What a great little place!! Food was fantastic and the staff was so sweet! If you stop by after a day at the beach, you won't be disappointed!! read more

If you're looking for a late night pizza joint when you're coming home from the bars, this is it. We got their white pizza and it was sooo flippin good!! You place your order at the window and there are picnic tables in the front you could sit at. No indoor seating. read more

Zeppe's Pizzeria - White pizza - Italian Near Me - Geneva, Ohio

See all

We went to see a band after dinner and needed a late night snack to take back to the room. This was the place to be on the walk back as all the tables were packed waiting. We opted for 2 slices and luckily they were made fresh and then an order of cookies. Both were very good. The cookies lasted us the whole weekend! read more

The pickle pizza, which was the pizza of the month for June, was awesome! It needs to be added to the menu. Only complaint is that I ordered on the app and went to pick it up. The line was all the way to the road and they expected me to wait in the line to pick up my pizza. They really need to have a dedicated pick up window because after an unexpected 20 minute wait in line to pick up the pizza you were on time to pick up, the pizza ends up cold! read more

Plus: Their regular pepperoni pizza was great. Their pizza has a unique sauce and great pepperoni. The food is perfect for after a night at the bar. Their chicken Philly and bacon chicken ranch subs were also pretty high quality. I would recommend this place to anyone staying in GOTL and looking for a quick bite or needing some food to take back to their hotel after a long night. The staff was super nice during our visit. Downsides: This location has no indoor seating, so if it's chilly, you want to order takeout. There is a patio with a roof so rain is not an issue. If you arrive later, close to closing, you may not be able to get pizza by slice. read more

They cannot take a simple order. This is the second time I've ordered plain wings with no sauce, and both times confirming that multiple times due to the "child" (word that the manager used to describe the worker) asking "what sauce? How many wings? On the side? Okay for both?" " both what, we want one order" "okay" like English was a second language. Then I show up and have to pay for two orders of wings, one mild and one spicy BBQ. Then the manager says that's what I ordered, only to turn around 5 seconds later and say they were made wrong. Like I said, this is the second time this has happened. These people do NOT know what they are doing whatsoever. Also blasting music that loud is goofy. Plenty of other places to get pizza besides this dump. $2.09 for toppings is also insane!!!! read more

Husband got hungry and can't wait. So we ordered one chicken salad and one sub and sit down. The outside sit down area is actually quite good, cool with lots of breeze. Few mins later, The waiter brought two box to us, it's our food. It's actually better than i thought. At least husband is quite satisfied. read more

Zeppe's Pizzeria - a man holding a sandwich - Italian Near Me - Geneva, Ohio

See all

great Gluten free crust and toppings are generous. delicious!!!! outside dining on the street read more

Pizza was good, like the sauce, dough was freshly made and tossed, quick service reasonable wait time for walk up order to go, plenty clean tables for outdoor seating in resort town. read more

Zeppe's Pizzeria - a pepperoni pizza - Italian Near Me - Geneva, Ohio

When we are in the area we try and stop at Zeppe's. We love their Veggie Pizza. It is the best anywhere. We wish we could find one like it at home. The crust is not greasy, the vegetables are fresh and the combination of provolone and mozzarella cheese is a hit. We always plan for a wait but we know it will be worth it. read more

Waited a very long time (several people left before getting their order) and, when it came out it didn't have everything we ordered on it. We dared not send it back and wait forever for the next one. And the pizza itself...Frozen pizza is better than the pizza that we got. One star because you are required to give a star to write a warning, I mean a review. read more

If I could give them a zero, I would! We ordered 2 pizzas, 2 sets of wings and a salad for take out. Upon taking the food back to our house, we discovered we didn't have any dressing for the salad. We also learned we didn't have the correct pizzas. After calling twice for the issues we decided to dive into the wings. They were RAW!!! Pink inside and all! Unfortunately a few of us had bites so we will see. When the driver came to "fix" the issues he made us show him the wrong pizzas and the raw chicken. He was in shock and just said clearly an employee clicked the wrong setting. Huge problem!!! Never go!! read more

Ridiculously long wait and understaffed place. Don't accept online or phone orders if you can't fill them.

The staff is very nice. The pizza takes a while but they have tons of options. I would recommend!!!!

I've never had anything bad from here! My only complaint is I feel the pizza is a little over priced and the wait times are usually horrendous. read more

We ordered 2 pizzas, the margharita, which we loved! The other was the double pepperoni, but we didn't like the sauce, therefore not thrilled. Didn't serve beer, which is fairly necessary with a pizza whilst on vacation! read more

Ate here twice with family this week. We enjoyed it both times. Good pizza and excellent chicken philly. Salads were excellent for a pizzeria read more

We were in town for a short trip. We got pizza, mild wings, and garlic twists. Everything was delicious. The pizza was a little bit garlicky. The boneless wings were the second best I have had, only to Bdubs. read more

Zeppe's Pizzeria - a pizza in a box - Italian Near Me - Geneva, Ohio

Good but not Great pizza. We tried one pizza and one calzone, both had the same issue - the pizza crust was not cooked completely so there was this moist layer next to the veggies and cheese. It was fine for one night and we were hungry - we would return if in the area. read more

Ordered food to be delivered to a nearby hotel. I've had food from other locations of this franchise in the past and was ordering before busy time, so I figured I was safe. Not so. First, food is delivered without my drink - which was the very first thing on the order list. The driver apologized and then went back and returned with my drink. I appreciated she made things right, but meanwhile the rest of my food was getting cold because of someone simply not checking the order before leaving the store. Then, got to my room, opened the main item I ordered - the zepperoni rolls - and they were charred on the bottom. They smelled burnt, looked burnt - clearly inedible. Called the store, and they offered to remake them. I requested a refund of the item price, tip, and delivery fee instead- tired of waiting for food from them. Now we shall see if the refund comes as promised. On the plus side, the store tried to make each issue right. But, I'm not sure how anyone leaves without checking to make sure they have everything in the order or what cook looks at the rolls I was served and thinks it is okay to send them out like that. A lot of issues would be avoided with simple quality control at the store before serving a customer. read more

Zeppe's Pizzeria - a basket of food - Italian Near Me - Geneva, Ohio

I got the pepperoni and meatball calzone and it was unbelievable, tasty and huge. The kids got pizza slices and they could not finish them, I took a bite and was very impressed with the texture and taste. Service was quick and the guy at the window was super friendly. We come to Geneva every two years and I will be back for another calzone in 2017! read more

Was staying at The Lodge and needed to feed a large group. They sell pizza by the sheet full and half. The chicken bacon ranch was different and it's worth trying. Loved every pizza (Supreme, meat extravaganza, and cheese ). Ordered 2 full sheets and 2 larges at 1pm for pickup at 5:30 pm. The pizza was just coming out at that time. The pizza was awesome and it was not greasy. read more

Pizza was great. Fast service and friendly staff. Pizza was fresh and delicious- will definitely be back upon our yearly trip to Geneva

We usually eat here if we take the family to GOTL for the day (we live nearby) because they have gluten free and regular pizza that is super tasty, and the pizza's are really large! We have one gluten-free eater in our household, so this is a place where we can all eat together! read more