Your Pie Pizza

Locally owned & operated

Veteran-owned & operated

Bartenders were amazing while waiting for a table. The espresso martinis were one of the best we…read morehad.

Blueberry Grill was absolutely delicious! Everything was fresh, flavorful, and cooked perfectly.read more

Come hungry. Leave happy. That's the Blueberry's promise.

Sip, savor, repeat. Mimosas and top dishes served all day long.

See all

From pancakes to shrimp & grits, we serve nothing but the best.

Molly Pitcher's American Grill

4.3(229 reviews)

0.5 mi

It was our first time here today and we loved it! They have a great place here…read more Service was great! Food was delicious! We had a reuban sandwich and the desparado sandwich with a cup of Manhattan clam chowder. It was really really good and the ambiance was very pleasing. Very nice inside with an old time feel and so much history. 5 Stars!

We arrived on a very busy Monday night. There were two people ahead of us that only wanted to sit…read moreat the bar, and the hostess suggested the outside bar area, since there was no room. We were next and got the last table for two. The place was completely full. After reading the menu, the daily special was 1/2 price burgers. They also gave first responders 20% off on Mondays. They have specials every night, so it is worth it to check that out before coming in. We started with a basket of hush puppies and corn muffins with yummy molasses butter. If you get in between 3:30 and 5pm, appetizers are 1/2 price Monday through Friday. I can see why this place is so busy! So I decided on a burger, who can pass up half price day? And we also got the knuckle sandwich, which was 20% off for first responders, so my hubs got that. Off to a good start. Also tried fresh squeezed lemonade, really delicious and fair priced. The burger and the sandwich were huge, we both had to take half to go. You get one side for $1.50, but added sides are $4 each. Still ok since the prices are good. There were charges for the added bacon and cheese on my burger but still at half price, it is a great deal. The restaurant is very rustic, pub atmosphere and very relaxed. The bar was completely full, so that must be the highlight of the restaurant. Looked lively and busy. Service is very good, the servers come back to check on you often. Chloe was very sweet and attentive. The only disappointment was dessert. We chose the cake of the day. It was chocolate Bundt cake with cinnamon frosting. To be completely honest, it tasted like boxed cake mix and canned frosting. It was very small, so I knew it was probably cake mix. There was nothing special about this; it was also pretty dry. Even if they purchased their desserts from a local bakery, it would have been better than what we got. I won't say avoid all their desserts, but I wanted to point out the cake specifically. So overall: The prices were excellent, food and service is really great, and the pub atmosphere was nice and comfortable. The plus was that on a busy night, we didn't wait for a table. They do not do reservations so prepare to wait, or just go earlier. I would definitely come back here, and enjoy some more of the large menu. 5 stars

Burger with bacon

See all

Long Island Ice Tea on the deck

Fish Bites Seafood Restaurant

4.4(974 reviews)

6.6 mi

This little out-of-the-way place gets my vote for the best seafood in Carolina Beach! Everything we…read morehad was fresh, flavorful, and delicious--and the best part was that it wasn't fried. They do have fried options on the menu, but we chose the fresh, lighter choices and were so glad we did. The homemade soups were fantastic. He tried both the lobster bisque and the New England clam chowder, and we also had the spinach salad with poppy seed dressing--absolutely delicious! Then we tried the daily special: a blackened shrimp wrap with a side of garlic mashed potatoes. You could tell the potatoes were homemade, and everything tasted fresh and made with care. I honestly can't say enough good things about this place. I wish we had discovered it years ago! Hands down, one of the best places I've eaten in Carolina Beach in many years. We will definitely be back as soon as possible!

Service was great, friendly and prompt. Food was incredible and came out fast and fresh. We had…read moresome raw oysters and lobster bisque. The catch of the day was blackened swordfish and it was fantastic. My wife had the crab cake sandwich and it was amazing. But the part that I loved the most was my son's fish sticks. I half expected Gorton's for a kid but they came out, fresh fried fish and it was delicious. I ended up eating the rest of what he couldn't finish. This wasn't my first visit but it's been years since I was here. Glad to see it's still going strong. It stays as my top recommendation for folks coming to Carolina Beach

Dining area

See all

Back bar

Copper Penny

4.4(1.4k reviews)

3.9 mi

This spot is popular for a reason. The interior is small (only 9 tables and bar seating), but it…read moreisn't cramped at all. There does tend to be a wait on weekend nights. I ordered the fish and chips, and upgraded to the Guy Fieri-approved onion rings. Pretty, fresh, and tasty meal. Also, the portion was perfect and I was part of the clean plate club. Service was friendly, prices were reasonable, overall- great spot!

What happened to the 109 Chestnut?! I have enjoyed it for…read moreyears. Eaten literally hundreds over the years. The last few months they have all tasted bland and dry. The chicken and the bread. I hope you guys are not trending down. It's no longer worth the wait and price... It's hard to say goodbye to such a great spot.

Order pick up!

Onion rings with spicy ketchup.

See all

Bbq wings delivered plain with bbq for those who like it that way

South Front Tavern

4.7(69 reviews)

3.3 mi

2 stars only because food was so good…read more Service was probably some of the worst I've ever had. A table arrived after we got our appetizers and got their food, a box, paid, and left before we even ordered our entrees. Each drink took minimum of 15 minutes and were incorrect. The server had to come back and double check multiple orders. We were not checked on once unless we flagged her down. The list goes on. Will not return unless we order take out.

Came in for dinner at South Front Tavern with two colleagues who between them have nearly fifty…read moreyears of North Carolina under their belts. I'm the St. Louis visitor in the group, here to be educated on what Southern cooking is supposed to taste like. The verdict by the end of the night was mixed. The space itself is cute and clean, with an industrial-chic, open feel inside, but it gets very loud once it fills up, like hard to hear your side neighbor loud. We lucked into a set of club chairs in a corner away from the main dining area, which knocked the noise down enough that we could hear each other. Without that, I'm honestly not sure we would have stayed. The host didn't blink at seating us over there, and the wait staff throughout the night was friendly. Drinks were fine across the table. My grilled peach old fashioned was the only one I tried, and I was hoping for a sharper, smokier profile, what I got leaned peachy without much else going on. The clams my friend ordered had a little grit in them, so not perfectly cleaned, but the flavor was there. The six-hour baby back ribs was a great start, great sauce, not smothered, fall-off-the-bone tender, the kind of thing I'd come back for. I didn't get a photo because we tore into them too fast, which tells you most of what you need to know. After that, things got uneven. The pork empanadas are listed with an ancho chili jam, but no jam or sauce came with ours. The pastry was crisp and tasty, but the pork inside was under-seasoned, and we left a whole empanada on the plate. The crab cakes was the bigger letdown, my friend, who grew up in Maryland and knows what a crab cake should be, said hers tasted more like a flat, minced patty (possibly with fish filler) than actual crab. She didn't finish it. My gumbo ya-ya had chicken, shrimp, and andouille, but the sauce was thin and tomato-forward where I was hoping for, and a richer sauce. Spice was fine; the whole thing just landed middle-of-the-road. Desserts split the difference. The key lime crème brûlée was genuinely excellent, I'd order it again on its own. The North Carolina blueberry bread pudding was beautifully plated but a little dry in execution for use. We left half of it. One thing worth flagging: the restaurant closes at 8:30, and at 8:30 sharp, with us still finishing dessert, the music came on with the unmistakable "we're closed" energy, even though we'd arrived at 7 and no one else was wandering in late. It made the end of the meal feel rushed in a way that didn't match the otherwise warm service. 3.4 starts out of 5. To be fair: we didn't leave feeling the food was bad, just that we'd ordered into the weaker half of the menu. Our server highly recommended the skillet mac and cheese and the quesadillas, and the skillet cornbread looked great online - we just didn't pull the triggers. We have generous optimism a version of this meal that goes much better than ours did, and on a second visit I'd lean into those recommendations. For now, though, with friends in town and a list of places I haven't tried yet, I probably won't be steering people here for your one night in Wilmington. I'd come back to give it a fairer second shot if I lived here.

Interior of South Front Tavern in Wilmington's South Front District.

South Front Tavern's Plancha Burger features Gruyere, Mushroom, Arugula, Tobacco Onion and Garlic Aioli on a Brioche Bun.

See all

South Front Tavern's Bayou Paella Shrimp, Clams, Andouille Sausage, Crawfish, Saffron, Bomba Rice

Elijah's Restaurant

3.6(656 reviews)

3.7 mi

Our hotel staff recommended this restaurant. I really wanted a nice and fresh fish sandwich. It…read morewas just a short walk down the Riverwalk. We went during lunchtime. The restaurant was nice and quiet.. the waiter was really friendly and gave great suggestions. The views from the restaurant was amazing since the restaurant is right on the Riverwalk, you have a nice view of the Cape Fear River. I ordered the fish and chips. The fish was so good! It was nice and crispy on the outside and really flaky on the inside. My husband got the calamari. He said that it was really good. I will definitely go back to Elijah's the next time that I am in Wilmington. It was a great dining experience.

Stopped from our Riverwalk to enjoy a beer in this rather muggy day. Since it's our last night in…read moreWilmington, we decided to eat an early dinner. We started with a nice draft and the baked crab dip. To me the horseradish is a unique ingredient that sounds odd but makes this an excellent dip. Coupled with the garlic bread it is a rather decadent starter. Since we are leaving the coast, we also enjoyed an order of local oysters? Fresh and tasty. I liked the "pico de gallo" and the habanero mango sauce. That made for a new way to enjoy the oysters. And finally, I enjoyed the Cajun shrimp tacos. The shrimp were seasoned and prepared to absolute perfection. Our server Damani was very nice, cheery and attentive. She did a great job and we appreciated that. I was pleasantly surprised with this place. I thought it was more touristy and would be ok at best. But it was one of the better lunches I've had in the past month of traveling up the southeast Atlantic coast.

Interior

"Clam bucket"

See all

Entrance of Elijah's

The River Grill

5.0(2 reviews)

I love this place! It's pretty much the best spot on the river - because you are essentially ON the…read moreriver! It is simple, cheap, and delicious. All of the employees are nice. It's a no-frills kind of place that's great for sitting and grabbing an easy lunch and a beer when you're walking around downtown. Definitely stop here - good food, good drinks, and a great breeze from the river!!

The River Grill, located on the barge where tour boats depart in downtown Wilmington, is the best…read moreburger in town! Super casual outdoor, dog friendly dining environment under the covered open barge! Enjoyed a hand patted super fresh burger on butter toasted kaiser with fries and a glass of cabernet! Perfect spot to kick back and relax watching the world pass by on the riverwalk! The burger can't be beat and the beer is cold! And in a tourist area, it's not easy to find a place where lunch with a drink and a tip still runs less than $10! This place does it right!

Rebellion NC

4.2(291 reviews)

Last week my family held an event on the second floor here. The staff at the bar and that brought…read moreout food worked hard! I had a couple of tasty cocktails such as an old fashioned and an orange-based liqueur cocktail. The food was also very tasty. The sliders, Mac and cheese, fries, and pretty much everything else was fresh and well made. The bar has a great ambiance for a party. Pretty much any drink is makable here with tons of options. You can also catch a sports game here pretty easily with all the TVs. This place has a great staff, good food, and fun vibe. Definitely worth you checking out.

Rebellion is a great spot not only to watch a game but enjoy some great food and drinks. Very warm…read moreand welcoming atmosphere, dimly lit, nice bar area and tons of open seating. My wife and I went there when they had some of their burgers specials and to watch a game. They're veteran owned, have a ton of bourbon and a nice craft beer selection. I opted for the 1836 burger. Was a double patty with tomato, arugula, white American cheese and thousand island dressing served on a nice sesame bun. Tremendous burger, highly recommend. My wife took in some wings which she liked, did wish they were a little crunchier. Nice spot to take in downtown for food and a game, I'd return!

Steak sandwich with taters

See all

Drink

Front Street Brewery

4.1(1.1k reviews)

I'm out of town, like usual, and I decided that I wanted to grab a burger. I turned to Yelp to help…read moreme find the best burger in the area and Yelp did not let me down! I went to Front Street Brewery and got the American Burger. That was a great decision. I had a very long road trip to get to this destination and I wanted to grab something to assist me unwind. I grabbed the FSB Old Fashioned to start and the American Burger to go. The Old Fashioned was amazing! The cocktail brought some serious flavor! They boast about having the largest selection of whiskey and from the looks of the bar, I believe them! The burger was nothing short of spectacular. It was two smash burgers with American cheese, lettuce, pickles, onions, and tomatoes. The price was great for the flavor that I received. This was a great way to start my trip. I cannot wait to come back and try something else on the menu!

Stopped by here with my daughter and some of her friends for lunch. I don't think they take…read morereservations. We had about a 45 minute wait for a table of 6 which was understandable as it was pretty busy at noon on Thursday. Drinks came quickly as we were seated. Appetizers were hit or miss. Fried pickles were surprisingly good and I'm not a pickle fan. However the pretzel was disappointing. Food was comparable to what you would find at other pubs. My smash burger was fantastic. We did have one issue where the vegetarian in our group got served a chicken bowl by accident. However they quickly remedied it and got him what he ordered ASAP. Unfortunately we were mostly done by the time his food came. They did comp the food that was late which was nice. If you are looking for a good bite and tasty beer then I would totally recommend this place.

Bar area

Beer Flight

See all

Mezzanine seating

Two Guys Grille

4.6(158 reviews)

8.1 mi

Amazing find for is on a little weekend getaway. Stopped in on the perfect weather day and had the…read moreperfect lunch. Great food, great service. Just right!

How a cheeseburger, regular old regular, and fries. Two beers. $30 before tip…read more Way too much salt, but an attentive staff. I'm told the philli subs are good, but that was a very expensive, over priced meal.

Things to do in Wilmington

The dinning area.

Blackened Mahi Tacos

See all

Tropical Lightning IPA-- 07-20-2025

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

13 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Mary Ellen H.

8 years ago

This is my 1st Yelp review & Your Pie is a great place to eat! Family friendly, very clean & awesome staff! I have been getting a pie there every week, sometimes twice a week since they opened. They serve pizza made exactly how you want it! Choose from white, wheat or gluten free dough, with fresh ingredients & it is cooked in a brick oven. Salads & Panini for entrees also. Craft beer & wine, gelato, 3 kinds of fresh side salads & brownies. I have had pie from every pizza place in Wilmington & this is my #1 spot from now on! I can't say enough great things about Your Pie! So add it to your list of places to try & you will defiantly be back! read more

Kara M.

4 years ago

This is my kids' go to place to eat out! The absolute LOVE the food and my oldest is a picky eater. The staff is always great with them and gives them the extra dough for the kids pizza to play with while they wait. The gelato is always delicious and the flavors are always changing. The hot honey pepperoni is my favorite! My kids also enjoy the outdoor games they have set up for them to play! read more

Heather G.

6 months ago

Our experience at Your Pie was wonderful! The pizza and gelato were delicious! Each one of us completely cleared our plates. The best part about it was the service. The staff were so friendly and kind. They were extremely prompt and eager to meet our needs from start to finish. Ross and Jason were amazing, and I would highly recommend going there! read more

Michelle F.

4 years ago

This is my favorite Friday date night to take my son! Food is awesome, priced right, great atmosphere and my son loves getting the extra dough to play with..and of course the gelato! Thanks for a great local place to go read more

Carrie J.

9 years ago

This place is amazing! The staff is super friendly and the pizza is so filling. I got a ranch based pizza and I'm amazed that I could put any toppings I wanted on it. I can't wait to return to try the gelato read more

Cory S.

4 years ago

My family loves Your Pie because it's made to order and fresh so everyone is happy! We visit regularly and it's consistently great food and service! read more

Nathaniel E.

7 years ago

A great new way to serve pizza with a friendly and fun staff. The food is great and atmosphere is welcoming. Highly recommend this restaurant. read more

Mac H.

8 years ago

Nice atmosphere. Especially for the kids. Food is very good and fast! Definitely would recommend to friends and family.

Nikita P.

8 years ago

Make your own pizza!!! What can be more better than that... From crust to top, I made my own pizza! It was delicious! read more

Rhee S.

188

8 years ago

Absolutely the only place I can eat pizza without feeling terrible. Perfect portions and delicious.

jacqueline m.

8 years ago

Excellent healthy salad for 7.99 and a kids meal for 5.49 with a drink and a dessert, win win.

N K.

8 years ago

Delicious great concept friendly staff fast service! Lots of options available great prices

Pam W.

4 years ago

this place is GREAT. GREAT for us older and GREAT for the grandkids.

Your Pie Pizza - tradamerican - Updated October 2026

Best of Wilmington

People found Your Pie Pizza by searching for…

People who viewed Your Pie Pizza also viewed

Slice of Life Pizzeria & Pub

3.2

(247 reviews)

Pizza is always good. Chicken wings are also always good. Always have good service as well. Love…read morethis place...

I would give a zero if I could. Went in, walked my wife to the bathroom, and was immediately…read moregreeted with a get the f out if you're not ordering food. When I clarified what was happening, and that my wife needed to use the restroom prior to me ordering food, and that the woman's immediate response was rude, I was told to "get out get out". I've been coming here for over a year, never expected this. won't come again.

Mellow Mushroom Wilmington - Downtown

4.1

(76 reviews)

The ambience was great with all the character and ethos of mellow mushroom in a small little…read morerestaurant nestled in the downtown Wilmington area right next to the waterway and Cape fear River. Her waitress was fantastic, very thoughtful and kind to the kids while being attentive to us and all the details. Choose the type of person you'd want to wait on you again and be happy to leave a large tip.

I was wandering down the street looking for somewhere open to eat dinner when I saw a woman with a…read morepizza box and she directed me to Mellow Mushroom. After my issues at the hotel, it just seemed that I was meant to go to Mellow Mushroom. I had never seen the Mellow Mushroom Downtown as it blended into the larger building. I was greeted when I arrived and seated in the bar area. I don't like high top seating but with the March Madness game on that meant I could watch the second half. My waitress was friendly and let me remove a topping from my pizza as I hate onions. I think she was the manager and doing many jobs at the same time. The white pizza wasn't bad. It was a good size and I couldn't finish it all. I had a pineapple drink that I enjoyed too. I will keep Mellow Mushroom in mind the next time I need a bite to eat in Wilmington.

Michaelangelo's New York Style Pizza

3.7

(88 reviews)

Winner winner chicken dinner lol I have found my favorite pizza spot in Wilmington nc I order a…read moregodfather size half cheese the other half pepperoni why u say because in order to taste the pizza it needs to be simple my brother and cousin wanted pepperoni but they ate my cheese too lol it was so good ask for it well done for that crispy crust the sauce was delicious the right balance of sweet and savory not too much cheese makes it a 9 out of 10 but in order for you to get these same results u have to eat it there fresh out the oven because once it gets cold it's a whole different flavor profile

This place isn't anything to write home about. I made the questionable choice of getting spaghetti…read moreat a pizza spot, but the garlic knots saved the day--super tasty and only $1 each. It's not a destination spot for me, but it's fine enough that I wouldn't protest if a group wanted to go.

Slice of Life

3.1

(80 reviews)

Don't order piece of pizza-order large pizza ! It's really good ! Try with Canadian sausage, green…read moreolives and salami!

We went early on a cold Friday night! We were a party of 6 and sat in their room off to the side…read more(looks like where they sit bigger groups/parties). We were greeted quickly and put in drink orders while we looked over the menu. We were pretty simple, 1 large half cheese, half pepperoni, the other large with half mushrooms and half sausage. The service was good, nothing extraordinary but we didn't require a lot!! The pizzas were good (not New Haven, CT good) but I had been spoiled most of my life. The seasoning was good, the amount of cheese was spot on and one star off because the dough was a bit chewy for me.

Gondolfo's Pizza

3.8

(64 reviews)

Pizza was the best around! Service was great!…read moreBeen down here and tried pizza at many locations. Gondolfo's is still the best!

7/2/26: I stopped by Gondolfo's Pizza while I was in the area and decided to try their 18"…read moreCrostata, which comes with a provolone and mozzarella cheese base, crumbled Italian sausage, whole peeled tomatoes, garlic, Parmesan cheese, and fresh basil. The first thing I noticed was the friendly service. I was greeted as soon as I walked in, and the staff made me feel welcome while I waited for my order. As for the pizza, it just wasn't my favorite. The crust was much doughier than I expected, and I found myself wishing there was more sauce and more of the whole peeled tomatoes to balance everything out. The Italian sausage had good flavor, but the pizza as a whole felt a little too bread-heavy for my taste. That said, I don't want to judge the entire restaurant based on one pizza. Looking at the menu, they have a lot of different specialty pies, and it's very possible I just didn't order the one that best represents what they do. Overall, I'd give Gondolfo's Pizza 3/5 stars. The service was friendly and welcoming, but the Crostata didn't quite hit the mark for me. I would still recommend giving the restaurant a try, and I'd be interested in coming back to sample some of their other pizzas before making a final judgment.

Slice of Life

3.2

(119 reviews)