Food, service & ambience ! Going back tonight! Great options…read moreand love supporting local!

Nice spot located near downtown. Drinks were really good, but dinner was amazing. Clarissa was…read moreable to handle our party of 14 with ease. Dinner was great and the desserts were the best. Highly recommend.

We love this place! Food is always top notch, service is great and we love the atmosphere…read more The downtown location makes it a great spot to walk around after dinner and there's even a local ice cream shop near by!

I don't even eat cornbread but ate 1/2 it by myself. The steak bowl was good. Decent quality steak…read moremeat used, tender and moist the potatoes were good and the greens were sweet but good nicely flavored. I was visiting from the NYC area and I will say the food was pleasing to taste. I also taste the fried catfish with the red beans and again I was it disappointed. And everything was very decently priced I spent less than $80 in drinks and meals for 2.

Came in at 830 even though I knew they close at 9…read more Joseph was my server and not once did he rush me at all. Enjoyed the black bean burger and onion fries were on point. Joseph's energy was really nice and enjoyed his customer service. Recommend this place 100% Big plus the restrooms were also very clean.

Stopped for lunch while in town visiting - we grabbed a couple drinks while waiting for a table…read more Espresso martini and a Bloody Mary - both great. Once our table was ready we started with onion rings - but not just any run of the mill, these were crispy, crunchy with minimal grease and the house made ketchup is next level. I had the patty melt on sourdough, with grilled onions and their sauce - so good, had half for lunch and took the rest with me! And the fries, they were perfectly crispy, crunchy and again, minimal grease Shout out to Erica who made our visit smooth and enjoyable!

Bartender was attentive n friendly. The food is always good n prices are more than reasonable. I…read morelove it all but the Italian roast beef with au jus dip is my favorite.

Been gone for 26 years but every thanksgiving when we get back into town this is where we come to…read moreget our pizza and Stromboli fix. It's changed hands a few times and is still good una style pizza portions aren't as big as they once were but that seems like everywhere since Covid but it's still good food

Food is never disappointing that's why it's a place we frequent often!…read moreEven when they are busy the service is always great! The ambiance and atmosphere is great very welcoming!

I ordered a 1/2 Deerhead club sandwich. It is described on the menu as being "thinly sliced turkey,…read moreroast beef, smoked ham and cheddar cheese on a hoagie bun. It does not come with tomato, onion, lettuce of mayonnaise, you have to order it on the side. I also ordered a cup of beef vegetable soup with my meal. What was served to me did not in the least look like what the menu described. It looked like ground beef with cheese melted on top. When I told the waitress that this was not the club sandwich that I had ordered, she assured me that it was their club sandwich. Upon looking at the menu online it appears to be their BBC sandwich instead of the Club. I went ahead and dressed the sandwich with the lettuce, tomato, and onion (I had asked for mayonnaise too, it didn't have any on the side, nor could I see or taste any on the sandwich) I dressed the sandwich and ate it. While it didn't taste bad, the hoagie bun was soft, but the meat and cheese inside were bland and had absolutely no flavor. I didn't taste turkey, smoked ham, or beef. Even the tomato had no flavor. The only thing I could taste was the red onion they served with it. The waitress forgot to bring my soup and I had to ask for it. It was good but could have used more salt. My overall impression of the food was not bad, but I certainly was not impressed. The last time I ate there, I had their Greek Salad (I had been told that it was wonderful, it was not.) I have a lot of friends who love to eat there. I guess I just haven't ordered the right dish. My husband had their Stromboli and said it was very good. I think it will be very unlikely that I will ever go back. The seating was good and the restaurant was clean. Our waitress was nice . Other than forgetting to bring my soup and not correcting my order, she was fairly attentive.

Great flavor on strom, asked for hot , did not disappoint! $13 doesn't seem like much in comparison…read moreto other stroms around town, but I think all of them have gotten too expensive. Price of everything has gone up so it's understandable but still a bit pricey for lunch. Owner was great to deal with, I would recommend a visit here based on the flavor of strom and the welcoming attitude of the man himself

Best thing about this meal were the breadsticks and cheese sauce. In my opinion I would have had a…read morebetter pizza if I stop in at a gas station. Pizza was very bland in my opinion and I would not be coming back for more. This was a one and done for me. Additionally, I added an additional $10 tip for the delivery driver (DoorDash driver), upon arrival I had asked the delivery person if she had received the $10 tip I added. She did not and Dontae's apparently kept it for themselves. Not a great look in my opinion. Hard pass on this place for me.

Very good pizza, Nice outdoor setting too. Good service. Worth the drive from Evansville.read more

Excellent food. Friendly service. Best pizza in the city! My favorite food to order is the…read moreCalzone. Thin crispy outside and a light and soft bread inside, stuff with all that melty cheesy goidnes and loaded with your choice of meat and veggies. Wow! You gotta go try this one!

I've been to a few local pizza joints and I'll be honest, NONE have impressed me. But Casey's…read moredugout, you have it ALL the way figured out! This isn't a restaurant. This isn't a pizza joint. This is home. Exceptional service, delicious food & welcoming atmosphere. The pizza was perfect. From the cheese, toppings & crust. Perfection. And the wings?! Crispy, juicy & they don't skimp on sauce like most places do! And 6 wings for $6? Are you kidding me! In this economy that's unheard of! Also, having SKI on tap? Right on. Other businesses should take note, Casey's is the definition of a perfect business model. I'll be a regular here, and I'll definitely tell my friends and family about this place. Thanks Casey! Keep up the great work boss!

Big supporter of local teams and I really appreciate that. I can get almost the same food other…read moreplaces but I like how they invest in our youth. Good tavern style pizza and sandwiches. Located in an easy to get to part of town.