For those who don't know about Amada, the restaurant is one of Jose Garces (Iron Chef's) restaurants. He's a recipient of the prestigious James Beard award in 2008, and word has it that this restaurant is one of the best places to get Tapas on the East Coast. At 4.5* reviews with over 900+ reviews in Philly, you can't go wrong right?
I've been to 3 regional winners of the James Beard Award: first was Michelle Richard's Citronelle in DC, the 2nd was Cucharamama in Hoboken NJ, and the 3rd is this. Unfortunately, this is strike 3 of 3 and I feel cheated for wasting money on subpar restaurants that serve mediocre food. FYI my combined average yelp rating for all 3 restaurants is roughly around 3*. I find yelp review are far more reliable than listening to the likes of the James Beard judges.
Today, I had high expectations for Mr. Iron Chef's restaurant and I tried 6 dishes for brunch. I decided to go with the traditional tapas dishes and dishes from the grill. The sixes dishes are:
1. PIQUILLOS RELLENOS-4*-crab stuffed peppers: the peppers were very well cooked and soft. It was stuffed with a creamy sauce smothered crab stuffing. This was the highlight dish of our meal. This was a great dish (not mindblowing). I cannot give top accolades to this because the taste was very, very predictable: the taste was very uniform from the moment the food entered my mouth until the tasting was finished. I really think that a bit of spice and flavoring to this dish would have worked wonders.
2. CROQUETAS DE JAMÓN-3.5*-we received 5 small pieces of croquettes. The sauce was an interesting hot pepper and carrot based sauce. It had the typical fried exterior with a small piece of ham at the center of the croquette. Unfortunately, this dish was extremely salty. If that issue is resolved it would be a near 4* dish.
3. ALBÓNDIGAS-3*- reminds me of Swedish meatballs. It was in a creamy, sauce similar to what was served with the crab stuff peppers. However, there was no crab to add flavoring to this dish. To top it off, this dish was way too salty.
4. Lobster-1*- for $16, I ordered 1/2 of a lobster (very small) that came with a parsley sauce that was prepared in a similar manner to a pesto sauce. The smell, however, was similar to kale. The lobster was...tough. Obviously, this was very very low grade lobster. How bad was it? I'd rather go to Red Lobster...yes you heard that right.
5. Calamari-2*- this was sauteed and had no flavors (oil sauteed) in the same parsley/pesto sauce as above.
6. Scallops-2*- low grade scallops that was very chewy and tough...it was in the same parsley/pesto sauce as above.
Honestly, I was appalled. About a year ago, I went on a tirade about a very highly rated Italian restaurant in Philadelphia and how they used "Ragu" spaghetti sauce for multiple dishes that were served in their pre-fixe course menu. Bad Karma or what not, the same thing happened today at Amada with the multiple dishes and their "parsley/pesto sauce".
What was so disappointing about the experience is that 3 dishes used the identical sauce (the parsley/pesto sauce). How lazy are you to recycle the same sauce for identical dishes or did I hit the lottery and happen to order the 3 dishes on the menu that used the same sauce? I wonder.
To add to my grief, the service was subpar. The waiter really really did not seem to care. As a matter of fact, he did not ask once how we felt about our food. The other servers seemed the same based on my observations.
In preparation of those who will try to derail my credentials, send ad hominem attacks (which happened with my previous review about a particular Philly restaurant), and who think I'm a Philly hater:
1. I''m not a Philly hater. There are lots of places in Philly I like: Bibou's bone marrow (which I think is one of the 5 best dishes I tried on the East Coast) + Capogiro Gelato(which I think beats out on any gelato I tried in Europe or the US)
2. My knowledge about tapas. I had at least 50 selected meals all with 4-4.5* ratings from European review sites and Tripsadvisor in Barcelona, Madrid, and Southern Spain including Torremolinos, Cordoba, Sevilla, Malaga, Andalucia, Granada, Marbella to name a few). First, Amada hits below average for a restaurant in all the aforementioned cities. Second, while Amada may sit "ok" or "good" with most people who ate in larger Spanish cities such as Barcelona and Madrid, tapas in the larger cities don't even come close to what you can get South of Madrid.
For those in DC who want to gauge the food at Amada, it ranks a star below Estadio in DC. For those who think I'm being a bit unfair of comparing Amada to tapas in Spain, I'll throw a recommendation: Seabra Marisqueria in Newark NJ. While not all dishes are spectacular, their grilled octopus at $23.50 is the closest seafood tapas dish that resembles what I had in Southern Spain. read more