I went here with a group of friends last week with high hopes. The reviews so far on this place have been very good, so the experience we had was surprising. Very surprising.
Let's get to it... I remember this place from before it was Woodyard Grill. Back then it was Newberry's Deli and Grill it was more of a breakfast and brunch kind of place, with a more rustic home-town feel. Now, it reminds me of a country barbecue place that had a head-on collision with a Hooters. I will say that the interior has been beautifully redone, as the Deli and Grill had seen better times.
The wait staff taking orders and bringing out food appeared to be all-female, dressed in black booty-shorts. I had to check the sign out front a second time to be sure there wasn't an owl on it. They were all nice, don't get me wrong, but an image is set right when you walk in the door.
Our first problem came right at the beginning. One of our folks had a dog, and he did the responsible thing and called ahead to find out if dogs were allowed on the patio area. The response he got on the phone was that it would not be a problem. However, once he got there, he was turned away with a no dogs policy. He had to take the dog home (about a fifteen minute trip each way). There is obviously some miscommunication on policies at the place.
We were seated outside and our drink orders were taken and brought out. We even got some appetizers ordered up. I ordered water, but one member of our group ordered a Dr. Pepper that turned out to be watery. Time to inspect those mixture proportions! Our one missing person showed up again sans dog, and the appetizers arrived shortly afterwards.
One of the things that did not happen with our table was that there was no silverware. When asked, they brought out cutlery for the one person that asked. We then had to ask again for the rest of us, at which point they had to go back inside the building and get more, which means that they have no wait stations for keeping things like cutlery, napkins, or other items necessary for maintaining tables except inside, despite half of their seating being outside.
I had ordered some wings (hot) and the other end of the table ordered some mild. The mild wings were probably a step or two above mild, and may have generated complaints from anyone looking for truly mild wings. Meanwhile, my hot wings were anything but. They were spicier than the mild (despite claims from others) but in my book they were mild, and the addition of your standard hot sauce from the store would have brightened them up. Throw in that they were relatively scrawny and I would rate their wings as less than average.
There are two issues with sitting outside here. One is that the road noise can be extreme because the clientele typically drive large pickup trucks with exhaust systems that were not meant to actually reduce noise.The second is that when they have the fires running you have a problem of ash falling down on your food and into your drinks, which is taking barbecue a bit far.
After waiting for twenty minutes, our waitress came back and took our food orders. I ordered the Woodyard Burger, which is a cheeseburger with onion supposedly cooked in the meat itself and coleslaw on the burger. This can be very tasty when done right... key words there. We also had ordered an impossible burger and the ribs, among other things. My burger just didn't have any taste. I could taste the coleslaw, but that was about it. The burger meat and everything else was simply bland. The ribs tasted as if they had not been truly smoked, but instead someone had gotten into a fight with a toddler over a bottle of liquid smoke. Apparently the impossible burger was even worse. It was bland, dry, and there were extra pickles on it instead of no pickles as ordered. To their credit, this was taken off of the bill, as the person that ordered it took all of two bites.
It was about this time that the karaoke started. I will give the guy running the karaoke credit in that he was good, and the first half dozen or so songs that were performed by various people were also decent. Eventually liquid courage from the bar gets people up there that should never try to hold a tune. I am not giving the rating I am giving because of the karaoke, however. That is one of those elements that some restaurants have. However, the volume level of the music was on the wrong side of what should be appropriate, so they get a hit for that. This was what eventually forced us to leave, by the by.
There were some good things. The fries were very good, and an interesting shape (one that I have not seen, actually). The garlic bread was apparently also quite good. That's it.
So yes, that is what I experienced. I really did have high hopes for this place, because the other reports from my fellow Yelpers have all been so good. I just... I can't give them a good rating myself. It was not good. We (my group) will not be back. read more