Every time I go there, the line is quick, the ice cream is perfection, and the staff is pleasant. I…read moretypically get a twist with sprinkles, but I have gotten the buckeye sundae and it is truly awesome, they put so much Reese's into it. Love this place and frequent it during the summers!

The Dairy Hut is a total hidden gem with big nostalgic energy like if your childhood and a brain…read morefreeze had a baby. The staff is always super sweet (pun intended), and even when there's a line, it moves pretty fast. We ordered a Oreo Blitzer, Buckeye Sundae, and Strawberry Shortcake Sundae and they didn't disappoint . Everything is affordable, old-school, and just hits different when the weather's hot and you need a little serotonin swirl. Definitely go with friends, your kids, or a cute date. Or just yourself. You deserve a cone and some peace.

I love the atmosphere with the decorative front porch and old school seating inside. So many…read morechoices for ice cream, sundaes, and shakes. I went with a simple butter brickle ice cream scoop. It was delicious especially on a hot summer day. The servers were quick and efficient. We will be back!

Pros: The were open on a chilly Easter Sunday…read moreTastes using regular spoon instead of plastic - the Earth thanks you! Super creamy ice creams with lots of flavor options Friendly service Cons: 6 dollars a scoop The caramel flavor didn't taste anything like caramel. If I closed my eyes I would have guessed it was vanilla. I'll try another flavor the next time. Pro tip: If you are visiting Buckeye Lake, it's worth a visit for the novelty.

I had breakfast at the Nutcracker today and it was the best meal I've had here. They added potato…read morecake hash browns (like McDonald's only better) to the menu. Our server said they added these about two months ago. They were a very good accompaniment to my Country Fried Steak, sausage gravy, two eggs over medium, and rye toast. And Nutcracker actually butters your toast!! Some places put such a tiny amount of butter on the toast it may as well not even be there at all. The coffee here is good too. The diner is decorated with hundreds of nutcrackers and old Pataskala memorabilia. Our server was excellent; friendly and attentive making sure we were well taken care of. Overall it was a delicious breakfast!

A breakfast order consisting of two pancakes, two eggs, and a sausage link…read more A children's breakfast option including sausage. Corned beef hash is available. The wait time on a Saturday was under ten minutes.

I managed all pandemic to avoid this place because I knew it'll be ALL BAD for my sugar tooth lol…read moreHowever I had the pleasure of checking it out with my family yesterday. Greeted immediately and staff was super helpful and patient with me as my 4 yo was a little undecided. She got the Over the Rainbow roll with strawberry ice cream. It's offered with a syrup of our choice but we opted out as the strawberry and fruity pebbles toppings were perfectly paired. I couldn't resist the lobster roll. Made it a jumbo to spilt with my bf. IT WAS SO DELICIOUS. A buttered bun with enough lobster meat to be considered a meal item. Lightly seasoned with what seems like an Old Bay, parsley and butter. I'll definitely be back for another. All was a little over $30. Definitely worth it. The assistant manager Tanisha and cashier S

We came in at 8:40 pm on a Sunday for three lobster rolls and was still greeted with a smile. We…read morehaven't eaten them yet, but this isn't my first rodeo. It was delicious before, but I needed a little salt. Hubby is so excited he started dancing. ;) I can't lie, I'm excited too.

OMG!!! This is a gem located in the middle of this residential area. They have plenty of options…read moreavailable. Their service is good. They helped explain their menu. They are good for sit-down and take out. They also have outdoor seating. It is good for family friendly and business casual. There is a huge parking space right in front of this ice cream place.

| Johnson's Real Ice Cream - New Albany, OH 160 W Main St,…read moreNew Albany, OH 43054 Visited: Aug 3, 2025 | Takeout -- What we ordered: * Jr. Scoop (Butterscotch Toffee) - Sugar Cone - $4.25 * Single Scoop split 1/2 Butter Pecan + 1/2 Butterscotch Toffee - Sugar Cone - $4.75 We asked for cups on the side -- these were two-handed cones, no question. -- Flavor notes: * Butterscotch Toffee: Buttery, smooth, with soft bits of toffee that didn't overtake the bite * Butter Pecan: Heavier on the pecans than the flavor. The base leaned a little plain -- almost watery in taste -- but it was full of nuts and held texture well. Melt-wise, it held up just long enough to enjoy without rushing -- not that artificial stuff that sits like wax, but not soft-serve-level meltdown either. You've got a comfortable few minutes before it starts sliding. -- Total: $10.98 (with tip) -- Quick info: * Wait time: 5-10 min * Parking: 1-hour signs closest to storefront; rest of the lot is unmarked and free * Seating: benches + brick ledge outside * Noise: chill, steady foot traffic * Accessibility: Yes * Allergy info: clearly posted * Dairy-free: Yes (coconut-based and sorbet) -- Would I come back? Absolutely. The ice cream was good, the scoops were serious, and the side cup wasn't extra -- but it was essential.

This Graeter's Ice Cream is open till 10:00 PM on a Sunday evening! I joined their loyalty program…read morea few years ago and they emailed me an offer too good to pass up. I received a free birthday sundae! I ordered the Tower 1870 and it was amazing. I love the raspberry chocolate chunk ice cream anyway and then to top it with hot fudge, whipped cream and pecans. Wow! But, that is not all... there was a piece of chocolate cake hidden in the bottom of the dish like a found treasure! Delicious! The service was quick and the restaurant was spotless. We will definitely be back!

I guess somehow we've never been to this one…read more Odd location, little lot alongside and big one in back, so be alert at busy periods. Inside, not as big as I expected. Some tables, plus a little wall to sit on outside. Friendly patient service. The kids tried several things. I tasted the Skyline, which is really not chili flavored. Pretty much cinnamon ice cream with what seems like pie crust chunks (actually crackers.) Not bad, not weird, not spicy. A bit of a letdown for me; I expected a challenge. Ended up with seasonal lemon meringue pie, which was excellent. Prices aren't bad. I'm sure we will be back.

I love Graeter's and had to come try their new flavor - Flying Pig Tracks, vanilla with peanut…read morebutter cups and fudge swirls. It was good but wasn't as fudge-y as I had anticipated. Still a good treat after dinner. This location was super clean, workers were good and fast and great at multi-tasking. It's a warm spring day so the drive thru was pretty busy but I was able to get served in a timely manner.

Ice cream cake we ordered awesome. Picked it up tonight and realized a 20% tip was added to this…read moreorder. Why am I tipping on an online order? Who am I tipping, the young man who provided service wandered around the store looking for this order for three minutes. Am I tipping him for not looking in the cooler he was standing next to when he asked me what I wanted? $39.99 for the product and 20% tip with no prompt or notice of a tip.

Cute ice cream shop next to a pizza place. They carry Velvet ice cream and had lots of flavors…read more Some seating inside and two picnic tables outside. We just got a few scoops of ice cream but there do have fancier sundaes. The only thing that I could see becoming an issue is the trash can is right beside the door and picnic table. Could see bees being a problem when warme. There are a few parking spots right out front.

Delicious Velvet Ice Cream wrapped in this cute little package!…read more Get pizza at Lakehouse (one of the best pizzasnext door and desert here!

When I saw their Banana Cream Pie cupcakes on social media, I was ready to order. This is the…read moreSunday special for March. Each month they have a cupcake of the day. I ordered 6 cupcakes for Sunday pick up. I got an email when they were ready and I headed over. Friendly service and delicious, moist cupcakes. My chosen flavors: 2 BCP, 2 Strawberry Shortcakes, 1 Boston Cream Pie, and a Birthday Cake. It's in Stoneridge Plaza, facing Hamilton (close to 101 Beer Kitchen). Plenty of parking. Very reasonable pricing. They also have cookies, and ice cream, made in-house. I will definitely order again.

Cute sweets shop located in the Stone Ridge Plaza. I went in the early evening so I didn't get to…read morechoose from a full menu. I came in only for ice cream but the cupcakes looked so good I had to get both. I went with the Cookie Butter Cheesecake ice cream which is always part of the menu. It had great chunks of cheesecake and that homemade taste. Yum! Went with a classic flavor for the cupcake, Strawberry Shortcake. My favorite part was the filling. It wasn't too sweet. They also have daily special flavors. Today was Pumpkin S'mores. I didn't get a chance to try their cookies or cakes. There is also indoor seating if you want to enjoy your treats immediately. Only gripe was I wasn't offered a bag for my treats. Overall great place to fix your sweet tooth cravings.

Oh Libby Lou's what a place!! This place is every child's dream come true, so many options and so…read moremany sweet treats. They are right by Studio 35 in a small location Service can be slow as they make everything fresh to order like waffles and crepes We enjoyed the S'mores Waffles which was simply delectable and delicious. They have several options for you to mix and match You can choose from various variations of ice creams to toppings to crepes or waffles Place is tiny and quaint so nothing fancy about it. Definitely amazing experience for anyone who loves a good dessert

Tara sold us a squishy that broke open before the next morning. Tara acknowledged that the glue was…read morefaulty, then wanted us to pick up at her place (a half hour away) or go to her next event. Customer satisfaction is FIRST for a small business, especially when you are at fault.