Food was excellent - cool, old timey atmosphere and friendly service too! We went for dinner during…read moreopening weekend for a bachelorette and were able to text ahead to get a reservation. Loved that! Highly recommend the spinach salad and artichoke dip for starters.

Place is unique and a really special atmosphere. Food is done well…read more Biggest negative is cost. I know, ever since Covid no one seems to care but still. They do not publish costs on their specials page. $130 for 1 fish fry and beef Wellington with 2 manhattans. Tip on top of that brings you to $150 I wish them well but know we all can do our part to be more realistic and successful together so there are more happier returns and patrons.

Wow, so glad we went! From the delicious food, through the great service, all accompanied by a…read morespectacular sunset, it was an awesome evening. Ben was our server and was impeccable. He had great suggestions and paced our courses well. We started with the wedge salad which was way better than the traditional wedge salad of bygone days. Everything was so fresh and the bacon was delicious. Baby lamb chops were cooked perfectly. And the sauce was yummy. Shrimp and grits were good. Halibut with lemon risotto was great too. We split everything so we'd get to taste it all. And we topped off the meal with a slice of their carrot cake. Moist cake with excellent cream cheese frosting elevated by a caramel swirl and birthday message!

Wow - blown away by this place. First of all, came in off the street - the hostess was so sweet and…read morewas able to seat us right away despite having a larger group. We were seated with a nice view and our waitress was so so nice, she told us all the specials and talked us into some oyster shots - which were surprisingly outstanding. The drink I got was using a pea infused vodka which was unusually refreshing and I mean, look at that presentation For the food, whitefish dip was also unusually good. The best thing was the steak with potatoes and carrots. The other star of the show was the sweet potato. I had high hopes for the pasta but unfortunately was a little let down , I liked other things more than this entree. Overall, I was to come back to this place I liked it so much. Ambiance, food and service all on point.

Another terrific meal at Wild Tomato! Pizza and family style…read moreCaesar salad was yummy! We will be back soon

Wild Tomato has two locations in Door County, and we visited the one in Sister Bay--a very popular…read morespot! When we arrived, we were told there would be a 1-hour wait for a table and a 1-hour wait for takeout. A wait that long is a bit much, but Door County is super popular in the summer, and we used the time to walk around the marina and explore the area. Their wood-fired pizzas are $23 for a small and $27 for a large. We ordered takeout, and our food was ready right on time after about an hour. The pizza was great, and I would definitely go back next time I'm in Door County. There's also free street parking nearby, which makes stopping in even easier. Just remember to go early if visiting in the summer to avoid long wait times!

Spent 3 nights in a king size room (unit 21) at the Settlement Courtyard Inn in June 2025. Great…read morelocation right outside of Fish Creek. Checking in was quick and easy which was lovely. They gave me a key with a huge wooden keychain so it would be hard to lose the key. Made it hard to walk around with. Later on after I was getting settled I went back down to the desk to ask 2 simple questions and the person at the desk didn't know the answers to my questions which was a little weird. Maybe a new staff member for the summer. The room had that quaint, countryside feel. It does have a musky scent when you first walk into the room. Once you're in there for a couple of mins you don't notice it anymore. Everything was very clean with the exception of the tub in the bathroom that had some hairs left behind by the former guest and some microscopic bugs by the sink. It was great having a full fridge and microwave which I used both. No stove or oven so keep that in mind. The temp in the room was great and can be changed whenever you want. The bathroom has small vials of shampoo, conditioner, lotion and bath/body gel - keep that in mind cause I'm always used to hotels having a huge refillable container of all those products. The TV is a regular tv with local and national channels. No logging into different streaming platforms if that's your thing. The Pool - spent a little amount of time there. The temp of the heated pool was great. Towels are available at the pool. The recliners aren't the most comfortable for a position to read but I made do. Breakfast - I went to the little nook in the morning for breakfast but only got a coffee and hard boiled eggs once. They had cereal, and some other items. I'm not much of a breakfast person. Parking - lots of parking. You'll register your car with the front desk. The only comment on this is that they need desperately to redo the lines in the parking lot cause it was hard to tell if they were specific spaces at all. Location - I think the location is perfect to hop down to Fish Creek or another neighboring bay city. It was central to everything I felt and Fish Creek ended up being one of my fav places to hang out and walk around. So many shops and restaurants.

This place is old, outdated and way too far from town. When we first drive up it' was a…read moredisappointment. A few shops just lingering there, only pie shop seems to have any business. Rooms are dirty.

Nice resort style hotel with nice rooms and a pool area for family time . Rooms available for rent…read morefor birthday parties as well

GOOD- full kitchen for staying in and relaxing. separate heat and tv in each room to appease…read moreeveryone. space. fireplace. jet tub. young man Friday afternoon at counter and nice lady that checked us out today. BAD - rest of the staff. horrible beds I'm in so much pain I never hardly slept. dirty walls and top of fridge. jets in tub need serious cleaning. dark black spots in grout. but worst handicapped parking. nothing is clearly marked and on ground it's half covered in snow and ice. people constantly illegally parked and staff really don't care. at the very end of your parking lot u have one spot with an actual upright sign. in winter especially not being accessible and clearly marked and cleaned and enforced by police is not ok with a child in a wheelchair in dead of winter. for what you charge, and up charge for Saturday night versus Thursday and Friday night it's definitely not worth it. will look somewhere else for next visit.

Very quaint inn. We stayed in room #1. Loved that it was the only room down the hall and our…read moreentrance was private The furnishings were in keeping with the era of the building . We had a queen size bed. There was also a small fireplace (gas) and a whirlpool tub. Cute patio , that faces the bay. The view is slightly obscured by trees and marsh grasses. The usual amenities. Mini fridge, one cup coffee pot and hair dryer. Unfortunately, we found the bed to be extremely uncomfortable. It was like laying on the floor. The pillows were down, but the kind that flattened and stay flat. The water in the shower is just gross. It left you feeling slimy. Never clean. My hair was a giant knot, no matter how much conditioner I used. Unfortunate. There is no microwave in the room. However , there is one by the coffee bar in the lobby. They also had a mini fridge with juices and flavored water. They did not offer water or ice anywhere. This was a huge inconvenience. We drink a lot of water and ice would have been nice. We did end up buying a case of water. As cute as the Blacksmith inn is, I would not go back. If you're not getting a good nights sleep it really affects your vacation. And not feeling clean after showering ick

We always love our stay at the Blacksmith Inn. It's like coming home! We enjoy the views, room,…read morepeacefulness of the Inn. The breakfasts are yummy and delivered hot and at the time we requested. If we expect to be a bit hungrier we order a bit extra. Never do we leave hungry! We enjoyed the coffee/brewery down the block called Sway. Always return home distressed!

All can I say is WOW! What an amazing dinner I had recently at Alexander's. The place gives an up…read morenorth higher end supper class vibe, I love all of the fish and seafood on the menu! I had the salmon and it was fantastic, and everyone else I was with loved their fish fry (the serving was HUGE!). The service was great as well, we never had an empty breadbasket or lacked water! definitely going back

Dined here about five years ago, and I just cooled off enough from that experience to talk about…read moreit. The hostess was pleasant and smiling, but the wait-staff were unprofessional through-and-through. Not a single smile was seen on a single server's face. Furthermore, the attitudes of the wait-staff made dining uncomfortable. I recall having ordered a steak, which was unremarkable. I'll never return. I suggest you avoid this place.

The price for the room and a delicious breakfast every morning is very reasonable for a tourist…read morearea.A nice self serve coffee tea bar all day long. We stayed in room 102. It was very nice. It has a sleigh bed that I believe is a double bed. The mattress needs to be updated. It was kind of uncomfortable.

It seems like when we want to visit Door County, everybody else has the same idea duh!  So like our…read morefirst visit last fall, we nabbed the last available room at our chosen hotel, and it was Church Hill Inn this time around. They have a great location atop a hill on main thoroughfare Highway 42, and a short 5 minute walk away from the heart of Sister Bay's vibrant commercial strip.  They are also a relative good value and get bonus points for having an English theme.  Having had many memorable and pleasant stays in the UK, any place that takes me back is a plus, and this place did that to a degree.   The owner and innkeeper Mike was at the desk when we arrived.  He's my kind of guy - a friendly Brit with a sense of humor.  When I said we had a party of 2 for 1 night, he dryly replied "Oh, but we have you for a party of 1 for 2 nights". As I rolled my eyes, he broke out into a chuckle, ha.  He's a native of Portsmouth, England and has owned and run this nice property for 25 years.  The 2-story property is homey, inn-like and not hotel-like, nicely and quaintly decorated in English style, and has a bar and several cozy sitting areas.  There's a 24 hour complimentary bean grinding coffee machine and the bar works on a self service guest honor system.  A swimming pool is also available in the back for those interested.  The included breakfast is comprised of a large and delicious selection, and their particularly delicious almond Danish pastry was more pie like and quite distinctive.  Each room has a name (ours was #104, the Winchester) and a small patio and it was comfortably laid out.   I really want to give this place 5 stars particularly for its location and value and theme but will have to hold back to 4 stars.   The reasons being that I didn't get a great sleep because 1) the pillows were too spongy and soft for me, 2) the king bed was a bit soft and bouncy, and 3) the wall A/C was quite loud when it kicked on briefly and frequently.    We may be back someday during the quieter heating season and try a different room (i.e., bed) also.  I may also start bringing my own pillows as my pillow complaint is not uncommon and not aimed just at the Inn here.  I really do like this place and the owner.

Julie's Cafe is simply excellent! Great food, service, & ambiance!…read more I chose the "Texas Eggs" and it was simply delicious, an absolute not miss! So much flavor! :-) The $0.50 upcharge for the sour dough toast was well worth it. I would have liked to have tried the cinnamon roll but no more room, what a lovely dessert it would have been! The coffee was plentiful & tasty. All in all a lovely experience from start to finish! Thank you, Team Julie! :-) Thank you, Patrick Shaughnessy Chicago, IL

I feel like for where you are and what you need at the moment, this is a quick fix. It just didn't…read morequite hit the spot for a good brunch meal- the hash was more on the greasy end, the Belgian waffle just reminded me of the ones you get at the hotels you make yourself, and the French toast wasn't evenly cooked through. The sourdough bread was maybe the part of the meal that was most worth it. Unfortunately, missed the mark for brunch. Plenty of parking though.

Friendly staff. Nostalgic setting…read more Delicious food. Butternut squash soup was very tasty, as was the roasted vegetables sandwich. Giant French toast was delicious, too.

My husband and I stayed at the White Gull Inn and ate at the restaurant three times, twice for…read morebreakfast and once for dinner. The food was great for dinner. I loved the dinner rolls. Breakfast was hit or miss depending on what you ordered. The eggs in my eggs benedict were overdone, which was a bummer. Prices are high, but that is expected of Door County. The Inn itself could really use an update. It's stuck in the 90s, and not in a charming way. Everyone who worked there was nice. I think we'd return to have dinner, but I wouldn't stay here again (despite the really good cookies you get).