It's always a good sign when you are greeted immediately when you enter a restaurant! And Kade is absolutely incredible welcoming and informative about his pizzas. The vibe is very chill, the music is perfect, not too loud! And the lighting is fantastic! We always go with a half pesto pizza and half red sauce, it's a perfect pizza and we couldn't be happier that Hailey finally has a good pizza place with friendly people! Great addition to the Valley! read more

2 Talls Pizzeria - Half red sauce pizza with Canadian Bacon ! - Pizza Near Me - Hailey, Idaho

See all

Very welcoming place with excellent pizza and salad. Came in to grab our last bite before we had to travel home. This place was very clean, casual and hospitable. The caesar salad came out promptly and was excellent - very fresh and huge portion. We shared a 12" Buckaroo pizza which was fantastic. Highly recommend this place. read more

The fact it was not greasy & had top notch ingredients such as fresh basil, grape tomatoes mozzarella pearls & balsamic drizzle on my Margarita pizza was promising, the sauce was flavorless & runny; the crust was flavorless - very bland. I agree with previous review(s) - Hailey does not need another mediocre pizza place. Too bad, I won't be going back. read more

A delicious thin crust pizza:, crisp as we like it, sauce was excellent and the cheese was creamy and made lovely strings. The chef was TALL! And his smile was even bigger. Recommend fir a casual dining experience. read more

The food was great we loved the bread and cheese knots, the pizza sauce is good, pretty mild, we spiced it up with red pepper flakes. The crust was spot on! The service was fast and friendly. The overall vibe was fun and inviting. The bathroom was clean, and so was the exposed kitchen. The dinning room is family friendly. read more

See all

Amazing food! Great service, they were very nice. We got a table right away and it was warm and quiet so we could talk. 10/10

Although they offer a nicely priced lunch special the pizza is not that great. It's the quality of a cheap gas station pizza...

The advertised gluten free pizza either had gluten in it or on it. The chicken on top maybe? Or maybe just cross contamination from how it was cooked or handled. The items and process need to be reviewed. Thanks. read more

I've had some good and some meh experiences here. Normally, it's good pizza. However, when it's busier I stay away. Every time I've come here when it's busy my pizza is like half done, cheese mostly unmelted and sometimes the dough needs an extra minute or two. That said, I like their menu, it's smaller but good. I will warn you the sizing is a bit weird here. The personal/pan/whatever is tiny for an adult. If I'm eating by myself, automatically a medium. A medium is also pretty fairly priced (even for this area). Though as you go up in size it gets kind of stupid fast. Safe bet: order one size up from what you'd think. They have a decent selection of adult beverages too, but some are ridiculously priced (and prices aren't listed either). So you may want to ask how much before you feel like a douche for grabbing a $13 stout or whatever. If I'm grabbing lunch I am usually able to make it out of here at the $30 mark. While dinner with the lady tends to run around the $50 point. Overall, I like the pizza here and the drinks (pricey or not) are good. Plus, the dudes working here are always pretty chill and unlike most of the places around seem to actually appreciate your patronage. read more

We've frequented this pizzeria several times in the last year. Our first pizza was awesome and we thought we found our pizza place. Unfortunately since then, the pizza has been inconsistent and we feel like we're done with this place. Our major gripe is that they don't put enough red sauce on the pizza. Despite asking for "heavy on the sauce" when ordering, the pizza comes out dry and overloaded with cheese. It's a shame as the staff is very friendly and the quality of the food is good. But if they can't make the pizza we've ordered, we have to go somewhere else. read more

2 Talls Pizzeria - No red sauce under the cheese - Pizza Near Me - Hailey, Idaho

See all

Well let's just say it's hard for me to give a 5 star review, but this place hands down wowed me! I actually got exactly what I ordered! The pizza was the best I've ever had ! The place was immaculate you could eat off the floor ! The staff were amazing and I can't wait to go back !!!! The thin crust was cooked to perfection and I added onions and roasted garlic ! They sent out some of the best garlic knots I've ever tried! Thank you all so much for an amazing meal!!!!! read more

2 Talls Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Hailey, Idaho

See all

Tall Guys is some of the best pizza I've ever had and it is made by some of the nicest people ever. Great pizza, great prices and excellent service. If you're taller than the owners you are supposed to get a free slice of pizza. Good luck with that... the owner is really tall. read more

We enjoyed a thin crust, perfectly prepared 12" pizza which was enough for two adults with some leftover. It was modestly priced and the service was quick on a Friday night. read more

The super tall family does a great job with fantastic flavors on a nice crispy thick crusted pie. Salads are solid and the pie selection is spot on. read more

2 Talls Pizzeria - Pie - Pizza Near Me - Hailey, Idaho

Used the Local Toast App today. Got a Sunny Italian pizza and cauliflower wings to go. Ready in about 15 minutes. Plus the 2 miles there and back. Didn't miss a minute of the game. Everything was hot and delicious. Looking forward to calzones and slices coming soon. read more

Great addition to pizza options in Hailey. Work in progress I feel. Good almost great crust. Sauce is good, almost great. Keep tweaking the recipe and this will be the go to in the south valley. Big fan. read more

This place has the best pizza in the valley! The crust is fluffy, the cheese is luscious and they are always so friendly and very fast service! read more

2 Talls Pizzeria - Garlic knots, tropical pig, and ranchero - Pizza Near Me - Hailey, Idaho

This was our second visit and it was even better than the first. The crust was perfect. We got the combo with extra vegetables and it was awesome. Excellent options for beer or drinks. We have tried every pizza place in the valley but 2 Talls is the best. We will be back every week. read more

Super great, friendly customer service. The pizza/crust is delicious. Hoping they do by the slice! Excited about this place for Hailey. Love a family owned business. read more

Amazing customer service....Beautiful restaurant....nice to see a family run business. However... the pizza was super doughy and not enough sauce. Love to try it again if you make adjustments. read more

We got our pizza to go. It came out fast, but it was still cold. Needed to put it back in the oven. We both found it very bland. The crust, sauce and the vegetables had no flavor, as if it needed salt. I am hoping they make some adjustments, and we will try it again. read more

Flavorless pizza. These people don't know what they are doing. Hailey isn't in need of another mediocre restaurant.

Outstanding experience start to finish! Pizza looks, smells, and taste awesome! Their gluten-free pizza might just be the best GF in the Valley! Nice selection of drinks- beers on tap, canned ciders, hard kombucha and several n/a beer options. We sat at the counter and had the opportunity to talk to Kade, he was personable and professional and took exceptional care of us! Service was incredible! We will absolutely be back! read more

The food was amazing. The staff was very friendly and the back story was very cool. Ambiance was great.

Surprisingly good pizza for this town. BUT, I ordered the Buckaroo pizza, and the mushrooms and onions were RAW. Def need to be sautéed before they're added. Otherwise, the Margarita was very good and the crusts were great - if slightly underdone. read more

Best pizza in the valley. I like the thin crust pizza. And the garlic parmersan knots are very good!

Great new pizza place in the valley! We got the Buckaroo and Sunny Italian and both were yummy.

Super friendly, fast service and the pizza tastes great!!!! I'll definitely be coming back for sure!

Great pies, owner is the nicest guy in the room, and makes sure your experience is as such from greeting to feeding.

This is a must visit in Hailey! Super friendly and welcoming from the moment you walk in the door. The pizza is fresh and flavorful, and the Caesar was crisp and cold with delicious dressing. Great NA Beer selection. Nice clean, efficient restaurant, with great food and a bright future. I will be back in my next time in town. read more