Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    50 Fish Tales

    2.5 (2 reviews)

    50 Fish Tales Photos

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - 50 Fish Tales

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    3 years ago

    Helpful 5
    Thanks 0
    Love this 4
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Ask the Community - 50 Fish Tales

    Pet Supplies Plus Depew

    Pet Supplies Plus Depew

    (24 reviews)

    Pet Supplies Plus in Depew is conveniently close, decently clean, and employed with…read morecompetent/professional staff. Pet items are easy to find in the aisles. If you cannot find an item you need just ask an associate and they are willing to help. The stores parking lot is narrow. Be cautious how you park to make your exit easier.

    I am beyond disappointed with the way my daughter and I were treated during our visit. We came into…read morethe store because I was seriously considering purchasing a pet next Wednesday. Instead of feeling welcomed, I left feeling humiliated and judged. I went directly to the reptile section and asked a few questions. While I was there, I noticed an employee go into the restroom. I have pelvic cancer and bladder issues, so I was waiting for the restroom to become available. While I waited, I walked down a nearby aisle to browse. Suddenly, two employees approached me from opposite ends of the aisle and began questioning me as if I had done something wrong. I had done absolutely nothing to deserve being treated like a suspect. What made this even worse was how obvious it felt that I was being judged by my appearance. Just because I have tattoos does not make me a criminal or a bad person. It's 2026--people need to stop making assumptions based on how someone looks. Disabilities are not always visible, and neither is someone's character. The way your employees and managers handled this situation was disrespectful, embarrassing, and completely unnecessary. You didn't just hurt my feelings--you hurt my daughter's as well. She watched her parent be treated with suspicion instead of kindness. You lost what would have been a paying customer. I was planning to buy a pet from your store next week, but after being made to feel so unwelcome, you will never receive another dollar from me. I hope management takes a serious look at how customers are treated because no one should have to leave a pet store feeling ashamed for simply existing.

    Notorious DOG - My sweet Kia

    Notorious DOG

    (18 reviews)

    I have driven past Notorious D.O.G. so many times that my dog could probably have written this…read morereview herself by now -- and the only thing I can say is... what on earth took me so long? From the moment you step inside, it feels like a magical little pet-boutique wonderland. There's stylish dog apparel, an incredible selection of treats, raw food options, supplements, goat's milk, and basically every wholesome, bougie, tail-wag-approved thing your furry family member could ever dream of. (Yes -- I even spotted Keon Coleman treats. And let's be honest: if your dog is a good doggo, they are definitely part of Bills Mafia and absolutely deserve them.) But what truly makes this place exceptional is the customer service -- specifically, Kristy, who is now basically my dog-mom best friend. On my very first visit, she spent so much time talking through my dog's skin issues, gut health, raw feeding, and supplementation. She sent me home with samples, walked me through their rewards program, and even helped me troubleshoot products I was already using at home. On a later visit, Kristy even special-ordered a product just so I could do more "one-stop shopping" with them -- which says everything about the level of care they provide. Even though we ended up going back to our previous food brand, this is absolutely where I go for everything else. I've sent so many people here, and when I drive past without stopping, I still wave and yell, "Hi Kristy!" from my car -- just in case she can hear me. Five stars, without hesitation. If you love your dog even a little bit, you need to be shopping here.

    My wonderful, perfect Golden Doodle, Kia, started having grand mall seizures all day, every day…read more Nothing was helping and that would mean her life would be cut short. :( My vet recommended Notorious D.O.G. I had no idea why, but they told me there was a woman there who was VERY knowledgeable. I was filled with fear and sadness... Kia was my baby! I spoke to the woman I was told to, and I explained what was going on. I couldn't help but cry. This was my soul-dog. Out of the 8 dogs I'd had in my life, (all of whom I loved so much), this one had a connection to me, and I to her, that I couldn't explain to this day. This wonderful and kind woman understood about my dog not wanting to eat and she suggested a raw food diet. Then she talked to me about a hemp oil that she believed would help. I bought it all. I gave Kia her first dropper-full of the oil that day, and she only had a couple small seizures that night. But in the days that followed, her seizures stopped!!!! She was running around as usual, eating the raw foods, playing with my other two dogs, and was her old self again. And that was how she stayed for two years, until the store didn't get a shipment of the oil at one point, and the one my vet provided wasn't working. Sadly, Kia passed away October 2019 at the age of 12. I will tell you this though... if it hadn't been for the expertise of that wonderful woman at the store, if she hadn't carefully considered what would be best for my girl, we would not have had her for those two years. I highly recommend the store and most of all, some really kind and caring workers.

    50 Fish Tales - localfishstores - Updated July 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...