5 Burros (I know it's 5 Burro Cafe) never disappoints. My favorite thing to get is still the steak in any form. It's always delicious. read more

5 Burro Cafe - Mexican Near Me - Forest Hills, New York

We thoroughly enjoyed. Is this considered a hole in the wall? This place is teeny tiny, but the food is really good and the staff were wonderful. We didn't drink, so we don't know about that part, but there is a bar and you could sit there if you were so inclined. This place is so convenient to the E/F train, there is no reason not to give it a try! We had fajitas and quesadillas with an appetizer of guacamole. It was all quite delicious.. read more

5 Burro Cafe - Cheese Quesadilla. - Mexican Near Me - Forest Hills, New York

See all

Classic Mexican restaurant with the happy hour margaritas and the chips with salsa.One meal was enough to share for two people but the food was filled with grilled chicken and steak with lots of rice and beans.All served up in a trinket filled restaurant that has been appreciated but forest hills residents and more to come . read more

5 Burro Cafe - Mexican Near Me - Forest Hills, New York

Service is great here. It's a hole in the wall kinda vibes with authentic food. The tacos were delicious and the soup was SO goood. My boyfriend suggested going here and I was not disappointed. I was so full I couldn't have dessert! Best part is I didn't feel overly bloated after! read more

5 Burro Cafe - Mexican Near Me - Forest Hills, New York

See all

This place gave me food poisoning I had to even go to the hospital! Don't recommend nobody to come here I should've known better I knew this place was dirty when I came in to eat never again read more

5 Burro Cafe - My discharge papers from the hospital because of this dirty place! - Mexican Near Me - Forest Hills, New York

What a great little hole in the wall. This is a gem. Love this place and will be coming back. Place has great food and a great vibe. Music playing. Decor that makes you feel like a tropical vibe. Great drinks. They have flavorful margaritas of all flavors. I love the modelo negra. Very small and quaint. Cozy for 2. Must try the food. Had shrimp cocktails and flautas. It's more Mexican dishes. To end the night the bartender brought us a round of shots. read more

5 Burro Cafe - Mexican Near Me - Forest Hills, New York

See all

You really can't go wrong eating here. The food is made with a little bit of magic. I usually get the steak burritos and have never been disappointed on flavor. The only disappointment is when your plate is empty and there is no more to enjoy. Space is in the smaller end; you'll be happier in parties of 2-4. It's a vibrant space with lots to look at on the walls. Service is friendly and fast. Drinks are delicious and pack a punch! read more

5 Burro Cafe - 2 Burritos (1 for Lunch) - Mexican Near Me - Forest Hills, New York

This place NEVER disappoints -- their margaritas are to die for & their chipotle chicken quesadillas are my favorite thing on the menu. Absolutely love their 5 burro quesadilla & their queso fundido. Already craving another frozen margarita! They have the cutest decor & phenomenal service. read more

See all

I loveee this spot. Definitely the GOAT in FoHi when it comes to Mexican food and I love the dive bar vibes in here. I came here with my mom the other day and we both noticed the price for frozen margs went up to $12 when they used to be $8. Fine, I don't mind a price increase and I do like to support a small owned business in our area, not a big deal. Margs still have the same great taste and super refreshing. Then we ordered tacos. Everything was delicious, though I noticed portions were a bit smaller. Much smaller servings of rice, beans, guac, etc. But the portions are still generous. All this to say, when I get the bill, the price for the entrees is not what was shown on the menu. Its fine if they increased prices, but the menu should reflect that or they should have signage regarding price increases. I'm disappointed to see the raise in prices and the decrease in portion sizes. Will I still come back here? Absolutely, its bomb. But I just wish there was a little more transparency with pricing. Its the least that can be done for the loyal customers. Pro tip: get the frozen watermelon marg, sooo good. Definitely a must have for summer. read more

5 Burro Cafe - 3 Tacos (2 for Lunch) Skirt Steak - Mexican Near Me - Forest Hills, New York

See all

The Food was on point. I had my usual enchiladas and tacos. Service was quick and Waiter kept my drinks full and cold.

Get food Great service very good service from host to server and busser And the food is really good cooked steak was amazing. Pitcher of margaritas hot the spot for Sure . read more

Came here last weekend and was a bit disappointed. We asked for outside seating and was told it would be over an hour and to come back in 45 minutes. We took a short walk and came back in 35 mins and the girl told us she forgot about us and gave away our table, twice. We waited about another 20-30 mins for a table inside which was near the window and as the girl said "close enough" to outside. She did apologize but it left a bad taste in my mouth. Then also cleaned the table and told us to sit but it was filthy. Had I sat, I would have gotten grease or oil on my pants if I didn't wipe my own seat. Food was the same as always, it's good but the whole experience wasn't the best read more

5 Burro Cafe - Dirty seat and floors - Mexican Near Me - Forest Hills, New York

ENTIRE FAMILY GOT FOOD POISONING!! And the fact that they issued a gift card is ridiculous, I mean it's my brothers but still. Why would I eat here again? If anything I'll get drinks BUT I DOUBT IT. Also the service is bad! My brother asked for soda water and the guy was super dismissive and said they don't have. And then the waiter brought it. Really weird staff in general We didn't pay over $200 to be throwing up all night I couldn't even go to work this place actually should be investigated read more

Amazing food and service! Highly recommend this place to others! The chicken quesadilla was delicious! Highly recommend this place to others! read more

5 Burro Cafe - Chicken Quesadilla - Mexican Near Me - Forest Hills, New York

5burro is the best place to go for good drinks and food with friends! I've been coming here for years with different groups of friends and the quality and quantity of their food has not changed. My go to orders are their steak tacos, steak quesadillas, and steak with fajitas. This place is always packed but it's worth the wait! They have great margaritas and other drinks to go with your food! It does get loud but it's always a good time. read more

I've never had a better frozen margarita! The food is equally impressive and delicious. It's a small place and I'm not a fan of sitting so close to other people that we can hear every word of each others' discussions. But overall the vibe is nice. Staff is friendly. They did mess up my husband's order. He ordered 3 tacos - shrimp, steak and ground beef - they skipped the shrimp and gave him chicken which he was really disappointed about (he's not a huge fan of chicken). We had a movie to get to so didn't bother with it but they did still charge us for the shrimp (which obviously means this was a kitchen error, not a server error). However even with that mistake - the food was melt-in-your-mouth delicious (IMO just a bit overpriced) and we would def come back (esp for the margaritas). read more

See all

We visited after too long of an absence and thanked our lucky stars as we got seated right away at this popular and bustling cafe! Even the hostess told us this was our lucky night as there is always a wait to get in. Yippee! While the place is on the small side and gets a bit cramped, it is such a a unique and welcoming place that allows you to feel instantly comfortable and relaxed. While 5 Burro's is well known for their frozen margaritas (they are fantastic) we opted for some Corona's (no draft beers, only bottles) and tequila shots. Complementary chips and salsa were bright to the table. We ordered the Mexican salad con carne with skirt steak-- a favorite go to that I have never gotten better anywhere. Their in house made dressing makes it so good. All was fresh and delicious. We loved picking some tunes to play on the jukebox. Service was super friendly and attentive. The restrooms were clean and well maintained. On street parking only. Can't wait to come back. read more

See all

Went there on a Sunday night and the place was packed. The frozen coconut margaritas were dangerously delicious. I don't usually like margaritas but was told I had to try one - so glad I did!! We started off with the cheese and bean nachos. They were delicious, simple but very flavorful. I ordered the fish tacos (mahi mahi) omg, they were amazing!!! Maybe the best fish tacos, similar to the ones I had in Maui which set a very high bar. Everyone enjoyed their meals. The service was very friendly and attentive. Cannot wait to go back. read more

Swung by for dinner before a show at Forest Hills Stadium. Food and ambience were great! The hostess is a star and made everyone feel right at home, and our waiter was timely, helpful, and pleasant. read more

5 Burro Cafe - 3 Enchiladas del Norte (2 for Lunch) - Mexican Near Me - Forest Hills, New York

See all

Great as always. Portions are large and prices still reasonable. Hard to believe any bad reviews; probably the competition trying to steal a little business. I can't comment on the drinks again as I've slowed down with that quite a bit. read more

Food was amazing, ambience was cozy and lively. Service was excellent! I would recommend to my family and friends!

If you want to experience every toxic Hispanic household's characteristic in one night, come right on here. It's popular, but usually so are all the places that people who haven't experienced authenticity are usually drawn to, places that will place the Mexican flag all over the walls. The food is good, don't get me wrong -- but you will have to wait at least an hour for a burrito and every dismissive comment from wait staff the moment you ask if everything is okay. We had a few margaritas, a few chips, and we notice that our conversation was running dry. We look at the clock and, oh, we notice it's been 40 minutes since we order. We get it, it's popular but we check. The waiter interrupts my friend just to say "it's coming." 50 minutes since we order: "hey so... we have a show to catch, can you check?" The waiters face looked like we had asked him the most useless question, "wait." It's been more than an hour, and I ask to just round up. We wanted to ask to just pay for the drinks we had and leave, and we weren't heard. "Two minutes." After another ten minutes, it comes out. Waiter has the gall to say "Thanks, bye." Salmon tacos? More like rock tacos; if you have a kidney condition, don't eat this. You're guaranteed another stone. The ground beef is made better by Taco Bell. The steak is the size of a pinky -- pathetic. You know what IS good? The margaritas. It's like they make them strong on purpose so you lose track of time because dinner time will extend to brunch time. I've heard great things about this place; but my first time was enough to let me know, don't come here again. read more

Very nostalgic place . Been coming here for over 25 years . Had many dates here with my now husband . Fortunate enough to bring out teenage children here . The steak salad always hits home . Tender steak perfectly cooked and the most freshest avocado salad with the most fantastic lemony dressing Best frozen margaritas in town !!! Never fails !!! Thank you for the continued great memories read more

See all

I've been going to 5 Burro café for many many years. the food has been consistently steady/ good. The wait staff has been there for years and is really friendly and helpful. The wait times are consistently bad at diner time. The bathrooms are god awful - filthy, disgusting, never cleaned when ppl are sick or pass out. Tonight's experience was no different.... But now I have some new disappointments. Prices went up about 15% - not completely unexpected but the menus reflect original prices and nobody mentions it. However, the portions ie., toco sizes are smaller, and food portions started shrinking a few weeks ago and are down 25% or more. So when you combine it all, 5 Burro cafe leaves me wondering if I should start going to other places for my Mexican food fix. What. U say? Abt ur most recent visit! Hey Marla what's happening? read more

I love this place and come here regularly. First, the atmosphere is chill, usually with great music, which varies from rock to more old popish and Mexican depending on who is working...and the staff gets to know you and seems to act friendly to everyone. Really great place! Usually go for our regular order: 1) Nachos sin carne 2) Chicken fajitas and 3 margaritas but changed it up this time with the Combo Fajitas, the Enchiladas Suizas, and other times we have brought Questo Fundito aficionados from Cali and they were impressed....always been really happy with everything ordered...the food taste, the drinks, its quality, the atmosphere and the staff. Last think the price is great...hope nothing changes so we continue to eat here about once a week for a long time to come... read more

See all

Food is good, just a bit expensive. However, margaritas here are delightful! And Jess the seating hostess is the kindest and most beautiful personality there! read more

A RACIST MEXICAN RESTAURANT ? I've been visiting this restaurant since I was in college. For over 10 years! I will NEVER visit this place again. Today the hostess/waitress a larger woman with short black hair who is usually quite lovely and personable made inappropriate comments about several black and POC people. She even went as far as putting her hand in another woman's face while she held her son who was no older than a year. When I glared at her for doing so she stated. "You know how these people are" and then gestured toward the Hispanic woman with her child. This behavior was disturbing. What was one my favorite restaurant and third place is now a tainted memory. DO BETTER ! read more

This is my favorite go to spot! Casual, fun, the staff is great and I always bring my friends here :)

Food is always good. The later you go, the more crowded and noisier it gets. Great drinks too.

5 Burro Cafe is a must-visit for anyone craving authentic Mexican cuisine. The dishes are rich with traditional flavors, and the drinks, especially the Micheladas, are both authentic and delicious. My gf and I went together for our first meal arriving to NY from FL - she got the cheese quesadilla and I got the chicken enchiladas. The atmosphere is lively and inviting, creating a perfect backdrop for a great meal. The customer service is exceptional, with staff going above and beyond to make you feel welcome and attended to. Whether you're there for a casual dinner or a celebratory meal, 5 Burro Cafe delivers a fantastic dining experience. read more

5 Burro Cafe - Mexican Near Me - Forest Hills, New York

It's Tex Mex We came on a busy Friday Yes, I would come back again Food 3/5 Fajitas--steak 3.5/5 Asked for medium rare, got medium Too much black pepper Flautas--veggie 2.5/5 It's big fat rolls, which makes them deep friend enchiladas instead! It's a unexpected mix of vegetables that would have been better in fajitas. Plain mashed potato would have been better because the veggies were overcooked Drinks Piña Colada--virgin Too sweet even if it had alcohol (Virgin is $4 less than alcoholic) The bar leaves milk gallon out and it gets warm :( Price 2.25/5 For the lack of cooking technique and below average service More expensive than surrounding businesses Service 2.75/5 Our server was chillin at the bar and I had to walk the check up to him from outdoor sitting area They are busy so they don't come by often but when they do, they are friendly just not the most experienced as servers Cleanliness 2.75/5 Bathroom faucets are leaking Floors are wet Bathrooms are tight Back lid lifted Ambiance 3.75/5 It's chill cantina vibes with an outdoor sitting area. It's pregame club vibes read more

5 Burro Cafe - Fajitas De Carne - Mexican Near Me - Forest Hills, New York

See all

No Wine?! No Sangria?! I was appalled! But if they do Margaritas, then that's what it is. Unfortunately I don't do Tequila so I opted for the Strawberry Daiquiri. It was flavorful, but not too strong. It felt good going down though because it was hot up in there. It's a very small restaurant. You will definitely hear the next tables' convo clearly but they bring you water and chips and salsa immediately so you can start eating that and strike up your own convo. The salsa was good. A tad bit spicy for me because I'm a mild one but still good.' I ordered the Salmon Fajitas and my boyfriend ordered chicken quesadilla with a side of rice and beans. My food was absolutely delicious! The salmon was cooked perfectly for me. Tender and the skin was off. The onions were sweet, the rice, the beans, the pico, everything absolutely delicious! My boyfriend enjoyed his quesadilla as well. The servers were very nice and accommodating. They only lose a star because of the bathroom. The bathroom was disgusting. Pee and tissues all over the floor. And the bathroom is so small, you have no choice but to step in it. Garbage toppling over. I was mad I had to use it once I saw it. Otherwise, it was a good time. read more

5 Burro Cafe - Strawberry Daiquiri - Mexican Near Me - Forest Hills, New York

See all

Came here recently and loved it. I'd never been but I'm glad we tried it. Had the nachos to start and they were very tasty. I had the steak salad and it was delicious. The steak had great flavor . Also had a michelada and I usually don't like it with tomato juice but it was very good. Place is very small and you can't sit at the tables unless you're eating . Service was fine. Had a good time . read more

5 Burro Cafe - Mi helada - Mexican Near Me - Forest Hills, New York

So born and raised on the West Coast, I know amazing Mexican food. Coming to NY often, let me tell you, it's been rough finding amazing Mexican food in the city or queens. I've finally found a Mexican joint that I prefer over any in my hometown even! 5 Burro has the most amazing chicken nachos. The chicken is simple and tastes so good! Not spicy, just good chicken. Hard to even explain, just try it. We've tried just about everything on the menu yet we always go back to the nachos! Now the fries, these are a new guilty pleasure. They are fresh cut and crispy fried little pieces of heaven! My "I'm not a fry guy" husband loved em too! Drinks are reasonably priced. The piña colada is one of the best! The place is kinda dark and a bit of a bar like ambiance but really comfortable and great staff too! read more

5 Burro Cafe - Best fries of my LIFE! Just get em. - Mexican Near Me - Forest Hills, New York

See all

Kinda divey joint nestled a few blocks from 71st Ave/Continental on Austin Street in glamorous Forest Hills. 5 Burro Cafe has been here since the 90's, at least since I went to school up the street. Every time I come here the hosts act like your non-existent but it's ok, I come for the nachos and margaritas! Nachos were the bomb yo! Loaded with plenty of chicken and melted cheese, more than enough to share with a fellow compadre. Margaritas were equally explosive, tasted great, no over-pour (please not at lunch). The server came around often to refill our dranks and they weren't stingy with extra salsa. Been here several times, definitely a Forest Hills favorite when I come visit. read more

5 Burro Cafe - Con Pollo - Mexican Near Me - Forest Hills, New York

My favorite Mexican place in the NY/NJ region. Fajitas, tacos, chimichangas and everything else is great. Staff is also friendly. On weekends you can expect a wait so I suggest going early. Don't forget to try their margarita!! read more

See all

This review is off 1 visit with a party of 5 on a Friday night. The one thing that I remember the most from my visit here was the staff. Everyone was incredibly nice and accomodating. They bent over backwards to make sure we were able to get a table, even after we constantly had to delay them. The food and drinks were great as well. Everything from the complimentary chips and salsa to the Enchiladas del Norte, coconut margarita, and flautas we ordered were very enjoyable. The restaurant is a bit small so keep that in mind if necessary. Overall, I had an amazing night with friends and definitely want to return to try more items from their menu. read more

See all

I love eating at 5 Burro Cafe! My food was exceptionally delicious! The staff is highly friendly! read more

5 Burro Cafe - Mexican Near Me - Forest Hills, New York

See all

time and time again my favorite spot in the fhills. i measure other places molé against 5 burros molé

Order: - Chicken Enchilada (4/5) - Al Pastor Tacos (5/5) - Strawberry Frozen Margarita (4/5) - Mango Frozen Margarita (4/5) Pros: - Great tasting food - Large portion sizes - A lot of unique options to choose from off of the menu - You can mix and match different proteins if you get tacos - Free chips and salsa for the table Cons: - Very busy. You will probably have to wait for a seat - Small restaurant; I hope you don't mind sitting shoulder to shoulder with other people - Service can be a bit slow since the restaurant is very busy - A little more expensive than what I had expected Overall: Great tasting food. I will definitely come again but I recommend trying to beat the dinner rush read more

5 Burro Cafe - Tacos Al Pastor & Chicken Enchiladas - Mexican Near Me - Forest Hills, New York

See all