What a treat!!!! I pulled off 71 South in route from Cleveland to Columbus and accidentally found 8 Sisters Bakery! I am so happy I did!!!! I ordered the maple bacon donut and a buckeye coffee - the donut was phenomenal!!! Especially the cream inside. My husband ordered a blueberry fritter which was great and a chai tea. The place was super clean, staff were so kind, and informative, and service was quick!! I almost can't wait to drive south again so I can grab another donut! read more

8 Sisters Bakery - Bakeries Near Me - Mount Gilead, Ohio

See all

Stopped by 8 Sisters Bakery recently and picked up a few treats for the grandkids--and it did not disappoint. We grabbed a large M&M cookie, plus a cherry, blackberry, and blueberry fry pie--one of each. The cookie was a hit right away, but those fry pies were the real standout. Flaky, sweet, and packed with filling--they were delicious. Each flavor had its own thing going on, and honestly, it'd be hard to pick a favorite. The portion sizes were solid, and everything felt like a really good value for the price, which is always a plus. They do offer lunch items too, which we didn't try this time, but it gives me a good reason to come back and check out more of the menu. Overall, a great little bakery stop--especially if you've got a sweet tooth or want to grab something quick that still feels homemade. read more

See all

We've stopped by this bakery many times for a sweet treat and this morning there was a line of about 15 people in front of us (always a good sign). The service was good, efficient and the ambiance is plain and simple - Amish style, but cute and clean. We ordered a maple bacon and a coconut creamstick. There was so much bacon!! And the coconut was really good! read more

See all

Absolutely fantastic. Glad that I had to stop to charge my car. Doubt that I would've ever found this place otherwise. Now I need to figure out a way or a reason to come back. The pastries are every bit as good as what everybody else has said, and I had the lunch special which was pulled pork sandwich with bacon, jam, and my mind is blown. read more

8 Sisters Bakery - Pulled pork sandwich with maple, bacon, jam, and a box of fritters. - Bakeries Near Me - Mount Gilead, Ohio

So, so good! Stopped here on a trip up to Cleveland. I had never heard of it, but saw it in a highway sign. It's a small place, but full of charm and great food. There is no seating inside and limited seating outside, but we were able to find seating easily. There was a constant flow of people in and out the whole time that we were there. I ordered a mixed dozen of donuts and er ordered the onion and cheese quiche and the spinach and cheese quiche. Both of them were great! The egg mixture was firm, the seasonings and ingredients mixed in were flavorful with a nice flaky crust. The nice surprise when we opened the boxes was that they had put small cups of bread pudding in. It tasted just like French toast. So good! We will end up going back and I'll buy a full quiche the next time. The donuts were some of the best I've had! The apple fritter is now my favorite fritter ever. The chocolate cake donut had great flavor, I was told that the others were great also. If you're passing through Ashland off I-71, stop, it's worth it. read more

See all

Delicious!! We ordered 4 sandwiches - BLTs and Ham/swiss- and they were delicious! And it did not take long for them to be made. We also bought cookies and the "Chow mein" and they were very tasty too. Highly recommend for a quick stop that has real food. read more

Let me just say: 8 Sisters Bakery has the bestest donuts. I travel to Pittsburgh frequently and stop by to grab a couple dozen. I've been feeding my team of engineers these glorious pastries, and now they're convinced I have some kind of underground connection to the Menonite mafia--or that I've kidnapped a crew of Amish bakers to work exclusively for me. Neither is true (I promise!), but these donuts are that good. Seriously, every time I show up with a couple of boxes, it's like watching a room full of caffeine-deprived engineers turn into kids on Christmas morning. We're talking fluffy perfection, with just the right balance of sweet and melt-in-your-mouth magic. These donuts aren't just breakfast--they're a morale-boosting, project-saving experience. So, to 8 Sisters Bakery: Please know that I'm not secretly Menonite, nor have I abducted any skilled bakers from Morrow County. But YOU are guilty of making donuts so good, they've become a necessary part of my engineering team's workflow. 5/5 would keep my "donut supplier" status under suspicion to keep the donuts coming. read more

8 Sisters Bakery - Amish Grand Slam - wear your stretchy pants. Yummy Breakfast sandwich to go with you - Bakeries Near Me - Mount Gilead, Ohio

Love, love their doughnuts! This review is about a birthday cake. Five stars for the cake too! Not only moist but decorated perfectly for my granddaughter's 4th birthday. The theme was Malibu Barbie. Highly recommend! read more

8 Sisters Bakery - Malibu Barbie birthday cake - Bakeries Near Me - Mount Gilead, Ohio

Top notch!!! Friendly, excellent selection, and delicious food and drinks!!! We were just passing through, but won't forget the experience! Keep reaching for the stars!!!!! DenverG read more

I stopped for McDonald's and as I sat in the parking lot. I seen a small sign that said bakery. Now of course I had to go in. And the smell just was perfectly amazing. I got a few things because I couldn't decide on just one. They have drinks as well. I'll be back for sure next time I am driving through. You should stop and check it out. The staff was extremely friendly read more

8 Sisters Bakery - Bakeries Near Me - Mount Gilead, Ohio

We just happened to stop there on our way to North Canton. They have the BEST donuts ever. I seriously have not stopped thinking about them since we ate them on the road. Can't wait for our next trip there! I talk about them to literally anyone who will listen. Sincerely, The girl who is thinking of making a 6 hour trip to go get donuts!!!!! read more

They close at 3 and we stumbled across this place at 230. Thought there would be nothing left and there wasn't. But what was left was all amazing. Peanut butter cookies, raspberry fry pie, buckeyes and cheesecake. SO glad we stopped! read more

I was meeting a friend who lives in Wooster - me in Columbus. Meethalfway targeted this area as midway between us. I looked at the photos and the pastries looked delicious. We were meeting at 11 AM so a coffee and pastry would be perfect. The photos showed seating as we were going to chat a couple hours as we had not spoken FOREVER. Our meet up was as planned and the bakery is only a stone's throw from 71. Thank goodness I was using Goodle maps/GPS as I would have never turned in the right entrance. It is hidden past a laundromat and carwash in Bonecutter Plaza. Unfortunately, no seating. Regardless, we had to check out the baked goods. From the photos I had seen online - the real thing did not disappoint. They all looked so good, I didn't even worry about price. I got 2 regular cream puffs - one for me and one for hubby. I also got a caramel coconut one that I liked best. It was amazing. The cream puffs turned out to be $5,50 each or so. More than I normally spend but so worth it. I made my puffs last almost a week savoring every bite and eating only part of one every day. I also got a chocolate chip muffin for the hubby. He was returning that night from a week out of town and would have no food to eat. I knew he'd eat the muffin for breakfast the next morning - and sure enough he did! I'm guessing the muffin was $3-4 as I think my total bill came to around $20. So we got our orders to go (HAHA - only option) and drove next door to McD's to chat. We each got a soft drink and sat and chatted about 2.5 hours. I do not regret picking the bakery as a place to meet. I never spoil myself with awesome baked goods like this - so it was such a treat. I posted my pics of the puffs on FB and mentioned where we got them. So many people knew of this bakery and spoke highly of it. If you're going north or south on 71 and looking for some excellent pastries - STOP HERE! You will not be disappointed! read more

8 Sisters Bakery - Yummmmm! Regular and caramel coconut cream puffs - Bakeries Near Me - Mount Gilead, Ohio

BEST CINNAMON ROLLS EVERRRRR!! I have been getting my mom to get me cinnamon rolls from here since the very beginning when their shop was in downtown Mt. Gilead. Now I'm in North Carolina and get my mom to bring them to me every time she visits anndddd my in-laws and whoever else comes down haha. Always have and always will love not only any baked good I've had from them but also the owners themselves. read more

If I could give a 0 I would. Asked for a maple donut and they gave me maple bacon. Was so disgusting. I had to spit it out.. then I ask for a plain maple and they gave me a peanut butter donut. Glad I don't have a nut allergy. read more

8 Sisters Bakery - Maple bacon donut - Bakeries Near Me - Mount Gilead, Ohio

Amazing fresh and tasty pastries! The best cream stick/long John I've ever had. The bear claw and cinnamon twists were very good too.

Portions have gotten smaller over the years and the prices has risen a bit, but overall still an above average experience given it is located in a rural area. Quality has not changed, still just delicious Amish baked goods read more

Excellent donuts, depending on the day. We have only been twice but on our first visit in October 2023 the donuts were only ok but on a second visit more recently (August 2025) they had significantly improved. Staff good but not the friendliest. Definitely not chatty but not rude. Very clean bakery. Selection is very minimal towards the afternoon. read more

The service was quick, easy and friendly. Their coffee is amazing and they give the vibe of any other small local coffee shop and bakery. Their food is also great! If you're tired of the big corporation coffee shops & want to try local I recommend this place! read more

This bakery is not only amazing but the pricing can not be beat. It will leave you wanting more. The donuts are like a food artwork. They look so go that you hate to eat them. I have never tasted a blueberry donut like theirs before. Amazing. Same with the lavender lemonade. It is not sugary or sour. I could have drank another one. It was beyond fabulous. The staff was very friendly and did not rush you out the door. The line was almost out the door but moved quickly. I will defiantly go back. read more

See all

Using the EV charger and stopped in. Doesn't disappoint! Yummy yum!!!! They even offer lunch but it was out away since they close in 30 minutes, ha! read more

See all

Ordered a birthday cake. It was moist and fresh but reminded me of a cake I would make, meaning it was good, but didn't look like I bought it from a bakery. The cake was delicious tho, just not sure if I will order one from here again. read more

Absolutely love the doughnuts! No matter what time of day they are always fresh! The long john creamed filled are our favorite!

The breakfast sandwich is great - freshly made, nicely seasoned sausage, and good sauce (it's probably just mayo and mustard, but it works). It also came with a side of warm cinnamon bread pudding, which was a lovely surprise. The coffee is... fine? It seemed a little watery. The cream puff is also good - the cream is whipped cream based, so it's pretty fresh, not too sweet, not too heavy. The puff pastry is ok... I never like that part though. If it's your thing, this is probably a quite good cream puff. They have some outdoor seating, which is nice considering the mask compliance indoors is abysmal. They have a mask sign up, but I was in there ten minutes and they served two people who didn't even pretend to wear masks, so just be aware of that. Kitchen staff also didn't cover their noses, which almost makes me more irritated than the outright non-compliance, but YMMV. read more

See all

Unfortunately, as someone else has mentioned no prices on anything posted anywhere. Not on the individual items prepackaged on the line tables or on the menu board. We bought 5 donuts and it was $15. The regular glazed donut was so thick it was like eating a piece of white bread, same for the long Johns. Overall not impressed. read more

My husband and I stopped here on our way to KY and we're so glad we did! These donuts have a beautiful doughy consistency, the flavors are very different from each other, it's not just sugar and dough thrown into oil to fry. You can really get a taste of the work that was put into the donuts (since 4am that morning, THEY'RE SO FRESH!) We got there around 8am just before the lines begin and the staff member helping us let us know customers happily wait on line for a while but they love it! The nice lady helping us choose our donuts was patient, pleasant and informative, which helped me bc I just could not choose!!!! The business is clean, decorative and they're friendly atmosphere made this such a gem to stop in to! read more

8 Sisters Bakery - Blueberry Fritter, blueberry cake donut, donut twist, maple bacon, strawberry cheesecake, and sticky bun! - Bakeries Near Me - Mount Gilead, Ohio

This is a great family owned business! The food and drinks are good. We love to support local businesses.

Everyone working here is amazing, some of the friendliest people I've ever met. All the pastries, pies, donuts and breakfast sandwiches are very good. Try one of everything, I have. read more

Beware you will pay $50 + for 2 dz donuts and if you get any donuts deemed specialty it almost $3 more per donut. There are zero prices listed for anything and zero communication. I believe no prices are listed so with the high prices at the register people are to embarrassed to say I don't want this. Make sure you also ask for a breakdown or they gladly over charge you. The manager is also extremely rude and condescending, and will blame you for any issues.​ read more

At the last minute we decided to ditch our usual boring breakfast and make a trip to 8 Sisters. My boyfriend has been here a few times so we went to grab some donuts! Everything at the counter looked delicious and fresh. I opted for the Cinnamon Twist and it was amazing. The woman offered to warm it up for me and I'm glad she did. My bf got the Buckeye Donut and a Strawberry filled one. I snagged a bite of his and both were very good. The Buckeye is very peanut buttery- a bit too much for me but still tasty. The Strawberry filling was very good and clearly made from scratch. We didn't realize it beforehand but they also have a fairly large selection of other food items such as sandwiches, wraps and salads. All of which sounded really yummy. Everything is very reasonably priced and definitely worth the stop! There's also a farmers market that sets up right next to them! read more

See all

Apparently this place, is the place to get doughnuts!! I can't speak for that because they are so amazing they are sold out every time we've been in the area But their bakery items have been insanely delicious! The cupcakes had such delicious frosting. And the blueberry fritters were crunchy and soft and sticky, perfection. read more

Nice little gem off Interstate 71 to grab a sweet treat! You will not be disappointed. Friendly staff with amazing selections!

Placed a large catering order and was very dissatisfied with how the order turned out. Breads were undercooked and dense, the opposite of what you would expect of a bread. Before I placed a larger order, I ordered 1 bread to make sure I knew exactly what I was buying and how much it was going to cost. It good, fluffy, full of cinnamon and spices and brown like one would expect. When I placed the large order it was about $2 more per bread than I paid for the 1 test bread I ordered. I was advised the previously ordered bread was not up to bakery standard however the bulk order of loaves would be larger and better quality. When I picked them up they looked the exactly the same in size as the one bread I ordered previously. I brought it to the managers attention before I left the store and she was dismissive and sent me on way. What's worse is when I go to slice the breads they were grayish, not quite cooked enough or there was too much water in the batter, so they just weren't that good. Not what I was expecting, disappointed in the product and service. read more

8 Sisters Bakery - Bakeries Near Me - Mount Gilead, Ohio

See all

If you are looking for a sweet treat, look no further, eight sisters is amazing. Every year for my birthday my husband gets me a white almond raspberry cake and it is always fantastic. It is a double layer almond cake with raspberry filling. I have taken it far and wide in central Ohio and people always love it. They can't believe it came from a small town bakery. I can't forget to mention their pies and donuts they are in a league all by themselves. If you are up for a road trip, it is a great destination and I guarantee you that you won't be disappointed. read more

Stopped here to grab lunch on a whim. Very good, homemade bread was awesome on the Italian sandwich. Very very good! Could use more meat and home made dressing. But definitely would go back. Very solid sandwich. read more

8 Sisters Bakery - Bakeries Near Me - Mount Gilead, Ohio

I stopped in for lunch while on a road trip. This place has quite the operation going. They start at 4am! The bakery goods were beautiful, fresh and delicious. I tried one of the Christmas sugar cookies and they were melt in your mouth buttery flavor. I ordered a Turkey wrap to go. It was more like a panini and it was delicious. It had homemade ranch dressing and was very filling. This is a great place so I recommend you stop! read more

See all

A hidden gem stop for donuts, sandwiches and salads! Right off I-71 and easy to get to!

If you're looking for a great sandwich, coffee and dessert, look no further. Absolutely a shame if you haven't stopped by. It's just a quick jaunt from Ohio St Rt 71. read more

8 Sisters Bakery - Swiss cheese and ham Panini - Bakeries Near Me - Mount Gilead, Ohio

See all

Average pulled pork sandwich. Donuts had nice outer crispy coating indicating a nice fry but were somewhat dry inside. Charming place with nice workers. read more

8 Sisters Bakery - Blueberry cake donut - Bakeries Near Me - Mount Gilead, Ohio

Had my first donut fro here. My boyfriend is from the area and he mentioned homemade donuts and I was like yes please! Had the maple bacon with cream filling which was very filling... next time I'll try the Apple fritter. read more