and out of the four , the Saison was the only beer that really had any kind of flavor to it that was totally light and overly fruity in aroma and flavor. About the only compliment I can give this restaurant is the friendliness and attentiveness of the staff. And they did comp the sandwich that I returned the kitchen after two bites read more