Love Graeter's! There's several ice cream options in Dublin, but when I want black raspberry chip - there is only one place to go and that is Graeter's! All of their ice cream is delicious though and appreciate that they happily offer samples. I tried a sample of their Skyline Oyster crackers - unique! Took me a little to the spices in the fall and the oyster crackers gave it some texture (I thought in a good way!). Black Raspberry Chip is so good! The chips this time around felt much larger (nickel size) than I've had in the past (I prefer smaller ones), Great place with seating inside and out! The staff is friendly and keep the line moving. read more

Graeter's Ice Cream - Black Raspberry Chip - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Dublin, Ohio

Stopped in quickly for a couple of to go pints. It was busy but service was quick. Many flavors to choose from. We have both a Graeters and Jeni's in Pittsburgh where we traveled from. Definitely more bang for your buck at Graeters but more creative flavors at Jeni's. We were satisfied with this stop over Jeni's not far away. read more

Graeters is amazing!!!! It's a cute little local ice cream shop and always happens to be very busy, I assume it's popular with the locals. My first couple times going there, I had to disclose that I have a peanut allergy because I got a cone (I've worker at Culvers, I'm familiar with how they store/use all the ice cream scoopers in the same water and for multiple different flavors), and I felt that one of the workers (a girl, I didn't get her name) was annoyed about it. I get it, having an allergy is embarrassing enough and I know there are annoying protocols, especially when I feel not all those are necessary to follow for my SPECIFIC allergy, but the workers have to follow it all, and for that I'm sorry!! Eventually I just started getting their Island Blast smoothie because there would be no space for cross contamination there with the shake machine or ingredients, and it was so, sooo good! It obviously wasn't real fruit that they included, you can tell it was artificial flavoring or powder/juice, but nonetheless it was still delicious!! Highly recommend this place, they have tons of flavors and will let you sample them before you commit! read more

Graeter's Ice Cream - Menu - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Dublin, Ohio

See all

Best ice cream around with sooo many choices and great service. Highly recommend this as a go to place

Great ice cream every time. They're a throwback to when REAL ice cream couldn't be beat and you'd laugh at the notion of soft serve. Great variety of flavors and seasonal selections. Graeter's is hands down the best ice cream in Columbus, possibly all of Ohio. read more

Jennifer needs a raise I got a butter pecan milkshake and my husband got a smores/pecan milkshake and they were both delicious. The place was packed but somehow still squeaky clean and FAST service. They have a free water station which I thought was super cool in today's world. read more

Very good. Shout out to Diana V for picking up a few flavors to bring home: Buckeye Blitz: Chocolate peanut butter ice cream base with peanut butter cookie dough and chocolate chips. Very decadent. Packed with flavorful and sweetness. Key Lime: Flavored with real key lime juice and complimented by graham crust. Wonderful bright, citrusy flavors combined with the hearty crunch/bite of the crust. Yum - a fantastic limited edition offering. There's so much good ice cream throughout Central Ohio, yet Graeter's remains a timeless classic. It's definitely richer and sweeter than competitors given their French Pot style, but oftentimes that's exactly what one wants. Enjoy. read more

See all

Service is great, the ice cream is delicious and is made quite quickly. Tables are also clean and it has a nice interior.

It really is as good as people say. We are very fussy ice cream eaters. We avoid grocery store brands. We had the seasonal peach ice cream. Wow! Creamy, with real pieces of peach. The coffee wasn't too bad either. There is a fun shop as well, all things Graeter's. Good service. Fair prices. Can't wait to go back. read more

Graeter's Ice Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Dublin, Ohio

I remember being a kid in the 90s and my parents taking me to Graeter's. Now I've moved away and have my own kid, but whenever I come back to Ohio I have to come to Graeter's and share it with my son. Best ice cream anywhere! read more

Graeter's Ice Cream - Black Raspberry Chip - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Dublin, Ohio

Had to get the famous black raspberry ice cream. It was delicious to say the least. Just the right amount of tart and dark chocolate. The ice cream itself is very smooth. Service was great, will definitely be back! read more

Graeter's Ice Cream - Black Raspberry - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Dublin, Ohio

Graeter's serves the best ice cream. My favorite is the black raspberry chip, They also have a chocolate and peanut butter ice cream Called Buckeye Blitz. This is also good. read more

I live very close and visit here a lot, but today I wanted to try the "Cheesecrown" limited edition ice cream, and it is so good. I asked for it to be made into a drinkable shake, and she did a great job, perfect flavor and drinkable. You can either eat inside or go outside, and there are about 4 benches to sit out, especially if it's a nice day. The customer service is incredible every time I visit. Always a smile and a greeting followed by some delicious samples. If you have a chance to try cheescrown and this place go for it, it's #delicious read more

See all

I don't have all night for your employees to be flirting with the girls. He stopped making my order 8 times to walk over and talk to them. Then he was jealous the other coworker was talking to them. So, again, he stopped working on my order. YOU ARE THERE TO WORK read more

It's getting to the point where I've reviewed so many Graeters' on Yelp that I need to make it a personal goal to review all of them! All in good time, I guess! Well if you can't tell from my Profile Pic, I am obsessed with Graeter's. I'm such a mega ice cream fan and you can find me at multiple scoop shops within a given week, especially in summer! I always love that Graeter's hasn't strayed from their french pot process making only 2.5 gallons at a time. They've been in business 150 years, so that in and of itself means RESPECT! I remember having Graeter's the first time as a kid and I was blown away by how good it is. The best part (as most fans would agree) are the mega chocolate chunks in any of their chip flavors. My sister and I used to compete for who had the biggest chunk left in their ice cream! My personal favorites are Double Chocolate Chip, Peanut Butter Chip, Black Raspberry Chip, Strawberry and Buckeye Blitz. I also love the new 150th Anniversary Birthday Cake! This Graeter's location is in a business area of Dublin. Lots of great seating outside-- I was able to enjoy my ice cream and overlook a small pond. The girls working inside were super nice and friendly! I saw so many other families enjoying their ice cream on a Sunday afternoon-- Graeter's is all about community and I love that! A must try whether you're an Ohio native or if you're just passing through the area! read more

Graeter's Ice Cream - National Ice Cream Day 2020! Strawberry, chocolate and birthday cake on a waffle cone. Yum! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Dublin, Ohio

We love Graeter's but tonight was a HORRIBLE experience. We were eating ice cream with our family and the ceiling started leaking. One of the employees said "this is what we have to deal with." We took a video of the situation because it was comical how they handled the situation. Natalie started yelling at us about it. Do NOT recommend, horrible service. read more

This is absolutely the best ice cream I have had. Blackberry chocolate is my favorite.

When you walk in it smells exactly what you'd expect an ice cream shop to smell like! Great service. Fun flavors. Lots of treats to purchase. read more

Out of this world ice cream flavors! I mixed the carmel cream and the Local flavor that is peanut butter chocolate and nuts! oh my was it so smooth! read more

My second trip to a graeters location in two days. Being in town this ice cream is a necessity. It's the best ice cream around. Chocolate chunks are absolutely to die for. Black raspberry chip and mocha chocolate chip are sooooo delicious. Friendly staff. Reasonable prices for what you get. Highly recommend graeters. read more

I will always love their ice cream, but I was not a fan of my serving size the night I came. For $4.00 I thought it should be a larger serving. I know we came in ten minutes before closing not sure if they were not happy about that. Their indoor seating is greatly reduced due to covid regulations but you can sit out side read more

There was a day when I thought my opportunity to have really good ice cream was a past event. I have had Halo and other ones that are low glucose related. I was vacationing in Columbus and entered a Graeter's asking if they had any low glucose ice cream. They explained that they use Monk Fruit as a sweetener and gave me a sample; I about fainted. Let me be clear, their Mint Chocolate Chip is just amazing and the Madagascar Vanilla Bean is also excellent. They have all of your other ice creams too and their quality is excellent. For my family they love going because of unique flavors that are always consistent and delicious, but if you need low glucose solutions this place will be your dream. I always go with a cooler and bring home extra pints so I have my treats for weeks to come. read more

You can't beat an ice cream cone in the summer time (or any time, really). This Graeter's location is great because they have a ton of parking spaces and lots of tables inside to enjoy your ice cream. If the weather is nice, there are benches to sit outside as well. To be honest, there are other ice cream shops in town that I like way more than Graeter's, but if you're looking for friendly service and a variety of flavors, this is a good place for ice cream. There have been tons of families/kids during every visit at this location, so be prepared to wait on kids who can't decide what ice cream they want to order. I'd personally rate the ice cream a 3 of 5 but the overall experience warrants a 4 of 5. I'd come back for the s'mores flavor and the friendly service. read more

Not only did i find a disgusting piece of hair at the bottom of my ice cream, i also went to this establishment with my service dog and was asked not just once but 3 times if he was a service dog? read more

Graeter's Ice Cream - Hair at the bottom of my ice cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Dublin, Ohio

I looooove Graeter's, and this seems to be the closest one to my apartment. Not complaining at all. In the summer, though, even at 9 PM, the line seems to be all the way to the door. Guess everyone else loves Graeters as much as me. The staff is always friendly. This location is nice because the seating area inside is large and they have outdoor seating as well. Not too close to the major roads so it's a pretty quiet area. Also, if you're new and have never had Graeter's before, go with Black Raspberry Chocolate Chip. That is my favorite, and one of their signature flavors. read more

Graeter's Ice Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Dublin, Ohio

Super friendly staff! Delicious ice cream and a clean establishment with lots of indoor and outdoor seating.

Amazing service and the girl behind the counter was an absolute dime. I'm not a big ice cream eater but will definitely be back to see the team manager erin. My goodness she's cute read more

One of my Fav ice cream places in Columbus! Can't go wrong with any of the "chip" flavors! They have THE largest chocolate chips EVER!! I got the salted caramel chip and coconut chip!! Super Delish!!!!! read more

Not a pleasant experience. Server did not pay attention to my wife's order, my malt was liquid with lumps ( had to take it back and then the manager said that is how they make it!). The ice cream was okay but nothing special. Not going back, there are other choices. read more

First time at this place. The location is near my hotel in Dublin, Ohio and heard from people I work with that this ice cream parlor is popular, even with OSU because they have favorite named sundae. They have 4 different styles of creamery items...classic ice cream, gelato, fruit sorbet, featured or seasonal flavors (the one I tried was key lime pie ice cream, that tasted like whole crushed pie as an ice cream), & their signature chocolate chip flavors. The chocolate chips are no joke, more like chocolate chip chunks, almost like the ones you use for baking. I ordered the 1870 Tower sundae. Although it came in a banana split tray, it was due me ordering an additional scoop. Ok, details...1870 Tower normally comes with black raspberry chocolate chip ice cream, a mini bundt cake, heated, & topped with whipped cream, hot fudge, walnuts & a cherry, and like a tower shape. I also added another scoop called dark chocolate gelato. What I didn't know is each of their gelato flavors have flavored truffles that matched their gelato. The one I got was dark chocolate gelato with dark chocolate truffles. Wholly crap, it tasted awesome. I was thinking of trying more flavors but might wait till tomorrow. Even as I write this review, people are streaming in this location. It's already 9:50p & still people steady flow of customers (closes at 11pm). Other than their standard ice cream scoops, they have ice cream to go in quarts, pints, small 5 oz containers, & in ice cream cakes (sizes varies). They have classic sundaes, signature sundaes, shakes & malts, smoothies, and something called double dip sodas. It has sparkling water, 2 scoops of their vanilla bean ice cream, and your choice of fountain syrups. Ambiance is good. Easy on the eyes. I think this location is in the suburbs. You can get ice cream to go or eat in. On your receipt, you register for a rewards card program as well. Great price value for a tasty treat after a hard days work. read more

See all

The ice cream is to die for!!!!!!!!!! I love the strawberry, black raspberry, and the seasonal pumpkin! The store is really cute and when I went today for my birthday, the manager there, Caitlyn, was soooooo friendly and helpful!!!!!! 10/10 love this place! read more

Whoa they really know how to sell happiness in a bowl. Lol. Great Buckeye Sundae! It was peanut buttery and delicious. Get that if you like peanut butter and chocolate!!! First time here and it was great! From NYC and it was totally worth it!! read more

Graeter's Ice Cream - Buckeye sundae!!! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Dublin, Ohio

For all the hype it gets, I was actually pretty disappointed. I've been to quite a few ice cream shops in my time and this one definitely wasn't the best or the worst. I'd say that it probably lies a little above some really high-quality store-bought ice cream. Maybe I got the wrong flavor (mint chocolate chip), but the mint tasted pretty bland (I usually expect mint to pop in my mouth). The chocolate chips also seemed a bit overwhelming for an ice cream that is supposed to be centered around mint. read more

I wasn't as crazy about it as I thought I'd be. I had the brownie sundae. Kind of small brownie, especially for the price. The ice cream was ok. My husband said the cotton candy ice cream was one of the best he's had. We've had ice cream at many places and even places that claim to the city favorite. My favorite so far is a dairy farm in Connecticut so it's not like we don't have a basis for comparison. I will have to try a shake or smoothie next time because I wasn't impressed with the sundae. The service was really good though. Two people behind the counter, both super friendly and gave suggestions. They offered samples, explained the menu, and even made a cute little face with candy eyes in the kids bowls. Service is always the most important part to me so that's why I gave them 4 stats. read more

We came here late on Friday 15 minutes before close: The woman working was amazing! Very kind to us coming in late and great customer service by her! Thank you!!!! You deserve a raise!!!! read more

Another busy night. Seems that the later the evening the more crowded the shop becomes. Has a large selection of chocolate chip ice creams, sorbets and others. Cones, cups and specialty desserts. Indoor and outdoor seating. read more

When I'm in Dublin, I usually prefer Graeter's over Jeni's from a price point perspective as well as the places I frequent tend to have Jeni's rather than Graeter (ie. Short North). 1 thing I enjoy here is the ice cream & milk based milkshake. I'll admit - Graeter's is the place of more traditional ice cream flavors when compared to Jeni's & Handel's but none of the other 2 makes shakes the Graeter's way. Love the vanilla, cookies & cream, and cookie dough. read more

Had the Black Cherry Chocolate Chip. Very flavorful. The ambience is happy-happy, favorite of kiddos.

The best ice cream in the country. The french pot process makes all the difference plus no added air or non fat filler. This is a rich think full fat ice cream that features huge chocolate chunks from liquid chocolate added to the mix causing huge chips of chocolate. The all time best is the black raspberry chip, the fruit and chocolate combination is excellent. At every location there is always a line. My waistline is glad that the nearest location is 100's of miles away from New Orleans. read more

My first visit left me disappointed. I got a scoop of coffee and a scoop of salted caramel. Both had freezer burn. Lots of rice sized pieces of ice! read more