Amá was, start to finish, a beautifully executed and memorable experience. Aesthetic, drinks, food, service, and everything in between. I absolutely love Mexican food and will get excited as soon as I see a menu like the one at Amá, but ultimately tasting is believing and I can now report that my expectations were definitely met and perhaps even exceeded. I don't get to dine out in Philly that often. Though it's my hometown, I haven't lived here for some years now, but my foodie sensibility is the way that it is because of the culinary expertise coming out of the city.
We came here at 8:15 on a Saturday night. Though this restaurant is wildly popular, I can see why it wasn't impossible to get a reservation here because it quite a large space. As others have said, the interior is gorgeous and chic, open concept, modern decor, tasteful use of lighting and decor elements that really punctuate the more minimalist backdrop.
I started with the El Chapo (gin, sotol, verjus, aloe, clarified aguachile)
which is the obvious choice for all of your martini lovers out there. At this point I never assume I've seen it all when it comes to garnishes, because they're getting more and more wacky and creative by the day. This one came donned with a tortilla chip atop which sat a delightful dollop of roe. I then got the Dixbee (mezcal, reposado, mole negro, totomoxtle) which gives more Old Fashioned than Negroni and is definitely more of a dessert or at least later-in-the-meal drink as it's richer with some chocolatey notes. I've had mole in mezcal drinks a good amount and there's something about the combo that just hits.
Food-wise, though I go to Mexican restaurants a fair amount, there were quite a few ingredients I didn't recognize on the menu which was both disorienting and exciting. Amá showcases live fire technique which means you'll see (and smell) and lot of smoked, grilled, charred, etc., on the menu. Goes very well with the bountiful mezcal they offer.
I don't need to do my typical grading system with this one because everything was an A+. I definitely looked at which dishes were praised most in reviews prior to ordering but it seems incredibly hard to go wrong here. Eats, below:
Chips and Salsas w/ house guacamole, six variations of salsas, heirloom corn tostadas
A salsa sampler is one of my favorite things. For one, I absolutely love salsa. All of the variations but the spicier the better. And second, my partner is not very into spice so we don't end up getting a lot of spicy dishes when we split things but such a sampler allows each person to try at their leisure and own risk. And even though I got it for the salsa, the guac was incredible too.
Aguachile del Día (kampachi)
Absolutely divine. Fresh, bright, with a little spice from some serranos and a little crunch from some corn nuts. Also served with some tortilla chips so you can get it all in one bite.
Shrimp Ceviche Tostada w/ pico de gallo, burnt árbol, ancho chamoy
There's a reason this one is being talked about. Another impeccably fresh dish, the shrimp and herbs combined with the creamy avo and crispy tostada all tied together with the bright, spicy chamoy.
Wood Fire Caesar w/ little gem, pipicha, parm, crispy masa crunch
We were between a few different veggie dishes and our server strongly encouraged use to get the Caesar. I think he said something along the lines of "a Caesar salad has no business being this good" and he was right on. Hard to say I've had a Caesar salad that competes with this because this is honestly in its own league.
Pollo a la Leña w/ adobo, crispy potatoes, ají verde, atapakua sauce
Though we don't usually get chicken for this we made an exception because of the hype around this dish. You can see how magnificent it is from the picture. Between the dusting on the skin and sauce and the juiciness of the chicken itself, this is really how a chicken entree changes minds and hearts. read more